Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / StarTrekFirstContact

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* There's something sweet about how Lily, who is not part of the crew of the ''Enterprise'', nevertheless remembers Ensign Lynch, enough to employ his memory in an attempt to talk some sense into Picard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Even sweeter - the Vulcan captain was confirmed in canon to be Solkar; the first Vulcan ambassador to Earth, and father of Skon, grandfather of Sarek and great-grandfather of Spock.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No meta moment, see this query.


** It's also great in meta sense, many of Gene Roddenberry's older fans have often gone on the record of how Star Trek's creator would not have approved of many of the shows and films that have come out since his death. But just about ''everyone'' can agree that he would have liked the idea of the first meeting between humanity and Vulcans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Worf''': ''(Standing up a little straighter)'' Thank you, sir.

to:

-->'''Worf''': ''(Standing ''(standing up a little straighter)'' Thank you, sir.



-->'''Worf''': ([[TranquilFury coldly furious]], looming over Picard) If you were ''any other man'', I would '''kill''' you where you stand...

to:

-->'''Worf''': ([[TranquilFury (''[[TranquilFury coldly furious]], looming over Picard) Picard'') If you were ''any other man'', I would '''kill''' you where you stand...



* Picard telling Riker to "stay out of history's way" when evacuating the ''Enterprise'' crew to [[http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Gravett_Island Gravett Island]]. There's something charming and heartwarming about the scene - probably because they think they won't be able to return home and it's sort of a retirement package to live out their days on a deserted Polynesian island... [[Series/GilligansIsland Wait a minute...]]

to:

* Picard telling Riker to "stay out of history's way" when evacuating the ''Enterprise'' crew to [[http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Gravett_Island Gravett Island]]. There's something charming and heartwarming about the scene - probably because they think they won't be able to return home and it's its sort of a retirement package to live out their days on a deserted Polynesian island... [[Series/GilligansIsland Wait a minute...]]



** Every little moment of wonder from the 21 century humans led to a slight dampness of eye, because it's so perfectly what Trek is about--''this is what the future could be!'' And then when the first Vulcan pulls back his hood to reveal his ears, and the music crests, and you know everything that will unfold and everything that is to come.

to:

** Every little moment of wonder from the 21 21st century humans led to a slight dampness of eye, because it's so perfectly what Trek is about--''this is what the future could be!'' And then when the first Vulcan pulls back his hood to reveal his ears, and the music crests, and you know everything that will unfold and everything that is to come.



*** When you remember that Vulcans are touch-telepaths and as such avoid unnecessary physical contact to avoid accidentally sharing thoughts, this is an even bigger deal. It's the equivalent of finding a culture who greets people by open-mouth kissing them and taking it in stride.

to:

*** When you remember that Vulcans are touch-telepaths and as such avoid unnecessary physical contact to avoid accidentally sharing thoughts, this is an even bigger deal. It's the equivalent of finding a culture who greets people by open-mouth open mouth kissing them and taking it in stride.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Riker helps Cochrane get over his fear of destiny:

to:

* Riker helps helping Cochrane get over his fear of destiny:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This also carries a bit of FridgeBrilliance, as ballistic missiles such as the Titan used by Cochrane were also used as launch vehicles for satellites and spacecraft throughout the Cold War.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Riker:''' (''grinning'') You did, ten years from now.
** Really Riker's whole interaction with Cochrane is this. Unlike everyone else on the enginering staff even Geordi to an extent falling all over themselves at his historical significance to their field and having trouble processing the actual flawed man, Riker just takes it in stride. He doesn't even seem to judge him for admitting he started the whole project for money, seemingly believing he'll change his tune and appreciate the significance to humanity in time. Either Riker has incredible people skills or he's a history buff aware of Cochrane's entire past and not just the shiny famous parts.

to:

-->'''Riker:''' (''grinning'') [[YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre You did, ten years from now.
now]].
** Really Riker's whole interaction with Cochrane is this. Unlike everyone else on the enginering staff staff, even Geordi to an extent extent, falling all over themselves at his historical significance to their field and having trouble processing the actual flawed man, Riker just takes it in stride. He doesn't even seem to judge him for admitting he started the whole project for money, seemingly believing he'll change his tune and appreciate the significance to humanity in time. Either Riker has incredible people skills or he's a history buff aware of Cochrane's entire past and not just the shiny famous parts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Data:''' It is an historical irony that Dr. Cochrane would choose an instrument of mass destruction to inaugurate an era of peace.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After hearing how badly the fight is going for the Starfleet forces, Picard announces his intention to violate orders and take the ship into combat to help, but will allow any dissenters to speak up. As funny and awesome as it is, Data's response after the beat is also a heartwarming display of loyalty:

to:

* After hearing how badly the fight is going for the Starfleet forces, Picard announces his intention to violate orders and take the ship into combat to help, but will allow any dissenters to speak up.up and make sure it is noted so they won't face repercussions from Starfleet. They all say nothing, making it clear they are fully prepared to follow Picard. As funny and awesome as it is, Data's response after the beat is also a heartwarming display of loyalty:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Cochrane nervously clutching Lily's hand before walking towards the Vulcans to greet them.

Changed: 142

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The epilogue, where aliens land to find the human who flew Earth's first warp-drive vessel. When the visitors reveal themselves to be [[spoiler:Vulcans]] (because [[ForegoneConclusion of ''course'' they were]]), you know it is the DawnOfAnEra where humanity's time of desolation and despair has ended and its hopeful beginning of the building of TheFederation has begun.
** Every little moment of wonder from the 21 century humans led to a slight dampness of eye, because it's so perfectly what Trek is about--''this is what the future could be!'' And then when [[spoiler:the first Vulcan pulls back his hood to reveal his ears, and the music crests, and you know everything that will unfold and everything that is to come...yeah.]] Definitely something in the eye.

to:

* The epilogue, where aliens land to find the human who flew Earth's first warp-drive vessel. When the visitors reveal themselves to be [[spoiler:Vulcans]] (because [[ForegoneConclusion of ''course'' they were]]), Vulcans, you know it is the DawnOfAnEra where humanity's time of desolation and despair has ended and its hopeful beginning of the building of TheFederation has begun.
** Every little moment of wonder from the 21 century humans led to a slight dampness of eye, because it's so perfectly what Trek is about--''this is what the future could be!'' And then when [[spoiler:the the first Vulcan pulls back his hood to reveal his ears, and the music crests, and you know everything that will unfold and everything that is to come...yeah.]] Definitely something in the eye.come.



** ''[[Series/StarTrekEnterprise Enterprise]]'' later used this to illustrate how the Mirror Universe diverges, with Cochrane [[spoiler:suddenly shooting the Vulcan instead]], and it works very effectively as a deliberate ShockingSwerve because of how heartwarming the original scene was.

to:

** ''[[Series/StarTrekEnterprise Enterprise]]'' later used this to illustrate how the Mirror Universe diverges, with Cochrane [[spoiler:suddenly suddenly shooting the Vulcan instead]], instead, and it works very effectively as a deliberate ShockingSwerve shocker because of how heartwarming the original scene was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Really Riker's whole interaction with Cochrane is this. Unlike everyone else on the enginering staff even Geordi to an extent falling all over themselves at his historical significance to their field and having trouble processing the actual flawed man, Riker just takes in in stride. He doesn't even seem to judge him for admitting he started the whole project for money, seemingly believing he'll change his tune and appreciate the significance to humanity in time. Either Riker has incredible people skills or he's a history buff aware of Cochrane's entire past and not just the shiny famous parts.

to:

** Really Riker's whole interaction with Cochrane is this. Unlike everyone else on the enginering staff even Geordi to an extent falling all over themselves at his historical significance to their field and having trouble processing the actual flawed man, Riker just takes in it in stride. He doesn't even seem to judge him for admitting he started the whole project for money, seemingly believing he'll change his tune and appreciate the significance to humanity in time. Either Riker has incredible people skills or he's a history buff aware of Cochrane's entire past and not just the shiny famous parts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Terrans in the Mirror Universe killed the Vulcans at First Contact.


** Every little moment of wonder from the 21 century Terrans led to a slight dampness of eye, because it's so perfectly what Trek is about--''this is what the future could be!'' And then when [[spoiler:the first Vulcan pulls back his hood to reveal his ears, and the music crests, and you know everything that will unfold and everything that is to come...yeah.]] Definitely something in the eye.

to:

** Every little moment of wonder from the 21 century Terrans humans led to a slight dampness of eye, because it's so perfectly what Trek is about--''this is what the future could be!'' And then when [[spoiler:the first Vulcan pulls back his hood to reveal his ears, and the music crests, and you know everything that will unfold and everything that is to come...yeah.]] Definitely something in the eye.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Both times Cochrane witnesses Earth from space show his cynical facade cracking and then breaking away; first time when it is getting to orbit in preparation for the flight, and the second time from the apogee of their warp flight as they return.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Worf''': ([[TranquilFury coldly furious]]) If you were ''any other man'', I would '''kill''' you where you stand...

to:

-->'''Worf''': ([[TranquilFury coldly furious]]) furious]], looming over Picard) If you were ''any other man'', I would '''kill''' you where you stand...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Worf''': ([[TranquilFury coldly furious) If you were ''any other man'', I would '''kill''' you where you stand...

to:

-->'''Worf''': ([[TranquilFury coldly furious) furious]]) If you were ''any other man'', I would '''kill''' you where you stand...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Worf''': If you were ''any other man'', I would '''kill''' you where you stand...

to:

-->'''Worf''': ([[TranquilFury coldly furious) If you were ''any other man'', I would '''kill''' you where you stand...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:"Live long and prosper."]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:"Live long and prosper." "Thanks."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* There's a certain irony that the ship destined to help unite the people of Earth and usher in the Federation being built from an ICBM, a tool originally designed in no small way to usher in the end of the world. It even still has the US Air Force markings on it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It helps that Data was a major key to saving Picard (and the Federation in the process). He and Worf were the two people sent to fetch him from the Borg Cube, and then Data interfaced with the collective via Picard in order to stop the cube's advance. There are several people Picard owes his freedom to, but none more so than Data.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** When you remember that Vulcans are touch-telepaths and as such avoid unnecessary physical contact to avoid accidentally sharing thoughts, this is an even bigger deal. It's the equivalent of finding a culture who greets people by open-mouth kissing them and taking it in stride.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Picard going back for Data as the ship is evacuating because he's certain the android is still alive. He justifies it by recalling how the crew risked everything to save him from the Borg years earlier.

to:

* Picard [[NoOneGetsLeftBehind going back for Data Data]] as the ship is evacuating because he's certain the android is still alive. He justifies it by recalling how the crew risked everything to save him from the Borg years earlier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As has been said elsewhere, Picard is one of only 3 people who could say such a thing and survive (the other two being his son Alexander and Sisko).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Really Riker's whole interaction with Cochrane is this. Unlike everyone else on the enginering staff even Geordi to an extent falling all over themselves at his historical significance to their field and having trouble processing the actual flawed man, Riker just takes in in stride. He doesn't even seem to judge him for admitting he started the whole project for money, seemingly believing he'll change his tune and appreciate the significance to humanity in time. Either Riker has incredible people skills or he's a history buff aware of Cochrane's entire past and not just the shiny famous parts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Picard''': I apologize for some of the things I said to you earlier.

to:

-->'''Picard''': I apologize for regret some of the things I said to you earlier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Picard:''' I envy you; taking these first steps into a new frontier.

to:

'''Picard:''' I ''I'' envy you; ''you''; taking these first steps into a new frontier.frontier. I shall miss you, Lily.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's also the fact that [[ThePolyanna Riker]] shows no sign of BrokenPedestal after Cochrane makes his admission of only being in it for the money. It's easy to see the 24th century as a utopia, and many an episode that brings up humanity's past have had gentle (and not so gentle) condemnations of humanity of the present and the motivations that drive them. But Cochrane says that he was set on creating warp drive for the money, and Riker just takes it in stride, then says simply "Someone once said 'Don't try to be a great man. Just be a man, and let history make its own judgments.'" A quote of Cochrane, ten years later, and Riker saying that the why doesn't matter as much as what he did and what it led to.

to:

** There's also the fact that [[ThePolyanna [[ThePollyanna Riker]] shows no sign of BrokenPedestal after Cochrane makes his admission of only being in it for the money. It's easy to see the 24th century as a utopia, and many an episode that brings up humanity's past have had gentle (and not so gentle) condemnations of humanity of the present and the motivations that drive them. But Cochrane says that he was set on creating warp drive for the money, and Riker just takes it in stride, then says simply "Someone once said 'Don't try to be a great man. Just be a man, and let history make its own judgments.'" A quote of Cochrane, ten years later, and Riker saying that the why doesn't matter as much as what he did and what it led to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's also the fact that Riker shows no sign of BrokenPedestal after Cochrane makes his admission of only being in it for the money. It's easy to see the 24th century as a utopia, and many an episode that brings up humanity's past have had gentle (and not so gentle) condemnations of humanity of the present and the motivations that drive them. But Cochrane says that he was set on creating warp drive for the money, and Riker just takes it in stride, then says simply "Someone once said 'Don't try to be a great man. Just be a man, and let history make its own judgments.'" A quote of Cochrane, ten years later, and Riker saying that the why doesn't matter as much as what he did and what it led to.

to:

** There's also the fact that Riker [[ThePolyanna Riker]] shows no sign of BrokenPedestal after Cochrane makes his admission of only being in it for the money. It's easy to see the 24th century as a utopia, and many an episode that brings up humanity's past have had gentle (and not so gentle) condemnations of humanity of the present and the motivations that drive them. But Cochrane says that he was set on creating warp drive for the money, and Riker just takes it in stride, then says simply "Someone once said 'Don't try to be a great man. Just be a man, and let history make its own judgments.'" A quote of Cochrane, ten years later, and Riker saying that the why doesn't matter as much as what he did and what it led to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's also the fact that Riker shows no sign of BrokenPedestal after Cochrane makes his admission of only being in it for the money. It's easy to see the 24th century as a utopia, and many an episode that brings up humanity's past have had gentle (and not so gentle) condemnations of humanity of the present and the motivations that drive them. But Cochrane says that he was set on creating warp drive for the money, and Riker just takes it in stride, then says simply "Someone once said 'Don't try to be a great man. Just be a man, and let history make its own judgments.'" A quote of Cochrane, ten years later, and Riker saying that the why doesn't matter as much as what he did and what it led to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Riker:''' Don't try to be a great man. Just be a man, and let history make its own judgments.

to:

-->'''Riker:''' Don't Someone once said, "Don't try to be a great man. Just be a man, and let history make its own judgments."



-->'''Riker:''' (grinning) You did, ten years from now.

to:

-->'''Riker:''' (grinning) (''grinning'') You did, ten years from now.

Top