Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / HaveYouToldAnyoneElse

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/WithoutAClue'': After Watson admits to his publisher (who is afraid the truth will hurt sales) that Holmes is a fictional character, the publisher asks if anyone else knows about this. Watson denies it, but after getting a raised eyebrow, admits his housekeeper and informants know the truth. Unusually, the publisher plans to threaten to sue Watson rather than harm him to keep the secret.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Krypton}}'': In "Blood Moon", [[spoiler:Jayna and Dev]] ask two {{Mook}}s they've just captured if anyone else know they are there. The two prisoners remain defiant and don't answer, but are spared after [[spoiler:Lyta]] convinces them to make a MookFaceTurn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Supergirl(2015)}}'' – Mild-mannered reporter Kara Danvers goes to the Oval Office, where she notices some kryptonite by the window, which she is told is because it was recently attacked by Supergirl.

to:

* ''Series/{{Supergirl(2015)}}'' ''{{Series/Supergirl|2015}}'' – Mild-mannered reporter Kara Danvers goes to the Oval Office, where she notices some kryptonite by the window, which she is told is because it was recently attacked by Supergirl.



''(Kara gives Baker a large envelope. Baker puts it in his desk draw without looking at it.)''\\

to:

''(Kara gives Baker a large envelope. Baker puts it in his desk draw drawer without looking at it.)''\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Supergirl

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Supergirl(2015)}}'' – Mild-mannered reporter Kara Danvers goes to the Oval Office, where she notices some kryptonite by the window, which she is told is because it was recently attacked by Supergirl.
-->''' Kara:''' The United States is in danger, sir.- I came here to warn you. Lex Luthor has allied with the Kaznian government and they are going to attack. And Supergirl didn't attack you. A clone that worked for Lex did. And your Chief of Staff is in collusion with them.\\
'''US President Baker (Bruce Boxleitner):''' Do you have... Do you have any proof?\\
''(Kara gives Baker a large envelope. Baker puts it in his desk draw without looking at it.)''\\
'''Baker''' Now, Ms. Danvers, has anyone else seen this evidence?\\
'''Kara:''' No, I thought it was more important to warn you as soon as possible.\\
'''Baker''' You did the right thing.\\
''(Baker presses a button under his desk. Someone puts a black bag over Kara's head). Episode ends.)''

Added: 737

Changed: 439

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Series/PokerFace'', Charlie carelessly volunteers the information that she hasn't told the FBI her deduction yet. As her suspects are a pair of nursing home residents it presumably didn't occur to her to think of them as a direct physical threat, but in fact they try to murder her on the spot and would have succeeded if the FBI hadn't arrived. She ''had'' been telling her contact her suspicions, she just hadn't told him the final clue she'd worked out.

to:

* ''Series/PokerFace'',
**
In ''Series/PokerFace'', episode 5, "Time of the Monkey", Charlie carelessly volunteers the information that she hasn't told the FBI her deduction yet. As her suspects are a pair of nursing home residents it presumably didn't occur to her to think of them as a direct physical threat, but in fact they try to murder her on the spot and would have succeeded if the FBI hadn't arrived. She ''had'' been telling her contact her suspicions, she just hadn't told him the final clue she'd worked out.out.
** In episode 8, "The Orpheus Syndrome", the opening murder victim Max affirms that no one else has seen the footage he's uncovered. Although the murderer had already poisoned his drink before hearing this part, only knowing he hasn't given it to the police yet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Series/PokerFace'', Charlie carelessly volunteers the information that she hasn't told the FBI her deduction yet. As her suspects are a pair of nursing home residents it presumably didn't occur to her to think of them as a direct physical threat, but in fact they try to murder her on the spot and would have succeeded if the FBI hadn't arrived. She ''had'' been telling her contact her suspicions, she just hadn't told him the final clue she'd worked out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ComicBook/{{Transformers|2019}}'': During a stand-off between the Autobots and a group of Risers led by Ruckus, Senator Soundwave (who is secretly a high-ranking Rise member) arrives to ostensibly negotiate. He goes into the Rise hideout, promises to arrange an escape route for them, then [[SchmuckBait asks if any of them know anything of value]]. Ruckus is [[TooDumbToLive too stupid to catch the implication and blithely confirms that he does]]. Soundwave then casually makes an excuse to leave, and as soon as he's at a safe distance, he detonates the explosive spear he had snuck in with him, [[HeKnowsTooMuch killing everyone in the bunker to keep their knowledge out of Autobot hands]].

to:

* ''ComicBook/{{Transformers|2019}}'': During a stand-off between the Autobots and a group of Risers led by Ruckus, Senator Soundwave (who is secretly a high-ranking Rise member) arrives to ostensibly negotiate. He goes into the Rise hideout, promises to arrange an escape route for them, then [[SchmuckBait asks if any of them know anything of value]]. Ruckus is [[TooDumbToLive too stupid to catch the implication and blithely confirms that he does]]. Soundwave then casually makes an excuse to leave, and as soon as he's at a safe distance, he detonates the explosive spear he had snuck in with him, [[HeKnowsTooMuch killing everyone in the bunker to keep their knowledge out of Autobot hands]]. Unlike most examples of this trope, Soundwave was rather obviously trying to hint that Ruckus should say "no" and was visibly disturbed by their deaths afterword.

Removed: 447

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
doesn't fit the trope description


* In a short story written by Creator/BertoltBrecht, a young boy cries in the street after being mugged. A man finds him there, and asks him why he hadn't called for help. The boy says he screamed as loudly as he could, but nobody heard him. The man then proceeds to rob the boy as well. This raises the obvious question: [[FridgeLogic Why?]] Did the second mugger [[IdiotBall expect the first mugger to have left the boy with anything valuable?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the thriller ''Film/NoWayOut1987'', a technician that the protagonist took into his confidence in an attempt to delay the BigBad's plan has an attack of conscience and tells... the BigBad, after which this trope is played out verbatim.

to:

* In the thriller ''Film/NoWayOut1987'', a technician that the protagonist Farrell took into his confidence confidence, in an attempt to delay the BigBad's plan developing of a Polaroid photo that shows his face, has an attack of conscience and tells... tells Pritchard, under the BigBad, after which assumption that he's a friend of Farrell. Unfortunately, Pritchard is the villain behind everything and so this trope is played out verbatim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ''VideoGame/WatchDogs'': Early in the story, a small-time crook, fresh from escaping a botched burglary that attracted a lot of police attention and left his partner dead at the scene, is brought to meet with the mob boss that ordered it. The boss takes the MacGuffin the crook stole, spends a couple minutes calming him down and telling him to relax, then quietly asks him "Get a chance to talk to your momma? Your friends? Your girl?" When the [[OhCrap now even more apprehensive]] crook replies no, the boss and his bodyguard jump him.

to:

* ''VideoGame/WatchDogs'': Early in the story, a small-time crook, fresh from escaping a botched burglary that attracted a lot of police attention and left his partner dead at the scene, is brought to meet with the mob boss that ordered it. The boss takes the MacGuffin the crook stole, spends a couple minutes calming him down and telling him to relax, then quietly asks him "Get a chance to talk to your momma? Your friends? Your girl?" When the [[OhCrap now even more apprehensive]] apprehensive crook replies no, the boss and his bodyguard jump him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the 1987 thriller ''Film/NoWayOut'', a technician that the protagonist took into his confidence in an attempt to delay the BigBad's plan has an attack of conscience and tells... the BigBad, after which this trope is played out verbatim.

to:

* In the 1987 thriller ''Film/NoWayOut'', ''Film/NoWayOut1987'', a technician that the protagonist took into his confidence in an attempt to delay the BigBad's plan has an attack of conscience and tells... the BigBad, after which this trope is played out verbatim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


* ''Literature/PresidentsVampire'''s ''Red, White and Blood'': Taken UpToEleven when President Curtis sends his Secret Service detail out of the room so that he can confront his traitorous vice-president privately.

to:

* ''Literature/PresidentsVampire'''s ''Red, White and Blood'': Taken UpToEleven when President Curtis sends his Secret Service detail out of the room so that he can confront his traitorous vice-president privately.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''[[Creator/JohnGrisham The Judge's List]]'': The SerialKiller captures an AmateurSleuth and asks her if Lacy, a judicial investigator who's been asking about him, also knows about his killings. His prisoner falsely denies this so he won't go after Lacy, but he's not convinced and leaves to kill her. He fails, and [[BondVillainStupidity when he comes back to finish off his prisoner, he finds that the police have already rescued her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheCourtJester'': A variant. Hawkins and Gene plan to kidnap Giacomo the jester and have Hawkins impersonate him. They express fake concern about whether he'll be able to get in and ask if he's sure no one at the castle has seen his fate. A few seconds after saying "Not yet", he gets a TapOnTheHead.

to:

* ''Film/TheCourtJester'': A variant. Hawkins and Gene plan to kidnap Giacomo the jester and have Hawkins impersonate him. They express fake concern about whether he'll be able to get in admitted to the castle and ask if he's sure no one at the castle there has seen his fate.face. A few seconds after saying "Not yet", he gets a TapOnTheHead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'': Had this happen to Roy when he tried to tell one of the top military brass about the GovernmentConspiracy with the Homunculi. Only to find out too late they were all in on it. [[spoiler: Fortunately they had left him alive with the threat of harm to his fellow soldiers. But this just allows Roy to rework his plan to take down the corrupted officials.]]

to:

* ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'': Had this happen to Roy when he tried to tell one of the top military brass about the GovernmentConspiracy with the Homunculi. Only to find out too late they were all in on it. [[spoiler: Fortunately they had left him alive with the threat of harm to his fellow soldiers. But soldiers—but this just allows Roy to rework his plan to take down the corrupted corrupt officials.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/DarkHeritage'', IntrepidReporter Clint Harrison meets up with [[spoiler:Mr. Daniels]] to tell him what he has learned about the Dansen clan and the murders. It is only after [[spoiler:Mr. Daniels]] asks him if he has shared his findings with anyone else does the truth start to dawn on him: that [[spoiler:Mr. Daniels]] is actually a member of the Dansen clan and plans to silence him before he can make his findings public.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheCorellianTrilogy'': Unusually, the person who fears the lethal effects of this trope is the one to ask the question. Han asks the Selonians who are showing him their secret tunnels if anyone else knows about them because of the answer if yes then they'll have less reason to kill him to keep their secret. He’s worried when they say he’s the first non-Selonian to learn this secret, but ultimately they let him leave alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/MoonBaseAlpha'': In the audio recording of Dr. Holtz's last moments, [[spoiler:His companion asks him if the aliens have made contact with anyone else. When Holtz says no, that person makes it clear that he shuns FirstContact and forces Holtz to commit suicide--by threatening his family--in an effort to delay an interplanetary meeting.]]

to:

* ''Literature/MoonBaseAlpha'': [[Literature/SpaceCase In the first book]], in the audio recording of Dr. Holtz's last moments, [[spoiler:His companion asks him if the aliens have made contact with anyone else. When Holtz says no, that person makes it clear that he shuns FirstContact and forces Holtz to commit suicide--by threatening his family--in an effort to delay an interplanetary meeting.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Applies in principle in ''Fanfic/AvengersInfiniteWars'' when the Avengers discover the programming chips in the clones and the existence of Order 66. Until they know more about the purpose of the chips and who might be responsible for them, they only tell their closest allies in the Senators and the Jedi about this particular discovery, allowing them to control the information until they have a plan to deal with the chips on a large scale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/MoonBaseAlpha'': In the audio recording of Dr. Holtz's last moments, [[spoiler:His companion asks him if the aliens have made contact with anyone else. When Holtz says no, that person makes it clear that he shuns FirstContact and forces Holtz to commit suicide--by threatening his family--in an effort to delay an interplanetary meeting.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheCourtJester'': A variant. Hawkins and Gene plan to kidnap Giacomo the jester and have Hawkins impersonate him. They express fake concern about whether he'll be able to get in and ask if he's sure no one at the castle has seen his fate. A few seconds after saying "Not yet", he gets a TapOnTheHead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Real Life]]
* Prevalent during the [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osage_Indian_murders Osage Reign of Terror]], when a real-life example of TheConspiracy plotted the murder of members of the oil-rich Osage tribe in order to take control of the oil. Multiple investigators figured out that [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Hale_(cattleman) William Hale]] was behind it before the FBI got involved, but every one of them had a bad habit of bragging about how they'd figured it out but holding off on telling anyone for a while, with the result that all of them were killed before they could name Hale.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/NoOrdinaryFamily'': In the second episode, the Watcher uses his powers to incapacitate [[spoiler:Detective Cho]] and asks if anyone else knows that [[spoiler:Reed Koblenz, whom she shot]], had teleportation powers. Jim knows, and in fact [[spoiler: Detective Cho]] didn't know until he told [[spoiler:her]], but [[spoiler:she]] lies that no one else knows, presumably suspecting that [[spoiler:she's]] dead either way and wanting to protect Jim. Sure enough, [[spoiler:Detective Cho]] is shot seconds later, but Jim and his family stay off the villains' radar for several more episodes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheDeep'': When salty treasure hunter Treece finds out that David and Gail have found a wreck he's heavily interested in, he asks who else knows about it. After a moment's pause, they truthfully reply that a local man named Bondurant has approached them about the wreck. However, it quickly becomes clear that Treece is a hero (or at least an AntiHero) and Bondurant is a ruthless crime lord.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/YoungSherlockHolmes'': In ''Death Cloud'', the villains capture Sherlock and demand to know who else he's told about the bee attacks. He names four of the five other people (leaving out someone who lives nearby and would be easier to kill than the other four) who know. Baron Maupertuis unhappily notes that this is too many people to kill (specially since they're not all close together) and decides he needs to accelerate his plan instead. He still tries to kill Sherlock, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/RedRockWest'': After Wayne discovers that Michael isn't the hitman he sent for to kill his wife, he demands to know if Michael has told anyone else about what Wayne tried to hire him to do. Hoping to calm the angry Wayne, Michael says that he hasn't told anyone and just wants to leave town. Wayne tries to kill him.

Added: 176

Changed: 155

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''WesternAnimation/Incredibles2'', Rick Dicker asks Tony this before he erases Tony's memories of Violet to check if he needs to do likewise to anyone else.
* A non-villain -- and non-lethal -- variant in ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'' short ''WesternAnimation/JackJackAttack''; [[TheMenInBlack Agent Dicker]] asks [[BadlyBatteredBabysitter Kari]] if she's told anyone else about her disastrous attempt to look after a suddenly superpowered baby, as he's setting up a device to give her LaserGuidedAmnesia.

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/Incredibles2'', Rick Dicker asks Tony this before he erases Tony's memories of Violet to check if he needs to do likewise to anyone else.
*
''Franchise/TheIncredibles'':
**
A non-villain -- and non-lethal -- variant in ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'' short ''WesternAnimation/JackJackAttack''; [[TheMenInBlack Agent Dicker]] asks [[BadlyBatteredBabysitter Kari]] if she's told anyone else about her disastrous attempt to look after a suddenly superpowered baby, as he's setting up a device to give her LaserGuidedAmnesia.LaserGuidedAmnesia.
** Happens again in ''WesternAnimation/Incredibles2'', Rick Dicker asks Tony this before he erases Tony's memories of Violet to check if he needs to do likewise to anyone else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Murder at the ABA'' follows an author, Darius Just, who suspects that a colleague of his was murdered. He discusses [[spoiler: how the hotel manager doesn’t believe him while having drinks with a security guard who seems sympathetic yet concerned that a murder investigation will make his employer look bad. He asks if Just has told his scandal-risking suspicions to anyone besides the manager, and Just untruthfully says that he hasn't The security guard is the killer and sends an assassin to try and kill Just a few hours later.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ComicBook/BatmanNoMansLand'': One ''Batman Legacy'' story has Bane getting sensitive information from an AlmightyJanitor in R'as al Ghul's palace. Bane doesn't want this information getting around, but doesn't want to kill anyone whose presence will be missed.
--> '''Bane:''' You said that The Demon scarcely regards you?
--> '''Shuram:''' As I said, I remain out of his sight. I perform my tasks beneath his notice.
--> '''Bane:''' Then he would hardly notice your absence?
--> '''Shuram:''' I suppose that is true. Why would-[[ExplainExplainOhCrap Oh]].
--> ''Cue ShadowDiscretionShot.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This gets asked several times in '' Film/MarginCall'' about the analysis showing the company is massively in debt while its purchased assets are losing value fast. The answer is always "Eric Dale", an employee that was fired that morning, prompting the CEO to send a goon after him. This being a more grounded film though, they merely tell him they'll either screw him on his severance pay, or they'll give him 3 million dollar to sit in a room for a day and not talk to anyone while the company sells all those assets to other firms before they too find out the assets are worthless.

Top