Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / WonderWoman

Go To

OR

Added: 323

Changed: 542

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The fact that she's a character in a largely PG-13 rated universe. It's a fudge to keep her from flashing her naughty bits to impressionable young readers while still maintaining her as a 'wild' character. Maybe not the most creative or exciting answer, but there it is.




to:

** She might not grow hair. Female baldness is less common than male baldness, but it still occurs.




to:

** The Lasso of Truth is literally magic, so it presumably is capable of informing the person what the actual truth is and then guiding them to say it.



*** Because (a) she's not as large as Superman, meaning that there's more chance that she might not be able to block the person she's in front of, (b) she presumably decides she'd rather deflect the bullets away from the person she's protecting rather than risk any getting past her and (c) it looks cool and it's a comic.



** Ultimately it's probably down to whim of the creator. When she was first created, while she was obviously influenced by her stories weren't as heavily built around or focussed on Greek mythology as they became when Greg Rucka started writing her in the 1980s, so it was most likely because William Moulton Marston simply preferred the name Diana and wasn't as interested in strict adherence to Greek myth or language. However, intentionally or not, it does serve a few purposes:

to:

** Ultimately it's probably down to whim of the creator. When she was first created, while she was obviously influenced by her stories weren't as heavily built around or focussed on Greek mythology as they became when Greg Rucka George Perez started writing her in the 1980s, so it was most likely because William Moulton Marston simply preferred the name Diana and wasn't as interested in strict adherence to Greek myth or language. However, intentionally or not, it does serve a few purposes:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Wonder Woman is an Amazon with deep ties to Greek culture, her native language is Greek and she moves among Greek gods and godesses; then why does she have a Latin name? She's called Diana... the actual Greek equivalent would be Artemis.

to:

* If Wonder Woman is an Amazon with deep ties to Greek culture, her native language is Greek and she moves among Greek gods and godesses; then why does she have a Latin name? She's called Diana... the actual Greek equivalent would be Artemis.Artemis.
** Ultimately it's probably down to whim of the creator. When she was first created, while she was obviously influenced by her stories weren't as heavily built around or focussed on Greek mythology as they became when Greg Rucka started writing her in the 1980s, so it was most likely because William Moulton Marston simply preferred the name Diana and wasn't as interested in strict adherence to Greek myth or language. However, intentionally or not, it does serve a few purposes:
*** It makes it less confusing if the actual goddess Artemis shows up at any point (which, given how the Greek Gods still play a part in things, isn't unlikely).
*** For her early years with a secret identity, it makes it easier to conceal who she is. Diana Prince sounds less like someone who might be a superheroine given life by the Greek Gods than Artemis Prince.
*** Thematically, it distinguishes her from the rest of the Amazons, both in her origins (unlike them she is a statue given life by the Gods / an actual daughter of Zeus, depending on which origin you go with), and in the fact that she is the one who is chosen to become Wonder Woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While there is almost certainly some truth to the HollywoodHomely explanation, Helen's plight wasn't so much that she was genuinely ugly, but more that she was ''plain''. In other words, her problem was precisely that she was, as you put it, "no Wonder Woman." She's only described as being ugly because she's being compared to actual prima ballerinas... by men, which explains her hatred of them.

to:

** While there is almost certainly some truth to the HollywoodHomely explanation, Helen's plight wasn't so much that she was genuinely ugly, but more that she was ''plain''. In other words, her problem was precisely that she was, as you put it, "no Wonder Woman." She's only described as being ugly because she's being compared to actual prima ballerinas... by men, which explains her hatred of them.them.

* If Wonder Woman is an Amazon with deep ties to Greek culture, her native language is Greek and she moves among Greek gods and godesses; then why does she have a Latin name? She's called Diana... the actual Greek equivalent would be Artemis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The Nemesis in question is Tom Tresser (Diana's love interest during Gail Simone's run). He and Diana became partners working at the Department of metahuman affairs in Allan Heinberg's story "Who is Wonder Woman."

to:

*** The Nemesis in question is Tom Tresser (Diana's love interest during Gail Simone's run).[[ComicBook/WonderWoman2006 run]]). He and Diana became partners working at the Department of metahuman affairs in Allan Heinberg's story "Who is Wonder Woman."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Why would she need to use her bracelets for that? If she's really bulletproof, then she could just stand in front of whoever she's protecting and let the bullets bounce off of her, like Superman does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She has a telepathic link with it, in the same vein as the telepathic communications system the Amazons developed.

to:

** She has In ''ComicBook/WonderWoman1942,'' before her telepathic powers were jettisoned, she had a telepathic link with it, in it via the same vein as the "mental radio" telepathic communications system the Amazons developed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Helen Alexandros the original Silver Swanin her mortal form is described as hideous but her picture is actually rather cute, sure she had freckles and was no Wonder Woman but she was hardly ugly to the point of saying "I hate men".

to:

* Helen Alexandros the original Silver Swanin Swan in her mortal form is described as hideous but her picture is actually rather cute, sure she had freckles and was no Wonder Woman but she was hardly ugly to the point of saying "I hate men".



** While there is almost certainly some truth to the HollywoodHomely explanation, Helen's plight wasn't so much that she was genuinely ugly, but more that she was ''plain''. In other words, her problem was precisely that she was, as you put it, "no Wonder Woman." She's only described as being ugly because she's being compared to actual prima ballerinas.

to:

** While there is almost certainly some truth to the HollywoodHomely explanation, Helen's plight wasn't so much that she was genuinely ugly, but more that she was ''plain''. In other words, her problem was precisely that she was, as you put it, "no Wonder Woman." She's only described as being ugly because she's being compared to actual prima ballerinas.ballerinas... by men, which explains her hatred of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While there is almost certainly some truth to the HollywoodHomely explanation, Helen's plight wasn't so much that she was genuinely ugly, but more that she was ''plain''. In other words, her problem was precisely that she was, as you put it, "no Wonder Woman." She's only described as being ugly because she's being compared to actual ballerinas.

to:

** While there is almost certainly some truth to the HollywoodHomely explanation, Helen's plight wasn't so much that she was genuinely ugly, but more that she was ''plain''. In other words, her problem was precisely that she was, as you put it, "no Wonder Woman." She's only described as being ugly because she's being compared to actual prima ballerinas.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** HollywoodHomely

to:

** HollywoodHomelyHollywoodHomely
** While there is almost certainly some truth to the HollywoodHomely explanation, Helen's plight wasn't so much that she was genuinely ugly, but more that she was ''plain''. In other words, her problem was precisely that she was, as you put it, "no Wonder Woman." She's only described as being ugly because she's being compared to actual ballerinas.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Does Wonder Woman have an archenemy? Superman has Lex Luthor and Batman has The Joker, so who does Wonder Woman have? Is she like Spiderman, who's got three different archenemies, or what?

to:

* Does Wonder Woman have an archenemy? Superman has Lex Luthor and Batman has The Joker, so who does Wonder Woman have? Is she like Spiderman, Spider-Man, who's got three different archenemies, or what?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Lord loves his mother last time i checked exempting him from cm status.


*** Furthermore, Maxwell Lord was, and is, a complete monster. While Zatanna got vetoed and banned from mindwiping anyone because, last time she did, she turned Doctor Light into "Rapist [=McRape=], the Rapist Therapist", Maxwell Lord proved during the ComicBook/BrightestDay storyline to be not above killing superpowered children, getting Magog explode in a crowded city just to get a ComicBook/KingdomCome thrown at the JLI and sending his creations to get some petty revenge over Franchise/WonderWoman herself while claiming to be the world's savior. Basically, he was in Diana's eyes a deeply disturbed man handling the most powerful humanoid on Earth. And she doesn't seem pained by killing him, but rather by the realization that Brother Eye, broadcasting her actions without relaying the context, actually turned her mission to spread peace in the Patriarch World into an instant failure.

to:

*** Furthermore, Maxwell Lord was, and is, a complete a monster. While Zatanna got vetoed and banned from mindwiping anyone because, last time she did, she turned Doctor Light into "Rapist [=McRape=], the Rapist Therapist", Maxwell Lord proved during the ComicBook/BrightestDay storyline to be not above killing superpowered children, getting Magog explode in a crowded city just to get a ComicBook/KingdomCome thrown at the JLI and sending his creations to get some petty revenge over Franchise/WonderWoman herself while claiming to be the world's savior. Basically, he was in Diana's eyes a deeply disturbed man handling the most powerful humanoid on Earth. And she doesn't seem pained by killing him, but rather by the realization that Brother Eye, broadcasting her actions without relaying the context, actually turned her mission to spread peace in the Patriarch World into an instant failure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** To protect other people. A lot of the time (at least, in bulletproof versions) when Wonder Woman plays "bullets and bracelets", she's standing in front of someone who ''isn't'' bulletproof and deflecting the fire away from them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Furthermore, Maxwell Lord was, and is, a complete monster. While Zatanna got vetoed and banned from mindwiping anyone because, last time she did, she turned Doctor Light into "Rapist [=McRape=], the Rapist Therapist", Maxwell Lord proved during the ComicBook/BrightestDay storyline to be not above killing superpowered children, getting Magog explode in a crowded city just to get a ComicBook/KingdomCome thrown at the JLI and sending his creations to get some petty revenge over WonderWoman herself while claiming to be the world's savior. Basically, he was in Diana's eyes a deeply disturbed man handling the most powerful humanoid on Earth. And she doesn't seem pained by killing him, but rather by the realization that Brother Eye, broadcasting her actions without relaying the context, actually turned her mission to spread peace in the Patriarch World into an instant failure.

to:

*** Furthermore, Maxwell Lord was, and is, a complete monster. While Zatanna got vetoed and banned from mindwiping anyone because, last time she did, she turned Doctor Light into "Rapist [=McRape=], the Rapist Therapist", Maxwell Lord proved during the ComicBook/BrightestDay storyline to be not above killing superpowered children, getting Magog explode in a crowded city just to get a ComicBook/KingdomCome thrown at the JLI and sending his creations to get some petty revenge over WonderWoman Franchise/WonderWoman herself while claiming to be the world's savior. Basically, he was in Diana's eyes a deeply disturbed man handling the most powerful humanoid on Earth. And she doesn't seem pained by killing him, but rather by the realization that Brother Eye, broadcasting her actions without relaying the context, actually turned her mission to spread peace in the Patriarch World into an instant failure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Helen Alexandros the original Silver Swanin her mortal form is described as hideous but her picture is actually rather cute, sure she had freckles and was no Wonder Woman but she was hardly ugly to the point of saying "I hate men".

to:

* Helen Alexandros the original Silver Swanin her mortal form is described as hideous but her picture is actually rather cute, sure she had freckles and was no Wonder Woman but she was hardly ugly to the point of saying "I hate men".men".
** HollywoodHomely
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Given that all of the individuals chosen to represent those Corps were nearby -- and given how many people the Black Lanterns have killed -- all it would take would be for Wonder Woman to love the entire world more than anyone else ''available nearby''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Apparently, the idea was to make her distinct from the other big two superheroes (Superman and Batman) in that she can and will kill if absolutely necessary (the one time the Post-Crisis Superman consciously killed someone � when he executed the three pocket universe Kryptonian supervillains � it was ''huge deal'' to him and haunted him for a long time afterwards, which doesn't seem to be the case with Wonder Woman). Even if this was a RetCon, it kinda makes sense, as (unlike Superman and Batman), WW was raised in a [[ProudWarriorRaceGuy warrior culture]]. During Gail Simone's run, WW explicitly states that she can kill to save innocent lives, but not for selfish reasons, such as revenge.

to:

** Apparently, the idea was to make her distinct from the other big two superheroes (Superman and Batman) in that she can and will kill if absolutely necessary (the one time the Post-Crisis Superman consciously killed someone � - when he executed the three pocket universe Kryptonian supervillains � - it was ''huge deal'' to him and haunted him for a long time afterwards, which doesn't seem to be the case with Wonder Woman). Even if this was a RetCon, it kinda makes sense, as (unlike Superman and Batman), WW was raised in a [[ProudWarriorRaceGuy warrior culture]]. During Gail Simone's run, WW explicitly states that she can kill to save innocent lives, but not for selfish reasons, such as revenge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The lasso regularly shows people truths they were not aware of, it's how she breaks mindcontrol and illusions on others, can tell if she's been lied to by using it on herself, and her most often used method for reforming her villains is by showing them the truth about their motivations or the end result of their plans should they succeed. It normally does ''not'' cause physical pain like it does in [[Film/WonderWoman2017 the movie]], but the truth itself can hurt and some of her villains [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone commit suicide]] after having it used on them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I think she has a telepathic link with it, or something.

to:

** I think she She has a telepathic link with it, or something.in the same vein as the telepathic communications system the Amazons developed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I haven't been keeping up lately, but I know the New52 says that Barbara Minerva was a criminal even before she became the Cheetah. But I can't find anything that says what specific crimes she committed.

to:

* I haven't been keeping up lately, but I know the New52 ComicBook/New52 says that Barbara Minerva was a criminal even before she became the Cheetah. But I can't find anything that says what specific crimes she committed.



* Does Athena exist in the New52? Given how she was Wonder Woman's patron pre-reboot, the fact that her responsibilities and personality are very similar to Wonder Woman's, and how Wonder Woman's now part of the Olympian family, her absence from the story (based on the first two trade paperbacks, this headscratcher may be out of date) is kind of jarring.

to:

* Does Athena exist in the New52? ComicBook/New52? Given how she was Wonder Woman's patron pre-reboot, the fact that her responsibilities and personality are very similar to Wonder Woman's, and how Wonder Woman's now part of the Olympian family, her absence from the story (based on the first two trade paperbacks, this headscratcher may be out of date) is kind of jarring.



** Also, Athena is goddess of the more positive aspects of war, not to mention wisdom, crafts, occasionally justice depending on the myth, and was patron of a city. Ares is god of the bloodthirsty aspects of war, the slaughter and chaos and pain and fear, and (unless you're a Roman and talking about Mars) god of not really much else. Before the New52 made the Amazons into StrawFeminist assholes, Athena was a much more sensible choice for a society based around ideals of peace, justice, equality, etc to worship. (Also, in the Post-Crisis era, she was one of their patrons and creators, so there was a fair bit of gratitude involved as well.)

to:

** Also, Athena is goddess of the more positive aspects of war, not to mention wisdom, crafts, occasionally justice depending on the myth, and was patron of a city. Ares is god of the bloodthirsty aspects of war, the slaughter and chaos and pain and fear, and (unless you're a Roman and talking about Mars) god of not really much else. Before the New52 ComicBook/New52 made the Amazons into StrawFeminist assholes, Athena was a much more sensible choice for a society based around ideals of peace, justice, equality, etc to worship. (Also, in the Post-Crisis era, she was one of their patrons and creators, so there was a fair bit of gratitude involved as well.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Helen Alexandros the original Silver Swanin her mortal form is described as hideous but her picture is actually rather cute, sure she had freckles and was no Wonder Woman but she was hardly ugly to the point of saying "I hate men".

* Isn't Azzarello's origin for the Amazons more accurate to Greek Mythology? SadlyMythtaken, TheThemeParkVersion and {{Disneyfication}} are pet peeves of several, so why is ''Rebirth'' reinforcing those tropes and acting like it's a good thing? Shouldn't Azzarello be praised for writing a TruerTotheText origin for the Amazons?

to:

* Helen Alexandros the original Silver Swanin her mortal form is described as hideous but her picture is actually rather cute, sure she had freckles and was no Wonder Woman but she was hardly ugly to the point of saying "I hate men".

* Isn't Azzarello's origin for the Amazons more accurate to Greek Mythology? SadlyMythtaken, TheThemeParkVersion and {{Disneyfication}} are pet peeves of several, so why is ''Rebirth'' reinforcing those tropes and acting like it's a good thing? Shouldn't Azzarello be praised for writing a TruerTotheText origin for the Amazons?
men".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Isn't Azzarello's origin for the Amazons more accurate to Greek Mythology? SadlyMythtaken, TheThemeParkVersion and Disneyfication are pet peeves of several, so why is ''Rebirth'' reinforcing those tropes and acting like it's a good thing? Shouldn't Azzarello be praised for writing a TruerTotheText origin for the Amazons?

to:

* Isn't Azzarello's origin for the Amazons more accurate to Greek Mythology? SadlyMythtaken, TheThemeParkVersion and Disneyfication {{Disneyfication}} are pet peeves of several, so why is ''Rebirth'' reinforcing those tropes and acting like it's a good thing? Shouldn't Azzarello be praised for writing a TruerTotheText origin for the Amazons?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Helen Alexandros the original Silver Swanin her mortal form is described as hideous but her picture is actually rather cute, sure she had freckles and was no Wonder Woman but she was hardly ugly to the point of saying "I hate men".

to:

* Helen Alexandros the original Silver Swanin her mortal form is described as hideous but her picture is actually rather cute, sure she had freckles and was no Wonder Woman but she was hardly ugly to the point of saying "I hate men".men".

*Isn't Azzarello's origin for the Amazons more accurate to Greek Mythology? SadlyMythtaken, TheThemeParkVersion and Disneyfication are pet peeves of several, so why is ''Rebirth'' reinforcing those tropes and acting like it's a good thing? Shouldn't Azzarello be praised for writing a TruerTotheText origin for the Amazons?

Added: 233

Changed: -20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For the record, current Wonder Woman has no longer secret identity. But for the time she had; finger prints are not that easy to collect, they require a lot of special handling and lab work, and even if you get WW’s finger prints, you would compare them to who exactly? You’ll have to suspect she’s Diana Prince and compare them in the first place, otherwise then you’ll have to use WW’s finger prints and run them into the system and only if Prince has her prints registered for some reason would be a match. Besides, for the time WW has a secret identity I think the technology for running finger prints on a national-level register was no yet available.

to:

** For the record, current Wonder Woman has no longer secret identity. But for the time she had; finger prints are not that easy to collect, they require a lot of special handling and lab work, and even if you get WW’s finger prints, you would compare them to who exactly? You’ll have to suspect she’s Diana Prince and compare them in the first place, otherwise then you’ll have to use WW’s finger prints and run them into the system and only if Prince has her prints registered for some reason would be a match. Besides, for the time WW has a secret identity I think the technology for running finger prints on a national-level register was no yet available.available.

* Helen Alexandros the original Silver Swanin her mortal form is described as hideous but her picture is actually rather cute, sure she had freckles and was no Wonder Woman but she was hardly ugly to the point of saying "I hate men".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

** In the movie, she used it on Steve, which made him say that their current plan was horrible and that they were all going to die. It varies DependingOnTheWriter, but it's safe to say it doesn't grant one knowledge that they wouldn't otherwise have, and their responses are still colored by opinions and emotions, but they'll at least be honest about those.


Added DiffLines:

** Or Circe, or Ares. I'd say that well-rounded Circe is her Lex Luthor, super-dangerous grand-scheming Ares is her Darksied, and highly physical and combative Cheetah is her Metallo.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There are two possible answers to this question (and no real straight, solid one, because the difference between truth and lies is difficult to judge). Either you you would say 4pm because that's the truth to you consciously, or you would say 5pm because if you've merely forgotten it, then you know what the real truth is, if only subconsciously.

to:

*** There are two possible answers to this question (and no real straight, solid one, It says [[http://wonder-woman.wikia.com/wiki/Lasso_of_Truth here]] that the Lasso of Truth can "restore people's lost memories" so I would say that, by that logic, I would say 5pm, because the difference between truth and lies is difficult lasso forces me to judge). Either you you would say 4pm because that's remember the truth to you consciously, or you would say 5pm because if you've merely forgotten it, then you know what the real truth is, if only subconsciously.truth.

Added: 253

Changed: 155

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The new version is a goddess of war instead of truth, and got a yellow ring instead of a sapphire one, I don't think she's an all loving hero anymore.


Added DiffLines:

** Originally in New Earth continuity, she wasn't bullet proof. Then she died, became a goddess of truth, and was kicked out of Olympus for interfering too much, but kept the base perks of having a body that's literally divine, like being bullet proof.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Atlantis doesn't generally worship the Greek gods in the DC franchise, they have their own deities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** No, the lasso works on the concept of truth itself, people can't even lie to themselves while within its coil. So Maxwell's answer was the absolute truth no matter what his prejudices and personality would have him think otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Since Wonder Woman doesn't wear gloves as part of her costume (like SuperMan), wouldn't it be fairly easy to collect fingerprint samples from both her and Diana Prince and deduce they are one in the same?

to:

* Since Wonder Woman doesn't wear gloves as part of her costume (like SuperMan), wouldn't it be fairly easy to collect fingerprint samples from both her and Diana Prince and deduce they are one in the same?same?
**For the record, current Wonder Woman has no longer secret identity. But for the time she had; finger prints are not that easy to collect, they require a lot of special handling and lab work, and even if you get WW’s finger prints, you would compare them to who exactly? You’ll have to suspect she’s Diana Prince and compare them in the first place, otherwise then you’ll have to use WW’s finger prints and run them into the system and only if Prince has her prints registered for some reason would be a match. Besides, for the time WW has a secret identity I think the technology for running finger prints on a national-level register was no yet available.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Yes, it's Cheetah.

to:

** Yes, it's Cheetah.Cheetah.
* Since Wonder Woman doesn't wear gloves as part of her costume (like SuperMan), wouldn't it be fairly easy to collect fingerprint samples from both her and Diana Prince and deduce they are one in the same?

Top