Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / KnivesOut

Go To

OR

Added: 471

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After the will reading when the Thromby's turn on Marta, Blanc moves in between them and her. Blanc tries to calm the family down and encourages Marta to leave until things settle down. This becomes even more important once you realize that Blanc ''knew Marta had something to do with Harlan's murder,'' showing that he really was on her side for a considerable length of time and wasn't willing to let her get abused by Harlan's family.

to:

** After the will reading when the Thromby's Thrombeys turn on Marta, Blanc moves in between them and her. Blanc tries to calm the family down and encourages Marta to leave until things settle down. This becomes even more important once you realize that Blanc ''knew Marta had something to do with Harlan's murder,'' showing that he really was on her side for a considerable length of time and wasn't willing to let her get abused by Harlan's family.


Added DiffLines:

** We can see the exact moment that Harlan decides to sacrifice himself for Marta--watching her panic and frantically look for the missing naloxone, knowing she would never have given him the overdose intentionally and is desperately trying to fix a horrible accident, and realizing that she would do anything to save him, even if it meant getting herself and her family in huge trouble. She proved how much she cares about him, and he proved how much he cares about her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After the will reading when the Thromby's turn on Marta, Blanc moves in between them and her. Blanc tries to calm the family down and encourages Marta to leave until things settle down. [[spoiler: This becomes even more important once you realize that Blanc ''knew Marta had something to do with Harlan's murder,'' showing that he really was on her side for a considerable length of time and wasn't willing to let her get abused by Harlan's family.]]

to:

** After the will reading when the Thromby's turn on Marta, Blanc moves in between them and her. Blanc tries to calm the family down and encourages Marta to leave until things settle down. [[spoiler: This becomes even more important once you realize that Blanc ''knew Marta had something to do with Harlan's murder,'' showing that he really was on her side for a considerable length of time and wasn't willing to let her get abused by Harlan's family.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Though given the disdainful attitude most of the Thrombeys have towards "the help", they may be less shocked that Ransom committed murder and more that he will actually be punished for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And while his death may have turned out to be a SenselessSacrifice, he cared enough about Marta that he chose to ''literally'' give his life for her, and to do what he could to salvage her situation and keep her undocumented-immigrant mother off the legal radar. It's telling that when she first informs him that she has just committed an AccidentalMurder on him, he ''never'' gets fearful or angry (either or both would be quite justified); instead, he [[FaceDeathWithDignity Faces Death with Dignity]] and spends his last minutes looking out for her.

to:

** And while his death may have turned out to be a SenselessSacrifice, he cared enough about Marta that he chose to ''literally'' give his life commit HeroicSuicide for her, and to do what he could to salvage her situation and keep her undocumented-immigrant mother off the legal radar. It's telling that when she first informs him that she has just committed an AccidentalMurder on him, he ''never'' gets fearful or angry (either or both would be quite justified); instead, he [[FaceDeathWithDignity Faces Death with Dignity]] and spends his last minutes looking out for her. It's hard to ask for more of an ActOfTrueLove than that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No meta moment, see this query.


** Meta example: Chris Evans, a known dog-lover, really got along with the two German shepherds off-camera. Someone even joked that Evans' best acting isn't being Ransom, it's ''pretending he doesn't love dogs.''



** Meta-heartwarming: he is played by Noah Segan, who had previous played one of the antagonists in ''Brick'' and ''Looper''. Considering the fact that both films were by the same director, it's genuinely nice to see him play a character who isn't a villain and a ButtMonkey.




!! Meta
* When Lee of ''WebVideo/CinemaWins'' did his video on the movie, he was curious about one particular character's job, so he took to Twitter to ask the actress about it. Rian Johnson did him one better and answered the question himself, to Lee's delight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* While talking to Marta, Harlan explains his motives for cutting his family out of the will, wanting Walt to be able to spread his wings and become his own person, and also wanting to actually be a parent to his daughter-in-law Joni, which means putting his foot down rather than let her continue leeching off his money. Harlan says he did this "like you said I should." This is heartwarming both because Harlan trusts Marta enough to confide in her about deeply personal family problems and ask her advice, and because he actually ''took'' said advice. It also reveals Marta really did have the family's best interests at heart, encouraging Harlan to [[PositiveFriendInfluence fix his mess and make them better people]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Fundamentally, the movie believes RousseauWasRight: A good person attempts to continue being a good person, and, despite also being the MainCharacter in a MurderMystery, is ultimately rewarded for their actions.

to:

* Fundamentally, the movie believes RousseauWasRight: A good person attempts to continue being a good person, and, despite also being the MainCharacter in a MurderMystery, is ultimately rewarded for their actions. This is a good {{Aesop}} for any age, but was ''incredibly'' timely and meaningful in 2019.



** Marta only needs a second's hesitation when she thinks Fran is blackmailing her but dying from an overdose. First, she tells Fran not to talk and save her strength, that she's going to be okay. Then she dials 911, places the phone on the floor, and starts performing CPR. Benoit points out that this moment undid Ransom's plan because Fran made it to the hospital, and he underestimated Marta's fundamental goodness.

to:

** Marta only needs a second's moment's hesitation when she thinks Fran is blackmailing her but dying from an overdose. First, she tells Fran not to talk and save her strength, that she's going to be okay. Then she dials 911, places the phone on the floor, and starts performing CPR. Benoit points out that this moment undid Ransom's plan because Fran made it to the hospital, and he underestimated Marta's fundamental goodness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** After the will reading when the Thromby's turn on Marta, Blanc moves in between them and her. Blanc tries to calm the family down and encourages Marta to leave until things settle down. [[spoiler: This becomes even more important once you realize that Blanc ''knew Marta had something to do with Harlan's murder,'' showing that he really was on her side for a considerable length of time and wasn't willing to let her get abused by Harlan's family.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Even though Walt ends up being released from the publishing house, Harlan tries to break the news to him as gently as possible, assuring him that it's not because he's done anything wrong and mentioning that "they'll talk details tomorrow." He even affectionatly pats Walt on the cheek, calling him a good boy. Compared to Harlan cutting Joni off financially and Ransom being removed from the will, [[PetTheDog it's a lot tamer and hints that the negotiation that would have taken place would not have been that drastic.]]

to:

* Even though Walt ends up being released from the publishing house, Harlan tries to break the news to him as gently as possible, assuring him that it's not because he's done anything wrong and mentioning that "they'll talk details tomorrow." He even affectionatly pats Walt on the cheek, calling him a good boy. Compared to Harlan Harlan's harsh words when cutting Joni off financially and removing Ransom being removed from the will, [[PetTheDog it's a lot tamer and hints that the negotiation that would have taken place would not have been that drastic.]]

Added: 524

Changed: 615

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Despite being just as horrible and vicious as the rest of her family, Harlan's eldest daughter Linda revealing to Walt that she does actually mourn her father's death, seemingly the only one of his descendants who does miss him and isn't just preoccupied with who gets what in the will.
** At the beginning of the scene, Linda is shown weeping in her bedroom, and Walt walks in and gently asks if she is alright. It's a lovely, understated moment of affection between the siblings, and at the end of the scene, the two share a hug.
* Even though Walt ends up being released from the publishing house by Harlan, he mentions that "they'll talk details tomorrow" and even affectionatly pats him on the cheek, calling him a good boy; Compared to Harlan cutting Joni off financially and Ransom being removed from the will, [[PetTheDog it's a lot tamer and hints that the negotiation that would have taken place would not have been that drastic.]]

to:

* Despite being just as horrible and vicious to Marta as the rest of her family, Harlan's eldest daughter Linda revealing is mentioned to Walt that she does have been particularly close to her father and actually mourn her father's mourns his death, seemingly the only one of his descendants who does miss him and isn't just preoccupied with who gets what in the will.
** At the beginning of the scene, When Linda is shown weeping in her bedroom, and Walt walks in and gently asks if she is alright. It's a lovely, understated moment of affection between the siblings, and at the end of the scene, the two share a hug.
** At the end of the film, Linda finds a secret message from Harlan in which he reveals her husband's infidelity, encourages her to divorce him, and affirms his love for her. While she doesn't get a share of the inheritance, she's at least able to find some closure.
* Even though Walt ends up being released from the publishing house by Harlan, he mentions house, Harlan tries to break the news to him as gently as possible, assuring him that it's not because he's done anything wrong and mentioning that "they'll talk details tomorrow" and tomorrow." He even affectionatly pats him Walt on the cheek, calling him a good boy; boy. Compared to Harlan cutting Joni off financially and Ransom being removed from the will, [[PetTheDog it's a lot tamer and hints that the negotiation that would have taken place would not have been that drastic.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Even though Walt ends up being released from the publishing house by Harlan, he mentions that "they'll talk details tomorrow" and even affectionatly pats him on the cheek, calling him a good boy; Compared to Harlan cutting Joni off financially and Ransom being removed from the will, [[PetTheDog it's a lot tamer and hints that the negotiation that would have taken place would not have been that drastic.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Furthermore, when Marta's mother is telling her sister to turn off the violent crime show she's watching, she describes Harlan as "a friend Marta loved very much", rather than a boss, which indicates how fond Marta was of him.

to:

** Furthermore, when Marta's mother is telling her sister to turn off the violent crime show she's watching, she describes Harlan as "a friend Marta loved very much", much," rather than a boss, which indicates how fond Marta was of him.



** After Harlan’s will is read and the family starts freaking out, Linda starts yelling at Marta and corners her. Meg, seeing this, immediately runs to help hold Linda back, and after Linda accuses Marta of “boinking” Harlan, Meg instantly takes offense and in the background of the commotion can be seen defending Marta and arguing with Linda about it.

to:

** After Harlan’s Harlan's will is read and the family starts freaking out, Linda starts yelling at Marta and corners her. Meg, seeing this, immediately runs to help hold Linda back, and after Linda accuses Marta of “boinking” "boinking" Harlan, Meg instantly takes offense and in the background of the commotion can be seen defending Marta and arguing with Linda about it.



* Lieutenant Elliott and Benoit have a pretty wholesome working relationship. The former trusts him and affectionately calls him "Benny". The detective may be quirky, but he's also in the field for a reason.

to:

* Lieutenant Elliott and Benoit have a pretty wholesome working relationship. The former trusts him and affectionately calls him "Benny". "Benny." The detective may be quirky, but he's also in the field for a reason.



* When arguing with the family over the will, Harlan's lawyer Alan explicitly mentions Marta's "hard work and good humour". While it's likely mostly a StealthInsult at the family, it could also indicate one of several options - Alan has met Marta before and thinks highly of her; Harlan basically sang her praises when he came to change his will in her favour; or that Alan got a read on Marta in the time it took to come to the house for the reading and saw she was a good person. Or a combination of the options.

to:

* When arguing with the family over the will, Harlan's lawyer Alan explicitly mentions Marta's "hard work and good humour". humor." While it's likely mostly a StealthInsult at the family, it could also indicate one of several options - Alan has met Marta before and thinks highly of her; Harlan basically sang her praises when he came to change his will in her favour; favor; or that Alan got a read on Marta in the time it took to come to the house for the reading and saw she was a good person. Or a combination of the options.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When arguing with the family over the will, Harlan's lawyer Alan explicitly mentions Martha's "hard work and good humour". While it's likely mostly a StealthInsult at the family, it could also indicate one of several options - Alan has met Martha before and thinks highly of her; Harlan basically sang her praises when he came to change his will in her favour; or that Alan got a read on Martha in the time it took to come to the house for the reading and saw she was a good person. Or a combination of the options.

to:

* When arguing with the family over the will, Harlan's lawyer Alan explicitly mentions Martha's Marta's "hard work and good humour". While it's likely mostly a StealthInsult at the family, it could also indicate one of several options - Alan has met Martha Marta before and thinks highly of her; Harlan basically sang her praises when he came to change his will in her favour; or that Alan got a read on Martha Marta in the time it took to come to the house for the reading and saw she was a good person. Or a combination of the options.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When arguing with the family over the will, Harlan's lawyer Alan explicitly mentions Martha's "hard work and good humour". While it's likely mostly a StealthInsult at the family, it could also indicate one of several options - Alan has met Martha before and thinks highly of her; Harlan basically sang her praises when he came to change his will in her favour; or that Alan got a read on Martha in the time it took to come to the house for the reading and saw she was a good person. Or a combination of the options.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* A subtle one in the ending: Benoit asked the cops to clear out all of the Thrombeys so that he could prove Marta was innocent. Who wasn't ordered to leave the house? Nana. The ending implies that Marta is going to take care of her, so she's not left out in the dust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In addition to the above, Linda is also shown to adore her father's dogs, greeting them with a joyful "Hello, puppy!" when they come running to her, and petting one during Marta's attempted confession.

to:

* In addition to the above, Linda is also shown to adore her father's dogs, greeting them with a joyful "Hello, puppy!" "My puppies!" when they come running to her, and petting one during Marta's attempted confession.

Added: 230

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Benoit realizes that Ransom murdered Fran to shut her up, he sounds sad that Fran didn't think of going to the cops to tell them what she saw, which would have landed all suspicion on him. Now ''that'' is NiceToTheWaiter.



** Marta finds out on the phone that Fran died, which means they lost their proof that Ransom was the killer, and Marta lost another of her friends in less than a month. She turns around, smiles, and lies that Fran will be okay. This goads Ransom to do EvilGloating and threaten Marta and only then does Marta throw up. After she coughs and catches her breath, Marta reveals with TranquilFury, "Yes, Fran is dead. And you just confessed to her murder." She made sure that Fran's efforts to clear her name weren't in vein. That's friendship.

to:

** Marta finds out on the phone that Fran died, which means they lost their proof that Ransom was the killer, and Marta lost another of her friends in less than a month. She turns around, smiles, and lies that Fran will be okay. This goads Ransom to do EvilGloating and threaten Marta and only then does Marta throw up. After she coughs and catches her breath, Marta reveals with TranquilFury, "Yes, Fran is dead. And you just confessed to her murder." She made sure that Fran's efforts to clear her name weren't in vein.vain. That's friendship.

Added: 1600

Changed: 352

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* One thing to be said about the Thrombeys: most of them are downright horrified in the ending when the cops explain to them offscreen Ransom's plan to murder Harlan. Meg is crying, Richard tries to bribe the cops to release his son, and Linda looks like she's in shock. As Marta put it, none of them would have killed Harlan, no matter their grudges.
* If you hear Fran calling out Ransom for killing Harlan, or so she thought, she says she always knew that Harlan would never kill himself and sounds genuinely heartbroken. She loves Harlan like a friend, and not just as a boss.
* Fran and Marta's relationship. They bonded over being the hired help, and joints.
** Marta only needs a second's hesitation when she thinks Fran is blackmailing her but dying from an overdose. First, she tells Fran not to talk and save her strength, that she's going to be okay. Then she dials 911, places the phone on the floor, and starts performing CPR. Benoit points out that this moment undid Ransom's plan because Fran made it to the hospital, and he underestimated Marta's fundamental goodness.
** When calling out "Hugh," Fran was genuinely angry that he had tried to frame Marta. She calls him a "sneaky son of a bitch" for a reason.
** In hindsight, a dying Fran is warning Marta where her backup copy is and that "Hugh did this" but her pronunciation is garbled. She's trying to tell her the real killer and to be careful.
** Marta finds out on the phone that Fran died, which means they lost their proof that Ransom was the killer, and Marta lost another of her friends in less than a month. She turns around, smiles, and lies that Fran will be okay. This goads Ransom to do EvilGloating and threaten Marta and only then does Marta throw up. After she coughs and catches her breath, Marta reveals with TranquilFury, "Yes, Fran is dead. And you just confessed to her murder." She made sure that Fran's efforts to clear her name weren't in vein. That's friendship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And while his death may have turned out to be a SenselessSacrifice, he cared enough about Marta that he chose to ''literally'' give his life for her, and to do what he could to salvage her situation and keep her undocumented-immigrant mother off the legal radar. It's telling that when she first informs him that she has just committed an AccidentalMurder on him, he ''never'' gets fearful or angry; instead, he spends his last minutes looking out for her.

to:

** And while his death may have turned out to be a SenselessSacrifice, he cared enough about Marta that he chose to ''literally'' give his life for her, and to do what he could to salvage her situation and keep her undocumented-immigrant mother off the legal radar. It's telling that when she first informs him that she has just committed an AccidentalMurder on him, he ''never'' gets fearful or angry; angry (either or both would be quite justified); instead, he [[FaceDeathWithDignity Faces Death with Dignity]] and spends his last minutes looking out for her.




to:

* Fundamentally, the movie believes RousseauWasRight: A good person attempts to continue being a good person, and, despite also being the MainCharacter in a MurderMystery, is ultimately rewarded for their actions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And while his death may have turned out to be a SenselessSacrifice, he cared about Marta enough that he chose to literally give his life for her and came up with an elaborate scheme just so she wouldn't get in trouble for his death, even if accidental, especially knowing her undocumented mother would also be at risk should legal authorities need to look deeper into Marta. It's telling that when she first informs him of the mix-up, the look he gives her as she starts panicking and hunting for the antidote is not one of anger or fear, but acceptance and affection.

to:

** And while his death may have turned out to be a SenselessSacrifice, he cared enough about Marta enough that he chose to literally ''literally'' give his life for her, and to do what he could to salvage her situation and came up with an elaborate scheme just so she wouldn't get in trouble for his death, even if accidental, especially knowing keep her undocumented undocumented-immigrant mother would also be at risk should off the legal authorities need to look deeper into Marta. radar. It's telling that when she first informs him of the mix-up, the look he gives her as that she starts panicking and hunting has just committed an AccidentalMurder on him, he ''never'' gets fearful or angry; instead, he spends his last minutes looking out for the antidote is not one of anger or fear, but acceptance and affection.her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Lieutenant Elliott and Benoit have a pretty wholesome working relationship. The former trusts him and affectionately calls him "Benny". The detective may be quirky, but he's also in the field for a reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Harlan expressly tells Marta during his plan to give her an alibi that the dogs like her, so they won't bark. Indeed, they come to her for cuddles and she takes the time to pet them. In a FreezeFrameBonus, you can see one of the dogs looking worried when Marta nearly falls off the trellis. (This explains how the dog ended up with the piece of wood it later gave to Marta and later Benoit.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Meta example: Chris Evans, a known dog-lover, really got along with the two German shepherds off-camera.

to:

** Meta example: Chris Evans, a known dog-lover, really got along with the two German shepherds off-camera. Someone even joked that Evans' best acting isn't being Ransom, it's ''pretending he doesn't love dogs.''



* Marta's relationship with Harlan - from the brief moments we see the warmth and playfulness between them makes it clear how close the two of them were. It's even more clearly established to be genuine affection when Marta even calls him "abuelo" during their last Go session, and "abuelo" is Spanish for "grandfather." Even if the other Thrombeys never really accepted her, it's clear from that alone that Marta was and always had been part of Harlan's family, whether the rest of the Thrombey's chose to accept it or not.

to:

* Marta's relationship with Harlan - from the brief moments we see the warmth and playfulness between them makes it clear how close the two of them were. It's even more clearly established to be genuine affection when Marta even calls him "abuelo" during their last Go session, and "abuelo" is Spanish for "grandfather." Even if the other Thrombeys never really accepted her, it's clear from that alone that Marta was and always had been part of Harlan's family, whether the rest of the Thrombey's Thrombeys chose to accept it or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Marta's relationship with Harlan - from the brief moments we see the warmth and playfulness between them makes it clear how close the two of them were.

to:

* Marta's relationship with Harlan - from the brief moments we see the warmth and playfulness between them makes it clear how close the two of them were. It's even more clearly established to be genuine affection when Marta even calls him "abuelo" during their last Go session, and "abuelo" is Spanish for "grandfather." Even if the other Thrombeys never really accepted her, it's clear from that alone that Marta was and always had been part of Harlan's family, whether the rest of the Thrombey's chose to accept it or not.

Added: 447

Changed: 441

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Though we don't see much of the Cabrera family they are, hands down, far more stable than the Thrombeys. As early as the movie's second scene Marta's mother is trying to be aware of her daughter's sensitivities in the wake of Harlan's death by asking Marta's sister to turn off the murder mystery she was watching. Then there's nothing but warm interactions between Marta and her mother when she comes home that night. While Marta's sister gets a bit snappy with her mother over the subject, she is sincerely apologetic to Marta herself about it.

to:

* Though we don't see much of the Cabrera family they are, hands down, far more stable than the Thrombeys.
**
As early as the movie's second scene Marta's mother is trying to be aware of her daughter's sensitivities in the wake of Harlan's death by asking Marta's sister to turn off the murder mystery she was watching. Then there's nothing but warm interactions between Marta and her mother when she comes home that night. watching. While Marta's sister gets a bit snappy with her mother over the subject, she is sincerely apologetic to Marta herself about it.it.
** Then there's nothing but warm interactions between Marta and her mother when she comes home that night.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Top