Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / OnceUponATimeS4E19Lily

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
An Aborted Arc is when a subplot is left unresolved. It sounds like shoehorning They Wasted A Perfectly Good Plot on the main page.


* AbortedArc: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the 'helpless' Marian being defamed by a 'jealous' Regina trying to discredit her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, it's a nice way to keep from padding an already-complex and diffuse story.

Changed: 377

Removed: 380

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouCantFightFate:
** Regina speculates that Emma and Lily are destined to [[ArcWords always find each other]], no matter how far apart they get. The fact that Lily essentially lived right in Emma's backyard for years without either one knowing it supports this idea, as does the fact that a Emma's car [[PlotDrivenBreakdown blows a tire]] within spitting distance of the diner where Lily now works.

to:

* YouCantFightFate:
**
YouCantFightFate: Regina speculates that Emma and Lily are destined to [[ArcWords always find each other]], no matter how far apart they get. The fact that Lily essentially lived right in Emma's backyard for years without either one knowing it supports this idea, as does the fact that a Emma's car [[PlotDrivenBreakdown blows a tire]] within spitting distance of the diner where Lily now works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Regina speculates that Emma and Lily are destined to [[ArcWords always find each other]], no matter how far apart they get. The fact that Lily essentially lived right in Emma's backyard for years without either one knowing it supports this idea, as does the fact that a Emma's car [[PlotMandatedBreakdown blows a tire]] within spitting distance of the diner where Lily now works.

to:

** Regina speculates that Emma and Lily are destined to [[ArcWords always find each other]], no matter how far apart they get. The fact that Lily essentially lived right in Emma's backyard for years without either one knowing it supports this idea, as does the fact that a Emma's car [[PlotMandatedBreakdown [[PlotDrivenBreakdown blows a tire]] within spitting distance of the diner where Lily now works.

Added: 758

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiChrist: Lily considers herself "The Anti-Savior"; Emma tells her not to call herself that.



** A straighter example would be Zelena's pregnancy with Robin's child, which prevents him from leaving her and keeps Regina from her happy ending. It was foreshadowed in "Heart of Gold" when she mentionned having "a meatloaf in the oven".

to:

** A straighter example would be Zelena's pregnancy with Robin's child, which prevents him from leaving her and keeps Regina from her happy ending. It was foreshadowed in "Heart of Gold" when she mentionned mentioned having "a meatloaf in the oven".



* PleaseKillMeIfItSatisfiesYou: Lily urges Emma to shoot her, pointing out that she'll only destroy everyone in Storybrooke and arguing that her life isn't worth saving. After a lot of thought (and urging from Regina), Emma puts her gun down, letting Lily live.



-->'''Maleficent''': I'm not the one you should be apologizing to...You think that will possibly be enough? If I can't forgive you...what makes you think she will?

to:

-->'''Maleficent''': I'm not the one you should be apologizing to...You think that will possibly be enough? If I can't forgive you...what makes you think she will?will?
* YouCantFightFate:
** Regina speculates that Emma and Lily are destined to [[ArcWords always find each other]], no matter how far apart they get. The fact that Lily essentially lived right in Emma's backyard for years without either one knowing it supports this idea, as does the fact that a Emma's car [[PlotMandatedBreakdown blows a tire]] within spitting distance of the diner where Lily now works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A straighter example would be Zelena's pregnancy with Robin's child, which prevents him from leaving her and keeps Regina from her happy ending.

to:

** A straighter example would be Zelena's pregnancy with Robin's child, which prevents him from leaving her and keeps Regina from her happy ending. It was foreshadowed in "Heart of Gold" when she mentionned having "a meatloaf in the oven".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KarmaHoudini: InUniverse, Maleficent and Lily overlook the part the Author played in their separation instead focusing their hate on the Charmings.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Emma and Lily, in terms of how their lives went vs. how they could have (same background, and whether one was good or evil/had a happy life or one of suffering was enforced by a spell). Described by Lily as "Savior. vs. Anti-Savior."

to:

** Emma and Lily, in terms of how their lives went vs. how they could have (same background, and whether one was good or evil/had a happy life or one of suffering was enforced by a spell). Described by Lily as "Savior. "Savior vs. Anti-Savior."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Maleficent''': I'm not the one you should be apologizing to...You think that will possibly be enough? If I can't forgive you...what makes you think she will?
*

to:

-->'''Maleficent''': I'm not the one you should be apologizing to...You think that will possibly be enough? If I can't forgive you...what makes you think she will?
*
will?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityNod: Emma's ability to find people is brought up (by Regina, and then indirectly by Maleficent!), and her ability to tell when people are lying returns. Also, the wolf which drove her off the road when she tried to leave Storybrooke back in season 1 appears again. (The fact it was connected to Graham, and Regina was sitting right there and dismissing it, is [[ElephantInTheLivingRoom a separate issue]].)

to:

* ContinuityNod: Emma's ability to find people is brought up (by Regina, and then indirectly by Maleficent!), Maleficent, and her ability to tell when people are lying returns. Also, the wolf which drove her off the road when she tried to leave Storybrooke back in season 1 appears again. (The fact it was connected to Graham, and Regina was sitting right there and dismissing it, is [[ElephantInTheLivingRoom a separate issue]].)



** A straighter example would be Zelena's pregnacy with Robin's child, which prevents him from leaving her and keeps Regina from her happy ending.

to:

** A straighter example would be Zelena's pregnacy pregnancy with Robin's child, which prevents him from leaving her and keeps Regina from her happy ending.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbortedArc: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the 'helpless' Marian being defamed by a jealous Regina trying to discredit her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, it's a nice way to keep from padding an already-complex and diffuse story.

to:

* AbortedArc: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the 'helpless' Marian being defamed by a jealous 'jealous' Regina trying to discredit her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, it's a nice way to keep from padding an already-complex and diffuse story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LonelyFuneral: For Cruella, with only Gold and the Author in attendance (and a plain wooden coffin). Acts as {{Foreshadowing}} that Maleficent was about to turn on Gold for his betrayal, but also displays how hardly anyone cared about her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SadisticChoice: Emma is presented with one: Kill Lily and protect her family and friends, but darken her heart, or let Lily live and risk the lives of everyone in Storybrooke. She ultimately goes with option two, believing she can help Lily.



-->'''Maleficent''': I'm not the one you should be apologizing to...You think that will possibly be enough? If I can't forgive you...what makes you think she will?

to:

-->'''Maleficent''': I'm not the one you should be apologizing to...You think that will possibly be enough? If I can't forgive you...what makes you think she will?will?
*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PowerIncontinence: When Emma is raging at Lily, her magic goes briefly out of control, busting the car headlights. [[AStormIsComing The sky also quickly becomes overcast]], which could just be EmpathicWeather and [[DramaticThunder fortuitous drama]], but then again...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--'''Maleficent''': I'm not the one you should be apologizing to...You think that will possibly be enough? If I can't forgive you...what makes you think she will?

to:

--'''Maleficent''': -->'''Maleficent''': I'm not the one you should be apologizing to...You think that will possibly be enough? If I can't forgive you...what makes you think she will?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReasonYouSuckSpeech: Lily blasts Emma for abandoning her, and how it was because of her that her life was ruined, just to keep her "perfect" and heroic. By proxy, she also gives one to Snow and Charming for having done what they did, though she still attacks Emma for this too--somewhat irrationally, since as Emma herself says she had nothing to do with their decision, but Lily also goes on to point out she was still defending them from her despite what they did.



* ThisIsReality: Emma tries to pull this to explain how she isn't falling into darkness, just dealing with a world where life sucks and you have to sometimes take less-than-ideal actions to protect yourself and those you love. Regina isn't buying it.

to:

* ThisIsReality: Emma tries to pull this to explain how she isn't falling into darkness, just dealing with a world where life sucks and you have to sometimes take less-than-ideal actions to protect yourself and those you love. Regina isn't buying it.it.
* ThisIsUnforgivable: In a chilling moment when David and Mary Margaret speak to Maleficent, desperate to atone. (And based on what Lily later says to Emma, her mother was right.)
--'''Maleficent''': I'm not the one you should be apologizing to...You think that will possibly be enough? If I can't forgive you...what makes you think she will?

Added: 287

Changed: 490

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Hypocrite}}: Emma thinks Regina is being this in warning her not to go off on a RoaringRampageOfRevenge ("Excuse me, ''Your Majesty''") but it's [[SubvertedTrope actually]] Regina knowing from experience the danger signs of JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope, and thus legitimately worried.



** Emma and Regina. Continually lampshaded by the latter to try and steer Emma off her dark course.

to:

** Emma and Regina. Continually lampshaded by the latter to try and steer Emma off her dark course. Emma at first also tries to play this card by pointing out what she would do to protect her family is no different than what Regina would do to Zelena to protect Robin...but aside from the fact Regina's quite right about it being different (she isn't the Savior, so taking such actions only threatens her own heroism and happiness, not everyone else's), the fact Emma is saying being more like Regina is a ''good'' thing is cause for alarm. Even Regina's "Really, Swan?" look says as much.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MacGuffin: Lily's moon necklace, which she sent Emma for to give her the time to rob her foster parents. Although based on what the Apprentice said, it might just have more meaning...

Added: 586

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompulsiveLiar: Lily. Enforced, however, by the nature of the curse/darkness within her.

to:

* CompulsiveLiar: ConsummateLiar: Lily. Enforced, however, by the nature of the curse/darkness within her.


Added DiffLines:

* MeaningfulName: Lily, the OUAT equivalent of a MadeOfEvil TykeBomb, has the given name of Lilith.


Added DiffLines:

* SiblingYinYang: Although not actually related, Emma and Lily are played as this in a number of ways: blonde vs. brunette, saving/protecting lives vs. ruining them, light vs. darkness, able to detect lies vs. constantly telling them. Interestingly, Lily claims that when they are together the DiabolusExMachina of her life is pushed away and things get better/more balanced, implying that [[WonderTwinPowers only by combining their light and dark]] can either reach a state of normalcy.

Added: 4304

Changed: 359

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbortedArc: What could have been a several-episodes-spanning plot of the 'helpless' Marian being defamed by a jealous Regina trying to discredit her to get Robin back is cut short when Zelena decides to expose herself instead and use the pregnancy to trap him. Whether Zelena knew she couldn't keep Robin in the dark indefinitely, that Regina or Emma would eventually be able to expose her, or she just liked twisting the knife in both him and Regina, it's a nice way to keep from padding an already-complex and diffuse story.
* TheBabyTrap: Zelena pulls this on Robin, rather than trying to continue a charade as Marian she knows can't be sustained.
* BeingGoodSucks: Emma can't kill an innocent (or an old friend), and instead makes the tough choice of sparing Lily and trying to fix her life as atonement for what her parents did. But since Lily herself said that doing this would let her destroy everyone in Storybrooke, and Maleficent would be happy to help her punish the Charmings in particular, Emma has just set herself up for a future conflict when she might have to kill Lily anyway.
* ChaseScene: Emma's VW didn't have a chance.
* CompulsiveLiar: Lily. Enforced, however, by the nature of the curse/darkness within her.
* ContinuityNod: Emma's ability to find people is brought up (by Regina, and then indirectly by Maleficent!), and her ability to tell when people are lying returns. Also, the wolf which drove her off the road when she tried to leave Storybrooke back in season 1 appears again. (The fact it was connected to Graham, and Regina was sitting right there and dismissing it, is [[ElephantInTheLivingRoom a separate issue]].)



* GenreSavvy: Gold knows that Emma seeking Lily out will actually help his plan and advance Emma's darkness rather than derailing it. Some of this is because of his own knowledge (the Author and Maleficent telling him what the Charmings did, any scrying he may have done of Lily) but it seems more generally him being aware that the past (whether what the Charmings did or Emma) has a way of catching up with you in stories and that being heroic is never that simple.



* NiceJobBreakingItHero: The Apprentice decided to seek out Lily and tell her everything because he felt she had a right to know why her life sucked. Unfortunely it led to Lily developing a homicidal obession with Emma and her parents.

to:

* ManipulativeBastard: Gold appeals to Will's feelings for Belle (and reveals she doesn't have her heart) in order to get him to help him. He then proceeds to distract Maleficent by talking with her about Emma and Lily so that Will can steal the heart.
* MoralEventHorizon: In-universe, Emma killing Lily in cold blood (even to protect her parents and the rest of Storybrooke) would be the line she dare not cross, since Cruella's death was accidental/arranged by Gold. Luckily [[TheAtoner Regina]] [[CharacterDevelopment keeps her from doing so]].
* MoralityChain: ''Regina'' manages to be this to Emma. Hook also speaks of this as to how she can stay on the right path (and what is keeping him on his).
* NiceJobBreakingItHero: The Apprentice decided to seek out Lily and tell her everything because he felt she had a right to know why her life sucked. Unfortunely Unfortunately it led to Lily developing a homicidal obession obsession with Emma and her parents.parents.
* NotSoDifferent:
** Emma and Lily, in terms of how their lives went vs. how they could have (same background, and whether one was good or evil/had a happy life or one of suffering was enforced by a spell). Described by Lily as "Savior. vs. Anti-Savior."
** Emma and Regina. Continually lampshaded by the latter to try and steer Emma off her dark course.
* PetTheDog: The Author is genuinely upset over Cruella's death.
* RoomFullOfCrazy: Lily has one with a StringTheory of conspiracies about Emma. Interestingly, instead of it leading to AloneWithThePsycho or her trying to kill Emma and Regina, it was just a distraction to let her steal Emma's car.
* ThereAreNoCoincidences: At least not in the case of Emma and Lily--as the Sorcerer himself says, the two of them are bound together forever (thanks to both the nature of the spell and the former's darkness being placed in the latter) and thus will keep being drawn together. Lampshaded by both Regina (referencing her having adopted the son of the Savior) and Emma. Subverted a bit, though, since while Emma and Lily's first meeting and the one shown in the flashback happened on their own, it seems very clear that Lily and Emma living near each other as adults is due to the Apprentice's information.
* ThisIsReality: Emma tries to pull this to explain how she isn't falling into darkness, just dealing with a world where life sucks and you have to sometimes take less-than-ideal actions to protect yourself and those you love. Regina isn't buying it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceJobBreakingItHero: The Apprentince decided to seek out Lily and tell her everything because he felt she had a right to know why her life sucked. Unfortunely it led to Lily developing a homicidal obession with Emma and her parents.

to:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: The Apprentince Apprentice decided to seek out Lily and tell her everything because he felt she had a right to know why her life sucked. Unfortunely it led to Lily developing a homicidal obession with Emma and her parents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnemyMine: Maleficent teams up with the others to stop Gold. However it's heavilly implied that she plans to kill the Charmings once Emma finds Lily for her.

to:

* EnemyMine: Maleficent teams up with the others to stop Gold. However it's heavilly implied that she plans to kill the Charmings once Emma finds Lily for her.reunites her with Lily.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceJobBreakingItHero: The Apprentince decided to seek out Lily and tell her everything because he felt she had a right to know why here life sucked. Unfortunely it led to Lily developing a near homicidal obession with Emma and her parents.

to:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: The Apprentince decided to seek out Lily and tell her everything because he felt she had a right to know why here her life sucked. Unfortunely it led to Lily developing a near homicidal obession with Emma and her parents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** PetTheDog: But by the end he entrusted Will with protecting Belle's heart because he felt unworthy.

to:

** PetTheDog: But by the end he entrusted Will with protecting Belle's heart because he felt unworthy.unworthy.
* NiceJobBreakingItHero: The Apprentince decided to seek out Lily and tell her everything because he felt she had a right to know why here life sucked. Unfortunely it led to Lily developing a near homicidal obession with Emma and her parents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** PetTheDog: by the end he entrusted Will with protecting Belle's heart because he felt unworthy.

to:

** PetTheDog: But by the end he entrusted Will with protecting Belle's heart because he felt unworthy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KickTheDog: Gold tells Will he's not as close to Bell as he thinks since he didn't notice that her heart had been swiped.

to:

* KickTheDog: Gold tells Will he's not as close to Bell Belle as he thinks since he didn't notice that her heart had been swiped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A straighter example would be Zelena's pregnacy with Robin's child, thus prevents him from leaving her and keep Regina from her happy ending.

to:

** A straighter example would be Zelena's pregnacy with Robin's child, thus which prevents him from leaving her and keep keeps Regina from her happy ending.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KickTheDog: Gold tells Will he's not as close to Bell as he thinks since he didn't notice that her heart had been swiped.

to:

* KickTheDog: Gold tells Will he's not as close to Bell as he thinks since he didn't notice that her heart had been swiped.swiped.
** PetTheDog: by the end he entrusted Will with protecting Belle's heart because he felt unworthy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilVsEvil: Maleficent has abandoned Gold after Cruella's death and throws her lot in with the others so Emma can find her daughter. But Gold being Gold, this actually works out in his favor.

to:

* EvilVsEvil: Maleficent has abandoned Gold after Cruella's death and throws her lot in with the others so Emma can find her daughter. But Gold being Gold, this actually works out in his favor.favor.
* KickTheDog: Gold tells Will he's not as close to Bell as he thinks since he didn't notice that her heart had been swiped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''Season 4, Episode 19''':
!Lily

Emma’s potential for darkness is looming over everyone, but when Emma realizes Maleficent's daughter Lily is in fact her closest friend from her foster care days, she resolves to find Lily and reunite her with her mother. Regina joins forces with Emma and together they set out to track down Lily and to warn Robin about Zelena. However, neither of them is prepared for the harsh realities they’ll encounter in the outside world. Meanwhile, in Storybrooke, Gold faces a crisis involving Belle. In a foster care flashback, things are looking up for young Emma with her new family until Lily’s appearance threatens to destabilize everything.


!!Tropes:
* DiabolusExMachina: In-universe, this is Lily's life in a nutshell. Something will always happen to screw with her.
** A straighter example would be Zelena's pregnacy with Robin's child, thus prevents him from leaving her and keep Regina from her happy ending.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnemyMine: Maleficent teams up with the others to stop Gold. However it's heavilly implied that she plans to kill the Charmings once Emma finds Lily for her.
* EvilVsEvil: Maleficent has abandoned Gold after Cruella's death and throws her lot in with the others so Emma can find her daughter. But Gold being Gold, this actually works out in his favor.

Top