Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Skullgirls

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I don't know, but I think doing so [[NiceJobBreakingItHero just unleashes the Skullgirl early]] - at the very least, it won't prevent it from just finding another host.

to:

** I don't know, but I think doing so [[NiceJobBreakingItHero just unleashes the Skullgirl early]] - at the very least, it won't prevent it from just finding another host.host.
* How can Black Dahlia be so ''old'' yet look so [[GrandmaWhatMassiveHotnessYouHave ''good'']]? Seriously, she's almost as toned as Ms. Fortune despite being old enough to be graying. [[http://static1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120528144849/skullgirls/images/9/9b/Blackdahlia.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The coffins in the Rooftops Assault stage are shown covered in chains, which may have held in previous generations. Marie being able to uproot graves and entire buildings likely overpowered them.

to:

** The coffins in the Rooftops Assault stage are shown covered in chains, which may have held in previous generations. Marie being able to uproot [[spoiler:uproot graves and entire buildings likely overpowered them.]]



** The Queen had to threaten all 3 kingdoms so had to cross some borders. Squigly may have just been out of range and stayed dead.

to:

** The Queen had to threaten all 3 kingdoms so had to cross some borders. Squigly [[spoiler:Squigly may have just been out of range and stayed dead. ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The coffins in the Rooftops Assault stage are shown covered in chains, which may have held in previous generations. Marie being able to uproot graves and entire buildings likely overpowered them.


Added DiffLines:

** The Queen had to threaten all 3 kingdoms so had to cross some borders. Squigly may have just been out of range and stayed dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If you know that you're going to become a Skullgirl eventually (as certain characters do in their endings) and you want to make sure the world isn't terrorized by your Skullgirl self in the future, what's to stop you from committing suicide? Can the Skull Heart stop you?

to:

* If you know that you're going to become a Skullgirl eventually (as certain characters do in their endings) and you want to make sure the world isn't terrorized by your Skullgirl self in the future, what's to stop you from committing suicide? Can the Skull Heart stop you?you?
** I don't know, but I think doing so [[NiceJobBreakingItHero just unleashes the Skullgirl early]] - at the very least, it won't prevent it from just finding another host.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** As a JerkassGenie, the Skull Heart would certainly not be above taking advantage of the ExactWords. And those exact words are "...if she is impure of heart..." Meaning that while Parasoul's ''wish'' was totally selfless and pure, if the Skull Heart looked deep inside Parasoul and found even the tiniest ''trace'' of impurity--like, I dunno, a memory of shoplifting a candy bar once when she was a kid or something--then it could go "Aha! Your heart isn't pure because you haven't been 100% completely good all your life! That means I can turn you into a Skullgirl, mwahaha!"



* [[spoiler:Skullgirls are said to appear every seven years. So Squigly's mom was the one 14 years ago, then Parasoul's mom 7 years ago, then Marie now. Still, it's as if she somehow did nothing during the time of Parasoul's mom as a Skullgirl.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:Skullgirls are said to appear every seven years. So Squigly's mom was the one 14 years ago, then Parasoul's mom 7 years ago, then Marie now. Still, it's as if she somehow did nothing during the time of Parasoul's mom as a Skullgirl.]]]]
* If you know that you're going to become a Skullgirl eventually (as certain characters do in their endings) and you want to make sure the world isn't terrorized by your Skullgirl self in the future, what's to stop you from committing suicide? Can the Skull Heart stop you?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** More likely it'll [[spoiler: [[KillEmAll wipe out humanity]] [[LoopholeAbuse to ensure there's nobody LEFT ALIVE to become a Skullgirl]].]]


Added DiffLines:

** That, or [[CrystalDragonJesus The Church of The Trinity]] [[HonorBeforeReason has strict religious tracts ensuring all corpses should be buried instead of burned if possible]]. [[spoiler: Which makes sense, [[GodIsEvil since they were behind the Skull Heart in the first place]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: [[LoopholeAbuse The Skull Heart will make]] [[SpearCounterpart Skullboys]]? This is probably along with turning the wisher into a male, so she, now he, can become the first Skullboy.]]

to:

** *** [[spoiler: [[LoopholeAbuse The Skull Heart will make]] [[SpearCounterpart Skullboys]]? This is probably along with turning the wisher into a male, so she, now he, can become the first Skullboy.]]

Added: 518

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Or what if somebody wished that there will be no more Skullgirls, ever?
** [[spoiler: [[LoopholeAbuse The Skull Heart will make]] [[SpearCounterpart Skullboys]]? This is probably along with turning the wisher into a male, so she, now he, can become the first Skullboy.]]



** It's possible it might not do any good. A lot of the minions the Skullgirl summons are almost totally skeletal in nature, and while cremation takes care of bone, Marie's shown some modicum of regeneration from nigh-obliteration. It's possible this transfers down to the Skullgirl's minions .

to:

** It's possible it might not do any good. A lot of the minions the Skullgirl summons are almost totally skeletal in nature, and while cremation takes care of bone, Marie's shown some modicum of regeneration from nigh-obliteration. It's possible this transfers down to the Skullgirl's minions .minions.
* [[spoiler:Skullgirls are said to appear every seven years. So Squigly's mom was the one 14 years ago, then Parasoul's mom 7 years ago, then Marie now. Still, it's as if she somehow did nothing during the time of Parasoul's mom as a Skullgirl.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It seems like the Skullheart's been around a while -- though not, as Leviathan says, forever. Still, why hasn't the Canopy Kingdom started practicing cremation of the dead (like the Free Folk of ASongOfIceAndFire do to keep their own dead from rising as wights) to keep the undead legions the Skullgirls can raise down to a minimum?

to:

* It seems like the Skullheart's been around a while -- though not, as Leviathan says, forever. Still, why hasn't the Canopy Kingdom started practicing cremation of the dead (like the Free Folk of ASongOfIceAndFire do to keep their own dead from rising as wights) to keep the undead legions the Skullgirls can raise down to a minimum?minimum?
** It's possible it might not do any good. A lot of the minions the Skullgirl summons are almost totally skeletal in nature, and while cremation takes care of bone, Marie's shown some modicum of regeneration from nigh-obliteration. It's possible this transfers down to the Skullgirl's minions .
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It seems like the Skullheart's been around a while -- though not, as Leviathan says, forever. Still, why hasn't the Canopy Kingdom started practicing cremation of the dead (like the Free Folk of ASongOfIceAndFire do) to keep the undead legions the Skullgirls can raise down to a minimum?

to:

* It seems like the Skullheart's been around a while -- though not, as Leviathan says, forever. Still, why hasn't the Canopy Kingdom started practicing cremation of the dead (like the Free Folk of ASongOfIceAndFire do) do to keep their own dead from rising as wights) to keep the undead legions the Skullgirls can raise down to a minimum?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It seems like the Skullheart's been around a while -- though not, as Leviathan says, forever. Still, why doesn't the Canopy Kingdom start practicing cremation of the dead like the Free Folk of ASongOfIceAndFire have learned to?

to:

* It seems like the Skullheart's been around a while -- though not, as Leviathan says, forever. Still, why doesn't hasn't the Canopy Kingdom start started practicing cremation of the dead like (like the Free Folk of ASongOfIceAndFire have learned to?do) to keep the undead legions the Skullgirls can raise down to a minimum?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So Squigly[[spoiler:'s mother became the Skullgirl 14 years before the story.]] Given that Squigly [[spoiler:rose in response to the Skullheart before and]] rises in response to Marie becoming the Skullgirl, and Parasoul's mother being the previous one....what happened with Squigly during THAT Skullgirl's rise?

to:

* So Squigly[[spoiler:'s mother became the Skullgirl 14 years before the story.]] Given that Squigly [[spoiler:rose in response to the Skullheart before and]] rises in response to Marie becoming the Skullgirl, and Parasoul's mother being the previous one....what happened with Squigly during THAT Skullgirl's rise?rise?
* It seems like the Skullheart's been around a while -- though not, as Leviathan says, forever. Still, why doesn't the Canopy Kingdom start practicing cremation of the dead like the Free Folk of ASongOfIceAndFire have learned to?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Uh... SuperSoldier program? Hey, it's not like [[TheEmpire the Canopy Kingdom]] is any stranger to PlayingWithSyringes...

to:

** Uh... SuperSoldier program? Hey, it's not like [[TheEmpire the Canopy Kingdom]] is any stranger to PlayingWithSyringes...PlayingWithSyringes...
* So Squigly[[spoiler:'s mother became the Skullgirl 14 years before the story.]] Given that Squigly [[spoiler:rose in response to the Skullheart before and]] rises in response to Marie becoming the Skullgirl, and Parasoul's mother being the previous one....what happened with Squigly during THAT Skullgirl's rise?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Vice-Versa can ''grow sunglasses,'' I don't think changing colors is that implausible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I always thought Viceversa was painted white to fit in the PlayBoyBunny motif.

Added: 197

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Sampson's mouth is on the back of Filia's head, what happened to Filia's brain?
** Sampson is just a shapeshifting mass; the mouth doesn't go anywhere. Filia's brain is probably fine.

to:

* If Sampson's Samson's mouth is on the back of Filia's head, what happened to Filia's brain?
** Sampson Samson is just a shapeshifting mass; the mouth doesn't go anywhere. Filia's brain is probably fine.fine.
** I thought Samson could've eaten all of Filia's internal organs and Filia's entire body was already filled with his shapeshifting goo. I mean, it's a good source of bones for her Level 3 super...

Added: 492

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It's outright stated the Cerebella is the only one capable of controlling Vice-Versa, which is why Vitale even bothers keeping her around. This likely Josses the "multiple Vice-Versas", or at least means only one can be "activated" by Cerebella at a time.



** I assumed it was because the Skull Heart is a colossal dick and is deliberately ''trying'' to find reasons to declare wishes impure.

to:

** I assumed it was because the Skull Heart is [[JerkassGenie a colossal dick dick]] and is deliberately ''trying'' to find reasons to declare wishes impure.



*** [[spoiler: [[LoopholeAbuse Or make the nearest woman a Skullgirl, who kills them immediately after]] ]]



* If Gigans are infertile with other races, how the hell is Scythana only PART Gigan?

to:

* If Gigans are infertile with other races, how the hell is Scythana only PART Gigan?Gigan?
** Uh... SuperSoldier program? Hey, it's not like [[TheEmpire the Canopy Kingdom]] is any stranger to PlayingWithSyringes...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[UndyingLoyalty Loyalty]] [[HonorBeforeReason Before Reason]], most likely.

to:

** [[UndyingLoyalty Loyalty]] [[HonorBeforeReason Before Reason]], most likely.likely.
* If Gigans are infertile with other races, how the hell is Scythana only PART Gigan?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[LoopholeAbuse The Skull kills them and makes their corpse a Skullgirl[/spoiler]

to:

** [[spoiler: [[LoopholeAbuse The Skull Heart kills them and makes their corpse a Skullgirl[/spoiler]Skullgirl]] ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't Cerebella just use the Skull Heart to wish for another Life Gem or something?

to:

* Why didn't Cerebella just use the Skull Heart to wish for another Life Gem or something?something?
** [[UndyingLoyalty Loyalty]] [[HonorBeforeReason Before Reason]], most likely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[LoopholeAbuse The Skull kills them and makes their corpse a Skullgirl[/spoiler]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** See also: declaring Filia's wish as ever-so-slightly impure, because Filia, in her amnesiac state, ''thinks'' she harmed Painwheel in her past. Her guilt isn't even ''real''.

to:

*** See also: declaring Filia's wish as ever-so-slightly impure, because Filia, in her amnesiac state, ''thinks'' she harmed Painwheel in her past. Her guilt isn't even ''real''.''real''.
* [[LogicBomb What if somebody wished to not become the Skullgirl?]]
* Why didn't Cerebella just use the Skull Heart to wish for another Life Gem or something?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I assumed it was because the Skull Heart is a colossal dick and is deliberately ''trying'' to find reasons to declare wishes impure.

to:

** I assumed it was because the Skull Heart is a colossal dick and is deliberately ''trying'' to find reasons to declare wishes impure.impure.
*** See also: declaring Filia's wish as ever-so-slightly impure, because Filia, in her amnesiac state, ''thinks'' she harmed Painwheel in her past. Her guilt isn't even ''real''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Parasoul's wish might have been seen as impure because it was only a wish to protect her sister, the one person most important to her, without much thought to anyone else. It was selfless, but maybe not selfless enough for the Skull Heart? She may also be non-pure hearted. Or, since the wish disqualified Umbrella from being the Skullgirl, it could have needed to shuck off the burden onto a different host.

to:

** Parasoul's wish might have been seen as impure because it was only a wish to protect her sister, the one person most important to her, without much thought to anyone else. It was selfless, but maybe not selfless enough for the Skull Heart? She may also be non-pure hearted. Or, since the wish disqualified Umbrella from being the Skullgirl, it could have needed to shuck off the burden onto a different host.host.
** I assumed it was because the Skull Heart is a colossal dick and is deliberately ''trying'' to find reasons to declare wishes impure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Multiple Vice-Versas doesn't sound unbelieveable. But one would assume nobody else would be able to use the "alternate" Vice-Versas either.



* Just how the hell is Parasoul's wish impure? Her only goal is to protect the innocent people, and she has literally no selfish gain from the wish whatsoever.

to:

* Just how the hell is Parasoul's wish impure? Her only goal is to protect the innocent people, and she has literally no selfish gain from the wish whatsoever.whatsoever.
** Parasoul's wish might have been seen as impure because it was only a wish to protect her sister, the one person most important to her, without much thought to anyone else. It was selfless, but maybe not selfless enough for the Skull Heart? She may also be non-pure hearted. Or, since the wish disqualified Umbrella from being the Skullgirl, it could have needed to shuck off the burden onto a different host.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Sampson is just a shapeshifting mass; the mouth doesn't go anywhere. Filia's brain is probably fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Sampson's mouth is on the back of Filia's head, what happened to Filia's brain?

to:

* If Sampson's mouth is on the back of Filia's head, what happened to Filia's brain?brain?
* Just how the hell is Parasoul's wish impure? Her only goal is to protect the innocent people, and she has literally no selfish gain from the wish whatsoever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's seen in multiple colors in gameplay, so I wouldn't be surprised if Vice-Versa could change colors at Cerebella's will.

to:

** It's seen in multiple colors in gameplay, so I wouldn't be surprised if Vice-Versa could change colors at Cerebella's will.will.
* If Sampson's mouth is on the back of Filia's head, what happened to Filia's brain?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Are there multiple Vice-Versas? Canonically, it's orange, but Cerebella's ending shows her wearing a white one.

to:

* Are there multiple Vice-Versas? Canonically, it's orange, but Cerebella's ending shows her wearing a white one.one.
** It's seen in multiple colors in gameplay, so I wouldn't be surprised if Vice-Versa could change colors at Cerebella's will.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Are there multiple Vice-Versas? Canonically, it's orange, but Cerebella's ending shows her wearing a white one.

Top