Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / BurnTheWitch

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the short film "Jungle Drums", one of the ''WesternAnimation/SupermanTheatricalCartoons'', Lois Lane had to endure being tied to a stake as part of an interrogation by Nazis in Africa.[[note]]The Nazis did have operations in Northern Africa, though they didn't venture far enough south to deal with jungles[[/note]] Taken captive after her plane crashes she's held tied to a chair and threatened with fire by Nazi operatives if she doesn't answer any questions. Naturally being Lois she declines to answer and they tie her to the stake and prepare to burn her until Superman arrives to save the day.

to:

* In the short film "Jungle Drums", one of the ''WesternAnimation/SupermanTheatricalCartoons'', Lois Lane had to endure being tied to a stake as part of an interrogation by Nazis in Africa.[[note]]The Nazis did have operations in Northern Africa, though they didn't venture far enough south to deal with jungles[[/note]] jungles.[[/note]] Taken captive after her plane crashes she's held tied to a chair and threatened with fire by Nazi operatives if she doesn't answer any questions. Naturally being Lois she declines to answer and they tie her to the stake and prepare to burn her until Superman arrives to save the day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the short film "Jungle Drums", one of the ''WesternAnimation/SupermanTheatricalCartoons'', Lois Lane had to endure being tied to a stake as part of an interrogation by Nazis in Africa.[[labelnote]]The Nazis did have operations in Northern Africa, though they didn't venture far enough south to deal with jungles[[/labelnote]] Taken captive after her plane crashes she's held tied to a chair and threatened with fire by Nazi operatives if she doesn't answer any questions. Naturally being Lois she declines to answer and they tie her to the stake and prepare to burn her until Superman arrives to save the day.

to:

* In the short film "Jungle Drums", one of the ''WesternAnimation/SupermanTheatricalCartoons'', Lois Lane had to endure being tied to a stake as part of an interrogation by Nazis in Africa.[[labelnote]]The [[note]]The Nazis did have operations in Northern Africa, though they didn't venture far enough south to deal with jungles[[/labelnote]] jungles[[/note]] Taken captive after her plane crashes she's held tied to a chair and threatened with fire by Nazi operatives if she doesn't answer any questions. Naturally being Lois she declines to answer and they tie her to the stake and prepare to burn her until Superman arrives to save the day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the short film "Jungle Drums", one of the ''WesternAnimation/SupermanTheatricalCartoons'', Lois Lane had to endure being tied to a stake as part of an interrogation by Nazis in Africa(!)Taken captive after her plane crashes she's held tied to a chair and threatened with fire by Nazi operatives if she doesn't answer any questions. Naturally being Lois she declines to answer and they tie her to the stake and prepare to burn her until Superman arrives to save the day.

to:

* In the short film "Jungle Drums", one of the ''WesternAnimation/SupermanTheatricalCartoons'', Lois Lane had to endure being tied to a stake as part of an interrogation by Nazis in Africa(!)Taken Africa.[[labelnote]]The Nazis did have operations in Northern Africa, though they didn't venture far enough south to deal with jungles[[/labelnote]] Taken captive after her plane crashes she's held tied to a chair and threatened with fire by Nazi operatives if she doesn't answer any questions. Naturally being Lois she declines to answer and they tie her to the stake and prepare to burn her until Superman arrives to save the day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheWheelOfTime'': Eamon Valda burns a captured Aes Sedai from the Yellow Ajah at the stake, in keeping with his belief that they're evil witches deserving of death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not an example. Conan is throwing the witch off him to defend himself, he didn't specifically try to burn her, and he didn't do it only for her being a witch. Also it is implied the fire does not actually harm her.


* ''Film/ConanTheBarbarian1982''. Conan throws the witch into a fire and she instantly bursts into flames. However she does not die, but instead transforms into a fireball and shoots off into the woods with an EvilLaugh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/ConanTheBarbarian1982'', Conan throws the witch into a fire and she instantly bursts into flames.

to:

* In ''Film/ConanTheBarbarian1982'', ''Film/ConanTheBarbarian1982''. Conan throws the witch into a fire and she instantly bursts into flames.flames. However she does not die, but instead transforms into a fireball and shoots off into the woods with an EvilLaugh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''TabletopGame/Warhammer40000'' is actually somewhat nuanced on the subject. There's a distinction between ''psykers'' and ''witches''. Psykers have an innate connection with the warp. There's always a chance they could be possessed, but they can (provided that they're strong enough, and receive the proper training, and are lucky not to attract a dangerous demon, they can survive). ''Witches'', on the other hand, are those who deliberately use rituals and spells to draw power form the warp, usually by making some pact with some malevolent warp entity or daemon. Also, inquisitors and witchhunters are very numerous and diverse. Some of them are diehard witch-burners, others are compromising pragmatists, others are severe radicals who will use witches for their own purposes. In fact, the Imperium needs psykers, Astropaths for communication and Navigators to guide starships through the [[HyperspaceIsAScaryPlace Warp]], and just about every branch of the Imperial military uses sanctioned psykers, there are even many Inquisitors who are psykers. While those who are too weak to use for those purposes can be fed to the GodEmperor. So, needless to say, a lot of Inquisitors try to take psykers who aren't involved with Chaos alive. If a witch is deemed dangerous enough however, they'll [[EarthShatteringKaboom burn the whole planet]] just to be safe. Outside of the Inquisition itself this distinction is almost completely unknown, and all psykers get lumped together as witches; the more sophisticated might avoid using the term for sanctioned psychers out of politeness.

to:

** In ''TabletopGame/Warhammer40000'' is actually somewhat nuanced on the subject. There's a distinction between ''psykers'' and ''witches''. Psykers have an innate connection with the warp. There's always a chance they could be possessed, but they can (provided that they're strong enough, and receive the proper training, and are lucky not to attract a dangerous demon, they can survive).demon) avoid anything demonic and even work for the Imperium in rare cases. ''Witches'', on the other hand, are those who deliberately use rituals and spells to draw power form the warp, usually by making some pact with some malevolent warp entity or daemon. Also, inquisitors and witchhunters are very numerous and diverse. Some of them are diehard witch-burners, others are compromising pragmatists, others are severe radicals who will use witches for their own purposes. In fact, the Imperium needs psykers, Astropaths for communication and Navigators to guide starships through the [[HyperspaceIsAScaryPlace Warp]], and just about every branch of the Imperial military uses sanctioned psykers, there are even many Inquisitors who are psykers. While those who are too weak to use for those purposes can be fed to the GodEmperor. So, needless to say, a lot of Inquisitors try to take psykers who aren't involved with Chaos alive. If a witch is deemed dangerous enough however, they'll [[EarthShatteringKaboom burn the whole planet]] just to be safe. Outside of the Inquisition itself this distinction is almost completely unknown, and all psykers get lumped together as witches; the more sophisticated might avoid using the term for sanctioned psychers out of politeness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Similarly, in ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13981875/1/Witching-Hour Witching Hour]]'', set in Medieval times, Gaz becomes suspected of being a witch after a series of strange events happen around her [[spoiler: [[FrameUp all arranged by Zim]]]]. The final nail in her coffin is when she's found in the woods surrounded by ritualistically slaughtered animals, cover in their blood; after this, she's seized, put through a KangarooCourt, and finally burned at the stake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The ''Literature/HarryPotter'' fanfic ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/2868247/1/They-Burn-Witches-Don-t-They They Burn Witches, Don't They?]]'' is an AlternateUniverse fic set in the Middle Ages. The titular witch-burning involves the fire, a torturous Inquisition, and an angry mob.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''ComicBook/SevenSoldiers of Victory'', ComicBook/KlarionTheWitchBoy nearly gets burned by the women of Limbo Town after trying to warn them of the impending invasion by Melmoth, because the Croatoans have long been taught that there is no world beyond theirs.

to:

* In ''ComicBook/SevenSoldiers of Victory'', ''ComicBook/SevenSoldiers'', ComicBook/KlarionTheWitchBoy nearly gets burned by the women of Limbo Town after trying to warn them of the impending invasion by Melmoth, because the Croatoans have long been taught that there is no world beyond theirs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''TabletopGame/{{Pathfinder}}'': After the First Mendevian Crusade, the demons of the Worldwound changed tactics and began corrupting crusaders and sending cultists to infiltrate them, leading to the capture of the Crusade's forward base Drezen. The Crusaders responded by forming an Inquisition, which uses burning as a main form of execution. And while ProperlyParanoid, they've burned a lot of innocent people along with the guilty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the backstory of the ''VideoGame/{{Dragon Age|Origins}}'' [[VideoGame/DragonAgeII games]], Andraste was burned at the stake after her husband betrayed her to the Tevinter Imperium. The leader of the Imperium, Archon Hessarian, felt pity for Andraste in her final moments and drove his sword into her heart so she wouldn't suffer any longer. He became the first convert to the Chant of Light and helped spread it over Thedas. The Blades of Mercy are enchanted replicas of Hessarian's sword and are considered badges of honor in the Imperium. An inversion, as Andraste was burned ''by'' witches (well, mages).

to:

* In the backstory of the ''VideoGame/{{Dragon Age|Origins}}'' [[VideoGame/DragonAgeII games]], ''Franchise/DragonAge'' games, Andraste was burned at the stake after her husband betrayed her to the Tevinter Imperium. The leader of the Imperium, Archon Hessarian, felt pity for Andraste in her final moments and drove his sword into her heart so she wouldn't suffer any longer. He became the first convert to the Chant of Light and helped spread it over Thedas. The Blades of Mercy are enchanted replicas of Hessarian's sword and are considered badges of honor in the Imperium. An inversion, as Andraste was burned ''by'' witches (well, mages).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The passage of Exodus 22:18 from the Bible (and its quite popular King James variant mentioned as the page quote) was used to justify many a WitchHunt back in the bad old days. It should be noted, however, that the meaning of "witch" or "sorceress" back then primarily referred to someone who used bad and injurious magic, rather than all magic.

to:

* The passage of Exodus 22:18 from the Bible Literature/TheBible (and its quite popular King James variant mentioned as the page quote) was used to justify many a WitchHunt back in the bad old days. It should be noted, however, that the meaning of "witch" or "sorceress" back then primarily referred to someone who used bad and injurious magic, rather than all magic.

Added: 806

Changed: 939

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The legendary origin of the ''[[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erythrina_crista-galli ceibo]]'' tree and flowers is tied to this trope. It says that as the Spanish conquerors explored the lands of what's now UsefulNotes/{{Argentina}}, the Guarani tribe opposed them fiercely; one of their biggest enemies was Anahí, an ActionGirl who used to be an ugly but kind FriendToAllLivingThings MysteriousWaif, but TookALevelInBadass to defend her people. When the Spanish finally captured poor Anahí, they burned her at the stake; according to different versions either [[DefiantToTheEnd she sang a last song as she burned to death]] and her charred corpse became a ''ceibo'' tree in the morning, or the flames refused to touch Anahí and she slowly turned into into a ''ceibo'' in front of the conquerors.

to:

* The passage of Exodus 22:18 from the Bible (and its quite popular King James variant mentioned as the page quote) was used to justify many a WitchHunt back in the bad old days. It should be noted, however, that the meaning of "witch" or "sorceress" back then primarily referred to someone who used bad and injurious magic, rather than all magic.
* The legendary origin of the ''[[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erythrina_crista-galli ceibo]]'' tree and flowers is tied to this trope. It says that as the Spanish conquerors ''conquistadores'' explored the lands of what's now UsefulNotes/{{Argentina}}, the Guarani tribe opposed them fiercely; one of their biggest enemies was Anahí, an ActionGirl who used to be an ugly but kind FriendToAllLivingThings MysteriousWaif, but TookALevelInBadass to defend her people. When the Spanish finally captured poor Anahí, they burned her at the stake; according to different versions either [[DefiantToTheEnd she sang a last song as she burned to death]] and her charred corpse became a ''ceibo'' tree in the morning, or the flames refused to touch Anahí and she slowly turned into into a ''ceibo'' in front of the conquerors.

Changed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


When a community with a superstitious mindset suspects someone in their midst of magical or [[StockSuperPowers otherwise unusual powers]], especially if unexplained stuff such as kids disappearing has been happening, their response will usually be to root the person out to take the blame and some burning at the stake.

to:

When a community with a superstitious mindset suspects someone in their midst of magical or [[StockSuperPowers otherwise unusual powers]], powers, especially if unexplained stuff such as kids disappearing has been happening, their response will usually be to root the person out to take the blame and some burning at the stake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/ThePower'': Early on, some people burn girls with the Power as witches. Sister Veronica at the convent also proposes doing so, but she's killed before anything can happen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Series/{{SiempreBruja}}'', Carmen travels forward in time while being burned at the stake as a witch. She ends up in a hospital with burned feet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Also see TheHeretic, who is also a victim of this form of justice, but with a difference: the Witch is sentenced to incineration for deadly supernatural activity, while The Heretic is similarly sentenced to incineration for religious ThoughtCrime. TheWitchHunter is a related trope, although a Witch Hunter is someone who hunts witches professionally, while this trope tends to refer to [[TorchesAndPitchforks an angry mob]]. See also KillItWithFire and related tropes for the logic (such as it is) for this.

to:

Also see TheHeretic, who is also a victim of this form of justice, but with a difference: the Witch is sentenced to incineration for deadly supernatural activity, while The Heretic is similarly sentenced to incineration for religious ThoughtCrime. TheWitchHunter is a related trope, although a Witch Hunter is someone who hunts witches professionally, while this trope tends to refer to [[TorchesAndPitchforks an angry mob]]. See also KillItWithFire and related tropes for the logic (such as it is) for this.
this. Often associated with FanaticalFire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In AncientGreece and AncientRome, there were things that ''could'' be considered witch-hunts[[note]]Keep in mind that our modern conception of what a "witch" is [[NewerThanTheyThink actually developed around the Reformation era]][[/note]], but their word for "witch" could also be translated as "poisoner" (see, the above section on the KJV). In fact, it's possible they were interchangeable concepts back then.

to:

* In AncientGreece UsefulNotes/AncientGreece and AncientRome, there were things that ''could'' be considered witch-hunts[[note]]Keep in mind that our modern conception of what a "witch" is [[NewerThanTheyThink actually developed around the Reformation era]][[/note]], but their word for "witch" could also be translated as "poisoner" (see, the above section on the KJV). In fact, it's possible they were interchangeable concepts back then.

Changed: 11

Removed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]




to:

[[/folder]]

Added: 2514

Changed: 1100

Removed: 1081

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ancient Greco-Roman witch hunts (+ more info)


* An utterly bizarre example occurred with the death of the two last [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_auk Great Auks]]; apparently the last two individuals were killed because their capture occurred at the same time a storm came, leading the sailors to think the birds were witches.

to:

* An utterly bizarre example occurred with Translation:
** Interestingly,
the death passage quoted at the top of this page, from the King James Version, is actually a rather iffy translation. The term "witch" is a more recent invention of the two last [[http://en.English language, and of course no particular method of execution was prescribed. The word used in the original language roughly translates to "sorceress" with "[[MindRape one who twists the minds of others]] for personal gain" connotations. Though rulers described as serving God often stamped out ''all'' practitioners; this is why Saul had trouble finding one when he decided to actually consult one.
** Another translation renders the word as ''prostitute''. Sacred prostitutes often served the god(desse)s of the nations opposing Israel. They were seen as trying to tempt God's people away from him. Some may have practiced sacred rites.
** It's also possible that the original word was ''poisoner'', as there was overlap between the Greek and Latin words for "poisoner" and "witch"; King James was [[TheWitchHunter rather obsessed with witchcraft]], which may have influenced the translation.
* In AncientGreece and AncientRome, there were things that ''could'' be considered witch-hunts[[note]]Keep in mind that our modern conception of what a "witch" is [[NewerThanTheyThink actually developed around the Reformation era]][[/note]], but their word for "witch" could also be translated as "poisoner" (see, the above section on the KJV). In fact, it's possible they were interchangeable concepts back then.
** Perhaps the first victim of witch-hunting in history we know the name of, was an ancient Greek woman named [[https://en.
wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_auk Great Auks]]; apparently the last two individuals org/wiki/Theoris_of_Lemnos Theoris of Lemnos]] (4th. century B.C.E./B.C.). She was executed with her children.
** Livy ([[https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.02.0155%3Abook%3D8%3Achapter%3D18 Ad Urbe Condita Libri VIII, xviii]]) records an instance of 170 women being burned for poisoning (witchcraft?), who
were killed because their capture occurred blamed for causing mass illness. Livy records that this is the scale of this persecution was never before seen in Rome at that point.
** In 81 B.C.E./B.C., the Roman legislator Sulla passed the ''Lex Cornelia de sicariis et veneficiis'', which prohibited occult practices along with posession of harmful poisons.
* UsefulNotes/JoanOfArc, who led the French army during UsefulNotes/TheHundredYearsWar, was eventually captured by the English. She was put on trial for heresy in a KangarooCourt, was found guilty, and burned
at the same time a storm came, leading the sailors to think the birds were witches.stake.
[[/folder]]



** During [[TheHighMiddleAges the Middle Ages proper]] witchcraft wasn't a major crime -- 'cunning folk' were practitioners of low-level magic that were generally not persecuted legally, unless they were accused of cheating their customers out of the supposed effects of the magic sold. Lethal magic was treated essentially as a subsection of poisoning, and punished accordingly with death, though not by burning, while lesser offenses could only lead to a fine or corporal punishment. Only with TheLateMiddleAges and the publication of the infamous ''[[Literature/MalleusMaleficarum Malleus]] [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malleus_Maleficarum Maleficarum]]'' did the mass witch hunts begin. Prior to this, the Church's position was largely that witches were not even real - or rather, that magic was not real, simply illusions of the Devil. The ''Malleus'' itself was banned when it came out as the heretical ravings of a lunatic, but unfortunately enthusiastic amateurs got a hold of it anyway, causing a boom among both Catholic and Protestant laymen.

to:

** During [[TheHighMiddleAges the Middle Ages proper]] witchcraft wasn't a major crime -- 'cunning folk' were practitioners of low-level magic that were generally not persecuted legally, unless they were accused of cheating their customers out of the supposed effects of the magic sold. Lethal magic was treated essentially as a subsection of poisoning, and punished accordingly with death, though not by burning, while lesser offenses could only lead to a fine or corporal punishment. Only with TheLateMiddleAges and TheCavalierYears, especially with the publication of the infamous ''[[Literature/MalleusMaleficarum Malleus]] [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malleus_Maleficarum Maleficarum]]'' did the mass witch hunts begin. Prior to this, the Church's position was largely that witches were not even real - or rather, that magic was not real, simply illusions of the Devil.Devil[[note]]In fact, belief in witches was condemned as Pagan and worthy of capital punishment at the Council of Paderborn (785 C.E./A.D.)[[/note]]. The ''Malleus'' itself was banned when it came out as the heretical ravings of a lunatic, but unfortunately enthusiastic amateurs got a hold of it anyway, causing a boom among both Catholic and Protestant laymen.



* Translation:
** Interestingly, the passage quoted at the top of this page, from the King James Version, is actually a rather iffy translation. The term "witch" is a more recent invention of the English language, and of course no particular method of execution was prescribed. The word used in the original language roughly translates to "sorceress" with "[[MindRape one who twists the minds of others]] for personal gain" connotations. Though rulers who served God often stamped out ''all'' practitioners; this is why Saul had trouble finding one when he decided to actually consult one.
** Another translation renders the word as ''prostitute''. Sacred prostitutes often served the god(desse)s of the nations opposing Israel. They were seen as trying to tempt God's people away from him. Some may have practiced sacred rites.
** It's also possible that the original word was ''poisoner'', as there was overlap between the Greek and Latin words for "poisoner" and "witch"; King James was [[TheWitchHunter rather obsessed with witchcraft]], which may have influenced the translation.



* [[http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/04/05/amnesty-calls-for-action-after-new-guinea-witch-burnings/ 2013 goings-on in Papua New Guinea]].

to:

* [[http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/04/05/amnesty-calls-for-action-after-new-guinea-witch-burnings/ 2013 goings-on in Papua New Guinea]].An utterly bizarre example occurred with the death of the two last [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_auk Great Auks]]; apparently the last two individuals were killed because their capture occurred at the same time a storm came, leading the sailors to think the birds were witches.



* UsefulNotes/JoanOfArc, who led the French army during UsefulNotes/TheHundredYearsWar, was eventually captured by the English. She was put on trial for heresy in a KangarooCourt, was found guilty, and burned at the stake.
[[/folder]]

to:

* UsefulNotes/JoanOfArc, who led the French army during UsefulNotes/TheHundredYearsWar, was eventually captured by the English. She was put on trial for heresy [[http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/04/05/amnesty-calls-for-action-after-new-guinea-witch-burnings/ 2013 goings-on in a KangarooCourt, was found guilty, and burned at the stake.
[[/folder]]
Papua New Guinea]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

For the band, see Music/BurningWitches.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This turns out to have been the fate of the vengeful spirit in ''VisualNovel/TheLetter''. She was accused of having used witchcraft, including using it to kill Lady Charlotte's husband, and was sentenced to be burned at the stake, a fate that she took to silently.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the ''WesternAnimation/InvaderZim'' fanfic ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/3680245/1/Witch-Hunt Witch Hunt]],'' in an alternate universe set in Puritan times, Gaz is accused of being a witch and performing evil magic against her neighbors. Although she is highly unpleasant and anti-social, her brother Dib knows she is not a witch and tries his best to defend her. Her only defense is to sneer that she's not a witch and call everyone idiots for believing in them. She eventually gets burned at the stake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Demon:''' ''[[SarcasmMode Lies?]] [[GodIsDispleased In your house of god?]]

to:

'''Demon:''' ''[[SarcasmMode Lies?]] Lies?]]'' [[GodIsDispleased In your house of god?]]

Added: 130

Changed: 59

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''WesternAnimation/Castlevania2017'', Dracula's wife is burnt at the stake as a witch for the crime of being a woman interested in science. Dracula ain't too happy about that, and returns one year after she's killed to rain down bloody vengeance on the town of Wallachia, both [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge figuratively]] and [[RainOfBlood literally]].

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/Castlevania2017'', Dracula's wife is burnt at the stake as a witch for the crime of being a woman interested in science. Dracula ain't too happy about that, and returns one year after she's killed to rain down bloody vengeance on the town of Wallachia, both [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge figuratively]] and [[RainOfBlood literally]]. The bishop who did the deed later tries to defend himself.
-->'''Bishop:''' [[NeverMyFault She was a witch!]]\\
'''Demon:''' ''[[SarcasmMode Lies?]] [[GodIsDispleased In your house of god?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The "swimming" of witches, one of the most famous methods of interrogating a suspected witch, had the virtue of being both pointless and redundant. Popular belief makes it out as a MortonsFork, saying that if the woman floated, that proved she was a witch, and they'd pull her out and kill her. If the woman drowned, that proved she wasn't a witch... but she'd still be dead. Actually the woman would be tied to a rope: if she did float, they would pull her out, and the fact would be regarded as incriminating. (Of course sometimes they wouldn't do this quick enough, and she'd still drown. "Floating" could also be achieved by trickery with the ropes). If she sank, they would pull her out and clear her of charges. The ducking stool is an unrelated, non-lethal device of punishment where a woman was dunked in cold water for being a public nuisance of some sort.

to:

The "swimming" of witches, one of the most famous methods of interrogating a suspected witch, had the virtue of being both pointless and redundant. Popular belief makes it out as a MortonsFork, saying that if the woman floated, that proved she was a witch, and they'd pull her out and kill her. If the woman drowned, sank, that proved she wasn't a witch... but she'd drown and still be dead. Actually the woman would be tied to a rope: if she did float, they would pull her out, and the fact would be regarded as incriminating. (Of course sometimes they wouldn't do this quick enough, and she'd still drown. "Floating" could also be achieved by trickery with the ropes). If she sank, they would pull her out and clear her of charges. The ducking stool is an unrelated, non-lethal device of punishment where a woman was dunked in cold water for being a public nuisance of some sort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The "swimming" of witches, one of the most famous methods of interrogating a suspected witch, had the virtue of being both pointless and redundant. Popular belief makes it out as a MortonsFork, saying that if the woman floated, that proved she was a witch, and they'd pull her out and kill her. If the woman drowned, that proved she wasn't a witch... but she'd still be dead. Actually the woman would be tied to a rope: if she did float, they would pull her out, and the fact would be regarded as incriminating. (Of course sometimes they wouldn't do this quick enough, and she'd still drown. "Floating" could also be achieved by trickery with the ropes). If she sank, they would pull her out all the same, but cleared of charges. The ducking stool is an unrelated, non-lethal device of punishment where a woman was dunked in cold water for being a public nuisance of some sort.

to:

The "swimming" of witches, one of the most famous methods of interrogating a suspected witch, had the virtue of being both pointless and redundant. Popular belief makes it out as a MortonsFork, saying that if the woman floated, that proved she was a witch, and they'd pull her out and kill her. If the woman drowned, that proved she wasn't a witch... but she'd still be dead. Actually the woman would be tied to a rope: if she did float, they would pull her out, and the fact would be regarded as incriminating. (Of course sometimes they wouldn't do this quick enough, and she'd still drown. "Floating" could also be achieved by trickery with the ropes). If she sank, they would pull her out all the same, but cleared and clear her of charges. The ducking stool is an unrelated, non-lethal device of punishment where a woman was dunked in cold water for being a public nuisance of some sort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The "swimming" of witches, one of the most famous methods of interrogating a suspected witch, had the virtue of being both pointless and redundant. Popular belief makes it out as a MortonsFork, saying that if the woman floated, that proved she was a witch, and they'd pull her out and kill her. If the woman drowned, that proved she wasn't a witch... but well, she'd still be dead. Actually the woman would be tied to a rope: if she did float, they would pull her out, and the fact would be regarded as incriminating. (Of course sometimes they wouldn't do this quick enough, and she'd still drown. "Floating" could also be achieved by trickery with the ropes). If she sank, they would pull her out all the same, but cleared of charges. The ducking stool is an unrelated, non-lethal device of punishment where a woman was dunked in cold water for being a public nuisance of some sort.

to:

The "swimming" of witches, one of the most famous methods of interrogating a suspected witch, had the virtue of being both pointless and redundant. Popular belief makes it out as a MortonsFork, saying that if the woman floated, that proved she was a witch, and they'd pull her out and kill her. If the woman drowned, that proved she wasn't a witch... but well, she'd still be dead. Actually the woman would be tied to a rope: if she did float, they would pull her out, and the fact would be regarded as incriminating. (Of course sometimes they wouldn't do this quick enough, and she'd still drown. "Floating" could also be achieved by trickery with the ropes). If she sank, they would pull her out all the same, but cleared of charges. The ducking stool is an unrelated, non-lethal device of punishment where a woman was dunked in cold water for being a public nuisance of some sort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is how it's done.


* ''[[Literature/TheWheelOfTime The Wheel of Time]]'': The Whitecloaks and their stronghold nation of Amadicia criminalize use of the One Power or simply training in the [[WizardingSchool White Tower]], and see all Aes Sedai as witches. Since only women can channel without going mad, this creates a ReversePsychology effect in Amadicia where men are more trusted than women to be healers even though male channelers are more dangerous, simply because the perceived threat of female channelers is far more present. In the past, the Whitecloaks managed to kill one [[TheArchmage Amyrlin Seat]], although a formal execution was considered difficult considering that she could actually channel the One Power. Instead, they had to opt for simply murdering the Amyrlin and [[DeadGuyOnDisplay hanging her body in the Fortress of the Light after she was already dead]].

to:

* ''[[Literature/TheWheelOfTime The Wheel of Time]]'': ''Literature/TheWheelOfTime'': The Whitecloaks and their stronghold nation of Amadicia criminalize use of the One Power or simply training in the [[WizardingSchool White Tower]], and see all Aes Sedai as witches. Since only women can channel without going mad, this creates a ReversePsychology effect in Amadicia where men are more trusted than women to be healers even though male channelers are more dangerous, simply because the perceived threat of female channelers is far more present. In the past, the Whitecloaks managed to kill one [[TheArchmage Amyrlin Seat]], although a formal execution was considered difficult considering that she could actually channel the One Power. Instead, they had to opt for simply murdering the Amyrlin and [[DeadGuyOnDisplay hanging her body in the Fortress of the Light after she was already dead]].

Top