Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / BlackVikings

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Reckoned to be the origin of the "Blue Men of Dublin," a 10th Century Irish-Viking warband.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The fact that Eartha is [[ButNotTooBlack Not Too Black]] also helps a little.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Bart isn't a cowboy, he's a sheriff of a town.


* ''BlazingSaddles'' has a black sheriff in the wild west, which would at first seem like this trope -- except that there were plenty of black cowboys, it's just that most Westerns didn't cast any.
** The fact that this is unusual for both the genre and the period is a pretty major plot point, anyway. It's not something that Brooks shied away from for a second.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moving to discussion


* Movies about Ghengis Khan, or the Mongolian Hordes, or the Scythian's bothering Rome, or what-have-you, tend to cast people who look Mongolian (or are meant to, at least). However, Ghengis Khan had ''red hair'' and ''green eyes''. All the plains-tribes of the area currently known as Mongolia (and the plains from the Caucasus east) had a massive variety of ethnicity as they intermingled with each other and the societies they raided. While the first Asian people the Romans met were tribes from this vast area, so too were the first Caucasian people the Chinese met. These tribes were from everywhere, genetically. Mongolians as they are now are fairly recent as a dominant people in the area.
** To be fair, the red hair and green eyes depiction is up for debate, and more historians side with him not having red hair and green eyes. Still no one is 100% certain what he looked like.
*** Nor does possessing either of those characteristics necessarily imply that he was Caucasian; Mongols are a relatively diverse people in terms of such physical characteristics compared to other Asian peoples, and Central Asian "Mongoloid" individuals with red or blond hair and blue or green eyes, while rarer than among Europeans, are far from unknown.
** It's not helped by the fact that Genghis outlawed anyone drawing a picture of him under penalty of death. He subscribed to the "get your picture taken, lose your soul" belief.
* Additionally, all Genghis Khan movies use normal European horses, when the breeds used by the Mongols were actually smaller and had larger heads.

Changed: 109

Removed: 139

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TheMightyThor'' movie has apparently cast Idris Elba as one of the Norse gods. So pretty much literal there. For bonus points, said god is Baldr, a god associated with light and whiteness. Apparently the casting decision was at least partly influenced by a desire to spite Neo-Nazis, many of whom are Norse mythology buffs. Seeing as they're gods and it's a movie based on the Thor comic, historical accuracy isn't exactly to be expected.
** In truth, he will be playing Heimdall. Who was sometimes called "whitest of the aesir" and "the white god". So, extra plus bones points?

to:

* ''TheMightyThor'' movie has apparently cast Idris Elba as one of the Norse gods. So pretty much literal there. For bonus extra irony points, said god he'll be playing Heimdall, who is Baldr, a god associated with light often referred to as "White-god" and whiteness."whitest of the Aesir". Apparently the casting decision was at least partly influenced by a desire to spite Neo-Nazis, many of whom are Norse mythology buffs. Seeing as they're gods and it's a movie based on the Thor comic, historical accuracy isn't exactly to be expected. \n** In truth, he will be playing Heimdall. Who was sometimes called "whitest of the aesir" and "the white god". So, extra plus bones points?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''TheSimpsons'': Carl portrays explorer William Clark (of course, Lenny is Meriwether Lewis). As an inversion, Lisa portrays Sacajawea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In truth, he will be playing Heimdall. Which was sometimes called "whitest of the aesir" and "the white god". So, extra plus bonus points?

to:

** In truth, he will be playing Heimdall. Which Who was sometimes called "whitest of the aesir" and "the white god". So, extra plus bonus bones points?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
sp


** In truth, he will be playing Heimdall. Which was sometimes called "whitest of the aesir" and "the white god". So, extra plus bones points?

to:

** In truth, he will be playing Heimdall. Which was sometimes called "whitest of the aesir" and "the white god". So, extra plus bones bonus points?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In truth, he will be playing Heimdall. Which was sometimes called "whitest of the aesir" and "the white god". So, extra plus bones points?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is especially likely to happen when the writers don't know the actual ethnicities available or when they are aiming at a color-blind cast at all costs.

Depending on the time and place, this can actually be [[AluminumChristmasTrees realistic]]. While other races were often rare and always a bit of a curiosity throughout history, racism as we know it only really caught on with the expansion of the slave trade. You can see this in works such as ''{{Othello}}'', where there is some discussion of Othello's race but for the most part he's one of the most respected men in Venice, you just wouldn't want your daughter to marry him.

to:

This is especially likely to happen when the writers don't know the actual ethnicities available or when they are aiming at a color-blind cast at all costs.

costs. Or perhaps they didn't have the budget to be picky with extras...

Depending on the time and place, this can actually be [[AluminumChristmasTrees realistic]]. While other races were often rare and always a bit of a curiosity throughout history, racism as we know it only really caught on with the expansion of the slave trade. You can see this in works such as ''{{Othello}}'', where there is some discussion of Othello's race but for the most part he's one of the most respected men in Venice, Venice; you just wouldn't want your daughter to marry him.



Subtrope of PoliticallyCorrectHistory.

to:

Subtrope of PoliticallyCorrectHistory. See also NotEvenBotheringWithTheAccent, RaceLift.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width:345:[[strike:...Not likely.]] See RealLife.]]

to:

[[caption-width:345:[[strike:...Not likely.]] See RealLife.]]
[[caption-width:345:One of these guys is not like the others. ([[CompletelyMissingThePoint He's missing a helmet!]])]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed the phrase "it being 500+ years before the invention of racism", because seriously what the hell


* Vikings traded down into the Mediterranean, and had a term for the dark skinned folk found in North Africa: Bluemen (blue meaning dark). One such joining a group of Vikings would not have been far fetched, and one ending up a thrall even less so. Of course, thralls often earned their freedom and the respect of the community, and it being 500+ years before the invention of racism...

to:

* Vikings traded down into the Mediterranean, and had a term for the dark skinned folk found in North Africa: Bluemen (blue meaning dark). One such joining a group of Vikings would not have been far fetched, and one ending up a thrall even less so. Of course, thralls often earned their freedom and the respect of the community, and it being 500+ years before the invention of racism...community.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****Actually, {{Othello}} is referred to as both "black" and "tawny," leaving some doubt as to whether he was truly a Moor or actually black. Shakespeare probably didn't know the difference.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TheMightyThor'' movie has apparently cast Idris Elba as one of the Norse gods. So pretty much literal there. For bonus points, said god is Baldr, a god associated with light and whiteness. Apparently the casting decision was at least partly influenced by a desire to spite white supremacist, many of whom are Norse mythology buffs. Seeing as they're gods and it's a movie based on the Thor comic, historical accuracy isn't exactly to be expected.

to:

* ''TheMightyThor'' movie has apparently cast Idris Elba as one of the Norse gods. So pretty much literal there. For bonus points, said god is Baldr, a god associated with light and whiteness. Apparently the casting decision was at least partly influenced by a desire to spite white supremacist, Neo-Nazis, many of whom are Norse mythology buffs. Seeing as they're gods and it's a movie based on the Thor comic, historical accuracy isn't exactly to be expected.

Changed: 343

Removed: 446

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TheMightyThor'' movie has apparently cast Idris Elba as one of the Norse gods. So pretty much literal there.
** Hilariously (or maybe not, if you're white) the Norse god he's casted as had the title of "whitest of the aesir." It's like casting Shaft as a white guy.
*** What's really hilarious is people thinking that refers to skin color. The Norse wouldn't have seen many black people and the terms 'black' and 'white' weren't used for skin back then. Anyway, acting like that's the biggest betrayal of mythology in the movie where Thor is a superhero...

to:

* ''TheMightyThor'' movie has apparently cast Idris Elba as one of the Norse gods. So pretty much literal there.
** Hilariously (or maybe not, if you're white)
there. For bonus points, said god is Baldr, a god associated with light and whiteness. Apparently the Norse god he's casted as had the title of "whitest of the aesir." It's like casting Shaft as decision was at least partly influenced by a desire to spite white guy.
*** What's really hilarious is people thinking that refers to skin color. The
supremacist, many of whom are Norse wouldn't have seen many black people and the terms 'black' and 'white' weren't used for skin back then. Anyway, acting like that's the biggest betrayal of mythology in the buffs. Seeing as they're gods and it's a movie where based on the Thor is a superhero... comic, historical accuracy isn't exactly to be expected.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width:345:...Not likely.]]

to:

[[caption-width:345:...[[caption-width:345:[[strike:...Not likely.]] See RealLife.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Given individual mobility and the human tendency to boff anybody available the existence of 'persons of color' in early Europe is very probable. What is NOT probable is that they constituted a large population or would not have been objects of curiousity to their contemporaries. BTW this also implies that there were 'white' folks in Africa and East Asia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It would help if the 'Gwen' in Guinevere didn't mean 'white' or 'fair'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Depending on the time and place, this can actually be [[AluminumChristmasTrees realistic]]. While other races were often rare and always a bit of a curiosity throughout history, racism as we know it only really caught on with the expansion of the slave trade. You can see this in works such as ''{{Othello}}'', where there is some discussion of Othello's race but for the most part he's one of the most respected men in Venice.

It is possible that when a Black Viking appears in film or TV, the character is still the right race. The actor used might have simply been the best available for the role, and the writers are merely asking us to use our imagination to make the actor's physical appearance fit the character's.

to:

Depending on the time and place, this can actually be [[AluminumChristmasTrees realistic]]. While other races were often rare and always a bit of a curiosity throughout history, racism as we know it only really caught on with the expansion of the slave trade. You can see this in works such as ''{{Othello}}'', where there is some discussion of Othello's race but for the most part he's one of the most respected men in Venice.

Venice, you just wouldn't want your daughter to marry him.

It is possible that when a Black Viking appears in film or TV, the character is still the right race. The actor used might have simply been the best available for the role, and the writers are merely asking us to use our imagination to make the actor's physical appearance fit the character's.
character's. Whiteface would of course be unthinkable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A [[SassyBlackWoman Black Moorish woman prosecuting attorney]] named [[{{Valkyries}} Brunhild]] (!) appears in the eponymous ''Die Morin'', written by [[HolyRomanEmpire German]] poet Hermann von Sachsenheim in the year ''[[TheLateMiddleAges 1453]]''. She is supposed to prosecute love cases for the goddess Venus and her lover, King [[RichardWagner Tannhäuser]] (!!), who, according to legend, lived in a subterranean kingdom under some mountain in Germany. Probably Sachsenheim assumed that a servant of Venus was a pagan, and a pagan was a Muslim, and a Muslim was a Moor, and that "Brun-hild" meant "brown-maiden" (instead of "byrnie (=mail-coat)-maiden").

to:

* A [[SassyBlackWoman Black Moorish woman prosecuting attorney]] named [[{{Valkyries}} Brunhild]] (!) appears in the eponymous ''Die Morin'', written by [[HolyRomanEmpire German]] poet Hermann von Sachsenheim in the year ''[[TheLateMiddleAges 1453]]''. She is supposed to prosecute love cases for the goddess Venus and her lover, King [[RichardWagner Tannhäuser]] (!!), who, according to legend, lived in a subterranean kingdom under some mountain in Germany. Probably Sachsenheim assumed that a servant of Venus was a pagan, and a pagan was a Muslim, and a Muslim was a Moor, and that "Brun-hild" meant "brown-maiden" (instead of "byrnie (=mail-coat)-maiden").(=mail-coat)-warrior").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width:345:Not Likely]]

to:

[[caption-width:345:Not Likely]]
[[caption-width:345:...Not likely.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The general population of the world doesn't appear to know that much about what's going on, at one point thinking the group that attacked the Statue of Liberty were terrorists. Considering that ''ARaisinInTheSun'' was ahead of its time in the '50s for showing an African American woman going to medical school I think we should just call this RefugeInCool.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And besides, that particular version is start to finish RuleOfFunny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** What's really hilarious is people thinking that refers to skin color. The Norse wouldn't have seen many black people and the terms 'black' and 'white' weren't used for skin back then. Anyway, acting like that's the biggest betrayal of mythology in the movie where Thor is a superhero...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Pretty much any game that features [[TheBaroness Nazi dominatrixes]] in a commanding position in the Nazi military hierarchy, given the extreme StayInTheKitchen (and pop out those Aryan babies while you're at it) attitude of the Third Reich. Then again, most such games tend to also feature Nazi vampires or Nazi cyborgs, so historical accuracy clearly isn't a major goal.

to:

* Pretty much any game that features [[TheBaroness Nazi dominatrixes]] in a commanding position in the Nazi military hierarchy, given the extreme StayInTheKitchen (and pop out those Aryan babies while you're at it) attitude of the Third Reich. Then again, most such games tend to also feature Nazi vampires or [[StupidJetpackHitler Nazi cyborgs, cyborgs]], so historical accuracy clearly isn't a major goal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Vikings traded down into the Mediterranean, and had a term for the dark skinned folk found in North Africa: Bluemen. One such joining a group of Vikings would not have been far fetched, and one ending up a thrall even less so. Of course, thralls often earned their freedom and the respect of the community, and it being 500+ years before the invention of racism...

to:

* Vikings traded down into the Mediterranean, and had a term for the dark skinned folk found in North Africa: Bluemen.Bluemen (blue meaning dark). One such joining a group of Vikings would not have been far fetched, and one ending up a thrall even less so. Of course, thralls often earned their freedom and the respect of the community, and it being 500+ years before the invention of racism...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[=~M* A* S* H~=]'', set during the Korean War, featured a black surgeon. (The TV show followed suit for a few episodes until the anachronism of the idea was pointed out to the producers.)
** I don't see how this qualifies, since the U.S. military was at least partially integrated in 1948 - and also because there were black doctors in the U.S. as early as the nineteenth century.

to:

* ''[=~M* A* S* H~=]'', ''[=~M*A*S*H~=]'', set during the Korean War, featured a black surgeon. (The surgeon (the TV show followed suit for a few episodes until the anachronism of the idea was pointed out to the producers.)
producers).
** I don't see how this qualifies, since the U.S. military was at least partially integrated in 1948 - -- and also because there were black doctors in the U.S. as early as the nineteenth century.



* In ''SpeedRacer'', during the "Casa Christo" crucible, one of the teams bribed to take out the Togokhan Team (Speed, Racer X, and Taejo) was a [[TokenTrio trio]] of Viking-esque barbarians, the leader of whom was black. Who fired [[BeeBeeGun nests of bees]] [[CrazyAwesome from their cars]]. Justified in that the team [[HandWave wasn't going for historical accuracy anyway.]]

to:

* In ''SpeedRacer'', during the "Casa Christo" crucible, one of the teams bribed to take out the Togokhan Team (Speed, Racer X, and Taejo) was a [[TokenTrio trio]] of Viking-esque barbarians, the leader of whom was black. Who fired [[BeeBeeGun nests of bees]] [[CrazyAwesome from their cars]]. Justified in that the team [[HandWave wasn't going for historical accuracy anyway.]]anyway]].



** Hilariously(Or maybe not, if you're white) the Norse god he's casted as had the title of "whitest of the aesir." It's like casting Shaft as a white guy.

to:

** Hilariously(Or Hilariously (or maybe not, if you're white) the Norse god he's casted as had the title of "whitest of the aesir." It's like casting Shaft as a white guy.



* Interesting little aversion: In an online discussion of the political correctness of ''DoctorWho'' producer RussellTDavies, the topic came up of a {{docudrama}} concerning a trial in VictorianLondon, in which they cast a black man as the judge. It emerged that, as surprising as it might seem, in actuality, a black judge really ''had'' presided over the case and the producers of the {{docudrama}} had merely [[ShownTheirWork presented what had happened in reality.]]
** In what is inarguably the ''best'' Doctor Who story of the 1980s, Curse of Fenric, one of the Russian soldiers led by Captain Sorin was played by a black man. (He's the one who spends most of the story under the sea, having been the first victim of the Haemovore.) However, his character being a Russian soldier in 1942, he also spends the episode under several millimetres of heavy white pancake make up.. ) The actor was actually one of the technical crew, and is part Dutch.
* In the 2006 series of ''Series/RobinHood'', one early episode feature [[{{TheDragon}} Guy of Gisbourne's]] political scheming against the [[{{BigBad}} Sheriff's]] current Master at Arms. The fact that the Master at Arms is black in 12th century England is never mentioned nor influence the plot. [[WordOfGod The producers have mentioned]] that originally there was no intention for the character to be black, but that the actor gave such a damned fine audition and performance that they felt he could pull it off regardless of the fact that that he would seem out of place, and gave him the part as-written, without any changes to make reference to his color.

to:

* Interesting little aversion: In an online discussion of the political correctness of ''DoctorWho'' producer RussellTDavies, the topic came up of a {{docudrama}} concerning a trial in VictorianLondon, in which they cast a black man as the judge. It emerged that, as surprising as it might seem, in actuality, a black judge really ''had'' presided over the case and the producers of the {{docudrama}} had merely [[ShownTheirWork presented what had happened in reality.]]
reality]].
** In what is inarguably the ''best'' Doctor Who story of the 1980s, Curse of Fenric, one of the Russian soldiers led by Captain Sorin was played by a black man. (He's man (he's the one who spends most of the story under the sea, having been the first victim of the Haemovore.) Haemovore). However, his character being a Russian soldier in 1942, he also spends the episode under several millimetres of heavy white pancake make up.. ) The actor was actually one of the technical crew, and is part Dutch.
* In the 2006 series of ''Series/RobinHood'', one early episode feature [[{{TheDragon}} [[TheDragon Guy of Gisbourne's]] political scheming against the [[{{BigBad}} [[BigBad Sheriff's]] current Master at Arms. The fact that the Master at Arms is black in 12th century England is never mentioned nor influence the plot. [[WordOfGod The producers have mentioned]] that originally there was no intention for the character to be black, but that the actor gave such a damned fine audition and performance that they felt he could pull it off regardless of the fact that that he would seem out of place, and gave him the part as-written, without any changes to make reference to his color.



* ''{{Merlin}}'' has been accused of this; Guinevere is black, as are several courtiers and some of the royal knights. The production team has {{handwave}}d this, and apparent anachronisms, by stating in interviews that the show is set in a mythical land that's not intended to be historically accurate. The Arthurian myths are already pretty anachronistic. French chivalry in dark age Britain? Come on...

to:

* ''{{Merlin}}'' has been accused of this; Guinevere is black, as are several courtiers and some of the royal knights. The production team has {{handwave}}d {{hand wave}}d this, and apparent anachronisms, by stating in interviews that the show is set in a mythical land that's not intended to be historically accurate. The Arthurian myths are already pretty anachronistic. French chivalry in dark age Britain? Come on...






Added: 253

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This qualifies. Although there were black surgeons and the Army was already integrated, there's no evidence that any black surgeons were in the Army in Korea during the war.

to:

** This qualifies. Although there were black surgeons and the Army was already integrated, there's no evidence that any black surgeons were in the Army in Korea during the war. war.
*** It would qualify if not for the fact that the story was basically a marginally fictionalized MEMOIR. That and Spearchucker was transferred into the 4077th to act as a ringer for a football game; the story never explains what unit he was with before.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Eartha Kitt as Freya the Norn in ''ErikTheViking''. Her performance is so well done, though, that most people key to the fact that Eartha Kitt is a ''black'' woman playing a Norse soothsayer [[FridgeLogic only after the movie is over]].

Top