Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ButNotTooBi

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
deleted inaccurate Homestuck example


* In ''Webcomic/{{Homestuck}}'', WordOfGod states that [[ProudWarriorRace the Trolls]] have no concept of gender in relationships, so nearly EveryoneIsBi. However, every reciprocated relationship seen among the main twelve is opposite-sex; if it wasn't for the author's confirmation and one off-hand line by one of the trolls stating bafflement at humans having a word for homosexuality, you'd have no idea they were bisexual by default.

to:

* In ''Webcomic/{{Homestuck}}'', WordOfGod states that [[ProudWarriorRace the Trolls]] have no concept of gender in relationships, so nearly EveryoneIsBi. However, every reciprocated relationship seen among the main twelve is opposite-sex; if it wasn't for the author's confirmation and one off-hand line by one of the trolls stating bafflement at humans having a word for homosexuality, you'd have no idea they were bisexual by default.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's only shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]], and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he [[PairingTheSpares randomly starts developing feelings for]] [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.

to:

* Haiji from ''AiKora'' ''Manga/AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's only shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]], and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he [[PairingTheSpares randomly starts developing feelings for]] [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jack Harkness was suffered from this in ''Series/DoctorWho'' and the first two seasons of Torchwood. Aside from one [[GirlOfTheWeek boy of the week]], his attachments to women were romantic and this attachments with men casual and played for laughs. ''ChildrenOfEarth'' balanced it out a bit, having him emotionally as well as sexually involved with a male. Then ''MiracleDay'' took it to the opposite extreme, portraying him almost entirely as homosexual.

to:

* Jack Harkness was suffered from this in ''Series/DoctorWho'' and the first two seasons of Torchwood. Aside from one [[GirlOfTheWeek boy of the week]], his attachments to women were romantic and this attachments with men casual and played for laughs. ''ChildrenOfEarth'' balanced it out a bit, having him emotionally as well as sexually involved with a male. Then ''MiracleDay'' took it to the opposite extreme, portraying him almost entirely as homosexual.

Changed: 207

Removed: 453

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cutting off the natter. We\'re compareing the character to himself, not to other characters.


* Jack Harkness was suffered from this in ''Series/DoctorWho'' and the first two seasons of Torchwood. Aside from one [[GirlOfTheWeek boy of the week]], his attachments to women were romantic and this attachments with men casual and played for laughs.
** YourMileageMayVary in terms of Season 2. While his relationship to Ianto smacked more of sexual rather than romantic attachment, it lasted much longer and had a bit more emotional investment than say Owen and Gwen's relationship in Season 1.
** ''ChildrenOfEarth'' balanced it out a bit, having him emotionally as well as sexually involved with a male. Then ''MiracleDay'' took it to the opposite extreme, portraying him almost entirely as homosexual.

to:

* Jack Harkness was suffered from this in ''Series/DoctorWho'' and the first two seasons of Torchwood. Aside from one [[GirlOfTheWeek boy of the week]], his attachments to women were romantic and this attachments with men casual and played for laughs.
** YourMileageMayVary in terms of Season 2. While his relationship to Ianto smacked more of sexual rather than romantic attachment, it lasted much longer and had a bit more emotional investment than say Owen and Gwen's relationship in Season 1.
**
laughs. ''ChildrenOfEarth'' balanced it out a bit, having him emotionally as well as sexually involved with a male. Then ''MiracleDay'' took it to the opposite extreme, portraying him almost entirely as homosexual.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** YourMileageMayVary in terms of Season 2. While his relationship to Ianto smacked more of sexual rather than romantic attachment, it lasted much longer and had a bit more emotional investment than say Owen and Gwen's relationship in Season 1.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jack Harkness was suffered from this in ''DoctorWho'' and the first two seasons of Torchwood. Aside from one [[GirlOfTheWeek boy of the week]], his attachments to women were romantic and this attachments with men casual and played for laughs.

to:

* Jack Harkness was suffered from this in ''DoctorWho'' ''Series/DoctorWho'' and the first two seasons of Torchwood. Aside from one [[GirlOfTheWeek boy of the week]], his attachments to women were romantic and this attachments with men casual and played for laughs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''{{Skins}}'', Tony Stonem and Cassie Ainsworth are seen having meaningless trysts with people of both sexes, but their only relationships are opposite-sex ones.

Added: 1107

Changed: 635

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a textbook case from ''TheLWord'', Alice was introduced as the token bisexual character, and it was indicated that she slept with men and women more or less equally. However, as time went on, her relationships with men were given increasingly little screentime, and were eventually phased out entirely. By the end of the series, Alice is in a stereotypically normative butch/femme relationship with Tasha, an [[spoiler: former]] army officer, and identifies as a lesbian. One of Alice's last male/female relationships on the show? With a man who identified as a "male lesbian". The show seems to want there to be [[NoBisexuals No]] [[UnfortunateImplications Bisexuals]].

to:

* In a textbook case from ''TheLWord'', ''TheLWord'' is frequently accused of this:
**
Alice was introduced as the token bisexual character, and it was indicated that she slept with men and women more or less equally. However, as time went on, her relationships with men were given increasingly little screentime, and were eventually phased out entirely. By the end of the series, Alice is in a stereotypically normative butch/femme relationship with Tasha, an [[spoiler: former]] army officer, and identifies as a lesbian. One of Alice's last male/female relationships on the show? With a man who identified as a "male lesbian". The show seems to want there to be [[NoBisexuals No]] [[UnfortunateImplications Bisexuals]].Bisexuals]].
** Played with in the case of Jenny Schechter, who is established as bi from the first episode and whose first-season arc is mainly about her discovering it. Of course, she doesn't have many relationships with men on the show, but then again, it's implied that she ''only'' dated men before moving to West Hollywood and may be making up for lost time. Regardless, though, since she's a DepravedBisexual she doesn't really do much to lift the show's attitude toward bis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jack Harkness was suffered from this in DoctorWho and the first two seasons of Torchwood. Aside from one [[GirlOfTheWeek boy of the week]], his attachments to women were romantic and this attachments with men casual and played for laughs.

to:

* Jack Harkness was suffered from this in DoctorWho ''DoctorWho'' and the first two seasons of Torchwood. Aside from one [[GirlOfTheWeek boy of the week]], his attachments to women were romantic and this attachments with men casual and played for laughs.
** ''ChildrenOfEarth'' balanced it out a bit, having him emotionally as well as sexually involved with a male. Then ''MiracleDay'' took it to the opposite extreme, portraying him almost entirely as homosexual.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Hellblazer}}'': Constantine has been said to be bisexual, but due to ExecutiveMeddling his experience with men has been limited to one very limited seduction.

to:

* ''{{Hellblazer}}'': ''ComicBook/{{Hellblazer}}'': Constantine has been said to be bisexual, but due to ExecutiveMeddling his experience with men has been limited to one very limited seduction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Oberyn Martell of ''ASongOfIceAndFire''

to:

* Oberyn Martell of ''ASongOfIceAndFire''
''ASongOfIceAndFire,'' to some extent; he only has one lover throughout the course of the series, and it's entirely possible that it would be unsafe for him to bring a male lover to court. The only evidence we have of his other relationships are [[AnythingThatMoves rumors]] and his bastard children, the latter of which [[CaptainObvious really couldn't come from his relationships with men.]] A more straightforward expample is Daenarys, who has and enjoys sex with Doreah and Irri, but her only relationships are with men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Nene from ''{{Hyakko}}'' says she's bi, but she only shows interest in girls. Since it's a comedy SliceOfLife aimed at men, this is probably [[PinkBishoujoGhetto intentional]].

to:

* Nene from ''{{Hyakko}}'' says she's bi, but she only shows interest in girls. Since it's a comedy SliceOfLife aimed at men, this is probably [[PinkBishoujoGhetto [[ImprobablyFemaleCast intentional]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In as much as DorianGray's sexuality can be established, it falls under this, with his relationships to men being largely ambiguous or sexual while his relationsip with Sybil is of a more traditional sort. {{Justified|Trope}} in that [[FairForItsDay there wasn't much room for any other depiction at the time.]]
* Oberyn Martell of ASongOfFireAndIce

to:

* In as much as DorianGray's Dorian Gray's sexuality can be established, it falls under this, with his relationships to men being largely ambiguous or sexual while his relationsip with Sybil is of a more traditional sort. {{Justified|Trope}} in that [[FairForItsDay there wasn't much room for any other depiction at the time.]]
* Oberyn Martell of ASongOfFireAndIce
''ASongOfIceAndFire''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Averted in a recent episode, [[spoilers: (and Thirteen's final episode) in which she has settled down with a woman.]]

to:

** Averted in a recent episode, [[spoilers: [[spoiler: (and Thirteen's final episode) in which she has settled down with a woman.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Averted in a recent episode, [[spoilers: (and Thirteen's final episode) in which she has settled down with a woman.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Oberyn Martell of ASongOfFireAndIce
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Sinkholes, spelling, grammar.


Writing about sexual orientation, especially same sex attraction brings a bucketful of implications and problems for a writer. Politically, the tug war between prejudice and gay advocacy makes a character's sexuality hard to balance so that one group can feel represented without causing an uproar. There is also a balance between having [[GirlOnGirlIsHot the]] [[GuyOnGuyIsHot exoticism]] of an uncommon sexuality without alienating a the target audience. This is where bisexuality comes in. While Bisexuality has historically been caught in this crossfire with the result being [[NoBisexuals an erasure of their existence]], the end result has also been that bisexuality, when it does surface in fiction, becomes a tool to consolidate this dilemma.

While bisexuality in RealLife spans a huge spectrum that covers both ends on the Kinsey scale and everything in between, it is actually very rare to see a show that treats attraction to two genders as equally valid and important. There is one form of bisexuality in particular that dominates fiction and that is the kind of bisexuality that, when it comes down to it, lies closer to the orientation of the target audience. There are many variations to this, but key is to create some form of pecking order between the sexes, presumably in order to make the character more appealing to the audience depending on what gender and sexuality they are expected to have, while at the same time having the titillation, commedic material or diversity of "deviant" sexual behaviour. Of course the prelevalence of the trope brings some UnfortunateImplications for real life bisexuals; that in the end it's only one gender that matters to them and that their experiences with the other one are worth less.

to:

Writing about sexual orientation, especially same sex attraction attraction, brings a bucketful of implications and problems for a writer. Politically, the tug war tug-of-war between prejudice and gay advocacy makes a character's sexuality hard to balance so that one group can feel represented without causing an uproar. There is also a balance between having [[GirlOnGirlIsHot the]] [[GuyOnGuyIsHot exoticism]] the exoticism of an uncommon sexuality without alienating a the target audience. This is where bisexuality comes in. While Bisexuality bisexuality has historically been caught in this crossfire with the result being [[NoBisexuals an erasure of their existence]], the end result has also been that bisexuality, when it does surface in fiction, becomes a tool to consolidate this dilemma.

While bisexuality in RealLife spans a huge spectrum that covers both ends on the Kinsey scale and everything in between, it is actually very rare to see a show that treats attraction to two genders as equally valid and important. There is one form of bisexuality in particular that dominates fiction and that is the kind of bisexuality that, when it comes down to it, lies closer to the orientation of the target audience. There are many variations to this, but key is to create some form of pecking order between the sexes, presumably in order to make the character more appealing to the audience depending on what gender and sexuality they are expected to have, while at the same time having the titillation, commedic comedic material or diversity of "deviant" sexual behaviour. Of course course, the prelevalence prevalence of the trope brings some UnfortunateImplications for real life bisexuals; that in the end it's only one gender that matters to them and that their experiences with the other one are worth less.



Alternatively, the character could be like one of the above examples but slanted in favor of homosexual relationships instead, but this is rarer and usually played for [[GirlOnGirlIsHot fenservice]] or a queer intended audience.

to:

Alternatively, the character could be like one of the above examples but slanted in favor of homosexual relationships instead, but this is rarer and usually played for [[GirlOnGirlIsHot fenservice]] fanservice]] or a queer intended audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Tony is not really technically an example of this. It\'s heavily implied that his one sexual encounter with Maxxie is performed out of boredom more than anything. And Maxxie is the only male he shows a remote sexual interest in, so it\'s more of a case of If Its You Its Ok


* Tony from the first and second season of ''{{Skins}}'' only dates girls, though he does sleep with his gay friend Maxxie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
If you only look at Miracle Day and the recent radio dramas, then maybe so, but this is the guy who made constant refenrences to his male attachments as a joke. Note the word \"male\", because that never happened with the opposite sex. No, they were the tragedies of lost love



to:

* Jack Harkness was suffered from this in DoctorWho and the first two seasons of Torchwood. Aside from one [[GirlOfTheWeek boy of the week]], his attachments to women were romantic and this attachments with men casual and played for laughs.

Added: 675

Changed: 453

Removed: 736

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
L-Word is television, no reason to index it separately. The torchwood example is so awkwardly shoehorned that it\'s simply Not An Example.


* In a textbook case from ''TheLWord'', Alice was introduced as the token bisexual character, and it was indicated that she slept with men and women more or less equally. However, as time went on, her relationships with men were given increasingly little screentime, and were eventually phased out entirely. By the end of the series, Alice is in a stereotypically normative butch/femme relationship with Tasha, an [[spoiler: former]] army officer, and identifies as a lesbian. One of Alice's last male/female relationships on the show? With a man who identified as a "male lesbian". The show seems to want there to be [[NoBisexuals No]] [[UnfortunateImplications Bisexuals]].



* Captain Jack from ''{{Torchwood}}'' in time and tone. While he does have some sort of relationship with Ianto, it was almost exclusively depicted as sexual from Jack's part up until [[spoiler: Ianto's death]]. This is contrasted with his very emotional but as yet asexual relationship with Gwen throughout the series. On a wider scale, casual comments are made about past boyfriends while his more romantic memories are mostly with women.
** In ''Series/TorchwoodMiracleDay'' it's more the other way.

to:

* Captain Jack from ''{{Torchwood}}'' in time and tone. While he does have some sort of relationship with Ianto, it was almost exclusively depicted as sexual from Jack's part up until [[spoiler: Ianto's death]]. This is contrasted with his very emotional but as yet asexual relationship with Gwen throughout the series. On a wider scale, casual comments are made about past boyfriends while his more romantic memories are mostly with women.
** In ''Series/TorchwoodMiracleDay'' it's more the other way.



!!Queer media

* In a textbook case from ''TheLWord'', Alice was introduced as the token bisexual character, and it was indicated that she slept with men and women more or less equally. However, as time went on, her relationships with men were given increasingly little screentime, and were eventually phased out entirely. By the end of the series, Alice is in a stereotypically normative butch/femme relationship with Tasha, an [[spoiler: former]] army officer, and identifies as a lesbian. One of Alice's last male/female relationships on the show? With a man who identified as a "male lesbian". The show seems to want there to be [[NoBisexuals No]] [[UnfortunateImplications Bisexuals]].

to:

!!Queer media

* In a textbook case from ''TheLWord'', Alice was introduced as the token bisexual character, and it was indicated that she slept with men and women more or less equally. However, as time went on, her relationships with men were given increasingly little screentime, and were eventually phased out entirely. By the end of the series, Alice is in a stereotypically normative butch/femme relationship with Tasha, an [[spoiler: former]] army officer, and identifies as a lesbian. One of Alice's last male/female relationships on the show? With a man who identified as a "male lesbian". The show seems to want there to be [[NoBisexuals No]] [[UnfortunateImplications Bisexuals]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Y'see, while bisexuality in RealLife spans a huge spectrum that covers both ends on the Kinsey scale and everything in between, it is actually very rare to see a show that treats attraction to two genders as equally valid and important. There is one form of bisexuality in particular that dominates fiction and that is the kind of bisexuality that, when it comes down to it, lies closer to the orientation of the target audience. There are many variations to this, but key is to create some form of pecking order between the sexes, presumably in order to make the character more appealing to the audience depending on what gender and sexuality they are expected to have, while at the same time having the titillation, commedic material or diversity of "deviant" sexual behaviour. Of course the prelevalence of the trope brings some UnfortunateImplications for real life bisexuals; that in the end it's only one gender that matters to them and that their experiences with the other one are worth less.

to:

Y'see, while While bisexuality in RealLife spans a huge spectrum that covers both ends on the Kinsey scale and everything in between, it is actually very rare to see a show that treats attraction to two genders as equally valid and important. There is one form of bisexuality in particular that dominates fiction and that is the kind of bisexuality that, when it comes down to it, lies closer to the orientation of the target audience. There are many variations to this, but key is to create some form of pecking order between the sexes, presumably in order to make the character more appealing to the audience depending on what gender and sexuality they are expected to have, while at the same time having the titillation, commedic material or diversity of "deviant" sexual behaviour. Of course the prelevalence of the trope brings some UnfortunateImplications for real life bisexuals; that in the end it's only one gender that matters to them and that their experiences with the other one are worth less.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ellen from ''ElGoonishShive''. Technically bi, due to the specifics of her creation, but is in a stable relationship with Nanase and eventually decides that she's basically just lesbian, after a traumatic "dream," thus checking off the time aspect. Of course, since Nanase is technically her first relationship, and since she is bi due to her specifically being created that way, it would be very unfair not to take her at her word.

to:

* Ellen from ''ElGoonishShive''. Technically bi, due to the specifics of her creation, creation (she's Elliot's DistaffCounterpart, after all), but is in a stable relationship with Nanase and eventually decides that she's basically just lesbian, after a traumatic "dream," thus checking off the time aspect. Of course, since Nanase is technically her first relationship, and since she is bi due to her specifically being created that way, it would be very unfair not to take her at her word.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Alternatively, the character could be like one of the above examples but slanted in favor of homosexual relationships instead, but this is rarer.

to:

Alternatively, the character could be like one of the above examples but slanted in favor of homosexual relationships instead, but this is rarer.
rarer and usually played for [[GirlOnGirlIsHot fenservice]] or a queer intended audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Alternatively, the character could be like one of the above examples but slanted in favor of homosexual relationships instead, but this is rarer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not a spoiler


** [[spoiler: Lightens up in ''Series/TorchwoodMiracleDay''.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Lightens up in ''Series/TorchwoodMiracleDay''.]]
In ''Series/TorchwoodMiracleDay'' it's more the other way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's onyl shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]] and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he [[PairingTheSpares randomly starts developing feelings for]] [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.

to:

* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's onyl only shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]] Hachibei]], and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he [[PairingTheSpares randomly starts developing feelings for]] [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's onyl shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]] and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he [[PairingTheRomanticLooseEmds randomly starts developing feelings for]] [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.

to:

* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's onyl shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]] and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he [[PairingTheRomanticLooseEmds [[PairingTheSpares randomly starts developing feelings for]] [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's onyl shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]] and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he gets StrangledByTheRedString to [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.

to:

* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's onyl shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]] and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he gets StrangledByTheRedString to [[PairingTheRomanticLooseEmds randomly starts developing feelings for]] [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's noyl shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]] and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he gets StrangledByTheRedString to [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.

to:

* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's noyl onyl shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]] and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he gets StrangledByTheRedString to [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Haiji from ''AiKora'' will love anyone whom he considers pure, but he's noyl shown showing interest in [[TheProtagonist Hachibei]] and entirely PlayedForLaughs at that, what with all the StupidSexyFlanders moments he causes Hachibei. Subverted later on in a way, as he gets StrangledByTheRedString to [[TheOjou Ayame]], but since StatusQuoIsGod it doesn't stick for long and he's back to loving Hachibei soon.

Top