Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheReader

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misplaced, moving to the correct tab


* BrokenAesop:
** The film's take on Michael and Hanna's relationship is that it was borderline abusive and very wrong. Yet the scenes of the affair revel in {{Fanservice}}y shots of nude Kate Winslet, and the statutory rapist is presented as merely a complicated person, as opposed to a predatory adult taking advantage of a minor.

Removed: 428

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That is NOT what the movie is suggesting. Hanna refuses to be honest with herself. Her illiteracy is just a shield she puts around her sins. The film makes it clear that Hanna is making excuses.


** The movie ties Hanna's complicity in the Holocaust to [[spoiler:her illiteracy, suggesting she didn't realise the horrors of what was going on until later in life when she learns to read.]] Except one doesn't require [[spoiler:reading skills]] to participate in mass murder, especially when she was a guard at a concentration camp. The movie even omitted a scene of said murder, so as not to make her seem too unsympathetic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected 1996 to 1966


In 1996, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. It turns out that she was a prison guard for the SS, and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women and children perish in a church fire. It also turns out that she hides something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?

to:

In 1996, 1966, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. It turns out that she was a prison guard for the SS, and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women and children perish in a church fire. It also turns out that she hides something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
ZCE


* TheBaroness: Hanna is a [[DeconstructedTrope deconstruction]].
* BathtubBonding: That's what kicks off Michael and Hanna's sexual journey.

to:

* %%* TheBaroness: Hanna is a [[DeconstructedTrope deconstruction]].
* %%* BathtubBonding: That's what kicks off Michael and Hanna's sexual journey.



* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler:Hanna.]]

to:

* %%* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler:Hanna.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Shouldn't these be spoilered? Gotta be consistent at least


** The movie ties Hanna's complicity in the Holocaust to her illiteracy, suggesting she didn't realise the horrors of what was going on until later in life when she learns to read. Except one doesn't require reading skills to participate in mass murder, especially when she was a guard at a concentration camp. The movie even omitted a scene of said murder, so as not to make her seem too unsympathetic.

to:

** The movie ties Hanna's complicity in the Holocaust to her [[spoiler:her illiteracy, suggesting she didn't realise the horrors of what was going on until later in life when she learns to read. read.]] Except one doesn't require reading skills [[spoiler:reading skills]] to participate in mass murder, especially when she was a guard at a concentration camp. The movie even omitted a scene of said murder, so as not to make her seem too unsympathetic.



* NeverLearnedToRead: Hanna can't read. It's why she has Michael read things for her, under the guise of just enjoying being read to. She's so ashamed of her inability that she passes up job promotions and would rather go to prison than reveal it. There's a subtext that we're defined by our interaction with the written text, to the point that not being able to read means ''not existing''. In the book, she's practically invisible to Michael's family and classmates.

to:

* NeverLearnedToRead: Hanna [[spoiler:Hanna can't read. It's why she has Michael read things for her, under the guise of just enjoying being read to. She's so ashamed of her inability that she passes up job promotions and would rather go to prison than reveal it. There's a subtext that we're defined by our interaction with the written text, to the point that not being able to read means ''not existing''. In the book, she's practically invisible to Michael's family and classmates.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In 1996, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. It turns out that she was a prison guard for the S.S., and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women and children perish in a church fire. It also turns out that she hides something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?

to:

In 1996, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. It turns out that she was a prison guard for the S.S., SS, and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women and children perish in a church fire. It also turns out that she hides something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In 1995 Germany, a lawyer named Michael Berg (Fiennes) meets his daughter Julia, who he hasn't seen for a while since he and her mother divorced. Before that, he recalls his sexual awakening as a teenager in 1958 when he began an affair with tram conductor Hanna Schmitz (Winslet). Their sexual liaison is highlighted by him reading to her literary classics, but the affair abruptly ends when she moves out of town.

In 1996, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. It turns out that she was a prison guard for the S.S., and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women inmates perish in a Church fire. It also turns out that she's hidden something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?

to:

In 1995 Germany, a lawyer named Michael Berg (Fiennes) meets his daughter Julia, who he hasn't seen for a while since he and her mother divorced. Before that, he recalls his sexual awakening as a teenager in 1958 when he began an affair with tram conductor Hanna Schmitz (Winslet). Their sexual liaison is highlighted by him reading to her literary classics, classics to her, but the affair abruptly ends when she moves out of town.

In 1996, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. It turns out that she was a prison guard for the S.S., and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women inmates and children perish in a Church church fire. It also turns out that she's hidden she hides something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:250:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/thereader_9833.jpg]]

to:

[[quoteright:250:https://static.[[quoteright:308:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/thereader_9833.jpg]]
org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_reader_2008.jpeg]]



A 1995 German novel by Bernhard Schlink, ''The Reader'', aka ''Der Vorleser'', was adapted for the screen in 2008 by Stephen Daldry and starred Creator/KateWinslet and Creator/RalphFiennes.

In 1995 Germany, a lawyer named Michael Berg meets his daughter, Julia, who he hasn't seen for a while since he and her mother divorced. Before that, he recalls his sexual awakening as a teenager in 1958 when he began an affair with tram conductor Hanna Schmitz. Their sexual liaison is highlighted by him reading to her literary classics, but the affair abruptly ends when she moves out of town.

In 1996, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. She, as it turns out, was a prison guard for the S.S., and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women perish in a Church fire. It also turns out that she hides something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?

'''''The Reader''''' was nominated for several Oscars and won Creator/KateWinslet a long-sought Best Actress award but also suffered some HypeBacklash from people who did not share the movie's perceived sympathy for an SS death camp guard. One critic retitled ''The Reader'' as [[http://www.slate.com/id/2209520/entry/2209521/ "Boohoo, I Bonked An Illiterate Nazi".]] There's also the issue of it being nominated for Best Picture over ''WesternAnimation/WallE'' and ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', both of which were more critically acclaimed than this one (this in particular may have spurred the Academy to expand the number of Best Picture nominees starting the following year).

to:

A 1995 German novel by Bernhard Schlink, ''The Reader'', aka ''Der Vorleser'', was adapted for the screen in into a [[TheFilmOfTheBook 2008 film]] directed by Stephen Daldry and starred starring Creator/KateWinslet and Creator/RalphFiennes.

In 1995 Germany, a lawyer named Michael Berg (Fiennes) meets his daughter, daughter Julia, who he hasn't seen for a while since he and her mother divorced. Before that, he recalls his sexual awakening as a teenager in 1958 when he began an affair with tram conductor Hanna Schmitz.Schmitz (Winslet). Their sexual liaison is highlighted by him reading to her literary classics, but the affair abruptly ends when she moves out of town.

In 1996, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. She, as it It turns out, out that she was a prison guard for the S.S., and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women inmates perish in a Church fire. It also turns out that she hides she's hidden something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?

'''''The Reader''''' The film was nominated for several Oscars five UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s and won Creator/KateWinslet Kate Winslet a long-sought Best Actress award award, but also suffered some HypeBacklash from people who did not share the movie's perceived sympathy for an SS death camp guard. One critic retitled ''The Reader'' as [[http://www.slate.com/id/2209520/entry/2209521/ "Boohoo, I Bonked An Illiterate Nazi".]] There's also the issue of it being nominated for Best Picture over ''WesternAnimation/WallE'' and ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', both of which were more critically acclaimed than this one (this in particular may have spurred the Academy to expand the number of Best Picture nominees starting the following year).



!! ''The Reader'' features examples of:

to:

!! ''The !!''The Reader'' features examples of:
of:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
there is no time travel in the nazi child sex movie


In 1966, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. She, as it turns out, was a prison guard for the S.S., and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women perish in a Church fire. It also turns out that she hides something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?

to:

In 1966, 1996, they meet again, with him as a law student and she as a defendant on trial for war crimes. She, as it turns out, was a prison guard for the S.S., and was present with several other female guards when they let 300 Jewish women perish in a Church fire. It also turns out that she hides something important about herself, a factor which would clear her of full responsibility for the incident. Will he help her get off?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualSuccessor: Can be seen as a 2000s version of ''Film/TheNightPorter''; both films portray a doomed romance between a Nazi war criminal and their [[AgeGapRomance much younger lover]] in post-war Germany, although this film [[GenderSwap reverses the genders]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenAesop:
** The movie ties Hanna's complicity in the Holocaust to her illiteracy, suggesting she didn't realise the horrors of what was going on until later in life when she learns to read. Except one doesn't require reading skills to participate in mass murder, especially when she was a guard at a concentration camp. The movie even omitted a scene of said murder, so as not to make her seem too unsympathetic.
** The film's take on Michael and Hanna's relationship is that it was borderline abusive and very wrong. Yet the scenes of the affair revel in {{Fanservice}}y shots of nude Kate Winslet, and the statutory rapist is presented as merely a complicated person, as opposed to a predatory adult taking advantage of a minor.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 39

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DefiniteArticleTitle: ''The Reader''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->It doesn't matter what I feel. It doesn't matter what I think. The dead are still dead.

to:

->It ->''"It doesn't matter what I feel. It doesn't matter what I think. The dead are still dead."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Nazisploitation}}: [[https://youtu.be/LUCFIGzIk6k Film critic Mark Kermode]] points out this film is a high class OscarBait variation of this subgenre.

to:

* {{Nazisploitation}}: Film critic Creator/MarkKermode [[https://youtu.be/LUCFIGzIk6k Film critic Mark Kermode]] points out out]] this film is a high class OscarBait variation of this subgenre.

Top