Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / Titanic1997

Go To

OR

Added: 303

Changed: 482

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* We never find out what happens to Ruth. But it makes sense that Rose herself doesn't know either: Ruth basically sold her daughter as a bride to a really rotten and abusive man, and Rose probably feared that her mom would likely force her into another unwanted reunion with another rich man, [[AbusiveParents if not punish Rose for her defiance and refusing the lifeboat]]. After getting a taste of true love with Jack, Rose would never go back to becoming just a TrophyWife, let alone being a tool for her mom anymore. Not bothering to look for her mom's whereabouts was the only Rose could finally break with her for good.

to:

* We never find out what happens to Ruth. But it makes sense that Rose herself doesn't know either: Ruth basically sold after her daughter mother tried to sell her as a bride to a really rotten and abusive man, and Rose probably feared that her mom would likely force her into another unwanted reunion marriage with another rich man, [[AbusiveParents if not punish Rose for her defiance and refusing the lifeboat]]. After getting a taste of true love with Jack, Rose would never go back to becoming just a TrophyWife, let alone being a tool for her mom anymore. Not bothering to look for her mom's whereabouts was the only Rose could finally break with her for good.
* Despite being on the Carpathia, Rose and Ruth never bumped into one another. But Rose was in the third-class survivor section and Ruth is a woman so classist she wanted the lifeboats to be segregated by class. Rose willingly chose to be in the third class, knowing her mom would never step foot there.



* Cal going bankrupt in the crash of 1929 isn't all too surprising: underneath [[FauxAffablyEvil his pretenses]] of gentlemanly behavior, he's a spoiled and controlling asshole who treated his fiancee like a possession. His upbringing was likely one in which he got everything handed to him, so he never really learned discipline or how to succeed in the business world. He, like many people in the 1920s, would've believed the stock market would remain on a permanently high plateau, only to be wiped out completely when the crash came. His ending his own life was because he knew without money no one would want anything to do with him.

to:

* Cal going bankrupt in the crash of 1929 isn't all too surprising: underneath [[FauxAffablyEvil his pretenses]] of gentlemanly behavior, he's a spoiled and controlling asshole who treated his fiancee like a possession. His upbringing was likely one in which he got everything handed to him, so he never really learned discipline or how to succeed in the business world. He, like Like many people in the 1920s, he would've believed the stock market would remain on a permanently high plateau, only to be wiped out completely when the crash came. His ending his own life was because he knew without money no one would want anything to do with him.




to:

* Cal's suicide was prompted by his going bankrupt in 1929. However, it is shown that Cal seemed somewhat remorseful about Rose, even wandering the Carpathia trying to find her. What if he was carrying lifelong guilt over what he did, on top of the trauma that many survivors of the Titanic held? His suicide may have been the result of going bankrupt, but all that guilt and self-loathing were kindling.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So, what DID happen to Rose's mother? She admits to Rose she's pressuring her to marry Cal because her deadbeat late husband left them with nothing but the family name and a pile of debt. Rose marries rich, they can pay off the creditors; if she doesn't, all their belongings are sold off and her mother's taking in sewing. Now, she might have been exaggerating, but the fact that Rose's marriage is apparently their only trump card suggests there aren't any close relatives to take them in. Old Rose mentions that she 'heard' Cal shot himself after the Crash of '29, but doesn't say anything about her mother. (You know, the previously-unknown great-grandmother of that nice granddaughter who feeds her Pomeranian and hauls her out for helicopter rides to Russian research vessel in the middle of the North Atlantic and presumably packed all those trunks? i.e., is doing Trudy's job now?) So did Ruth have to swallow her pride, hock all her belongings, and either take up seamstressing or throw herself on the charity and pity of her society friends? [[DriventoSuicide Or did she take a darker option?]]
** She could have remarried. A lot of widows from the ''Titanic'' did. She was still a name and could therefore be a somewhat attractive prospect for an older bachelor.
** Just a guess but: insurance. Rose 'dies' unmarried and her next of kin is Ruth, so Ruth can make claims for both their possessions on the ship. Now, that doesn't include the Heart of the Ocean, because we know Cal claims for that, but it could well include every other thing they had. The paintings, jewelry, expensive clothes, it was probably all insured. Assuming Cal got them a good deal and the claim value is about equal to the actual value of the lost goods, Ruth does better than selling them (buying second hand often gives you leeway to ask for a discount, especially if you know the seller is desperate and will take any offer). She presumably had some place arranged to stay before the wedding (even hotel reservations would be something) and there were many collections for the survivors who lost their breadwinners/source of income (craftsmen losing tools, merchants losing goods) that were pure charity if she could bring herself to ask for that. She talks to Rose about selling their fine things and taking in sewing but that is probably mother-drama. It's possible that Ruth could have lived reasonably as a distressed gentlewoman for the rest of her life if she could deal with the responsibility of choosing rent and food over new hats...
** Cal was still rich for a long time after the ship sank. He may have set up a trust fund to take care of Ruth as his mother-in-law, since he regarded Rose as his wife in practice if not by law. Cal would have been aware that his reputation as a gentleman would suffer if he cut Ruth off without any money after her only child was thought to have died in the sinking.
*** Plus, Ruth and Cal were BirdsOfAFeather who seemed to genuinely like each other. He may have had real affection for her and wanted to take care of her, by settling her debts if nothing else.

to:

* So, what DID happen to Rose's mother? She admits to Rose she's pressuring her to marry Cal because her deadbeat late husband left them with nothing but the family name and a pile of debt. Rose marries rich, they can pay off the creditors; if she doesn't, all their belongings are sold off and her mother's taking in sewing. Now, she might have been exaggerating, but the fact that Rose's marriage is apparently their only trump card suggests there aren't any close relatives to take them in. Old Rose mentions that she 'heard' Cal shot himself after the Crash of '29, but doesn't say anything about her mother. (You know, the previously-unknown great-grandmother of that nice granddaughter who feeds her Pomeranian and hauls her out for helicopter rides to Russian research vessel in the middle of the North Atlantic and presumably packed all those trunks? i.e., is doing Trudy's job now?) now?)
**
So did Ruth have to swallow her pride, hock all her belongings, and either take up seamstressing or throw herself on the charity and pity of her society friends? [[DriventoSuicide Or did she take a darker option?]]
** She could have remarried. A lot of widows from the ''Titanic'' did. She was still a name and could therefore be a somewhat attractive prospect for an older bachelor.
bachelor. She might even get help if she can milk the sympathy she'd get from her "dead" daughter.
** Just a guess but: insurance. Rose 'dies' unmarried and her next of kin is Ruth, Ruth so that Ruth can make claims for claim both their possessions on the ship. Now, that doesn't include the Heart of the Ocean, because we know Cal claims for that, but it could well include every other thing they had. The paintings, jewelry, expensive clothes, it was probably all insured. Assuming Cal got them a good deal and the claim value is about equal to the actual value of the lost goods, Ruth does better than selling them (buying second hand often gives you leeway to ask for a discount, especially if you know the seller is desperate and will take any offer). She presumably had some place arranged to stay before the wedding (even hotel reservations would be something) and there were many collections for the survivors who lost their breadwinners/source of income (craftsmen losing tools, merchants losing goods) that were pure charity if she could bring herself to ask for that. She talks to Rose about selling their fine things and taking in sewing but that is probably mother-drama. It's possible that Ruth could have lived reasonably as a distressed gentlewoman for the rest of her life if she could deal with the responsibility of choosing rent and food over new hats...
** Cal was still rich for a long time after the ship sank. He may have set up a trust fund to take care of Ruth as his mother-in-law, since he regarded Rose as his wife in practice practice, if not by law. Cal would have been aware that his reputation as a gentleman would suffer if he cut Ruth off without any money after her only child was thought to have died in the sinking.
***
sinking. Also, he seemed to show remorse and some longing for Rose, as shown by his aimless wandering on the Carpathia, [[TheAtoner so he might feel inclined to help Ruth as atonement for how he treated Rose.]] Plus, Ruth and Cal were BirdsOfAFeather BirdsOfAFeather, who seemed to genuinely like each other. He may have had real genuine affection for her and wanted to take care of her, her by settling her debts debts, if nothing else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** the strokers as well as the majority remained at their posts, only 25 or so survived.

to:

*** the strokers as well as the majority remained at their posts, fighting to desperately to hold the icy waters of the Atlantic back long enough for the boilers cool down enough to avoid a steam explosion that would’ve destroyed a good chunk of the ship and accelerate the sinking; the end result is that only 25 or so made it deck side and survived.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Third Class passengers received free postcards on their dining menus, so that they could get more business for White Star by praising the line to their friends and family back home, and the ship made two stops in France and Ireland that might have included some mail drop-off. It's possible Fabrizio wrote a postcard to his mother that made it off the ship, and when she didn't see his name on any survivor lists, she realized what had happened to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Something to consider is that, while yes Jack and Rose was together for a short while, the relationship helped Rose to break away from the restrictive life she was trapped in. If she didn't meet Jack, she would've either been married to Cal or committed suicide, thus never meeting her husband in the first place. Jack may have not been with Rose nearly as long as her husband, but he was still an important turning point in her life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rose became a famous actress, for most of her life she was living unafraid, in the open, and her former associates must have eventually seen her on screen (presumably they were too ashamed to contact her). Her silence on the subject more likely is because she didn't want to upset her husband and family with rhe knowledge of a romance which was so much more important to her than her relationship with them that she imagines herself going to the afterlife with Jack and not her husband.

to:

** Rose became a famous actress, for most of her life she was living unafraid, in the open, and her former associates must have eventually seen her on screen (presumably they were too ashamed to contact her). Her silence on the subject more likely is because she didn't want to upset her husband and family with rhe the knowledge of a romance which was so much more important to her than her relationship with them that she imagines herself going to the afterlife with Jack and not her husband.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The stokers suffered a very high death toll, and none of the engineers escaped the sinking. They are remembered as heroes today because they stayed at their post and kept the lights burning for as long as they did. Imagine being in the bottom of the ship, you can hear the steel squeaking in protest (and possibly can even see it beginning to warp), you know there's no way you can make it up the escape ladders now because the angle of the ship is too steep to allow you to climb them. You know that any minute the sea is going to rush in and kill you... and you STILL keep trying to maintain the ship's systems as long as possible to give the people on the upper decks a fighting chance of survival. How's that for HeroicSacrifice?

to:

** The stokers suffered a very high death toll, toll and none of the engineers escaped the sinking. They are remembered as heroes today because they stayed at their post and kept the lights burning for as long as they did. Imagine being in the bottom of the ship, you can hear the steel squeaking in protest (and possibly can even see it beginning to warp), you know there's no way you can make it up the escape ladders now because the angle of the ship is too steep to allow you to climb them. You know that any minute the sea is going to rush in and kill you... and you STILL keep trying to keep the ship afloat and maintain the ship's systems as long as possible to give the people on the upper decks a fighting chance of survival. How's that for HeroicSacrifice?



*** the strokers as well as the majority remained at their posts trying to hold the icy ocean at bay long enough for the pipping hot boilers to cool down to prevent them from exploding.

to:

*** the strokers as well as the majority remained at their posts trying to hold the icy ocean at bay long enough for the pipping hot boilers to cool down to prevent them from exploding. posts, only 25 or so survived.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** the strokers as well as the majority remained at their posts trying to hold the icy ocean at bay long enough for the pipping hot boilers to cool down to prevent them from exploding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Provided she didn't [[MercyKill smother them both once they fell asleep to spare them]]...


Added DiffLines:

*** Considering what happened to the other orphaned children rescued from the Titanic (who were looked after by volunteers while the newspapers published their photos in order to find their extended family members), she'd probably be all right.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Jack's fate was his frozen body being sent to the bottom of the Atlantic. In RealLife, the bodies of those who drowned either dissolved or were consumed by sea creatures, with nothing remaining of the victims except for their shoes and boots. It is depressing and nightmarish that all that might remain of Jack is footwear and the memories of an old lady.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** so [[WhyDidYouMakeMeHitYou she made him hit her?]] Or maybe controlling people find pretexts, excuses to abuse others, and those pretexts are not the reasons for the abuse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Rose became a famous actress, for most of her life she was living unafraid, in the open, and her former associates must have eventually seen her on screen (presumably they were too ashamed to contact her). Her silence on the subject more likely is because she didn't want to upset her husband and family with rhe knowledge of a romance which was so much more important to her than her relationship with them that she imagines herself going to the afterlife with Jack and not her husband.

Added: 1389

Changed: 98

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* How a character relates to poverty (or the fear of it) is a reflection of their moral character.
** Jack was born into poverty and remained a starving artist, but he never showed any shame or embarrassment from it, even when he was dining with some of the richest people in the world. He was a decent, humble guy who was secure with who he was. Rose went from being a wealthy but miserable (would-be) TrophyWife to a poor refugee with no possessions but clothes on her back (and a rare diamond she didn't pawn). And yet she managed to build herself up, become an actress, raise a family, and live into the 1990s.
** Ruth was an upper-class woman who dreaded being stuck in poverty and thus treated her own daughter as a show pony and a cash cow, proving how much of a selfish wench she was. Cal's choice to stick a pistol in his mouth after going bankrupt only showed how much of a weak coward he really was.
* Why did Rose keep the Heart of the Ocean for so many years?
** Rose made a conscious effort to break with her pre-Titanic life, changing her name, refusing to go back to her abusive family and living according to her own merits. Not pawning the diamond despite the wealth it would've brought her was because she didn't want to rely on something her cruel ex-fiancee gave her to support herself.
** Also, if she tried to pawn the diamond, its size, wealth, and in-universe lore would've revealed her true identity, which is something she apparently didn't want others to find out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Cal going bankrupt isn't all too surprising: underneath [[FauxAffablyEvil his pretenses]] of gentlemanly behavior, he's a spoiled and controlling asshole who treated his fiancee like a possession. His upbringing was likely one in which he got everything handed to him, so he never really learned discipline or how to succeed in the business world. He, like many people in the 20s, would've believed the stock market would remain on a permanently high plateau.

to:

* Cal going bankrupt in the crash of 1929 isn't all too surprising: underneath [[FauxAffablyEvil his pretenses]] of gentlemanly behavior, he's a spoiled and controlling asshole who treated his fiancee like a possession. His upbringing was likely one in which he got everything handed to him, so he never really learned discipline or how to succeed in the business world. He, like many people in the 20s, 1920s, would've believed the stock market would remain on a permanently high plateau.
plateau, only to be wiped out completely when the crash came. His ending his own life was because he knew without money no one would want anything to do with him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Cal going bankrupt isn't all too surprising: underneath [[FauxAffablyEvil his pretenses]] of gentlemanly behavior, he's a spoiled and controlling asshole who treated his fiancee like a possession. His upbringing was likely one in which he got everything handed to him, so he never really learned discipline or how to succeed in the business world. He, like many people in the 20s, would've believed the stock market would remain on a permanently high plateau.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He was clearly remorseful for what she did to Rose, so likely he treated his next wife much better.

to:

** He was clearly remorseful for what she he did to Rose, so likely he treated his next wife much better.



* It could be that Rose's father was a good man to his wife and daughter, but lost their money through external matters or a gambling vice.

to:

* ** It could be that Rose's father was a good man to his wife and daughter, but lost their money through external matters or a gambling vice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If it help alleviate the potential horror, given the bashing around the stern underwent before it made its final plunge, they would almost certainly have either been killed as they were buffeted around or at least knocked out, so either way were almost not conscious when the implosion occurred.

Added: 409

Changed: 176

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* While Cal did save the life of a little girl, albeit, for self-serving reasons, this action could have potentially caused a lot of harm since he functionally kidnapped a kid.
** If that kids' parents were still alive and looking for their daughter, how would they've reacted to not being able to find her on a rapidly sinking ship?
** How did that child feel, knowing that her parents were dead?
** Whatever became of that child? Hopefully, Cal was decent enough to give that poor kid home, but it is easy to imagine him dumping that child in an orphanage once her utility to him ended.

Added: 514

Changed: 1428

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* We never find out what happens to Rose's mom, Ruth. But it makes sense that Rose herself doesn't know for several reasons:
** Ruth basically sold her daughter as a bride to a really rotten and abusive man, and Rose probably feared that her mom would likely force her into another unwanted reunion with another rich man, [[AbusiveParents if not punish Rose for her defiance and refusing the lifeboat]]. After getting a taste of true love with Jack, Rose would never go back to becoming just a TrophyWife, let alone being a tool for her mom anymore.
** Rose was so desperate to escape her toxic life that she never even bothered to find out about her mother's whereabouts. Considering she covered up her aristocratic background and never told her story (or even origins) to her own family for over 80 years, forcing her mother out of her mind and forgetting she existed was part of that process.

to:

* We never find out what happens to Rose's mom, to Ruth. But it makes sense that Rose herself doesn't know for several reasons:
**
either: Ruth basically sold her daughter as a bride to a really rotten and abusive man, and Rose probably feared that her mom would likely force her into another unwanted reunion with another rich man, [[AbusiveParents if not punish Rose for her defiance and refusing the lifeboat]]. After getting a taste of true love with Jack, Rose would never go back to becoming just a TrophyWife, let alone being a tool for her mom anymore. Not bothering to look for her mom's whereabouts was the only Rose could finally break with her for good.
** * Going on the above, there is a reason why Rose waited 80 years to tell her story: she was so desperate to escape her toxic life, she hid her experiences out of fear someone from her old life that she never even bothered to find out about could track her mother's whereabouts. down. Considering how Cal wandered Carpathia to look for Rose, it makes sense why she covered up her aristocratic background and never told her story (or even origins) to her own family for over 80 years, forcing her mother out of her mind and forgetting she existed was part of that process.
would do this.


Added DiffLines:

** Even if Ruth somehow avoided the poorhouse, [[VillainousBSOD she's not going to be in good shape mentally]]: her daughter, as far as she knows, is dead. [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone And she has no one to blame but herself for driving her away]]. Ruth probably regrets [[PartingWordsRegret that her last moment with her daughter was complaining about lifeboat space and hollering at her with another abusive order]]. No amount of money in the world can make up for the fact that she has no one to really share it with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


** It's double Fridge Horror/Brilliance if you're familiar with the real Thomas Andrews. Andrews in real life was a father to a 2 year old girl named Elizabeth when the disaster happened. Based on his interactions with Rose in the film, it's implied that Andrews views her as like a daughter. The [[AdultFear look of fear and horror in his eyes when Rose confronts him about the iceberg]] shows that he's deathly worried for her and was no doubt thinking of his own daughter and what he'd do if she were there...hence his pleading with Rose to "don't wait".

to:

** It's double Fridge Horror/Brilliance if you're familiar with the real Thomas Andrews. Andrews in real life was a father to a 2 year old girl named Elizabeth when the disaster happened. Based on his interactions with Rose in the film, it's implied that Andrews views her as like a daughter. The [[AdultFear look of fear and horror in his eyes when Rose confronts him about the iceberg]] iceberg shows that he's deathly worried for her and was no doubt thinking of his own daughter and what he'd do if she were there...hence his pleading with Rose to "don't wait".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* It could be that Rose's father was a good man to his wife and daughter, but lost their money through external matters or a gambling vice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Imagine the company that overruled the double lifeboats for the ''Titanic'', which could've saved those who at the very least made it deckside. As soon as they heard the news about it's tragedy and the mortality rate, it's not off to think that whoever may have declined Andrew's order are now possibly living in guilt and turmoil...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Heaven probably has a bunch of polycules.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter


** You've forgotten Marjorie Bellamy.
*** Who is a fictional character from ''Series/UpstairsDownstairs'', the ''Series/DowntonAbbey'' of the 70s.

Added: 885

Changed: 462

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Ruth sees nothing wrong with selling Rose like a trophy to the highest bidder. But it is very well possible Ruth endured the same thing Rose did: her own parents forced her into a marriage with a wealthy man when she was still a young adult. This could mean Ruth was raised to believe these kinds of arranged marriages are normal, or she's forcing Rose to endure the same emotional hardship out of anger seeing her own youth and love life taken away from her.
* Was Ruth's father just like Cal? An abusive rich bastard who only care about himself and saw other women as objects? It is telling that Rose never once talks about her biological father, and the only time he's brought up, it is when Ruth disdainfully talks about how he apparently brought the family into debt and ruin. There are a lot of possibilities:
** Ruth has little problem with Cal's (at best) controlling behavior toward Rose, meaning she also had to endure a relationship with an abusive man [[ConditionedToAcceptHorror and probably thinks that kind of relationship is normal]].
** Or it could be Rose indirectly blames her father for the rotten life she nearly got: had he not died with the family in debt, she wouldn't have had to deal with Cal at all.
** Or perhaps Rose felt a sense of abandonment from her father dying, which is why she doesn't bother to think about him.

Added: 769

Changed: 127

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* We never find out what happens to Rose's mom, Ruth. But it makes sense that Rose herself doesn't know for several reasons:
** Ruth basically sold her daughter as a bride to a really rotten and abusive man, and Rose probably feared that her mom would likely force her into another unwanted reunion with another rich man, [[AbusiveParents if not punish Rose for her defiance and refusing the lifeboat]]. After getting a taste of true love with Jack, Rose would never go back to becoming just a TrophyWife, let alone being a tool for her mom anymore.
** Rose was so desperate to escape her toxic life that she never even bothered to find out about her mother's whereabouts. Considering she covered up her aristocratic background and never told her story (or even origins) to her own family for over 80 years, forcing her mother out of her mind and forgetting she existed was part of that process.



* An in-universe example with Rose when she remembers what Andrews told her earlier about the number of lifeboats while he is telling her that the ship is, in fact, sinking.

to:

* An in-universe example with Rose is when she remembers what Andrews told her earlier about the number of lifeboats while he is telling her that the ship is, in fact, sinking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So, what DID happen to Rose's mother? She admits to Rose she's pressuring her to marry Cal because her deadbeat dead husband left them with nothing but the family name and a pile of debt. Rose marries rich, they can pay off the creditors; if she doesn't, all their belongings are sold off and her mother's taking in sewing. Now, she might have been exaggerating, but the fact that Rose's marriage is apparently their only trump card suggests there aren't any close relatives to take them in. Old Rose mentions that she 'heard' Cal shot himself after the Crash of '29, but doesn't say anything about her mother. (You know, the previously-unknown great-grandmother of that nice granddaughter who feeds her Pomeranian and hauls her out for helicopter rides to Russian research vessel in the middle of the North Atlantic and presumably packed all those trunks? i.e., is doing Trudy's job now?) So did Ruth have to swallow her pride, hock all her belongings, and either take up seamstressing or throw herself on the charity and pity of her society friends? [[DriventoSuicide Or did she take a darker option?]]

to:

* So, what DID happen to Rose's mother? She admits to Rose she's pressuring her to marry Cal because her deadbeat dead late husband left them with nothing but the family name and a pile of debt. Rose marries rich, they can pay off the creditors; if she doesn't, all their belongings are sold off and her mother's taking in sewing. Now, she might have been exaggerating, but the fact that Rose's marriage is apparently their only trump card suggests there aren't any close relatives to take them in. Old Rose mentions that she 'heard' Cal shot himself after the Crash of '29, but doesn't say anything about her mother. (You know, the previously-unknown great-grandmother of that nice granddaughter who feeds her Pomeranian and hauls her out for helicopter rides to Russian research vessel in the middle of the North Atlantic and presumably packed all those trunks? i.e., is doing Trudy's job now?) So did Ruth have to swallow her pride, hock all her belongings, and either take up seamstressing or throw herself on the charity and pity of her society friends? [[DriventoSuicide Or did she take a darker option?]]



*** If she survived him. In the extended scene, Rose only says that Cal's sons fought for his inheritance.

to:

*** If she survived him. In the extended scene, Rose only says that Cal's sons fought for over his inheritance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Irish mother is last seen tucking in her children after realizing they're not going to survive. The accommodations for third class women and families were located in the stern. There's a possibility they may have still been alive after the breakup and died once the stern imploded beneath the surface, half a minute at most.

to:

* The Irish mother is last seen tucking in her children after realizing they're not going to survive. The accommodations for third class single women and families with children were located in the stern. There's a possibility they may have still been alive after the breakup and died once the stern imploded beneath the surface, half a minute at most.

Changed: 227

Removed: 175

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
orphaned reference


** A deleted scene on the ''Carpathia'' shows that the little girl did indeed survive (I believe she is even being held by the woman Cal handed her to.)
*** Although, we should all remember that this is a fictionalized account of a historical event, and you shouldn't look too hard for fictional names in historical survivors...

to:

** A During the montage of lifeboat passengers after Rose's rescue, the little girl and the woman Cal handed her to are seen sitting next to Cal. There's also a deleted scene on the ''Carpathia'' shows showing that the little girl did indeed survive (I believe she is even being held by the woman Cal handed her to.)
*** Although, we should all remember that this is a fictionalized account of a historical event, and you shouldn't look too hard for fictional names in historical survivors...
survive.



** TruthInTelevision: A number of ''Titanic'' victims were travelling under assumed names or the names of other people. For example, a man who intended to sign up for ''Titanic'' as a stoker left his discharge book (used as a sort of work record aboard ship) behind after a heavy night of drinking in the pub. Without his book he couldn't sign on for ''Titanic'', but somebody used his book to sign on as a stoker. The individual in question, who was assumed to be the man to whom the book really belonged, died in the sinking and it was assumed for a couple of months that the book's owner was the victim. When it became apparent that the owner of the book was not the stoker who went down, it left a little mystery behind. Who was the guy who found a discharge book in a pub and used it to sign up as a ''Titanic'' stoker, only to die when the ship went down? We'll never know.

to:

** TruthInTelevision: A number of ''Titanic'' victims were travelling traveling under assumed names or the names of other people. For example, a man who intended to sign up for ''Titanic'' as a stoker left his discharge book (used as a sort of work record aboard ship) behind after a heavy night of drinking in the pub. Without his book he couldn't sign on for ''Titanic'', but somebody used his book to sign on as a stoker. The individual in question, who was assumed to be the man to whom the book really belonged, died in the sinking and it was assumed for a couple of months that the book's owner was the victim. When it became apparent that the owner of the book was not the stoker who went down, it left a little mystery behind. Who was the guy who found a discharge book in a pub and used it to sign up as a ''Titanic'' stoker, only to die when the ship went down? We'll never know.

Added: 141

Changed: 498

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Old Rose seems privy to information about the ship she couldn't possibly have known at the time; same goes for seemingly knowing about things she never witnessed during the voyage. Well, it's been 84 years, so maybe she simply heard stories from other survivors and put it all together. It would also explain the [[HistoricalHeroUpgrade character]] [[HistoricalVillainUpgrade changes]] that the historical figures went through, as Rose is probably not an [[UnreliableNarrator unbiased narrator]].
** There have been lots of books and documentaries about the ''Titanic''; plenty to help Rose fill in the gaps a bit regarding what happened.

Top