Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AmbiguousGender

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**TheOtherWiki mentions that photo captions in C.G. Conn's magazine refer to the character as "he", adding the confusion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Actually the real question about all this is: 'why would it be frustrating?'. Isn't it that you only want to know a gender so that you can put the western view of a gender on it? Isn't it just frustration because you can't be sexist, yet at the same time, you are?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To make it even more confusing, her [[spoiler:human self]] was a Bifauxnen, so most people thought she was a boy.

to:

** To make it even more confusing, her [[spoiler:human self]] was a Bifauxnen, {{Bifauxnen}}, so most people thought she was a boy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the anime (this troper watched the English dub) it's implied that Envy (a shapeshifter) may have forgotten his original body (and gender), and simply returns to the pineapple-headed form because it's his favorite. Still, his voice sounds low and rough but feminine, and it's hard to tell for sure until it's stated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Although stated as female, Airrazor was physically ambiguous enough that when BeastWars was dubbed for a Japanese audience, her [[ShesAManInJapan gender changed]].
**Also, Transmutate's gender was a mystery. Other characters mostly referred to the deformed Transformer with "it". Aside from that, there was one utterance of "she" as a pronoun, and Transmutate was given voice by the show's voice director and Transformers alum SusanBlu, leading to the prevailing contention the character was female.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Wayward Vagabond from {{Homestuck}} still has yet to give any indication as to his or her gender. This has led to some rather interesting fanart. The general opinion is that WV is male, although a fair amount think that WV is female or are unsure.
** Then again, the character in question is so mysterious to begin with that it's often argued what species he/she/it is. The only commonly agreed fact about the character is that [[MemeticMutation WV has white nipples.]]
** The same dilemma applies to the Peregrine mendicant.
*** PM has been confirmed as female, by being shown with clothing that implies breasts as well as being addressed as female in a note from another character. However, there is now also an ambiguously gendered Aimless Renegade as well...
**** WV and AR are both male.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bowie also used this trope in his song "Rebel Rebel," where even the character's ''mother'' is "not sure if you're a boy or a girl."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a wiki word.


* The gender of secondary character Merideth in Vonda N. McIntyre's ''Dreamsnake'' is [[GenderNeutralWriting left entirely up to reader discretion]]. (Quite tellingly, when asked who would play the character in a film adaptation, McIntyre mentioned both [[DudeLooksLikeALady Jaye Davidson]] and [[{{Bifauxnen}} Tilda Swinton]] as possibilities.)

to:

* The gender of secondary character Merideth in Vonda N. McIntyre's [=McIntyre=]'s ''Dreamsnake'' is [[GenderNeutralWriting left entirely up to reader discretion]]. (Quite tellingly, when asked who would play the character in a film adaptation, McIntyre [=McIntyre=] mentioned both [[DudeLooksLikeALady Jaye Davidson]] and [[{{Bifauxnen}} Tilda Swinton]] as possibilities.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
addition, possibly relevant

Added DiffLines:

** This could very well not count, since it is very visible, non-ambiguous gender, just constantly changing. And you can change your own, too, using said makeover mage! And, continuing, both genders can wear same clothes, with just a few exceptions, and have long or short hair. [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-6pcgdLfb_A#t=2m14s This video]] should explain it better.

Added: 407

Changed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added on Flaky


* Flaky the porcupine from ''HappyTreeFriends''. It's a long-standing, and still present debate due to her ambiguous appearance (unlike the other female Tree Friends, she lacks TertiarySexualCharacteristics). Although WordOfGod says that Flaky's a female, there is still reason to believe otherwise.

to:

* Flaky the porcupine from ''HappyTreeFriends''. It's a long-standing, and still present debate due to her ambiguous appearance (unlike the other female Tree Friends, she lacks TertiarySexualCharacteristics). Although WordOfGod from Flaky's voice actress in an interview says that Flaky's a female, there is still reason to believe otherwise.otherwise.
** Among many pro-female arguments, an outstanding one is that [[DiscoDan Disco Bear]] (a male) has hit on Flaky on a couple of occasions, and "[[HeteronormativeCrusader Disco Bear would not wink at]] [[DroppedABridgetOnHim a guy.]]"
** [[http://www.happytreefriends.com/index.php/about/characters/htf-characters/flaky/ The official character page]] lists Flaky's gender as "?", being the superior WordOfGod.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
how did we miss this one?

Added DiffLines:

* Flaky the porcupine from ''HappyTreeFriends''. It's a long-standing, and still present debate due to her ambiguous appearance (unlike the other female Tree Friends, she lacks TertiarySexualCharacteristics). Although WordOfGod says that Flaky's a female, there is still reason to believe otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
linkify


* Pwt in ''Muse'' magazine. The subject is one of constant argument on the Muse Mail page.

to:

* Pwt in ''Muse'' magazine.''MuseMagazine''. The subject is one of constant argument on the Muse Mail page.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from [[Webcomic/MurphysLaw Murphy's Law]] have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.

to:

* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from [[Webcomic/MurphysLaw Murphy's Law]] have elves with lowered much less noticeable secondary sexual characteristics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Yubel (formerly pictured above) in ''{{Yu-Gi-Oh GX}}''. No body except a demonic arm, uses 'boku' and initially primarily a female voice. Then, Yubel starts shifting from a female to a male voice and back, and also mixes that in with the voice of the host's. Characters also refer to him/her as, well, him and her. The answer, of course, is that Yubel is a hermaphrodite human/spirit fusion... thing.

to:

* Yubel (formerly pictured above) [[http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/yubel_5845.jpg Yubel]] in ''{{Yu-Gi-Oh GX}}''. No body except a demonic arm, uses 'boku' and initially primarily a female voice. Then, Yubel starts shifting from a female to a male voice and back, and also mixes that in with the voice of the host's. Characters also refer to him/her as, well, him and her. The answer, of course, is that Yubel is a hermaphrodite human/spirit fusion... thing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As epic as a seven-tailed Beatle would be, I'm reasonably sure there are no early rock stars in Naruto.


* The 7-Tailed Beatle's host in ''{{Naruto}}''. Even the creator isn't sure, although he's leaning towards female at this point. S/he's dead anyway, so it's only supplementary.

to:

* The 7-Tailed Beatle's Beetle's host in ''{{Naruto}}''. Even the creator isn't sure, although he's leaning towards female at this point. S/he's dead anyway, so it's only supplementary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Same for Karuto and Ilumi.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* People are STILL debating the genders of some of the appliances (especially Toaster) from {{The Brave Little Toaster}}

Added: 213

Changed: 74

Removed: 272

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Theater]]
* The play Sylvia, by A.R. Gurney has a character named Leslie, a person of indeterminate gender, that asks the other characters to assign gender roles to him/her when they first meet.
[[/folder]]



* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from [[Webcomic/MurphysLaw]] have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.

to:

* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from [[Webcomic/MurphysLaw]] [[Webcomic/MurphysLaw Murphy's Law]] have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.






** According to the french translation, it's [[spoiler:a girl]]
** The German translation opts to make it a [[spoiler:boy]]

to:

** According to the french French translation, it's [[spoiler:a girl]]
** The
a girl; the German translation opts to make it a [[spoiler:boy]]boy.




[[folder:Theater]]
* The play Sylvia, by A.R. Gurney has a character named Leslie, a person of indeterminate gender, that asks the other characters to assign gender roles to him/her when they first meet.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The mystery was actually "solved" in a really round-about way. Fans debated endlessly about whether Pat was a man or a woman -- and the writers never planned on revealing the character's true sex -- until one particular sketch towards the end of Pat's run. The actress playing the character, Julia Sweeney, had been super careful throughout the series to never act in a gendered manner, but when Pat was to be kissed by another character, Sweeney instintively titled her head back ever so slightly the way a woman would. When fans brought this to her attention, Sweeney said that her little goof confirmed Pat was a woman and that it was now canon.

to:

** The mystery was actually "solved" in a really round-about way. Fans debated endlessly about whether Pat was a man or a woman -- and the writers never planned on revealing the character's true sex -- until one particular sketch towards the end of Pat's run. The actress playing the character, Julia Sweeney, had been super careful throughout the series to never act in a gendered manner, but when Pat was to be kissed by another character, Sweeney instintively titled her head back ever so slightly the way a woman would. When fans brought this to her attention, Sweeney said that her little goof confirmed Pat was a woman and that [[WordOfGod now it was now canon.canon]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The official English dub calls Crona a boy, but only because the writers (who are just as clueless) didn't know what else to say to avoid making the dub sound awkward.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from Webcomic/Murphy's Law have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.

to:

* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from Webcomic/Murphy's Law [[Webcomic/MurphysLaw]] have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from [[Webcomic/Murphy's Law]] have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.

to:

* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from [[Webcomic/Murphy's Law]] Webcomic/Murphy's Law have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from [[Webcomic/ptitletswco1hy Murphy's Law]] have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.

to:

* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from [[Webcomic/ptitletswco1hy Murphy's [[Webcomic/Murphy's Law]] have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Taking cues from ''OrderOfTheStick'', elves from [[Webcomic/ptitletswco1hy Murphy's Law]] have elves with lowered sexual characteristics.

Added: 46

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*In an episode of LloydinSpace, the characters spend an episode trying to figure out the gender of a new kid named Zoit. When asked about it at the end of the episode, Zoit reveals that [[spoiler:members of its (alien) species have no gender until they turn thirteen, at which point they have to decide to be male or female. Zoit chooses a gender, but we're never told which. ]]

to:

*In an episode of LloydinSpace, LloydInSpace, the characters spend an episode trying to figure out the gender of a new kid named Zoit. When asked about it at the end of the episode, Zoit reveals that [[spoiler:members of its (alien) species have no gender until they turn thirteen, at which point they have to decide to be male or female. Zoit chooses a gender, but we're never told which. ]]]]
* The monkey in [[KaBlam Prometheus and Bob]].

Changed: 363

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Roger from ''AmericanDad'' is apparently able to produce an egg and transmit it through 'kissing' someone, but other than this, he acts mostly male (although not very masculine). Since he's an alien, though, he most likely isn't really male or female.

to:

* Roger from ''AmericanDad'' is apparently able to produce an egg and transmit it through 'kissing' someone, but other than this, someone. He also lactates. It doesn't help that on one occasion, he acts mostly male (although not very masculine). Since claimed he "doesn't have a wang," yet in another episode he claims he's an alien, though, he most likely isn't just really male or female.small due to steroid abuse. He's also been shown to be sexually attracted to both males and females, and assumes identities of both genders with his many disguises.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Some of the anime examples can even be frustrating, as Pokemon are ''telepathic''. Even if the voice is clearly male, the characters will insist on saying "It".

to:

*** Some of the anime examples can even be frustrating, as most Pokemon in the movies are ''telepathic''. Even if the voice is clearly male, male or female, the characters will insist on saying "It"."It". The only logical example of this is the eleventh movie's Shaymin, who transitions from a female voice to a male voice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Some of the anime examples can even be frustrating, as Pokemon are ''telepathic''. Even if the voice is clearly male, the characters will insist on saying "It".

Top