Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekTheNextGenerationS1E21Symbiosis

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForcedAddiction: As the plot unfolds, it's revealed that the Brekkians created felicium to cure a virus affecting both races, but they realized that it also acts like an opioid. Now, they're keeping the Ornarans addicted to it by convincing them that the felicium is only holding the virus at bey when it was cured long ago and what they're actually suffering from is withdrawal. This leaves Picard with a test of the Prime Directive, which he solves by refusing to offer repairs to the Ornarans' ailing ships, which will eventually cause them to not be able to get felicium from the Brekkians and force the two races to deal with their situation on their own.

to:

* ForcedAddiction: As the plot unfolds, it's revealed that the Brekkians created felicium to cure a virus affecting both races, but they realized that it also acts like an opioid. Now, they're keeping the Ornarans addicted to it by convincing them that the felicium is only holding the virus at bey bay when it was cured long ago and what they're actually suffering from is withdrawal. This leaves Picard with a test of the Prime Directive, which he solves by refusing to offer repairs to the Ornarans' ailing ships, which will eventually cause them to not be able to get felicium from the Brekkians and force the two races to deal with their situation on their own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added entry under Plot Hole

Added DiffLines:

** The Ornarans don't have warp drive but they do have transporters?
Willbyr MOD

Added: 663

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking a new trope



to:

%%


Added DiffLines:

* ForcedAddiction: As the plot unfolds, it's revealed that the Brekkians created felicium to cure a virus affecting both races, but they realized that it also acts like an opioid. Now, they're keeping the Ornarans addicted to it by convincing them that the felicium is only holding the virus at bey when it was cured long ago and what they're actually suffering from is withdrawal. This leaves Picard with a test of the Prime Directive, which he solves by refusing to offer repairs to the Ornarans' ailing ships, which will eventually cause them to not be able to get felicium from the Brekkians and force the two races to deal with their situation on their own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AluminumChristmasTrees:
** While some fans found the concept ridiculous of an entire species turning their economy to selling drugs, it has some precedent with the Opium Wars. The British Empire made virtually its entire import sales from dealing opium to China and actively did their best to enforce it on the public.
** The fact that real life medical corporations turned to selling addictive painkillers that were massively exploited is also a truth of the 21st century.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: Almost to the point of being an outright DownerEnding; the Ornarans do manage to stave off more immediate suffering by getting their hands on the felicium, and there ''is'' the long-term hope that they'll break out of their addiction once their supply runs out, but no guarantee. The ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'' novels take this a step further by implying that while the Ornarans eventually did break their addiction, the Brekkians just started selling felicium to other races.

to:

* BittersweetEnding: Almost to the point of being an outright DownerEnding; the Ornarans do manage to stave off more immediate suffering by getting their hands on the felicium, and there ''is'' the long-term hope that they'll break out of their addiction once their supply runs out, but no guarantee. The ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'' novels take this a step further by implying that while the Ornarans eventually did break their addiction, addiction (which is then confirmed in ''WesternAnimation/StarTrekLowerDecks''), the Brekkians just started selling felicium to other races.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Pyrrhic Villainy has been merged into Pyrrhic Victory per TRS decision


* PyrrhicVillainy: To tighten their grip on the Ornarans, the Brekkians have made felicium more potent and more addictive. As a result, the Ornarans cognitive functions have diminished to the point that they can’t repair their cargo ships. When the last ship inevitably breaks down, the addiction will break, and the Brekkians, who have no other industry and are completely dependent on the Ornarans, will lose their only customers.

to:

* PyrrhicVillainy: PyrrhicVictory: To tighten their grip on the Ornarans, the Brekkians have made felicium more potent and more addictive. As a result, the Ornarans cognitive functions have diminished to the point that they can’t repair their cargo ships. When the last ship inevitably breaks down, the addiction will break, and the Brekkians, who have no other industry and are completely dependent on the Ornarans, will lose their only customers.

Added: 448

Changed: 291

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AluminumChristmasTrees: While some fans found the concept ridiculous of an entire species turning their economy to selling drugs, it has some precedent with the Opium Wars. The British Empire made virtually its entire import sales from dealing opium to China and actively did their best to enforce it on the public.

to:

* AluminumChristmasTrees: AluminumChristmasTrees:
**
While some fans found the concept ridiculous of an entire species turning their economy to selling drugs, it has some precedent with the Opium Wars. The British Empire made virtually its entire import sales from dealing opium to China and actively did their best to enforce it on the public.public.
** The fact that real life medical corporations turned to selling addictive painkillers that were massively exploited is also a truth of the 21st century.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

* AluminumChristmasTrees: While some fans found the concept ridiculous of an entire species turning their economy to selling drugs, it has some precedent with the Opium Wars. The British Empire made virtually its entire import sales from dealing opium to China and actively did their best to enforce it on the public.

Added: 1067

Changed: 147

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AddledAddict: The Ornarans can't even make basic repairs to their ship. The fact that their people believe they need felicium to survive implies that the Ornarans we see are the most capable their planet has to offer since they are tasked with a mission that is believed to be vital to their world.
* AffablyEvil: The Brekkinas are calm, polite and compliment Picard on his hospitality while ignoring and profiting from the suffering of the Ornarans.
* TheAggressiveDrugDealer: Not only do the Brekkians allow the Ornarans to believe that they need the felicium to survive, they continually refine it to make it even more addictive.



* GRatedDrug: Felicium apparently has an effect similar to opiods.

to:

* GRatedDrug: Felicium apparently has an effect similar to opiods. Crusher specifically called it a narcotic.



* PyrrhicVillainy: To tighten their grip on the Ornarans, the Brekkians have made felicium more potent and more addictive. As a result, the Ornarans cognitive functions have diminished to the point that they can’t repair their cargo ships. When the last ship inevitably breaks down, the addiction will break, and the Brekkians, who have no other industry and are completely dependent on the Ornarans, will lose their only customers.



* SkewedPriorities: How the ''Enterprise'' crew sees the Ornarans beaming their cargo over before themselves when their ship is about to explode, as well as the surviving Ornarans caring more about the cargo than their deceased friends.

to:

* SkewedPriorities: How the ''Enterprise'' crew sees the Ornarans beaming their cargo over before themselves when their ship is about to explode, as well as the surviving Ornarans caring more about the cargo than their deceased friends. Subverted when it's revealed that the cargo is medicine that (they think) their people need to survive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Picard tries to mediate a trade dispute between two neighboring planets, one of which is the sole supplier of a drug to treat the other's apparently fatal disease.

to:

Picard tries to mediate a trade dispute between two neighboring planets, one of which is the sole supplier of a drug to treat the other's apparently fatal disease.
disease. However, the drug turns out to be an addicting narcotic, and Dr. Crusher is torn on whether to offer help to the people suffering from withdrawal symptoms or follow the Prime Directive and not get involved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''Original air date:''' April 18, 1988

Added: 1691

Changed: 16

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HostageForMacGuffin: One of the Ornarians holds Riker hostage and threatens to kill him if Picard doesn't give them the medicine. Picard calls their bluff.
* InsufficientlyAdvancedAlien: The Ornarians have no idea how to repair their ships, which is quite the headache when Picard's attempts to help fall on people too stupid to implement them. Of course, it could be justified that [[FridgeBrilliance their addiction to Felicium has some side effects on their mental state]].

to:

* HostageForMacGuffin: One of the Ornarians Ornarans holds Riker hostage and threatens to kill him if Picard doesn't give them the medicine. Picard calls their bluff.
* InsufficientlyAdvancedAlien: The Ornarians Ornarans have no idea how to repair their ships, which is quite the headache when Picard's attempts to help fall on people too stupid to implement them. Of course, it could be justified that [[FridgeBrilliance their addiction to Felicium has some side effects on their mental state]].



** The reaction of the Brekkians and the Ornarans when Picard refuses to hand over the parts to fix their spaceships.



* PlanetOfHats: Brekka is a planet of drug dealers; Ornara is a planet of drug users.

to:

* PlanetOfHats: Brekka is a planet of drug dealers; Ornara is a planet of drug users.addicts.



* RulesLawyer: The Prime Directive prevents Picard from warning the Omarans about the true nature of their felicium dependency, as doing so would fundamentally alter the power dynamic of their system. However, he also uses it to his advantage by refusing to hand over spaceship parts to the Ornarans and Brekkians, ensuring that one way or another the Ornarans will be forced to deal with their addiction problems on their own.



* SmugSnake: The Brekkians in their interactions with the Ornarans and (once the truth about felicium comes out) the Enterprise crew, tend to be highly condescending and self-satisfied. Langor especially, who engages in outright EvilGloating... right up until Captain Picard [[OhCrap pulls the rug out]] from under the entire parasitic system.

to:

* SmugSnake: The Brekkians in their interactions with the Ornarans and (once the truth about felicium comes out) the Enterprise ''Enterprise'' crew, tend to be highly condescending and self-satisfied. Langor especially, who engages in outright EvilGloating... right up until Captain Picard [[OhCrap pulls the rug out]] from under the entire parasitic system.


Added DiffLines:

* TooDumbToLive: Neither the Brekkians or the Ornarans come across as the the brightest stars in their particular system:
** The Ornarans only have 3 sublight space freighters on their planet, 2 of which are non-functional, and the last one is destroyed in this episode, despite the survival of their species (as far as they know) being utterly dependent on trade with their neighbouring planet.
*** As Dr. Crusher notes, the "virus" that still affects their race is no longer contagious at all, and has all of the symptoms of substance withdrawal rather than a typical contagion, suggesting there are no competent doctors or scientists on the entire planet who could figure out the disease was cured long before the ''Enterprise'' showed up.
** As for the Brekkians, they've left the transportation of their sole export in the hands of their barely-competent drug addicted neighbours, rather than maintain and fly their own spaceships to keep their drug trade running. In fact, they've [[OneProductPlanet retooled their entire planetary economy into the manufacturing of felicium]], making them just as dependent on space trade to survive as Ornara.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Neither of these are examples.


* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: The Ornaran reaction to use of their "cure." InUniverse, even; it's their reaction that clues Dr. Crusher in on what's really going on.
** In a sense, their "symbiosis" is something akin to a toxic friendship: one friend has something, the other friend has to do stuff for that friend in order to get it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlotHole: The freighter ''Sanction'' was carrying both the medicine and the payment for said medicine. Logically, the payment would be delivered to Brekka prior to loading the medicine for the return voyage to Ornara. The payment was on the freighter purely to involve the ''Enterprise'' crew in a dispute of ownership.

to:

* PlotHole: The freighter ''Sanction'' was carrying both the medicine and the payment for said medicine.it. Logically, the payment would be delivered to Brekka prior to loading the medicine for the return voyage to Ornara. The payment was on the freighter purely to involve the ''Enterprise'' crew in a dispute of ownership.



* SkewedPriorities: How the ''Enterprise'' crew sees the Ornarans beaming their cargo over before themselves when their ship is about to explode, as well as the surviving Ornarans caring more about said cargo than their deceased friends.

to:

* SkewedPriorities: How the ''Enterprise'' crew sees the Ornarans beaming their cargo over before themselves when their ship is about to explode, as well as the surviving Ornarans caring more about said the cargo than their deceased friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not an example of the trope. Also not accurate. The Ornarians could leave before the Brekkians overcome their withdrawal.


* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: You'd figure the Brekkians would be a little more concerned about going to a planet full of people that are bound to get through their withdrawal, realize that they have been exploited for generations, and take their outrage out on the only two Brekkians that are on their planet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulName: "Felicium" sounds a lot like the Latin word ''felicitates'' and its Spanish derivative ''felicidad'', both of which mean "happiness". The name practically screams "happy drug."

to:

* MeaningfulName: "Felicium" sounds a lot like the Latin word ''felicitates'' and its Spanish derivative ''felicidad'', both of which mean "happiness"."felicity," meaning happiness. The name practically screams "happy drug."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FirstNameBasis: During their conversation in the turbolift, Picard repeatedly calls Dr. Crusher 'Beverly', indicating both the closeness of their characters and the seriousness of the conversation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulName: "Felicium" sounds a lot like the Latin word ''felicitates'' and its Spanish derivative ''felizidad'', both of which mean "happiness". The name practically screams "happy drug."

to:

* MeaningfulName: "Felicium" sounds a lot like the Latin word ''felicitates'' and its Spanish derivative ''felizidad'', ''felicidad'', both of which mean "happiness". The name practically screams "happy drug."

Added: 160

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoingColdTurkey: Picard hopes to make ''an entire planet'' do this, once the Ornaran ships can no longer function and they can't get the Felicium from Brekka.



* MeaningfulName: "Felicium" sounds a lot like the Latin word ''felix'' and its Spanish derivative ''feliz'', both of which mean "happy." The name practically screams "happy drug."

to:

* MeaningfulName: "Felicium" sounds a lot like the Latin word ''felix'' ''felicitates'' and its Spanish derivative ''feliz'', ''felizidad'', both of which mean "happy." "happiness". The name practically screams "happy drug."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CripplingOverspecialization: It’s indicated that the inevitable breakdown of the system between the Ornarans and Brekkians will affect the latter far more severely, as their entire planetary economy is built around the production of felicium.

to:

* CripplingOverspecialization: It’s indicated that the inevitable breakdown of the system between the Ornarans and Brekkians will affect the latter far more severely, severely in the longer term, as their entire planetary economy is built around the production of felicium.felicium, which they will no longer have a customer for once the Ornarans break their addiction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CripplingOverspecialization: It’s indicated that the inevitable breakdown of the system between the Ornarans and Brekkians will affect the latter far more severely, as their entire planetary economy is built around the production of felicium.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmugSnake: The Brekkians in their interactions with the Ornarans and (once the truth about felicium comes out) the Enterprise crew, tend to be highly condescending and self-satisfied.

to:

* SmugSnake: The Brekkians in their interactions with the Ornarans and (once the truth about felicium comes out) the Enterprise crew, tend to be highly condescending and self-satisfied. Langor especially, who engages in outright EvilGloating... right up until Captain Picard [[OhCrap pulls the rug out]] from under the entire parasitic system.

Top