Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / RelativelyFlimsyExcuse

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In TerryPratchett's ''{{Strata}}'', it's a running gag that when people ask the protagonist for her autograph, they always claim it's for a relative, not for themselves.

to:

* In TerryPratchett's ''{{Strata}}'', Creator/TerryPratchett's ''Literature/{{Strata}}'', it's a running gag that when people ask the protagonist for her autograph, they always claim it's for a relative, not for themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''That70sShow'', the gay couple who move in next door to the Foreman's mention that in their last place they lived they had to claim to be brothers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On the ''AmericanDad'' two-parter where the family goes to Saudi Arabia, Haley is going to be arrested for [[NoWomansLand being outside her home without a man]] when a random Saudi man comes forward and claims to be her brother. Possibly based on the ''Aladdin'' example above, especially since he winds up being her BoyOfTheWeek.
* In ''CodeLyoko'', after Aelita is retrieved from the virtual world, she had no known family or history that can be freely divulged without breaking TheMasquerade. To deal with this, the crew passed her off as Odd's cousin. She also had a FakeOutMakeOut with Odd in a later episode, but the issue was never addressed beyond that.

to:

* On the ''AmericanDad'' ''WesternAnimation/AmericanDad'' two-parter where the family goes to Saudi Arabia, Haley is going to be arrested for [[NoWomansLand being outside her home without a man]] when a random Saudi man comes forward and claims to be her brother. Possibly based on the ''Aladdin'' example above, especially since he winds up being her BoyOfTheWeek.
* In ''CodeLyoko'', ''WesternAnimation/CodeLyoko'', after Aelita is retrieved from the virtual world, she had no known family or history that can be freely divulged without breaking TheMasquerade. To deal with this, the crew passed her off as Odd's cousin. She also had a FakeOutMakeOut with Odd in a later episode, but the issue was never addressed beyond that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Played with in one episode of ''{{Futurama}},'' when Fry tries to deflect attention from what the Professor is saying by claiming that "Grandpa" is a bit senile. The Professor then angrily points out that he's not Fry's grandfather, Fry is actually is great-great-etc.-grandfather from a thousand years in the past...which of course, [[RefugeInAudacity just makes Fry's lie seem more accurate]].

to:

* Played with in one episode of ''{{Futurama}},'' when Fry tries to deflect attention from what the Professor is saying by claiming that "Grandpa" is a bit senile. The Professor then angrily points out that he's not Fry's grandfather, Fry is actually is his great-great-etc.-grandfather -uncle from a thousand years in the past...which of course, [[RefugeInAudacity just makes Fry's lie seem more accurate]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace shift


* In ''PrincessProtectionProgram'' Carter has to pretend that Rosie is her cousin.

to:

* In ''PrincessProtectionProgram'' ''Film/PrincessProtectionProgram'' Carter has to pretend that Rosie is her cousin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Lesbians sometimes will say that someone is a "sister" to indicate that she is a lesbian. Less common now, it was much more common when it was dangerous to be out to the general public, women could say they were sisters, that someone was a sister, or inquire whether someone was a sister, or So-and-so's sister ("So-and-so" might be the name of the person suspected of being her girlfriend, or it might be a name that a particular community used; "Leslie" was a common one, and so were some of the names of popular musicians, like "Meg" and "Chris") as a coded way of indicating or inquiring about sexuality without accidentally outing the person, or herself, in doing so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** And that it once happened immediately after they made out. ("We're close.")
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[AlienAmongUs Ax]] is introduced as Jake's "cousin Phillip" when he tries to visit their school in {{Animorphs}}, though to be fair, [[VoluntaryShapeshifting his disguise]] does include DNA from Jake and his actual cousin. They don't seem to think about the fact that Jake's brother and their school's vice principal are both enslaved by the mind-controlling aliens the Animorphs are fighting and could tear this story apart if they were to encounter "Phillip" ... Though this could be justified in that Jake's brother doesn't seem to go to their school and the vice principal presumably doesn't have every student's family tree memorized.

to:

* [[AlienAmongUs Ax]] is introduced as Jake's "cousin Phillip" when he tries to visit their school in {{Animorphs}}, ''Literature/{{Animorphs}}'', though to be fair, [[VoluntaryShapeshifting his disguise]] does include DNA from Jake and his actual cousin. They don't seem to think about the fact that Jake's brother and their school's vice principal are both enslaved by the mind-controlling aliens the Animorphs are fighting and could tear this story apart if they were to encounter "Phillip" ... Though this could be justified in that Jake's brother doesn't seem to go to their school and the vice principal presumably doesn't have every student's family tree memorized.

Changed: 11

Removed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''TheLastUnicorn'', Schmendrick tells King Haggard that the Lady Amalthea is his niece. Haggard doesn't believe him, but he doesn't really care.

to:

* In ''TheLastUnicorn'', ''Literature/TheLastUnicorn'', Schmendrick tells King Haggard that the Lady Amalthea is his niece. Haggard doesn't believe him, but he doesn't really care.



----
<<|FamilyTropes|>>

to:

----
<<|FamilyTropes|>>
----

Changed: 417

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* [[AlienAmongUs Ax]] is introduced as Jake's "cousin Phillip" when he tries to visit their school in {{Animorphs}}, though to be fair, [[VoluntaryShapeshifting his disguise]] does include DNA from Jake and his actual cousin.

to:

* [[AlienAmongUs Ax]] is introduced as Jake's "cousin Phillip" when he tries to visit their school in {{Animorphs}}, though to be fair, [[VoluntaryShapeshifting his disguise]] does include DNA from Jake and his actual cousin. They don't seem to think about the fact that Jake's brother and their school's vice principal are both enslaved by the mind-controlling aliens the Animorphs are fighting and could tear this story apart if they were to encounter "Phillip" ... Though this could be justified in that Jake's brother doesn't seem to go to their school and the vice principal presumably doesn't have every student's family tree memorized.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Superbook}}'', a Bible character who met Chris and Joy when she was younger remarks about this, and they claim to be their own descendants, rather than explain that they have this book that sends them back to different points in Bible times.

to:

* In ''{{Superbook}}'', a Bible character who met Chris and Joy when she was younger remarks about this, and they claim to be their own descendants, rather than explain that they have this book that sends them back to different points in Bible times.
times.
* In the BeachEpisode of ''MayoChiki'', the cast members who aren't in on [[{{bifauxnen}} Subaru's secret]] make an unexpected appearance and the main characters, in trying to deflect the question of why Subaru is in a bikini, introduce her as "Subaru's cousin Punyuru". Jirou immediately [[LampshadeHanging lampshades]] the ridiculousness of this explanation (or, at least, the name), but the others buy it anyway (well, most of them).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[AliensAmongUs Ax]] is introduced as Jake's "cousin Phillip" when he tries to visit their school in {{Animorphs}}, though to be fair, [[VoluntaryShapshifting his disguise]] does include DNA from Jake and his actual cousin.

to:

* [[AliensAmongUs [[AlienAmongUs Ax]] is introduced as Jake's "cousin Phillip" when he tries to visit their school in {{Animorphs}}, though to be fair, [[VoluntaryShapshifting [[VoluntaryShapeshifting his disguise]] does include DNA from Jake and his actual cousin.

Added: 997

Removed: 772

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''[[Literature/{{Twilight}} Breaking Dawn]]'', Edward tells Bella's father that Renesme is his niece that they're adopting. The kid is obviously their own, as she looks like Edward with Bella's eyes, but Charlie goes along with it because he doesn't want to know how they conceived and had a toddler within one month.
* TheBible has Abraham lie about Sara, his wife, and claims that she's only his sister in Egypt and Gerar (which is in his case, only bending the truth, as she is also his father's daughter), because he fears he would get killed out of jealousy by the king. Isaac does the same in Gerar with his wife.
* In ''TheLastUnicorn'', Schmendrick tells King Haggard that the Lady Amalthea is his niece. Haggard doesn't believe him, but he doesn't really care.


Added DiffLines:


* In ''[[Literature/{{Twilight}} Breaking Dawn]]'', Edward tells Bella's father that Renesme is his niece that they're adopting. The kid is obviously their own, as she looks like Edward with Bella's eyes, but Charlie goes along with it because he doesn't want to know how they conceived and had a toddler within one month.
* TheBible has Abraham lie about Sara, his wife, and claims that she's only his sister in Egypt and Gerar (which is in his case, only bending the truth, as she is also his father's daughter), because he fears he would get killed out of jealousy by the king. Isaac does the same in Gerar with his wife.
* In ''TheLastUnicorn'', Schmendrick tells King Haggard that the Lady Amalthea is his niece. Haggard doesn't believe him, but he doesn't really care.
* [[AliensAmongUs Ax]] is introduced as Jake's "cousin Phillip" when he tries to visit their school in {{Animorphs}}, though to be fair, [[VoluntaryShapshifting his disguise]] does include DNA from Jake and his actual cousin.
Camacan MOD

Changed: 23

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alt-titles are for searching. Tropes have one name.


* {{Angel}} once claimed that Cordelia was "family" to get into the hospital after she had a psychotic breakdown. This was also played as him [[FriendsLikeFamily seeing her as family despite not being related.]]

to:

* {{Angel}} once claimed that Cordelia was "family" to get into the hospital after she had a psychotic breakdown. This was also played as him [[FriendsLikeFamily [[TrueCompanions seeing her as family despite not being related.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The ''UglyAmericans'' episode "Attack of Mark's Clone" has this occur when[[spoiler: Grimes finds Mark trapped in his closet, only to have Clone Mark (who had imprisoned him there and taken his place) walk in. Clone Mark briefly and very unconvincingly tries to claim Mark is his brother "who lives in the closet" but quickly gives up and shoots Grimes in the leg.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Mr. Hyunh on ''HeyArnold'' tries this in order to get a job promotion, tricking his boss into thinking Granpa Phil is his dad, Arnold is his son, Oskar's wife Suzie is his wife and the rest of the people living in the border house are related to him... of course, it doesn't work in the end - plus the fact that he's asian and noone else in his supposed family is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the Reigai arc, Nozomi claims to be Rukia's cousin-- Rukia's been living at Ichigo's place long enough that the Kurosaki family takes Nozomi in with no further questions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''SymBionicTitan'', Lance and Alana pretend to be brother and sister and that Octus is their father.

Added: 131

Changed: 30

Removed: 131

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In HigurashiNoNakuKoroNi, this is Rika's explanation for Hanyuu (as a cousin). Not too far off - [[spoiler:she is related. Just her great grandmother from at a bare minimum eight generations back]].
* Rito tells people Lala is a distant relative in ToLoveRu. No one really pays any attention to this fact, seeing as she loudly declared that she was his bride, and it's not like she's subtle in her affections either, subverting the whole point of the lie. (As an excuse to why they are living together.)

to:

* In HigurashiNoNakuKoroNi, ''HigurashiNoNakuKoroNi'', this is Rika's explanation for Hanyuu (as a cousin). Not too far off - [[spoiler:she is related. Just her great grandmother from at a bare minimum eight generations back]].
* Rito tells people Lala is a distant relative in ToLoveRu.''ToLoveRu''. No one really pays any attention to this fact, seeing as she loudly declared that she was his bride, and it's not like she's subtle in her affections either, subverting the whole point of the lie. (As an excuse to why they are living together.)



* In ''WendyWu:HomecomingWarrior'' Wendy tells everyone at school that Shen is her cousin.

to:

* In ''WendyWu:HomecomingWarrior'' ''WendyWuHomecomingWarrior'' Wendy tells everyone at school that Shen is her cousin.



* In the film version of {{Chicago}}, Roxie tells a neighbor that Fred Casely is her brother.

to:

* In the film version of {{Chicago}}, ''{{Chicago}}'', Roxie tells a neighbor that Fred Casely is her brother.



* In ''Aladdin,'' Aladdin saves Princess Jasmine from getting her hand cut off for accidental thievery by jumping in and claiming that his "sister" gets confused sometimes.

to:

* In ''Aladdin,'' ''Disney/{{Aladdin}}'', Aladdin saves Princess Jasmine from getting her hand cut off for accidental thievery by jumping in and claiming that his "sister" gets confused sometimes.



* In TerryPratchett's ''Strata'', it's a running gag that when people ask the protagonist for her autograph, they always claim it's for a relative, not for themselves.

to:

* In TerryPratchett's ''Strata'', ''{{Strata}}'', it's a running gag that when people ask the protagonist for her autograph, they always claim it's for a relative, not for themselves.



[[AC: Theater]]
* In ''{{Rent}}'' the lesbian couple claim to be sisters on occasion. Keep in mind that they are of different races.



[[AC: Theater]]
* In ''{{Rent}}'' the lesbian couple claim to be sisters on occasion. Keep in mind that they are of different races.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rito tells people Lala is a distant relative in ToLoveRu. No one really pays any attention to this fact, seeing as she loudly declared that she was his bride, and it's not like she's sutble in her affections either, subverting the whole point of the lie. (As an excuse to why they are living together.)

to:

* Rito tells people Lala is a distant relative in ToLoveRu. No one really pays any attention to this fact, seeing as she loudly declared that she was his bride, and it's not like she's sutble subtle in her affections either, subverting the whole point of the lie. (As an excuse to why they are living together.)
* In ''{{Superbook}}'', a Bible character who met Chris and Joy when she was younger remarks about this, and they claim to be their own descendants, rather than explain that they have this book that sends them back to different points in Bible times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''CodeLyoko'', after Aelita is retrieved from the virtual world, she had no known family or history that can be freely divulged without breaking TheMasquerade. To deal with this, the crew passed her off as Odd's cousin. She also had a FakeOutMakeOut with Odd in a later episode, but the issue was never addressed beyond that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''[[{{Twilight}} Breaking Dawn]]'', Edward tells Bella's father that Renesme is his niece that they're adopting. The kid is obviously their own, as she looks like Edward with Bella's eyes, but Charlie goes along with it because he doesn't want to know how they conceived and had a toddler within one month.

to:

* In ''[[{{Twilight}} ''[[Literature/{{Twilight}} Breaking Dawn]]'', Edward tells Bella's father that Renesme is his niece that they're adopting. The kid is obviously their own, as she looks like Edward with Bella's eyes, but Charlie goes along with it because he doesn't want to know how they conceived and had a toddler within one month.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And later on, when a Troll officer is ordered to stop [[UnstoppableRage Sgt. Detritus]] he instantly asks to go to his grandmother's funeral. Colon questions it, and he responds, "It's her or me, Sarge."

to:

** And later on, when a Troll officer is ordered to stop [[UnstoppableRage Sgt. Detritus]] he instantly asks to go to his grandmother's funeral. Colon questions it, and he responds, "It's "It her or me, Sarge."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Such excuses are generally not very believable and tend to rely on the listener not knowing enough about the subject or the so-called relative to be able to discredit it, but few characters even consider seeing through them.

to:

Such excuses are generally not very believable and tend to rely on the listener not knowing enough about the subject or the so-called relative to be able to discredit it, but few characters even consider seeing through them.
them. Its also possible that someone might see through it, but really don't want to call them on it. (Are YOU going to tell the vampire his "brother" does not look anything like him?)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Random Co-Worker:''' Hey, Sully, is the kid yours?//
'''Sullivan:''' No! She's, uh...//
'''Mike:''' She's his...brother's niece!//

to:

-->'''Random Co-Worker:''' Hey, Sully, is the kid yours?//
yours?\\
'''Sullivan:''' No! She's, uh...//
\\
'''Mike:''' She's his...brother's niece!//niece!\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also done rather humorously in a deleted scene:
-->'''Random Co-Worker:''' Hey, Sully, is the kid yours?//
'''Sullivan:''' No! She's, uh...//
'''Mike:''' She's his...brother's niece!//
'''Sullivan:''' *{{Beat}}* Which makes her my ''daughter.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Done in ''[[HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows]]'' the seventh Harry Potter book, when Harry pretends to be Ron's cousin at Bill's wedding. Possibly subverted in that though Harry takes Polyjuice Potion, the kid he's mimicking is just a red-headed boy from the town the Weasleys live near, not an actual Weasley. It works pretty well though- so well that one of Ron's uncles wonders if Harry's his son.

to:

* Done in ''[[HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows]]'' ''HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows'' the seventh Harry Potter book, when Harry pretends to be Ron's cousin at Bill's wedding. Possibly subverted in that though Harry takes Polyjuice Potion, the kid he's mimicking is just a red-headed boy from the town the Weasleys live near, not an actual Weasley. It works pretty well though- so well that one of Ron's uncles wonders if Harry's his son.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''BackToTheFuture'', Marty [=McFly=] introduces Doc Brown to his teenage mother as his "uncle".

to:

* In ''BackToTheFuture'', Marty [=McFly=] introduces Doc Brown to his teenage mother as his "uncle"."uncle."




to:

* In ''Aladdin,'' Aladdin saves Princess Jasmine from getting her hand cut off for accidental thievery by jumping in and claiming that his "sister" gets confused sometimes.



* Done in [[HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows]] the seventh Harry Potter book, when Harry pretends to be Ron's cousin at Bill's wedding. Possibly subverted in that though Harry takes Polyjuice Potion, the kid he's mimicking is just a red-headed boy from the town the Weasleys live near, not an actual Weasley. It works pretty well though- so well that one of Ron's uncles wonders if Harry's his son.

to:

* Done in [[HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows]] ''[[HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows]]'' the seventh Harry Potter book, when Harry pretends to be Ron's cousin at Bill's wedding. Possibly subverted in that though Harry takes Polyjuice Potion, the kid he's mimicking is just a red-headed boy from the town the Weasleys live near, not an actual Weasley. It works pretty well though- so well that one of Ron's uncles wonders if Harry's his son.






* Subverted by one episode of ''{{Futurama}}'' in that Fry claims the Professor is his grandfather. In reality, Fry is the Professor's uncle from the year 2000, something the Professor lampshades.

to:

* Subverted by Played with in one episode of ''{{Futurama}}'' in that ''{{Futurama}},'' when Fry claims tries to deflect attention from what the Professor is his grandfather. In reality, Fry saying by claiming that "Grandpa" is the Professor's uncle from the year 2000, something the a bit senile. The Professor lampshades.then angrily points out that he's not Fry's grandfather, Fry is actually is great-great-etc.-grandfather from a thousand years in the past...which of course, [[RefugeInAudacity just makes Fry's lie seem more accurate]].




to:

* On the ''AmericanDad'' two-parter where the family goes to Saudi Arabia, Haley is going to be arrested for [[NoWomansLand being outside her home without a man]] when a random Saudi man comes forward and claims to be her brother. Possibly based on the ''Aladdin'' example above, especially since he winds up being her BoyOfTheWeek.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''KillBill,'' the Bride tries to pass her ex-lover Bill off as her father when he unexpectedly shows up at her wedding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the film version of {{Chicago}}, Roxie tells a neighbor that Fred Casely is her brother.



* In ''{{Rent}}'' the lesbian couple claim to be sisters on occasion.

to:

* In ''{{Rent}}'' the lesbian couple claim to be sisters on occasion. Keep in mind that they are of different races.

Top