Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / BeastMachines

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because the writers were told to do so, and not worry about how it affects the continuity/lore of the rest of the franchise. But if you still need an in-universe answer, its possible that whoever established Cybertron (the Quintessons for the cartoon, Primus for the comic) used a planet that has/had organic life on it. I wouldn't put it past the squids to wipe out all indigenous life to build a factory over it, would you?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's possible that it was still Rhinox's memory, but at the time the viral canisters released the virus to infect Cheetor and Optimus, Rhinox and whoever else was with him at that point was far enough away to not be hit by the viral gas.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why is there Earth Based Organic Life on Cybertron? How the hell did it get there and get fossilized?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the episode where Rattrap plugged into Tankor, he was able to regain some of his memories, and see some of Rhinox's memories. That I can understand, but there's one flashback that doesn't make sense to me. When we see the flashback of Optimus and Cheetor get hit with the virus, we see it from the POV of a character, but who's POV are we seeing? If it were Rhinox, why wasn't he captured like in the later flashback with Silverbolt and Rattrap? The only other possibility is that Rattrap ''somehow'' is accessing a memory of Blackarachnia, and if that's the case, how is he seeing that from plugging into Tankor/Rhinox?

Changed: 862

Removed: 856

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



* beast wars megatron ceased to be in a sense once he merged his spark with that of his decepticon ancestor the original megatron during the events of the beast wars season 3 episode master blaster because the original megatron imprinted his mindset and attitude onto the personality and ego of the predacon megatron from beast wars, in a word beast machines megatrons change of personality being due to the original megatron having frankensteined him into a mental hybrid clone of the original megatrons but with the predacon megatrons ego still being firmly in control of the hybrid mind, this would account for vehicon megatrons disgust for his beast mode and all cybertronians with such biological based alt modes
in a word the vehicon megatron having his ego influenced by the personality and attitude of the original megatron ghost in the machine like




to:

\n* beast wars megatron *** Beast Wars Megatron ceased to be in a sense once he merged his spark with that of his decepticon Decepticon ancestor the original megatron Megatron during the events of the beast wars season 3 episode master blaster because the original megatron Megatron imprinted his mindset and attitude onto the personality and ego of the predacon megatron Predacon Megatron from beast wars, in a word beast machines megatrons Megatron's change of personality being due to the original megatron Megatron having frankensteined him into a mental hybrid clone of the original megatrons Megatron's but with the predacon megatrons Predacon Megatrons ego still being firmly in control of the hybrid mind, this would account for vehicon megatrons disgust for his beast mode and all cybertronians with such biological based alt modes
in
modes,in a word the vehicon megatron Vehicon Megatron having his ego influenced by the personality and attitude of the original megatron Megatron ghost in the machine like



like
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


*beast wars megatron ceased to be in a sense once he merged his spark with that of his decepticon ancestor the original megatron during the events of the beast wars season 3 episode master blaster because the original megatron imprinted his mindset and attitude onto the personality and ego of the predacon megatron from beast wars, in a word beast machines megatrons change of personality being due to the original megatron having frankensteined him into a mental hybrid clone of the original megatrons but with the predacon megatrons ego still being firmly in control of the hybrid mind, this would account for vehicon megatrons disgust for his beast mode and all cybertronians with such biological based alt modes
in a word the vehicon megatron having his ego influenced by the personality and attitude of the original megatron ghost in the machine like



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Long story short? WriterOnBoard in the form of Bob Skir. In one of his old interviews, Skir admitted that he preferred that the heroes he writes for won't use guns. He wasn't exactly against firearms since he said that characters like The Punisher need to use guns as part of their character. However, he was of the belief that Maximal heroes like Optimus and Rattrap aren't absolutely required to have guns... which can make sense for a character like Optimus who has his strength and sword/mace-fighting skills to make up for not having firearms but absolutely no sense for Rattrap whose EstablishingCharacterMoment for his entire Beast Wars/Transformers tenure was that of a gun aficionado and expert marksman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Earth was very important to Cybertronian history. It's likely they've had a LOT of contact over the centuries, maybe even into their modern day, we just don't see it since Beast Wars largely took place in the past. It's not surprising Earth culture has seeped into Transformer consciousness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another episode has Nightscream and Silverbolt making a Monopoly reference. Same point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* At one point Nightscream makes a Tonka reference. I'm pretty sure he's never left Cybertron, much less ever been to Earth. Did Optimus Prime and the rest of the G1 Autobots really add this idiom to the culture upon returning?

Changed: 23

Removed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** AFAIK, he went back to Cybertron after finding the rest of the survivors. This is told on one of the comics post-WesternAnimation/BeastWars.

to:

*** AFAIK, he went back to Cybertron after finding the rest of the survivors. This is told on one of the comics post-WesternAnimation/BeastWars.post-''WesternAnimation/BeastWars''.



** I seem to remember reading on TFWiki that Waspinator was the ''Darksyde's'' pilot. Perhaps he cobbled something together out of spare Transwarp cells and a stasis pod.
* On a similar note and all fan theories aside, just how did Megatron get so anti-organic? He showed no such resentment for most of his battles in WesternAnimation/BeastWars, and actually seemed quite comfortable with his beast modes in general. Heck, with the power of his Dragon mode, he could defeat Optimus Primal in EVERY confrontation they had afterwards, with elemental strength. Why would he grow to hate something that gave him such power and the ability to overcome most of his enemies?

to:

** I seem to remember reading on TFWiki Wiki/TFWikiDotNet that Waspinator was the ''Darksyde's'' pilot. Perhaps he cobbled something together out of spare Transwarp cells and a stasis pod.
* On a similar note and all fan theories aside, just how did Megatron get so anti-organic? He showed no such resentment for most of his battles in WesternAnimation/BeastWars, ''WesternAnimation/BeastWars'', and actually seemed quite comfortable with his beast modes in general. Heck, with the power of his Dragon mode, he could defeat Optimus Primal in EVERY confrontation they had afterwards, with elemental strength. Why would he grow to hate something that gave him such power and the ability to overcome most of his enemies?



** By the end of WesternAnimation/BeastWars, he's pretty vehemently anti-organic and pro-God!Megatron. Being lost on Cybertron for untold ages as the sole organic transformer might well have driven him over the edge.

to:

** By the end of WesternAnimation/BeastWars, ''WesternAnimation/BeastWars'', he's pretty vehemently anti-organic and pro-God!Megatron. Being lost on Cybertron for untold ages as the sole organic transformer might well have driven him over the edge.



----
<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>

to:

----
<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I seem to remember reading on TFWiki that Waspinator was the ''Darksyde's'' pilot. Perhaps he cobbled something together out of spare Transwarp cells and a stasis pod.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, whatever happened to [[MemeticMutation ROBO-NOOGIES!?!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Rattrap had such a big problem with his lack of built-in weapons, why didn't he just pick up a gun? His old weapons, aside from his transmetal tail that he rarely used, weren't built-in, so it's not like things have changed that much. They're on a deserted Cybertron and continuously tearing heavily armed war drones to scrap, so it can't possibly be that hard for him to scavenge either a working weapon or the parts to make one. Was it just another example of the writers forgoing logic in the name of an overly simplistic theme?

to:

* If Rattrap had such a big problem with his lack of built-in weapons, why didn't he just pick up a gun? His old weapons, aside from his transmetal tail that he rarely used, weren't built-in, so it's not like things have changed that much. They're on a deserted Cybertron and continuously tearing heavily armed war drones to scrap, so it can't possibly be that hard for him to scavenge either a working weapon or the parts to make one. He's shown to keep around a variety of tools and made those seed bombs as well, but a reliable energy weapon would be far more efficient than lobbing grenades one at a time. Was it just another example of the writers forgoing logic in the name of an overly simplistic theme?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* If Rattrap had such a big problem with his lack of built-in weapons, why didn't he just pick up a gun? His old weapons, aside from his transmetal tail that he rarely used, weren't built-in, so it's not like things have changed that much. They're on a deserted Cybertron and continuously tearing heavily armed war drones to scrap, so it can't possibly be that hard for him to scavenge either a working weapon or the parts to make one. Was it just another example of the writers forgoing logic in the name of an overly simplistic theme?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** AFAIK, he went back to Cybertron after finding the rest of the survivors. This is told on one of the comics post-BeastWars.

to:

*** AFAIK, he went back to Cybertron after finding the rest of the survivors. This is told on one of the comics post-BeastWars.post-WesternAnimation/BeastWars.



* On a similar note and all fan theories aside, just how did Megatron get so anti-organic? He showed no such resentment for most of his battles in BeastWars, and actually seemed quite comfortable with his beast modes in general. Heck, with the power of his Dragon mode, he could defeat Optimus Primal in EVERY confrontation they had afterwards, with elemental strength. Why would he grow to hate something that gave him such power and the ability to overcome most of his enemies?

to:

* On a similar note and all fan theories aside, just how did Megatron get so anti-organic? He showed no such resentment for most of his battles in BeastWars, WesternAnimation/BeastWars, and actually seemed quite comfortable with his beast modes in general. Heck, with the power of his Dragon mode, he could defeat Optimus Primal in EVERY confrontation they had afterwards, with elemental strength. Why would he grow to hate something that gave him such power and the ability to overcome most of his enemies?



** By the end of BeastWars, he's pretty vehemently anti-organic and pro-God!Megatron. Being lost on Cybertron for untold ages as the sole organic transformer might well have driven him over the edge.

to:

** By the end of BeastWars, WesternAnimation/BeastWars, he's pretty vehemently anti-organic and pro-God!Megatron. Being lost on Cybertron for untold ages as the sole organic transformer might well have driven him over the edge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** By the end of BeastWars, he's pretty vehemently anti-organic and pro-God!Megatron. Being lost on Cybertron for untold ages as the sole organic transformer might well have driven him over the edge.

Removed: 3861

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Headcratchers complaining clean-up


* They transform by magic. That really bugs me.
** It's not magic. It's zen in the art of transformation.
** It's magic. They find enlightenment, and there's a bright glow and they morph (not shift and adjust) into their alt-modes. It's magic.
*** Given that it was granted by a proxy of a proxy of Primus, who their Sparks are supposed to be fragments of, it may be thought of as tapping into their own inherent divine power. Still not thematically apropos, but can be squeezed into given data if you use a handsaw and some crazy glue on the canon.
** They're part organic now. Organic things don't change shape by twisting and separating pieces of themselves, they morph fluidly.
* So the Beast Wars were fought in order to bring organic beast modes back to Cybertron. There are several problems with this. Problem 1: The beast wars would have never happened if Megatron had failed in stealing the golden disk. Problem 2: Most of the transformers that survived came back transmetal, so any organic material they had was compromised. Problem 3: There was no guarantee that the Maximals would ''win'' the beast wars, with Megatron almost '''rewriting history''' which would have created a Cybertron where technorganic life would never see the light of day. You would think '''someone''' would have checked continuity before creating a [[{{Wallbanger}} wallbanging]] Retcon.
** Primus works in mysterious ways.
** Actually, it's not too far-fetched. If you look at their Transmetal forms, the beast modes are metallic, while robot modes are more organic in appearance (an inversion of what the initial forms looked like). Then came Transmetal 2, where beast and 'bot modes looked staggeringly similar. The fusion of the organic with the technological was gradually shown (this probably wasn't the original intent during BeastWars, but it fits never the less). Remember, it was about bringing the organic back to MELD with the technological. As for the other issues...well, Megatron DID steal the Golden Disk and the Maximals DID win the Beast Wars. Moot points. If you wanted to take if further, you could argue that perhaps whatever forces drove the Maximals to prehistoric Earth also drove Megatron to steal the Disk as a reason to head to there, orchestrating a grand design. Either that, or said "Forces" knew Megs II would steal the artifact anyway and chose the Axalon and her crew to pursue him.
* Despite it's faults, I can appreciate what Beast Machines was going for. However, it [[{{Scrubs}} REA-HE-HE-HE-HE-LLY]] bugs me what they did with Rhinox. It's one thing to turn him evil...again...but to do so of his own free will? [[WallBanger The guy that liked to smell flowers?!]] And after all his willingly-committed crimes, he dies and joins with the Matrix? See, I'd always gotten the impression that the Matrix was "Heaven" and The Pit was "Hell", and after death bots would go to one according to how they lived their lives. But apparently you can betray your comrades of many years to conquer a planet and destroy anyone that gets in your way and become one with a grand, paranormal power. At the very least, they should've said it was Megatron fooling with his mind that ACTUALLY made him evil, exempting him of harsh punishments in the afterlife (it worked for Heracles). "Unexpected twist" or not, it was probably the WORST CharacterDerailment of just about any show I can think of.
** According to Bob Skir, his original intent was that Rhinox had "seen all sides of the argument, and was leaning more towards Megatron's ideas. After a quiet chat, he and Optimus would've parted company." However, Richard Newman delivered those lines snarling and shouting, making it sound like he was not right in the head. Admittedly, I'm not sure ''why'' Rhinox would've leaned towards Megatron's ideas. Maybe it was supposed to be a NotSoDifferent thing. I dunno.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** According to Bob Skir, his original intent was that Rhinox had "seen all sides of the argument, and was leaning more towards Megatron's ideas. After a quiet chat, he and Optimus would've parted company." However, Richard Newman delivered those lines snarling and shouting, making it sound like he was not right in the head. Admittedly, I'm not sure ''why'' Rhinox would've leaned towards Megatron's ideas. Maybe it was supposed to be a NotSoDifferent thing. I dunno.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They're part organic now. Organic things don't change shape by twisting and separating pieces of themselves, they morph fluidly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There was a Botcon script reading (or something like that) not long ago that involved Beast!Megatron interacting with Animated!Optimus and Sari on an AU!Cybertron. Maybe Sari's behavior during that is what convinced Megatron to be anti-organic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* On a similar note and all fan theories aside, just how did Megatron get so anti-organic? He showed no such resentment for most of his battles in BeastWars, and actually seemed quite comfortable with his beast modes in general. Heck, with the power of his Dragon mode, he could defeat Optimus Primal in EVERY confrontation they had afterwards, with elemental strength. Why would he grow to hate something that gave him such power and the ability to overcome most of his enemies?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually, it's not too far-fetched. If you look at their Transmetal forms, the beast modes are metallic, while robot modes are more organic in appearance (an inversion of what the initial forms looked like). Then came Transmetal 2, where beast and 'bot modes looked staggeringly similar. The fusion of the organic with the technological was gradually shown (this probably wasn't the original intent during BeastWars, but it fits never the less). Remember, it was about bringing the organic back to MELD with the technological. As for the other issues...well, Megatron DID steal the Golden Disk and the Maximals DID win the Beast Wars. Moot points. If you wanted to take if further, you could argue that perhaps whatever forces drove the Maximals to prehistoric Earth also drove Megatron to steal the Disk as a reason to head to there, orchestrating a grand design. Either that, or said "Forces" knew Megs II would steal the artifact anyway and chose the Axalon and her crew to pursue him.
* Despite it's faults, I can appreciate what Beast Machines was going for. However, it [[{{Scrubs}} REA-HE-HE-HE-HE-LLY]] bugs me what they did with Rhinox. It's one thing to turn him evil...again...but to do so of his own free will? [[WallBanger The guy that liked to smell flowers?!]] And after all his willingly-committed crimes, he dies and joins with the Matrix? See, I'd always gotten the impression that the Matrix was "Heaven" and The Pit was "Hell", and after death bots would go to one according to how they lived their lives. But apparently you can betray your comrades of many years to conquer a planet and destroy anyone that gets in your way and become one with a grand, paranormal power. At the very least, they should've said it was Megatron fooling with his mind that ACTUALLY made him evil, exempting him of harsh punishments in the afterlife (it worked for Heracles). "Unexpected twist" or not, it was probably the WORST CharacterDerailment of just about any show I can think of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Primus works in mysterious ways.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*So the Beast Wars were fought in order to bring organic beast modes back to Cybertron. There are several problems with this. Problem 1: The beast wars would have never happened if Megatron had failed in stealing the golden disk. Problem 2: Most of the transformers that survived came back transmetal, so any organic material they had was compromised. Problem 3: There was no guarantee that the Maximals would ''win'' the beast wars, with Megatron almost '''rewriting history''' which would have created a Cybertron where technorganic life would never see the light of day. You would think '''someone''' would have checked continuity before creating a [[{{Wallbanger}} wallbanging]] Retcon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The real question is, when did he ''arrive'' on Cybertron? Depending on how long he traveled, he might have even arrived before the Great Upgrade...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Given that it was granted by a proxy of a proxy of Primus, who their Sparks are supposed to be fragments of, it may be thought of as tapping into their own inherent divine power. Still not thematically apropos, but can be squeezed into given data if you use a handsaw and some crazy glue on the canon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's magic. They find enlightenment, and there's a bright glow and they morph (not shift and adjust) into their alt-modes. It's magic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's not magic. It's zen in the art of transformation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*They transform by magic. That really bugs me.

Top