Follow TV Tropes

Following

History PlayingWith / ManicPixieDreamGirl

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


** Alice wants to make Bob's life better, but as it turns out, there's a deeper reason for why her methods aren't working. As it turns out, Alice and Bob are both nihilists who believes that life is meaningless and that existence is pointless. But the difference between them is that while Bob is a perpetually depressed StrawNihilist BrokenBird, Alice is TheAntiNihilist who wears a happy MaskOfSanity. On the inside, they're both equally broken and empty, but the difference is that Alice uses the meaninglessness of life as an excuse to do whatever she wants and to be happy, Bob uses it as an excuse to always be sad and miserable. Eventually, they both figure out that they're NotSoDifferent from each other and that they're essentially cut from the same cloth, but this results in them confronting each other and getting into a massive argument over their respective viewpoints and life philosophies. Bob is trying to convince Alice that she's wrong because [[SillyRabbitIdealismIsForKids idealism is for kids]], while Alice wants to convince Bob that he's wrong because [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers cynicism is for losers]]. Their inherently incompatible existentialist views have a negative impact on their relationship, and out of stubbornness, neither of them wants to concede that the other might have a point, so their friendship ends up getting seriously strained. Basically, Alice accidentally made Bob become even more secluded and lonely than before, and she ends up blaming herself for it.

to:

** Alice wants to make Bob's life better, but as it turns out, there's a deeper reason for why her methods aren't working. As it turns out, Alice and Bob are both nihilists who believes that life is meaningless and that existence is pointless. But the difference between them is that while Bob is a perpetually depressed StrawNihilist BrokenBird, Alice is TheAntiNihilist who wears a happy MaskOfSanity. On the inside, they're both equally broken and empty, but the difference is that Alice uses the meaninglessness of life as an excuse to do whatever she wants and to be happy, Bob uses it as an excuse to always be sad and miserable. Eventually, they both figure out that they're NotSoDifferent no different from each other and that they're essentially cut from the same cloth, but this results in them confronting each other and getting into a massive argument over their respective viewpoints and life philosophies. Bob is trying to convince Alice that she's wrong because [[SillyRabbitIdealismIsForKids idealism is for kids]], while Alice wants to convince Bob that he's wrong because [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers cynicism is for losers]]. Their inherently incompatible existentialist views have a negative impact on their relationship, and out of stubbornness, neither of them wants to concede that the other might have a point, so their friendship ends up getting seriously strained. Basically, Alice accidentally made Bob become even more secluded and lonely than before, and she ends up blaming herself for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice wants to make Bob’s life better, but as it turns out, there’s a deeper reason for why her methods aren’t working. As it turns out, Alice and Bob are both nihilists who believes that life is meaningless and that existence is pointless. But the difference between them is that while Bob is a perpetually depressed StrawNihilist BrokenBird, Alice is TheAntiNihilist who wears a happy MaskOfSanity. On the inside, they’re both equally broken and empty, but the difference is that Alice uses the meaninglessness of life as an excuse to do whatever she wants and to be happy, Bob uses it as an excuse to always be sad and miserable. Eventually, they both figure out that they’re NotSoDifferent from each other and that they’re essentially cut from the same cloth, but this results in them confronting each other and getting into a massive argument over their respective viewpoints and life philosophies. Bob is trying to convince Alice that she’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitIdealismIsForKids idealism is for kids]], while Alice wants to convince Bob that he’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers cynicism is for losers]]. Their inherently incompatible existentialist views have a negative impact on their relationship, and out of stubbornness, neither of them wants to concede that the other might have a point, so their friendship ends up getting seriously strained.

to:

** Alice wants to make Bob’s life better, but as it turns out, there’s a deeper reason for why her methods aren’t working. As it turns out, Alice and Bob are both nihilists who believes that life is meaningless and that existence is pointless. But the difference between them is that while Bob is a perpetually depressed StrawNihilist BrokenBird, Alice is TheAntiNihilist who wears a happy MaskOfSanity. On the inside, they’re both equally broken and empty, but the difference is that Alice uses the meaninglessness of life as an excuse to do whatever she wants and to be happy, Bob uses it as an excuse to always be sad and miserable. Eventually, they both figure out that they’re NotSoDifferent from each other and that they’re essentially cut from the same cloth, but this results in them confronting each other and getting into a massive argument over their respective viewpoints and life philosophies. Bob is trying to convince Alice that she’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitIdealismIsForKids idealism is for kids]], while Alice wants to convince Bob that he’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers cynicism is for losers]]. Their inherently incompatible existentialist views have a negative impact on their relationship, and out of stubbornness, neither of them wants to concede that the other might have a point, so their friendship ends up getting seriously strained. Basically, Alice accidentally made Bob become even more secluded and lonely than before, and she ends up blaming herself for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As it turns out, Alice and Bob are both nihilists who believes that life is meaningless and that existence is pointless. But the difference between them is that while Bob is a perpetually depressed StrawNihilist BrokenBird, Alice is TheAntiNihilist who wears a happy MaskOfSanity. On the inside, they’re both equally broken and empty, but the difference is that Alice uses the meaninglessness of life as an excuse to do whatever she wants and to be happy, Bob uses it as an excuse to always be sad and miserable. Eventually, they both figure out that they’re NotSoDifferent from each other and that they’re essentially cut from the same cloth, but this results in them confronting each other and getting into a massive debate over their respective viewpoints and life philosophies. Bob is trying to convince Alice that she’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitIdealismIsForKids idealism is for kids]], while Alice wants to convince Bob that he’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers cynicism is for losers]]. Their inherently incompatible existentialist views have a negative impact on their relationship, and out of stubbornness, neither of them wants to concede that the other might have a point, so their friendship ends up getting seriously strained.

to:

** Alice wants to make Bob’s life better, but as it turns out, there’s a deeper reason for why her methods aren’t working. As it turns out, Alice and Bob are both nihilists who believes that life is meaningless and that existence is pointless. But the difference between them is that while Bob is a perpetually depressed StrawNihilist BrokenBird, Alice is TheAntiNihilist who wears a happy MaskOfSanity. On the inside, they’re both equally broken and empty, but the difference is that Alice uses the meaninglessness of life as an excuse to do whatever she wants and to be happy, Bob uses it as an excuse to always be sad and miserable. Eventually, they both figure out that they’re NotSoDifferent from each other and that they’re essentially cut from the same cloth, but this results in them confronting each other and getting into a massive debate argument over their respective viewpoints and life philosophies. Bob is trying to convince Alice that she’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitIdealismIsForKids idealism is for kids]], while Alice wants to convince Bob that he’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers cynicism is for losers]]. Their inherently incompatible existentialist views have a negative impact on their relationship, and out of stubbornness, neither of them wants to concede that the other might have a point, so their friendship ends up getting seriously strained.

Added: 1415

Changed: 152

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Played For Drama''': Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim... because she has 6 months to live and is trying to fulfill her bucket list.

to:

* '''Played For Drama''': Drama''':
**
Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim... because she has 6 months to live and is trying to fulfill her bucket list.list.
** As it turns out, Alice and Bob are both nihilists who believes that life is meaningless and that existence is pointless. But the difference between them is that while Bob is a perpetually depressed StrawNihilist BrokenBird, Alice is TheAntiNihilist who wears a happy MaskOfSanity. On the inside, they’re both equally broken and empty, but the difference is that Alice uses the meaninglessness of life as an excuse to do whatever she wants and to be happy, Bob uses it as an excuse to always be sad and miserable. Eventually, they both figure out that they’re NotSoDifferent from each other and that they’re essentially cut from the same cloth, but this results in them confronting each other and getting into a massive debate over their respective viewpoints and life philosophies. Bob is trying to convince Alice that she’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitIdealismIsForKids idealism is for kids]], while Alice wants to convince Bob that he’s wrong because [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers cynicism is for losers]]. Their inherently incompatible existentialist views have a negative impact on their relationship, and out of stubbornness, neither of them wants to concede that the other might have a point, so their friendship ends up getting seriously strained.

Added: 753

Changed: 779

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Reconstructed''': Alice and Bob eventually [[CharacterDevelopment develop as people]], and reach an agreeable compromise; Bob breaks out of his shell and becomes more willing to try new things out, while Alice settles down and becomes a mature (but still fun-loving) woman.

to:

** In spite of their differences, Alice and Bob get along well and she ''does'' help make his life better…but at the same time, Alice is also crazy. Not just in a harmless CloudCuckoolander kind of way, but genuinely crazy. She’s not evil, but she operates on borderline BlueAndOrangeMorality, and even Bob struggles to keep up with her sometimes, thus forcing Bob to often act as the OnlySaneMan to balance out Alice’s antics. They’re good friends, but Alice’s loony personality is responsible for getting them both in as much trouble as it helps make their lives better. Thus, while Alice will help Bob improve his own life and become a better person, the catch is that he also has to look out for Alice as much as she looks out for him.
* '''Reconstructed''': '''Reconstructed''':
**
Alice and Bob eventually [[CharacterDevelopment develop as people]], and reach an agreeable compromise; Bob breaks out of his shell and becomes more willing to try new things out, while Alice settles down and becomes a mature (but still fun-loving) woman.woman.
** Alice and Bob still manage to become good friends in spite of their differences, and they both recognize and accept each other’s flaws. They also realize that they should stick together from now on, because they make up for each other’s flaws too. Bob helps Alice stay grounded when she goes too far off the rails, while Alice cheers up Bob whenever he feels down and she helps him think outside the box. They hang out a lot together, and they become a CynicIdealistDuo.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Bob sighs endearingly, and turns to the camera.''\\

to:

''Bob ''[Bob sighs endearingly, and turns to the camera.''\\]''\\

Added: 1104

Changed: 173

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Gender inverted''':

to:

* '''Gender inverted''':Inverted''':



* '''Parodied''': Alice is a ChaoticStupid ''[[InterspeciesRomance literal]]'' [[TheFairFolk pixie]], and Bob is a ScheduleFanatic. [[NoAccountingForTaste They've been married for years]].

to:

* '''Parodied''': '''Parodied''':
**
Alice is a ChaoticStupid ''[[InterspeciesRomance literal]]'' [[TheFairFolk pixie]], and Bob is a ScheduleFanatic. [[NoAccountingForTaste They've been married for years]].years]].
** To Bob, Alice is a marvelous girl who's not afraid to take risks and always shows him something new. To [[UnsympatheticComedyProtagonist Alice]], Bob is a very easy accomplice.
-->'''Alice:''' Oh, no, it's terrible! I just met up with the guy who swindled me out of $5000, and I tried cutting off a loose string from his tuxedo with this knife, and now he's not moving! You've gotta help me move his body to that ditch over there so he can recover!\\
'''Bob:''' I dunno, Alice, ever since we had to flee Milton because you [[NoodleIncident accidentally drew money from the bank vault instead of your account,]] I'm starting to think you might be roping me into something!\\
'''Alice:''' Why, that would just be unladylike! [[ImpliedDeathThreat And I would never let someone walk around thinking of me as unladylike.]]\\
''Bob sighs endearingly, and turns to the camera.''\\
'''Bob:''' [[ComicallyMissingThePoint Ain't she an angel?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alice is "zany and different" because she ''is'' different, in a way Bob wouldn't actually tolerate. (Perhaps she's queer, or plural, or neurodivergent.) She makes sure only to present the "positive" qualities of being different, which ends up wearing her out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alice feels sorry for Bob and tries to help him out of sympathy. The feelings grow over time.
** Alice used to be like Bob and had people who brought her out of it, so she sees helping him as paying it forward.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice's life is pretty typical until she meets Bob, a CrazyAwesome professional [[LeParkour Free Runner]] with a quirky sense of humor.

to:

** Alice's life is pretty typical until she meets Bob, a CrazyAwesome CrazyIsCool professional [[LeParkour Free Runner]] with a quirky sense of humor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alice's childlike and immature personality quickly goes from novel to infuriating, and Bob realizes that the relationship has run its course and he feels more like an exasperated parent with an irresponsible child who refuses to grow up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Except all that was a JerkassFacade, and he eventually caves in.

to:

** Except all that was a JerkassFacade, just an act, and he eventually caves in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alice has dated several guys like Bob who use her to make their lives feel meaningful and dump her once they feel they have outgrown her. By the time Bob has come around, Alice is a BrokenBird who believes that love doesn't exist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Back to ManicPixieDreamGirl

to:

Back to ManicPixieDreamGirlManicPixieDreamGirl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ArmouredClosetGay Alice meets the loud and proud LipstickLesbian (because who are we kidding) Claire, who helps her put down her defenses and helps her [[ClosetKey embrace her true self]].

to:

** ArmouredClosetGay Alice meets the loud and proud LipstickLesbian (because who are we kidding) Claire, who helps her put down her defenses and helps her [[ClosetKey embrace her true self]].

Changed: 6

Removed: 35

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bob used to be a {{Badass}} whose life was filled with adventure, until he fell in love with Alice and [[RetiredBadass happily settled down into a more mundane life]].

to:

** Bob used to be a {{Badass}} badass whose life was filled with adventure, until he fell in love with Alice and [[RetiredBadass happily settled down into a more mundane life]].



%%* '''Plotted A Good Waste''': ???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice is an EmotionlessGirl, probably an UnkemptBeauty, who has a [[TheCynic hard time trusting people]]. In comes FunPersonified-Bob, who is all kinds of [[TheCharmer charming]], and tares down her [[DefrostingIceQueen metaphorical emotional walls.]]

to:

** Alice is an EmotionlessGirl, probably an UnkemptBeauty, who has a [[TheCynic hard time trusting people]]. In comes FunPersonified-Bob, who is all kinds of [[TheCharmer charming]], and tares tears down her [[DefrostingIceQueen metaphorical emotional walls.]]

Added: 382

Changed: 117

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Averted''': Alice ends up dating the equally wacky Charlie, and/or Bob settles down with the demure, down-to-earth GirlNextDoor.

to:

* '''Averted''': Alice '''Averted''':
**Alice
ends up dating the equally wacky Charlie, and/or Bob settles down with the demure, down-to-earth GirlNextDoor.GirlNextDoor.
**Bob realizes that Charlie set them up [[IJustWantMyBelovedToBeHappy because he wanted him to let go of his crush and let him find someone]]. Bob realizes this and [[RaceForYourLove chases after him before he goes back to Minnesota]] in order to confess his love.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed a wick for a split trope


** It turns out Bob doesn't ''want'' chaos and fun in his life; he's a content CreatureOfHabit, and wants Alice to [[StopHelpingMe just leave him alone]].

to:

** It turns out Bob doesn't ''want'' chaos and fun in his life; he's a content CreatureOfHabit, and wants Alice to [[StopHelpingMe [[UnwantedAssistance just leave him alone]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* '''Gender inverted''':
** Alice is an EmotionlessGirl, probably an UnkemptBeauty, who has a [[TheCynic hard time trusting people]]. In comes FunPersonified-Bob, who is all kinds of [[TheCharmer charming]], and tares down her [[DefrostingIceQueen metaphorical emotional walls.]]
** ArmouredClosetGay Alice meets the loud and proud LipstickLesbian (because who are we kidding) Claire, who helps her put down her defenses and helps her [[ClosetKey embrace her true self]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Zig Zagged''': Alice shows perky, optimistic Bob that life isn't really all it's cracked up to be, but through this Bob re-defines his values and finds true hapiness and has a stronger sense of self.

to:

* '''Zig Zagged''': Alice shows perky, optimistic Bob that life isn't really all it's cracked up to be, but through this Bob re-defines his values and finds true hapiness happiness and has a stronger sense of self.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Downplayed''': Instead of a whirlwind girlfriend who sweeps Bob off his feet, Alice cis a new friend who helps him think outside the box, and gives him a bit of help with his problems -- and he can return the favor, because Alice has a life outside of Bob.

to:

* '''Downplayed''': Instead of a whirlwind girlfriend who sweeps Bob off his feet, Alice cis is a new friend who helps him think outside the box, and gives him a bit of help with his problems -- and he can return the favor, because Alice has a life outside of Bob.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Downplayed''': Instead of a whirlwind girlfriend who sweeps Bob off his feet, Alice comes into his life as a new friend who helps him think outside the box, and doesn't fix all of his life's problems, but gives him a bit of perspective -- and he can return the favor, because Alice has a life outside of Bob.

to:

* '''Downplayed''': Instead of a whirlwind girlfriend who sweeps Bob off his feet, Alice comes into his life as cis a new friend who helps him think outside the box, and doesn't fix all of his life's problems, but gives him a bit of perspective help with his problems -- and he can return the favor, because Alice has a life outside of Bob.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Played For Drama''': Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim...because she has 6 months to live and is trying to fulfill her bucket list.

to:

* '''Played For Drama''': Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim... because she has 6 months to live and is trying to fulfill her bucket list.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bob is actually the one chasing Alice, thinking she'll help him and give his life meaning. Alice wants him and every other guy who thinks she can fix them to just leave her alone.

Added: 177

Removed: 154

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim...because she has 6 months to live and is trying to fulfill her bucket list.


Added DiffLines:

* '''Played For Drama''': Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim...because she has 6 months to live and is trying to fulfill her bucket list.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim...because she has 6 months to live.

to:

** Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim...because she has 6 months to live.live and is trying to fulfill her bucket list.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim...because she has 6 months to live and is trying to fulfill her BucketList.

to:

** Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim...because she has 6 months to live and is trying to fulfill her BucketList.live.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alice acts like there's no tomorrow and does random crazy things on a whim...because she has 6 months to live and is trying to fulfill her BucketList.

Top