Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / PhilipKDicksElectricDreamsS1E2ImpossiblePlanet

Go To

OR

Added: 264

Changed: 17

Removed: 269

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Direct linking.


* FromACertainPointOfView: [=RB29=]'s justification for lying to Irma. Interestingly, once confronted with the sheer bleakness of the real Emphor III, Andrews spits at this idea, even though he was [[{{Hypocrite}} using it as a justification to Norton the day before]].



* MetaphoricallyTrue: [=RB29=]'s justification for lying to Irma. Interestingly, once confronted with the sheer bleakness of the real Emphor III, Andrews spits at this idea, even though he was [[{{Hypocrite}} using it as a justification to Norton the day before]].



** HalfTruth: There was, in fact, a "solar event" that affected the real Earth... [[EarthShatteringKaboom it vaporized it]].

to:

** HalfTruth: MetaphoricallyTrue: There was, in fact, a "solar event" that affected the real Earth... [[EarthShatteringKaboom it vaporized it]].

Changed: 11

Removed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AdaptationalJerkass: Arguably, Andrews, who in Dick's original represented the cynicism of the modern era but wasn't as blatant about it as he is here.



** The sun ''will'', in fact, physically destroy the Earth when it reaches red giant size and swallows the Earth entirely, but that's slated to happen five BILLION years in the future, [[SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale not within any timescale where the year still has four digits]]. Arguably the EarthShatteringKaboom backstory is necessary to make it clear that an EarthAllAlong ending is completely [[TitleDrop impossible]].

to:

** The sun ''will'', in fact, physically destroy the Earth when it reaches red giant size and swallows the Earth entirely, but that's slated to happen five BILLION years in the future, [[SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale not within any timescale where the year still has four digits]]. Arguably the The EarthShatteringKaboom backstory is necessary to make it clear that an EarthAllAlong ending is completely [[TitleDrop impossible]].

Added: 2029

Changed: 3534

Removed: 433

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseAstronomy: The sun ''will'', in fact, physically destroy the Earth when it reaches red giant size and swallows the Earth entirely, but that's slated to happen five BILLION years in the future, [[SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale not within any timescale where the year still has four digits]]. Arguably the EarthShatteringKaboom backstory is necessary to make it clear that an EarthAllAlong ending is completely [[TitleDrop impossible]].
** The Solar System hasn't officially had "nine planets" [[PlutoIsExpendable since 2006]], although perhaps [[LostCommonKnowledge most data about Earth being garbled or forgotten]] could account for the discrepancy. (Although note that humans were spacefaring by the time Irma's grandparents lived, and as UsefulNotes/NeilDeGrasseTyson has pointed out, no one approaching our system from the outside would actually see it as having "nine planets", as opposed to a large number of Kuiper Belt objects surrounding four gas giants and four inner planets.)

to:

* ArtisticLicenseAstronomy: ArtisticLicenseAstronomy:
**
The sun ''will'', in fact, physically destroy the Earth when it reaches red giant size and swallows the Earth entirely, but that's slated to happen five BILLION years in the future, [[SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale not within any timescale where the year still has four digits]]. Arguably the EarthShatteringKaboom backstory is necessary to make it clear that an EarthAllAlong ending is completely [[TitleDrop impossible]].
** The Solar System hasn't officially had "nine planets" [[PlutoIsExpendable since 2006]], although perhaps [[LostCommonKnowledge most data about Earth being garbled or forgotten]] could account for the discrepancy. (Although discrepancy (though note that humans were spacefaring by the time Irma's grandparents lived, and as UsefulNotes/NeilDeGrasseTyson has pointed out, no one approaching our system from the outside would actually see it as having "nine planets", as opposed to a large number of Kuiper Belt objects surrounding four gas giants and four inner planets.)planets).



* CorruptCorporateExecutive: We learn very little about Linus Primo himself, but Andrews appears to believe he got where he is just by "picking a few pockets". (Although see below.)

to:

* CorruptCorporateExecutive: We learn very little about Linus Primo himself, but Andrews appears to believe he got where he is just by "picking a few pockets". (Although pockets" (although see below.)below).



* LostCommonKnowledge: Irma's initial monologue requires her to explain concepts like what oak trees are, and [=RB29=] apparently can't help her put on her dress because physical fasteners are now obsolete. She remembers the location of Elk River Falls, NC only as "Carolina", and even though [[HiddenDepths Andrews knows that Mars is the name of the god of war]], he appears ignorant that it was also once known as the "Red Planet".

to:

* LostCommonKnowledge: LostCommonKnowledge:
**
Irma's initial monologue requires her to explain concepts like what oak trees are, and [=RB29=] apparently can't help her put on her dress because physical fasteners are now obsolete. She remembers the location of Elk River Falls, NC only as "Carolina", and even though [[HiddenDepths Andrews knows that Mars is the name of the god of war]], he appears ignorant that it was also once known as the "Red Planet".



* MeaningfulName: The cheesy branding of the ship's name ''Dreamweaver'' becomes more meaningful by the ending. Possibly also Irma's name ([[PunnyName "Irma Gordon" = "Armageddon"]]) given that she's searching for an Earth that no longer exists.

to:

* MeaningfulName: MeaningfulName:
**
The cheesy branding of the ship's name ''Dreamweaver'' becomes more meaningful by the ending. Possibly also Irma's name ([[PunnyName "Irma Gordon" = "Armageddon"]]) given that she's searching for an Earth that no longer exists.



* MegaCorp: Everything in this universe seems to be owned by [[CorruptCorporateExecutive Linus Primo]] and [[EgocentricTeamNaming named after him]], although his own family name may be some kind of [[MeaningfulName title]] describing his position.

to:

* MegaCorp: MegaCorp:
**
Everything in this universe seems to be owned by [[CorruptCorporateExecutive Linus Primo]] and [[EgocentricTeamNaming named after him]], although his own family name may be some kind of [[MeaningfulName title]] describing his position.



* NotHisSled: The [[AllThereIsToKnowAboutTheCryingGame whole point]] of the original story is that Emphor III was EarthAllAlong. This time, we are explicitly told that Earth's total destruction is a basic, known fact, a la "[[Literature/AChristmasCarol Marley was dead]]", and moreover told that this is a setting where [[GreatBigLibraryOfEverything humans have exhaustively mapped and catalogued the entire universe]]. Aside from the superficial similarity of being the third of nine planets, with one moon -- which is what Andrews was searching for in the database -- Emphor III ''cannot'' be Earth. [[AmbiguousEnding And yet...]]

to:

* NotHisSled: The [[AllThereIsToKnowAboutTheCryingGame whole point]] of the original story is that Emphor III was EarthAllAlong. This time, we are explicitly told that Earth's total destruction is a basic, known fact, a la "[[Literature/AChristmasCarol Marley was dead]]", and moreover told that this is a setting where [[GreatBigLibraryOfEverything humans have exhaustively mapped and catalogued cataloged the entire universe]]. Aside from the superficial similarity of being the third of nine planets, with one moon -- which is what Andrews was searching for in the database -- Emphor III ''cannot'' be Earth. [[AmbiguousEnding And yet...]]



* SeamlessSpontaneousLie: Just at the moment Irma is about to PullTheThread and expose Andrews and Norton's con job, [=RB29=] suddenly comes up with a detailed story about how a "solar event" caused all of the discrepancies between the Sol and Emphor systems, having come to the decision to become TheShill rather than expose them.

to:

* SeamlessSpontaneousLie: ScatterbrainedSenior: Irma. She claims to be "sharp as a tack", and she almost unravels Andrews' plan once or twice, but the plot rests on her seeming to have forgotten all about the destruction of Earth despite this being CommonKnowledge. Her AmbiguousDisorder may not just be dementia but something more mystical, considering that her obsession with Earth seems connected to her mystical link with Norton.
* SeamlessSpontaneousLie:
**
Just at the moment Irma is about to PullTheThread and expose Andrews and Norton's con job, [=RB29=] suddenly comes up with a detailed story about how a "solar event" caused all of the discrepancies between the Sol and Emphor systems, having come to the decision to become TheShill rather than expose them.



* SpottingTheThread: The plan almost collapses when they fly by "Mars" and she sees it glowing green.
* {{Squick}}: If you take the episode completely literally, then Irma may end up [[spoiler: [[IncestIsRelative having sex with her own grandfather]], reincarnated]].



* ScatterbrainedSenior: Irma. She claims to be "sharp as a tack", and she almost unravels Andrews' plan once or twice, but the plot rests on her seeming to have forgotten all about the destruction of Earth despite this being CommonKnowledge. Her AmbiguousDisorder may not just be dementia but something more mystical, considering that her obsession with Earth seems connected to her mystical link with Norton.
* SpottingTheThread: The plan almost collapses when they fly by "Mars" and she sees it glowing green.
* {{Squick}}: If you take the episode completely literally, then Irma may end up [[spoiler: [[IncestIsRelative having sex with her own grandfather]], reincarnated]].
* VisionsOfAnotherSelf: Brian seems to have been having mysterious flashes of the life of Irma's grandfather, before he even met her, indicating some kind of {{Reincarnation}} may be going on (but see above). Based on what Irma says, Brian seems to share Bill Gordon's desire for the unknown.
* {{Zeerust}}: Compared to the rest of this series the future of this episode comes off as this, especially the character design of [=RB29=].

to:

* ScatterbrainedSenior: Irma. She claims to be "sharp as a tack", and she almost unravels Andrews' plan once or twice, but the plot rests on her seeming to have forgotten all about the destruction of Earth despite this being CommonKnowledge. Her AmbiguousDisorder may not just be dementia but something more mystical, considering that her obsession with Earth seems connected to her mystical link with Norton.
* SpottingTheThread: The plan almost collapses when they fly by "Mars" and she sees it glowing green.
* {{Squick}}: If you take the episode completely literally, then Irma may end up [[spoiler: [[IncestIsRelative having sex with her own grandfather]], reincarnated]].
* VisionsOfAnotherSelf: Brian seems to have been having mysterious flashes of the life of Irma's grandfather, before he even met her, indicating some kind of {{Reincarnation}} {{reincarnation}} may be going on (but see above). Based on what Irma says, Brian seems to share Bill Gordon's desire for the unknown.
* {{Zeerust}}: {{Zeerust}}:
**
Compared to the rest of this series the future of this episode comes off as this, especially the character design of [=RB29=].

Added: 281

Changed: 278

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: Creator/PhilipKDick's original story "[[TheTheTitleConfusion The]] Impossible Planet" was famous for its EarthAllAlong ending. Since in a post-Franchise/PlanetOfTheApes world this ending has become TheUntwist, this story makes it clear from the outset that this is not the case.

to:

* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: AdaptationalAlternateEnding:
**
Creator/PhilipKDick's original story "[[TheTheTitleConfusion The]] Impossible Planet" was famous for its EarthAllAlong ending. Since in a post-Franchise/PlanetOfTheApes world this ending has become TheUntwist, this story makes it clear from the outset that this is not the case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: DeathByAdaptation]]: [[spoiler: [=RB29=]'s role of being TogetherInDeath with Irma is taken by Norton.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: DeathByAdaptation]]: DeathByAdaptation: [[spoiler: [=RB29=]'s role of being TogetherInDeath with Irma is taken by Norton.]]



* [[spoiler: {{Flatline}}]]: [[spoiler: The onboard monitor for the spacesuits' O2 levels makes this sound when they drop to zero.]]

to:

* [[spoiler: {{Flatline}}]]: {{Flatline}}: [[spoiler: The onboard monitor for the spacesuits' O2 levels makes this sound when they drop to zero.]]



* [[spoiler: TogetherInDeath]]: [[spoiler: Brian Norton and Irma Gordon... ambiguously.]]

to:

* [[spoiler: TogetherInDeath]]: TogetherInDeath: [[spoiler: Brian Norton and Irma Gordon... ambiguously.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RaceLift: Andrews is played by BenedictWong.

to:

* RaceLift: Andrews is played by BenedictWong.Creator/BenedictWong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


->''"Of course, you're going to tell me that things have changed, that Earth back then is not Earth today or some such thing, but... If my life has taught me anything, Mr. Norton, it is that some places want to change, and some places don't want to change. And I think I know which one Elk River is."''

->''"We're ripping off an old lady so you can go on a holiday, and so I can move somewhere I don't actually wanna go."''
->''"We're not ripping anyone off. We're weaving dreams. We're artists, me and you."''
->''"''Con'' artists."''
->''"What other type is there?"''

to:

->''"Of course, you're going to tell me that things have changed, that Earth back then is not Earth today or some such thing, but... If my life has taught me anything, Mr. Norton, it is that some places want to change, and some places don't want to change. And I think I know which one Elk River is."''

->''"We're
"''\\
\\
''"We're
ripping off an old lady so you can go on a holiday, and so I can move somewhere I don't actually wanna go."''
->''"We're
"''\\
''"We're
not ripping anyone off. We're weaving dreams. We're artists, me and you."''
->''"''Con''
"''\\
''"''Con''
artists."''
->''"What
"''\\
''"What
other type is there?"''



* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: Creator/PhilipKDick's original story "[[TheTheTitleConfusion The]] Impossible Planet" was famous for its EarthAllAlong ending. Since in a post-PlanetOfTheApes world this ending has become TheUntwist, this story makes it clear from the outset that this is not the case.

to:

* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: Creator/PhilipKDick's original story "[[TheTheTitleConfusion The]] Impossible Planet" was famous for its EarthAllAlong ending. Since in a post-PlanetOfTheApes post-Franchise/PlanetOfTheApes world this ending has become TheUntwist, this story makes it clear from the outset that this is not the case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Geraldine Chaplin as Irma Gordon is far more beautiful (even for her age) than Mrs. Gordon was implied to be. [[spoiler: Ends up PromotedToLoveInterest for Norton]].

to:

* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Geraldine Chaplin Creator/GeraldineChaplin as Irma Gordon is far more beautiful (even for her age) than Mrs. Gordon was implied to be. [[spoiler: Ends up PromotedToLoveInterest for Norton]].



* MetaCasting: In a story about the lost, mythical past of Earth, the representative of that past is played by Geraldine Chaplin, associated by those who recognize her with classic films such as ''Film/DoctorZhivago'' and with her father, Creator/CharlieChaplin.

to:

* MetaCasting: In a story about the lost, mythical past of Earth, the representative of that past is played by Geraldine Chaplin, Creator/GeraldineChaplin, associated by those who recognize her with classic films such as ''Film/DoctorZhivago'' and with her father, Creator/CharlieChaplin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MetaCasting: In a story about the lost, mythical past of Earth, the representative of that past is played by Geraldine Chaplin, associated by those who recognize her with classic films such as DoctorZhivago and with her father, Creator/CharlieChaplin.

to:

* MetaCasting: In a story about the lost, mythical past of Earth, the representative of that past is played by Geraldine Chaplin, associated by those who recognize her with classic films such as DoctorZhivago ''Film/DoctorZhivago'' and with her father, Creator/CharlieChaplin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: PhilipKDick's original story "[[TheTheTitleConfusion The]] Impossible Planet" was famous for its EarthAllAlong ending. Since in a post-PlanetOfTheApes world this ending has become TheUntwist, this story makes it clear from the outset that this is not the case.

to:

* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: PhilipKDick's Creator/PhilipKDick's original story "[[TheTheTitleConfusion The]] Impossible Planet" was famous for its EarthAllAlong ending. Since in a post-PlanetOfTheApes world this ending has become TheUntwist, this story makes it clear from the outset that this is not the case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Solar System hasn't officially had "nine planets" [[PlutoIsExpendable since 2006]], although [[LostCommonKnowledge perhaps most data about Earth]] being garbled or forgotten could account for the discrepancy. (Although note that humans were spacefaring by the time Irma's grandparents lived, and as UsefulNotes/NeilDeGrasseTyson has pointed out, no one approaching our system from the outside would actually see it as having "nine planets", as opposed to a large number of Kuiper Belt objects surrounding four gas giants and four inner planets.)

to:

** The Solar System hasn't officially had "nine planets" [[PlutoIsExpendable since 2006]], although perhaps [[LostCommonKnowledge perhaps most data about Earth]] Earth being garbled or forgotten forgotten]] could account for the discrepancy. (Although note that humans were spacefaring by the time Irma's grandparents lived, and as UsefulNotes/NeilDeGrasseTyson has pointed out, no one approaching our system from the outside would actually see it as having "nine planets", as opposed to a large number of Kuiper Belt objects surrounding four gas giants and four inner planets.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Solar System hasn't officially had "nine planets" [[PlutoIsExpendable since 2006]], although [[LostCommonKnowledge perhaps most data about Earth]] being garbled or forgotten could account for the discrepancy. (Although note that humans were spacefaring by the time Irma's grandparents lived, and as UsefulNotes/NeilDeGrasseTyson has pointed out, no one approaching our system from the outside would actually see it as having "nine planets", as opposed to a large number of Kuiper Belt objects surrounding four gas giants and four inner planets.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArmorPiercingQuestion: "Do you ever dream of me, Barbara?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->''"Of course, you're going to tell me that things have changed, that Earth back then is not Earth today or some such thing, but... If my life has taught me anything, Mr. Norton, it is that some places want to change, and some places don't want to change. And I think I know which one Elk River is."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BlatantLies: When Irma sees Brian pull out two spacesuits right after Andrews said there weren't any, Brian just smiles and says "Mr. Andrews doesn't know everything." [[spoiler: Turns out Andrews knew perfectly well those spacesuits existed, and knew they weren't safe for any excursion longer than making emergency repairs.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"We're ripping off an old lady so you can go on a holiday, and so I can move somewhere I don't actually wanna go."
->"We're not ripping anyone off. We're weaving dreams. We're artists, me and you."
->"Con artists."
->"What other type is there?"''

to:

->''"We're ripping off an old lady so you can go on a holiday, and so I can move somewhere I don't actually wanna go."
->"We're
"''
->''"We're
not ripping anyone off. We're weaving dreams. We're artists, me and you."
->"Con
"''
->''"''Con''
artists."
->"What
"''
->''"What
other type is there?"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->''"We're ripping off an old lady so you can go on a holiday, and so I can move somewhere I don't actually wanna go."
->"We're not ripping anyone off. We're weaving dreams. We're artists, me and you."
->"Con artists."
->"What other type is there?"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Brian Norton is a young tour guide working for a company called Astral Dreams, taking wide-eyed travelers to see the natural wonders of the universe on the starship ''Dreamweaver''. Unfortunately it's not as glamorous as it sounds -- a lot of shuttling back and forth between highly-trafficked tourist traps, blatantly cheating to give his passengers their money's worth by using "visual enhancements" on the display windows to make supernovas more spectacular than they really are.

His colleague Andrews, who works in tech support, is happy to make a living fleecing the rubes so he can get drunk and watch porn in his off hours, but Norton wants something more. Not helping is his girlfriend Barbara back home, who keeps ramping up the pressure on him to graduate from his entry-level job for something more lucrative and secure.

Then one day a dotty old lady by the name of Irma Gordon shows up at the Astral Dreams office, accompanied only by her robot servant, seemingly out of touch with reality -- unable to operate the automated ticket kiosk or to understand that she's arrived after normal business hours. It only gets worse when she reveals she's come to book a ticket to Earth, a planet that, according to Andrews, everyone knows no longer exists.

Then the robot reveals that Ms. Gordon is, in fact, so out of touch that she can't use electronic banking, and instead has brought with her her entire life savings, in cash...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OlderThanTheyThink: Dick used this title for a short story fifty years before there was a [[Recap/DoctorWhoS28E8TheImpossiblePlanet Doctor Who episode]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[spoiler: {{Flatline}}]]: [[spoiler: The onboard monitor for the spacesuits' O2 levels makes this sound when they drop to zero.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigWhat: Andrews' reaction, shouted at [=RB29=], when he realizes [[spoiler:Brian and Irma have run out of oxygen and died]]. Possibly also a DefensiveWhat, given that the whole situation spiraled out from his own moneymaking scheme.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** SparedByTheAdaptation: [=RB29=].
** [[spoiler: DeathByAdaptation]]: [[spoiler: [=RB29=]'s role of being TogetherInDeath with Irma is taken by Norton.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbledInTheAdaptation: Partially. Mrs. Gordon in the original story is completely deaf and can only communicate with Andrews and Norton through writing or through her robot. In this version Irma is only hearing-impaired, claiming she can "hear some people (Norton) better than others", and can communicate more or less normally with the aid of an assistive device.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalJerkass: Arguably, Andrews, who in Dick's original represented the cynicism of the modern era but wasn't as blatant about it as he is here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MetaCasting: In a story about the lost, mythical past of Earth, the representative of that past is played by Geraldine Chaplin, associated by those who recognize her with classic films such as DoctorZhivago and with her father, Creator/CharlieChaplin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RaceLift: Andrews is played by BenedictWong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationJobChange: In the original story Andrews was the captain of an independent vessel. Here Andrews and Norton are both low-level employees of a corporation. (Notably nobody ever addresses Andrews or Norton as "Captain".)

to:

* AdaptationJobChange: AdaptationalJobChange: In the original story Andrews was the captain of an independent vessel. Here Andrews and Norton are both low-level employees of a corporation. (Notably nobody ever addresses Andrews or Norton as "Captain".)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationJobChange: In the original story Andrews was the captain of an independent vessel. Here Andrews and Norton are both low-level employees of a corporation. (Notably nobody ever addresses Andrews or Norton as "Captain".)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationNameChange: Minor example. The surnames all stay the same (despite Andrews' RaceLift), but in the original story the old lady was a widow named "Mrs. Gordon". In this story no mention is made of whether Irma was ever married, but it is a significant plot point that she inherited the surname "Gordon" from her grandfather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Geraldine Chaplin as Irma Gordon is far more beautiful (even for her age) than Mrs. Gordon was implied to be. [[spoiler: Ends up PromotedToLoveInterest for Norton]].


Added DiffLines:

* NamedByTheAdaptation: Norton gains the first name "Brian" and Mrs. Gordon the first name "Irma", while Mrs. Gordon's "robant" is given the designation [=RB29=].

Top