Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ExcaliburInTheStone

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


Not to be confused with SwordInTheStone or ExcaliburInTheRust. See also CowboyBebopAtHisComputer.

to:

Not to be confused with SwordInTheStone or ExcaliburInTheRust. See also CowboyBebopAtHisComputer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Most likely this is either an intentional reference or a confusion of the swords Excalibur and Joyeux, which where the swords of Arthur of England and Charlemange of Gaul respectively, and were sister swords that shared a third sister in Roland's sword Durendal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The film Excalibur attempts to use both versions; Merlin gets the sword from the Lady of the Lake himself and gives it to Uther to use to unite Britain. But, when Uther proves to be a jerk unworthy of being king by going to war with one of his vassals just so he can take the guy's wife, Merlin withdraws his support just as everyone starts rebelling. Uther ends up sticking Excalibur in a stone so that if he can't have it, then no one can. Later on Arthur, who was taken away by Merin and raised in secret, comes along and pulls Excalibur out of the stone simply because his foster brother Kay needs a sword for the tournament (the purpose of the tournament being, of course, to win a chance to try and pull the sword from the stone... Arthur was either extremely naive or not very bright.) Still later, Arthur manages to BREAK Excalibur and has to give it to the Lady of the Lake to be fixed.

to:

* The film Excalibur attempts to use both versions; Merlin gets the sword from the Lady of the Lake himself and gives it to Uther to use to unite Britain. But, when Uther proves to be a jerk unworthy of being king by going to war with one of his vassals just so he can take the guy's wife, Merlin withdraws his support just as everyone starts rebelling. Uther ends up sticking Excalibur in a stone so that if he can't have it, then no one can. Later on Arthur, who was taken away by Merin and raised in secret, comes along and pulls Excalibur out of the stone simply because his foster brother Kay needs a sword for the tournament (the purpose of the tournament being, of course, to win a chance to try and pull the sword from the stone... Arthur was either extremely naive or not very bright.) Still later, Arthur manages to BREAK Excalibur and has to give it to the Lady of the Lake to be fixed.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*The film Excalibur attempts to use both versions; Merlin gets the sword from the Lady of the Lake himself and gives it to Uther to use to unite Britain. But, when Uther proves to be a jerk unworthy of being king by going to war with one of his vassals just so he can take the guy's wife, Merlin withdraws his support just as everyone starts rebelling. Uther ends up sticking Excalibur in a stone so that if he can't have it, then no one can. Later on Arthur, who was taken away by Merin and raised in secret, comes along and pulls Excalibur out of the stone simply because his foster brother Kay needs a sword for the tournament (the purpose of the tournament being, of course, to win a chance to try and pull the sword from the stone... Arthur was either extremely naive or not very bright.) Still later, Arthur manages to BREAK Excalibur and has to give it to the Lady of the Lake to be fixed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Series/Merlin}}'', as of "The Coming of Arthur: Part 2". [[spoiler: The (technically still unnamed) sword that Merlin cast into the Lake of Avalon in the Season 1 episode "Excalibur" because it was too dangerous to use is retrieved by Freya (from the Season 2 episode "The Lady of the Lake") to defeat the undead army. And afterwards, since it's still too dangerous and it's been shown to be retrievable from the lake, Merlin takes it into the depths of the forest and drives it into a stone so it ''definitely'' can't be used again.]] Well, for now at least.

to:

* ''{{Series/Merlin}}'', as of "The Coming of Arthur: Part 2". [[spoiler: The (technically still unnamed) sword that Merlin cast into the Lake of Avalon in the Season 1 episode "Excalibur" because it was too dangerous to use is retrieved by Freya (from the Season 2 episode "The Lady of the Lake") to defeat the undead army. And afterwards, since it's still too dangerous and it's been shown to be retrievable from the lake, Merlin takes it into the depths of the forest and drives it into a stone so it ''definitely'' can't be used again.]] Well, for now at least.least; [[spoiler: The series 4 finale, "The Sword in the Stone", will see Arthur free it to prove his ability to reign]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Not to be confused with SwordInTheStone or ExcaliburInTheRust.

to:

Not to be confused with SwordInTheStone or ExcaliburInTheRust. See also CowboyBebopAtHisComputer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''BatmanTheBraveAndTheBold'' episode "Day of the Dark Knight!":

to:

* The ''BatmanTheBraveAndTheBold'' ''WesternAnimation/BatmanTheBraveAndTheBold'' episode "Day of the Dark Knight!":

Added: 188

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Series/Merlin}}'', as of "The Coming of Arthur: Part 2". [[spoiler: The (technically still unnamed) sword that Merlin cast into the Lake of Avalon in the Season 1 episode "Excalibur" because it was too dangerous to use is retrieved by Freya (from the Season 2 episode "The Lady of the Lake") to defeat the undead army. And afterwards, since it's still too dangeous and it's been shown to be retrievable from the lake, Merlin takes it into the depths of the forest and drives it into a stone so it ''definitely'' can't be used again.]] Well, for now at least.

to:

* ''{{Series/Merlin}}'', as of "The Coming of Arthur: Part 2". [[spoiler: The (technically still unnamed) sword that Merlin cast into the Lake of Avalon in the Season 1 episode "Excalibur" because it was too dangerous to use is retrieved by Freya (from the Season 2 episode "The Lady of the Lake") to defeat the undead army. And afterwards, since it's still too dangeous dangerous and it's been shown to be retrievable from the lake, Merlin takes it into the depths of the forest and drives it into a stone so it ''definitely'' can't be used again.]] Well, for now at least.



* Played with in Valerio Massimo Manfredi's historical fantasy, The Last Legion, in which "Excalibur" is actually the unnamed sword of Julius Ceasar. Following the battle at the novel's climax, the child-Emperor Romulas Augustus throws the sword so that it embeds itself in a stone in the middle of a lake. As if there were any confusion over the connection, the film of the book makes it even more obvious by the name Excalibur being derived from a partially obscured inscription, "E*** S*** Calibur***"

to:

* Played with in Valerio Massimo Manfredi's historical fantasy, The ''The Last Legion, Legion'', in which "Excalibur" is actually the unnamed sword of Julius Ceasar. Following the battle at the novel's climax, the child-Emperor Romulas Augustus throws the sword so that it embeds itself in a stone in the middle of a lake. As if there were any confusion over the connection, the film of the book makes it even more obvious by the name Excalibur being derived from a partially obscured inscription, "E*** S*** Calibur***"Calibur***"



* In the Infocom game ''ArthurTheQuestForExcalibur'', an usurper sinks the sword in the stone in a lake and swaps it with a fake that he can pull out to demonstrate that he's the true king. When the player wins the game, the Lady in the Lake parts the waters to reveal the real stone, sword included, and THEN Arthur pulls the sword out. Which sort of fulfills both legends, but not in the way most people picture it.

to:

* In the Infocom game ''ArthurTheQuestForExcalibur'', ''Arthur: The Quest For Excalibur'', an usurper sinks the sword in the stone in a lake and swaps it with a fake that he can pull out to demonstrate that he's the true king. When the player wins the game, the Lady in the Lake parts the waters to reveal the real stone, sword included, and THEN Arthur pulls the sword out. Which sort of fulfills both legends, but not in the way most people picture it.



** Which is actually a plot point-Arthur ''doesn't'' have Excalibur, but he'd very much like to. What he has is Excalibur's scabbard, which has it's own magical properties quite independent of the sword. [[spoiler: The reason Arthur doesn't have Excalibur, and Caliburn is able to transform into Excalibur at the end of the game, is because for some reason or another that doesn't make a whole lot of sense, Caliburn is Excalibur, minus the swords carried by Gawain, Percival, and Lancelot.]]

to:

** Which is actually a plot point-Arthur point - Arthur ''doesn't'' have Excalibur, but he'd very much like to. What he has is Excalibur's scabbard, which has it's own magical properties quite independent of the sword. [[spoiler: The reason Arthur doesn't have Excalibur, and Caliburn is able to transform into Excalibur at the end of the game, is because for some reason or another that doesn't make a whole lot of sense, Caliburn is Excalibur, minus the swords carried by Gawain, Percival, and Lancelot.]]


Added DiffLines:

* In {{Disney}}'s ''Disney/TheSwordInTheStone'', they never identify the sword by any name, Excalibur or otherwise. It's just the sword in the stone, thus skirting around the whole issue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*KingArthurTheRolePlayingWargame splits the difference, declaring that the Sword in the Stone is Excalibur but that it's full power cannot be unlocked until Arthur's meeting with the Lady of the Lake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Parodied by ''BlazingDragons'': it is one sword, but its name is an amalgam of both--"Excaliburn"--which is also a [[ThemeNaming a play on how everyone's names are related to firing or burning]].

to:

* Parodied by ''BlazingDragons'': it is one sword, sword (of unspecified origin), but its name is an amalgam of both--"Excaliburn"--which is also a [[ThemeNaming a play on how everyone's names are related to firing or burning]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Parodied by ''BlazingDragons'': it one sword, but its name is the exact same as this trope (is it the TropeNamer?), which is also a [[ThemeNaming a play on how everyone's names are related to firing or burning]].

to:

* Parodied by ''BlazingDragons'': it is one sword, but its name is the exact same as this trope (is it the TropeNamer?), which an amalgam of both--"Excaliburn"--which is also a [[ThemeNaming a play on how everyone's names are related to firing or burning]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Played with in Valerio Massimo Manfredi's historical fantasy, The Last Legion, in which "Excalibur" is actually the unnamed sword of Julius Ceasar. Following the battle at the novel's climax, the child-Emperor Romulas Augustus throws the sword so that it embeds itself in a stone in the middle of a lake. As if there were any confusion over the connection, the film of the book makes it even more obvious by the name Excalibur being derived from a partially obscured inscription, "E*** S*** Calibur***"
Camacan MOD

Changed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alt-titles are for searching. Tropes have one name.


Portrayals of KingArthur's sword {{Excalibur}} as the "Sword in the Stone". This is not the way the ArthurianLegend usually goes: Excalibur was the sword given to Arthur by the [[EmpoweringLakeLady Lady of the Lake]]. The one embedded in rock was nothing special (in most versions), except that it signified the right of the King to rule.

to:

Portrayals of KingArthur's sword {{Excalibur}} as the "Sword in the Stone". This is not the way the ArthurianLegend usually goes: Excalibur was the sword given to Arthur by the [[EmpoweringLakeLady [[EnigmaticEmpoweringEntity Lady of the Lake]]. The one embedded in rock was nothing special (in most versions), except that it signified the right of the King to rule.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Excalibur in ''SoulEater'' mixes both swords in regards to it location: It impales a rock inside a remote, watery cave inhabited by fairies, and legends claim only a 'true hero' can pull it from its resting place (which turns out to be untrue). Nothing is presently known about Excalibur's history (and therefore whether or not Arthur possessed another sword before it), apart from the fact that his [[MemeticMutation legend began in the 12th century, from United King he's looking for him, or that he's going to California]].

to:

* Excalibur in ''SoulEater'' mixes both swords in regards to it location: It impales a rock inside a remote, watery cave inhabited by fairies, and legends claim only a 'true hero' can pull it from its resting place (which turns out to be untrue). Nothing is presently known about Excalibur's history (and therefore whether or not Arthur possessed another sword before it), apart from the fact that his [[MemeticMutation legend began in dates back to the 12th century, from United King he's looking for him, or that he's going to California]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''SoulEater'' Excalibur can be obtained by a "true hero" if they pull it out of the pedestal it can be found him. Although in a twist [[spoiler: any meister can pull him out and claim him as their [[LivingWeapon partner]], but he's so insanely annoying and demanding (expecting his wielder to follow 1000 rules, including listening to him ramble for 5 hours every day) almost no one can put up with him]].

to:

* In Excalibur in ''SoulEater'' Excalibur can be obtained mixes both swords in regards to it location: It impales a rock inside a remote, watery cave inhabited by fairies, and legends claim only a "true hero" if they pull it out of the pedestal it can be found him. Although in a twist [[spoiler: any meister 'true hero' can pull him it from its resting place (which turns out and claim him as their [[LivingWeapon partner]], but to be untrue). Nothing is presently known about Excalibur's history (and therefore whether or not Arthur possessed another sword before it), apart from the fact that his [[MemeticMutation legend began in the 12th century, from United King he's so insanely annoying and demanding (expecting his wielder to follow 1000 rules, including listening to him ramble looking for 5 hours every day) almost no one can put up with him]].
him, or that he's going to California]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''TheDresdenFiles'', Harry does some research on Michael Carpenter and his sword and discovers that Michael is a descendant of King Arthur. When he's explaining this to another character, he makes a mention that Michael's sword is Excalibur, which King Arthur pulled from a stone.

to:

* In ''TheDresdenFiles'', Harry does some research on Michael Carpenter and his sword and discovers that Michael is a descendant of King Arthur.Charlemagne. When he's explaining this to another character, he makes a mention that Michael's sword is Excalibur, which King Arthur pulled from a stone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Merlin}} has the Lady of the Lake give Excalibur to the wizard before Arthur was even borne. He ends up sticking it in the stone which is part of a giant earth elemental in this version, and telling it to only let the sword go for one who is worthy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''TheDresdenFiles'', Harry does some research on Michael Carpenter and his sword and discovers that Michael is a descendant of King Arthur. When he's explaining this to another character, he makes a mention that Michael's sword is Excalibur, which King Arthur pulled from a stone.

Changed: 179

Removed: 477

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Gargoyles example given has nothing to do with trope, and is not an aversion, given what is established.



to:

* Played straight in ''Gargoyles'': the one Excalibur featured there was both pulled from the stone and created by The Lady of The Lake, as indicated in the episode "Pendragon".



* Played straight then subverted in ''{{Gargoyles}}''; when KingArthur is resurrected he finds that Excalibur is no longer with him. A prophecy states that the old King will receive the sword; the problem is that Macbeth believes he could be the King in question. When the sword is apparently found in the stone, Macbeth attempts to use it but finds that it's a fake. Arthur, more GenreSavvy, breaks the statue the stone is on, and finds real sword was inside the statue's eye.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{CastlevaniaSorrow Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow}}'' has a sword called Excalibur which is ''still in the stone''. So you go around swinging a sword with a giant rock at the end of it.

to:

* ''{{CastlevaniaSorrow ''[[CastlevaniaSorrow Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow}}'' Sorrow]]'' has a sword called Excalibur which is ''still in the stone''. So you go around swinging a sword with a giant rock at the end of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{CastlevaniaSorrow|Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow}}'' has a sword called Excalibur which is ''still in the stone''. So you go around swinging a sword with a giant rock at the end of it.

to:

* ''{{CastlevaniaSorrow|Castlevania: ''{{CastlevaniaSorrow Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow}}'' has a sword called Excalibur which is ''still in the stone''. So you go around swinging a sword with a giant rock at the end of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Forgot to close the link >.<


* ''{{CastlevaniaSorrow|Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow'' has a sword called Excalibur which is ''still in the stone''. So you go around swinging a sword with a giant rock at the end of it.

to:

* ''{{CastlevaniaSorrow|Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow'' Sorrow}}'' has a sword called Excalibur which is ''still in the stone''. So you go around swinging a sword with a giant rock at the end of it.



** This same twist is used in {{Magicka}}.

to:

** This same twist is used in {{Magicka}}.
''{{Magicka}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Castlevania}}: Aria of Sorrow'' has a sword called Excalibur which is ''still in the stone''. So you go around swinging a sword with a giant rock at the end of it.

to:

* ''{{Castlevania}}: ''{{CastlevaniaSorrow|Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow'' has a sword called Excalibur which is ''still in the stone''. So you go around swinging a sword with a giant rock at the end of it.




to:

** This same twist is used in {{Magicka}}.
ccoa MOD

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Merlin}}'', as of "The Coming of Arthur: Part 2". [[spoiler: The (technically still unnamed) sword that Merlin cast into the Lake of Avalon in the Season 1 episode "Excalibur" because it was too dangerous to use is retrieved by Freya (from the Season 2 episode "The Lady of the Lake") to defeat the undead army. And afterwards, since it's still too dangeous and it's been shown to be retrievable from the lake, Merlin takes it into the depths of the forest and drives it into a stone so it ''definitely'' can't be used again.]] Well, for now at least.

to:

* ''{{Merlin}}'', ''{{Series/Merlin}}'', as of "The Coming of Arthur: Part 2". [[spoiler: The (technically still unnamed) sword that Merlin cast into the Lake of Avalon in the Season 1 episode "Excalibur" because it was too dangerous to use is retrieved by Freya (from the Season 2 episode "The Lady of the Lake") to defeat the undead army. And afterwards, since it's still too dangeous and it's been shown to be retrievable from the lake, Merlin takes it into the depths of the forest and drives it into a stone so it ''definitely'' can't be used again.]] Well, for now at least.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''TheMuppets King Arthur'', despite the cover being a varient of the classic "Arthur in a boat beholding the sword" scene, the actual story has the Lady (Janice) simply there to tell Arthur (Kermit) that "There's a ''totally'' awesome sword in a rock over that hill". It was also her, not Merlin, who placed the Sword in the Stone, apparently to make some point about commercialism at rock festivals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:{{film}}]]

to:

[[AC:{{film}}]][[AC:{{Film}}]]



* ''{{Merlin}}'', as of "The Coming of Arthur: Part 2". [[spoiler: The (technically still unnamed) sword that Merlin cast into the Lake of Avalon in the Season 1 episode "Excalibur" because it was too dangerous to use is retrieved by Freya (from the Season 2 episode "The Lady of the Lake") to defeat the undead army. And afterwards, since it's still too dangeous and it's been shown to be retrievable from the lake, Merlin takes it into the depths of the forest and drives it into a stone so it ''definitely'' can't be used again.]]

to:

* ''{{Merlin}}'', as of "The Coming of Arthur: Part 2". [[spoiler: The (technically still unnamed) sword that Merlin cast into the Lake of Avalon in the Season 1 episode "Excalibur" because it was too dangerous to use is retrieved by Freya (from the Season 2 episode "The Lady of the Lake") to defeat the undead army. And afterwards, since it's still too dangeous and it's been shown to be retrievable from the lake, Merlin takes it into the depths of the forest and drives it into a stone so it ''definitely'' can't be used again.]]]] Well, for now at least.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Merlin}}'', as of ''The Coming of Arthur: Part 2''.

to:

* ''{{Merlin}}'', as of ''The "The Coming of Arthur: Part 2''.2". [[spoiler: The (technically still unnamed) sword that Merlin cast into the Lake of Avalon in the Season 1 episode "Excalibur" because it was too dangerous to use is retrieved by Freya (from the Season 2 episode "The Lady of the Lake") to defeat the undead army. And afterwards, since it's still too dangeous and it's been shown to be retrievable from the lake, Merlin takes it into the depths of the forest and drives it into a stone so it ''definitely'' can't be used again.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''SoulEater'' Excalibur can be obtained by a "true hero" if they pull it out of the pedestal it can be found him. Although in a twist [[spoiler: any meister can pull him out and claim him as their [[LivingWeapon partner]], but he's so insanely annoying and demanding (expecting his wielder to follow 1000 rules, including listening to him ramble for 5 hours every day) no one can put up with him]].

to:

* In ''SoulEater'' Excalibur can be obtained by a "true hero" if they pull it out of the pedestal it can be found him. Although in a twist [[spoiler: any meister can pull him out and claim him as their [[LivingWeapon partner]], but he's so insanely annoying and demanding (expecting his wielder to follow 1000 rules, including listening to him ramble for 5 hours every day) almost no one can put up with him]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The logic for this being: The player character is not actually Arthur, so he is obviously not allowed to draw the sword from the stone. . .

to:

** The logic for this being: The player character is not actually Arthur, so he is obviously not allowed to draw the sword from the stone. . .\n But he's also ''very strong''...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC:Television]]
* ''{{Merlin}}'', as of ''The Coming of Arthur: Part 2''.


Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Literature]]
* The ''GrailQuestSoloFantasy'' series spends a lengthy paragraph in the fourth book making the differences between the two swords clear.

Top