Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / DanganronpaV3KillingHarmony

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If the account of the outside world is accurate, humanity is living in a kind of golden age of abundance and peace. The Danganronpa show could be the result of people craving excitement and conflict after falling into a state of decadence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How exactly can Ryoma's clothes be intact laying next to him during the investigation if they have been torn to shreds by piranhas during his body discovery scene?

to:

* How exactly can Ryoma's clothes be laying intact laying next to him during the investigation if they have they've already been torn to shreds by piranhas during his body discovery scene?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Ryoma's clothes]]
* How exactly can Ryoma's clothes be intact laying next to him during the investigation if they have been torn to shreds by piranhas during his body discovery scene?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** For why he needed them, it was probably less for helping him reach the circle and more for helping him know where he was on the circle once he made it there. If he just walked there blindly in the dark, he could have ended up on any point of the circle and needed to take the time to deduce which direction to go from there. He could've made it there eventually if he had the time, but he only had until the song was finished to make his way to the floorboard, stomp it, and trace his way back. The corner lines made it so he could commit the murder swiftly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They don't. Kaede thinks there is, but after she dies, the students give up on the search until the mech holding bay is found- and only then because Shuichi notices that it has a bathroom. Monokuma wouldn't need one, so there must be a biological human who would be entering the bay regularly enough to need their own bathroom, even before the students were allowed. Since that person isn't a normal student and Monokuma hasn't raised a big stink about someone unauthorized on the grounds, they must have been working with Monokuma all along, giving credence to Kaede's theory.

Added: 1368

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding a new headscratcher and answering 2 of them


** Additionally, shot put balls are meant to be thrown with one hand and track & field teams have plenty of girls that do this.



** To answer the second question, if the show ran for 53 seasons, V3 is probably set decades after the in universe releases of the Danganronpa video games/side media so it definitely takes place a pretty large amount of time after the 2010s, and we’re only in the 2020s as of writing this, so futuristic technology is plausible.



----

to:

----
[[folder: Rantaro’s whereabouts before Danganronpa V3 (MAJOR CHAPTER 5/6 SPOILERS)]]
* How was Rantaro allowed in the Gofer Project if his talent would’ve been Ultimate Survivor by that point? Isn’t that a bit too unconventional? I also doubt that Team Danganronpa would even let him roam free in the real world between seasons 52 and 53. If I recall correctly, it’s implied that all of the students in the Gofer Project were normal high school students and recently-titled Ultimates at that point, and the existence of the Ultimate Hunt combined with Rantaro’s face being a part of the fake funeral confirms that he was out there and therefore not in the captivity of Team Danganronpa between seasons 52 and 53, which creates several plot holes. My only plausible theory is that it’s just in-universe bad writing for the sake of having a cameo and some sort of connection to the previous season for V3.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Looking for the mastermind]]
* While trying to figure the mastermind's identity, why doesn't anyone even entertain the thought that the mastermind could be Monokuma himself? In the previous games the students would assume there had to be someone controlling Monokuma, because he was just a robot. But in this game they actually have a fully sentient robot among them - Keebo. So why can't Monokuma be sentient and acting of his own will?
[[/folder]]

Added: 854

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why exactly did Monokuma execute Kaito by fulfilling his lifelong dream? While it's on brand with his usual DeathByIrony, wouldn't it be even more cruelly ironic to bait him with the possibility of finally going to space only for the rocket to just stop while drilling through the Earth's core, therefore killing him with the opposite of his goal? Especially since Celeste was set up to be burned at the stake, which she was enjoying before she got hit by a truck, dying in one of the most common ways imaginable.[[/folder]]

to:

* Why exactly did Monokuma execute Kaito by fulfilling his lifelong dream? While it's on brand with his usual DeathByIrony, wouldn't it be even more cruelly ironic to bait him with the possibility of finally going to space only for the rocket to just stop while drilling through the Earth's core, therefore killing him with the opposite of his goal? Especially since Celeste was set up to be burned at the stake, which she was enjoying before she got hit by a truck, dying in one of the most common ways imaginable.imaginable.
** Maybe there was some cruel twist planned, but since Kaito died from his illness Monokuma didn't get to show it.[[/folder]]

[[folder: The salt circle]]
* Maybe it's a minor thing, but I don't get why Korekiyo changed the design of the magic circle and added those lines leading to the corners of the room. All those additional lines did was cast suspicion on him, and his plan of hiding them was merely hoping they would be sufficiently destroyed by the crowd before someone took notice. It's explained he drew them in order to find the circle in the dark, but did he really need them? If you are positioned in a corner and you can feel both walls behind you, it should be easy to orient yourself towards the center of the room. All he had to do was to reach forward until he felt the salt line. It didn't seem to be too far from where he was.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** SHe probably didn't have a specific idea at the time. She just figured the ball might be used as a weapon and she'd come up with the plan later. Which she did.

to:

** SHe She probably didn't have a specific idea at the time. She just figured the ball might be used as a weapon and she'd come up with the a plan later. Which she did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** SHe probably didn't have a specific idea at the time. She just figured the ball might be used as a weapon and she'd come up with the plan later. Which she did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There's no rule that a blackened must be executed, and there's no rule that one can't be a blackened and a victim at the same time. I'm sure the first murderer would still be the blackened, and if they happened to be dead Monokuma would just perform some sort of symbolic execution, possibly using their dead body, or a picture, or something like that.

to:

*** There's no rule that a blackened must be executed, and there's no rule that one can't be a blackened and a victim at the same time. I'm sure the first murderer would still be the blackened, and if they happened to be dead Monokuma would just perform some sort of symbolic execution, possibly using their dead body, or a picture, or something like that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** There's no rule that a blackened must be executed, and there's no rule that one can't be a blackened and a victim at the same time. I'm sure the first murderer would still be the blackened, and if they happened to be dead Monokuma would just perform some sort of symbolic execution, possibly using their dead body, or a picture, or something like that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Yeah, it's true that revealing it to the audience was a wrong move, and it's proven when the audience, through Keebo, refused to vote. So basically she just made a huge mistake, most likely because she found herself in a situation she wasn't prepared for.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** There was still a chance of being spotted, if someone happened to be up that night. Even if they didn't think much of it at the time, they could still bring it up during the trial and then she'd become suspicious. She probably thought leaving the inner tube as it is would be safer. Even if it clued the others in about the method of the murder is still didn't point out to her as the culprit. As for the cloth scraps, she might've genuinely not noticed it. Remember, it was nighttime, and it's very unlikely she'd switch the light on, so even with a very good eyesight it's easy to miss a small piece of dark cloth near a dark inner tube in a dark pool.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Why kill Kaito in space instead of the underground?]]
* Why exactly did Monokuma execute Kaito by fulfilling his lifelong dream? While it's on brand with his usual DeathByIrony, wouldn't it be even more cruelly ironic to bait him with the possibility of finally going to space only for the rocket to just stop while drilling through the Earth's core, therefore killing him with the opposite of his goal? Especially since Celeste was set up to be burned at the stake, which she was enjoying before she got hit by a truck, dying in one of the most common ways imaginable.[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** If the rules are based off the original games, then a blackened doesn't have to be executed if they are already dead.


Added DiffLines:

** It's a pitch-black room with unclear acoustics and multiple people singing at once. A lot of noise going on at once, so plenty of cover for Kiyo to move. Plus he's not moving that close to anyone else, if his voice is bouncing off of the walls or getting drowned out by the others he's still vaguely in the direction they remember him being in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]][[/folder]]
----

Added: 437

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:[[center:[-''Franchise/{{Danganronpa}}'' '''[[Headscratchers/{{Danganronpa}} Main Headscratchers Page]]'''\\
'''''Main installments:''''' ''Headscratchers/DanganronpaTriggerHappyHavoc'' | ''Headscratchers/Danganronpa2GoodbyeDespair'' | ''Headscratchers/Danganronpa3TheEndOfHopesPeakHighSchool'' | '''''Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony'''''\\
'''''Spin-offs:''''' ''Headscratchers/DanganronpaAnotherEpisodeUltraDespairGirls''-]]]]]
----




to:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A man's shot put weighs 16 pounds. Any member of the cast would be able to pick one up with ease.


Added DiffLines:

** Kaede's shot would have landed near where Rantarou was even if it missed. There's absolutely no way Tsumugi would have been able to retrieve it without Rantarou noticing her.


Added DiffLines:

** Realistically, yes. They also would have heard his weight shift or his clothes brush against the floorboards. The third trial takes liberties with how well humans can hear, apparently.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* There's also the possibility that the ritual would simply not do anything. The book has to be burned as part of the process, so unless they think of copying down every page exactly beforehand, it would be fairly easy for Monokuma to just claim that they screwed up the ritual in some way, since they'd have no means of double checking after they burned the book.


Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Seance Singing]]
* Okay, so Korekiyo set up his trap in a way that allowed him to find his way to the proper location in the dark and jump on the end of the seesaw to shove Tenko into the blade. There's only one problem with this: during the part of the ritual, everyone, Korekiyo included, are supposed to be singing. Wouldn't somebody have noticed that his voice is moving around the room? Even if they ignored it while it was happening on the assumption that he was performing some part of the ritual, they would be immediately suspicious afterward if they heard his voice moving around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Do the rules ever say that someone must be executed? And if you can’t be a victim and blackened at the same time, then what would happen in the event of a suicide?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So what was Kaede planning to do with the shot put ball when she took it? Her inner monologue at the time implies that she just then thought about killing the mastermind when they them caught to ensure they don't all die, but at the time she didn't know they'd be staking out in the classroom near the stairs, let alone the vent connecting the classroom and library together. So what was her plan to kill the mastermind ''before'' learning about the vent? Was she just going to walk up to the mastermind after catching them and crack open their skull right in front of Shuichi?

to:

* So what was Kaede planning to do with the shot put ball when she took it? Her inner monologue at the time implies that she just then thought about killing the mastermind when they them caught them to ensure they don't all die, but at the time she didn't know they'd be staking out in the classroom near the stairs, let alone the vent connecting the classroom and library together. So what was her plan to kill the mastermind ''before'' learning about the vent? Was she just going to walk up to the mastermind after catching them and crack open their skull right in front of Shuichi?

Added: 502

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So what was Kaede planning to do with the shot put ball when she took it? Her inner monologue at the time implies that she just then thought about killing the mastermind when they caught to ensure they don't all die, but at the time she didn't know they'd be staking out in the classroom near the stairs, let alone the vent connecting the classroom and library together. So what was her plan to kill the mastermind ''before'' learning about the vent? Was she just going to walk up to the mastermind after catching them and crack open their skull right in front of Shuichi?

to:

* So what was Kaede planning to do with the shot put ball when she took it? Her inner monologue at the time implies that she just then thought about killing the mastermind when they them caught to ensure they don't all die, but at the time she didn't know they'd be staking out in the classroom near the stairs, let alone the vent connecting the classroom and library together. So what was her plan to kill the mastermind ''before'' learning about the vent? Was she just going to walk up to the mastermind after catching them and crack open their skull right in front of Shuichi?


Added DiffLines:

** But if Kaede had just taken the ball for self defense or to just incapacitate the mastermind, I don't see why she would have needed to hide it from Shuichi. Her dialogue after the trial pretty much says she took the ball with the idea of killing the mastermind since she wasn't sure just catching them would be enough (because they could have just played dumb to run out the timer), and her intent only solidified when learning about the vent. So what was her initial idea of killing the mastermind?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Better than trying it unarmed. What if it had been Gonta? Besides, she didn't need to crack their head open. Even just hitting them in the chest or leg would have been enough to disorient a person long enough to catch them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Kaede's Plan]]
* So what was Kaede planning to do with the shot put ball when she took it? Her inner monologue at the time implies that she just then thought about killing the mastermind when they caught to ensure they don't all die, but at the time she didn't know they'd be staking out in the classroom near the stairs, let alone the vent connecting the classroom and library together. So what was her plan to kill the mastermind ''before'' learning about the vent? Was she just going to walk up to the mastermind after catching them and crack open their skull right in front of Shuichi?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** My personal headcanon is that Team Danganronpa used hypnosis technology to ''force'' everyone into liking their shows. Shuichi managed to convince ''literally everyone'' to cancel the series in one go without anyone complaining about it is just a bit too suspicious for me. To me it would make more sense for that to happen IF he managed to break everyone free from Team Danganronpa's mind-control.

to:

** My personal headcanon is that Team Danganronpa used hypnosis technology to ''force'' everyone into liking their shows. Shuichi managed managing to convince ''literally everyone'' to cancel the series in one go without anyone complaining about it is just a bit too suspicious for me. To me it would make more sense for that to happen IF he managed to break everyone free from Team Danganronpa's mind-control.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** My personal headcanon is that Team Danganronpa used hypnosis technology to ''force'' everyone into liking their shows. Shuichi managed to convince ''literally everyone'' to cancel the series in one go without anyone complaining about it is just a bit too suspicious for me. To me it would make more sense for that to happen IF he managed to break everyone free from Team Danganronpa's mind-control.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Why were the cast given the obviously fake memories in the first place? Just plant the contents of that book in their heads and be done with it. There's no real need to make those small changes. Only one possible reason is to get caught with this intentionally.
** The book may be there as an another hint that everything is fictional theory is in fact a lie. I mean, somebody had to write that book, some credited researchers even, and who writes a thick history tome for a couple of shows and never mentions that they even, in fact, writing about a show? The thing should have "Learn all about your beloved Danganronpa" stickers all over it. And if the book was produced specifically for the cast, it raises the further questions of "Why you are you writing one thing in the text and putting another in their brains?"

Top