Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / DuckTales2017S1E9TheImpossibleSummitOfMtNeverrest

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* After the avalanche has brought everyone back to the tourist town, the streets are pretty much flooded by the snow. It doesn't seem likely that they were evacuated in time, so some people might have been buried alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Scrooge was probably being more intentionally reckless with the supplies than usual because him being weighed down by supplies was what caused Mallard to cut him loose in the past. He not only wanted to get farther than Mallard, he wanted to prove he wasn't the same young, wimpy duck who was too scared of losing his equipment to keep going.

to:

* Scrooge was probably being more intentionally reckless with the supplies than usual because him being weighed down by supplies was what caused Mallard Mallardy to cut him loose in the past. He not only wanted to get farther than Mallard, Mallardy, he wanted to prove he wasn't the same young, wimpy duck who was too scared of losing his equipment to keep going.



* The T-Shirt Mallard's skeleton is wearing (for that matter, how in the world did Mallard's body decay to a skeleton in a frozen cave in the first place?). The 'I Didn't Survive Mt. Neverrest' T-shirt that is sold ''in that exact style'' back at the tourist trap at Mt. Neverrest's base. It's highly unlikely those shirts have been on sale for 75 years with no change, especially since Scrooge is surprised by the tourist trap's very existence. Meaning that someone must have found him in that cave and put the shirt on him... and then promptly got lost trying to find their way back and likely died on the mountain themselves.

to:

* The T-Shirt Mallard's Mallardy's skeleton is wearing (for that matter, how in the world did Mallard's body decay to a skeleton in a frozen cave in the first place?).wearing. The 'I Didn't Survive Mt. Neverrest' T-shirt that is sold ''in that exact style'' back at the tourist trap at Mt. Neverrest's base. It's highly unlikely those shirts have been on sale for 75 years with no change, especially since Scrooge is surprised by the tourist trap's very existence. Meaning that someone must have found him in that cave and put the shirt on him... and then promptly got lost trying to find their way back and likely died on the mountain themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Huey gets confused while charting Mount Neverrest, he scribbles "WTD?" on the map. Although the "D" can stand for several GoshDangItToHeck-type swearwords (e.g. "deuce" or "devil"), it most likely stands for "duck" given the setting. Which is a very subtle way of GettingCrapPastTheRadar considering [[PrecisionFStrike what word it sounds similar to]].

to:

* When Huey gets confused while charting Mount Neverrest, he scribbles "WTD?" on the map. Although the "D" can stand for several GoshDangItToHeck-type swearwords (e.g. "deuce" or "devil"), it most likely stands for "duck" given the setting. Which is a very subtle way of GettingCrapPastTheRadar considering [[PrecisionFStrike what word it sounds similar to]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Repair do not respond.


* The sheer fact that Scrooge has had people use their dying breaths cursing his very name. How many people would that be? Would they all be his enemies or someone he only perceived as enemies? Worse, would the story "The Empire Builder from Calisota" be somewhat canon in this continuity?
** Considering that WordOfGod said ''ComicBook/TheLifeAndTimesOfScroogeMcDuck'' was a mandatory read for the writer crew, and Scrooge's backstory in this continuity largely follows that one, one can assume that "The Empire Builder from Calisota" is canon here.
** Except the events of said story led to Scrooge being estranged from his family, which didn't happen in this continuity until much later and happened for a different reason. If the story is canon then it'd have to explain why Della and Donald continued to adventure with Scrooge.
*** [[ForWantOfANail He accepted his sisters' "bygones" offer?]]
* Avalanche. Snow and ice covers the whole town and tourist attractions and possibly killing dozens (if not hundreds of people). Do I have say more?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Scrooge so obstinate about getting to the top of Mt. Neverrest, even at the cost of putting his family in danger? His [[FatalFlaw ''pride'']]. Scrooge's pride took a huge hit [[spoiler: 75 years ago when he not only failed, but was betrayed and humiliated to boot]] and he's aiming to settle the score. Plus, Scrooge really doesn't like admitting defeat. The fact that Huey is at all capable of talking him into it is a CrowningMomentOfAwesome in and of itself.

to:

* Why is Scrooge so obstinate about getting to the top of Mt. Neverrest, even at the cost of putting his family in danger? His [[FatalFlaw ''pride'']]. Scrooge's pride took a huge hit [[spoiler: 75 years ago when he not only failed, but was betrayed and humiliated to boot]] and he's aiming to settle the score. Plus, Scrooge really doesn't like admitting defeat. The fact that Huey is at all capable of talking him into it is a CrowningMomentOfAwesome SugarWiki/MomentOfAwesome in and of itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just a thought that popped up. Feel free to edit for clarity or missed tropes.

Added DiffLines:

** However, this slides into FridgeHorror with ''The Last Crash of the Sunchaser'' where [[spoiler: Scrooge probably realized he was being just as stubborn as Della, ignoring the pleas to turn back. He was not only reliving Della's final moments before she was lost. He was reenacting her actions.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* NoodleIncident aside, there is a certain logic in Scrooge hating Santa Claus: while Scrooge believes that hard work is the only thing to be rewarded, Santa gives gifts for children just for being nice. Scrooge probably thinks that Santa's gifts promote laziness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Scrooge was probably being more intentionally reckless with the supplies than usual because him being weighed down by supplies was what caused Mallard to cut him loose in the past. He not only wanted to get farther than Mallard, he wanted to prove he wasn't the same young, wimpy duck who was too scared of losing his equipment to keep going.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Avalanche. Snow and ice covers the whole town and tourist attractions and possibly killing dozens (if not hundreads of people). Do I have say more?

to:

* Avalanche. Snow and ice covers the whole town and tourist attractions and possibly killing dozens (if not hundreads hundreds of people). Do I have say more?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Avalanche. Snow and ice covers the whole town and tourist attractions and possibly killing dozens (if not hundreads of people). Do I have say more?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** [[ForWantOfANail He accepted his sisters' "bygones" offer?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is more of a headscratcher than Fridge Brilliance. Moving it there.


* Don't people care that famous billionaire/adventurer Scrooge McDuck was the Neverrest Ninny? It's something his rivals would have used against him for spite.
** Nobody probably knows. Scrooge last went up Mt Neverrest 75 years ago, he's probably the only living person still alive who knows he was the Neverrest Ninny. (Huey lampshades that noone's used the word "Ninny" in ages)
** More significantly, nobody really cares. Scrooge was beaten by the mountain, but so was everybody else. When everyone loses all the time, the best thing one can do is give up and accept it, which Scrooge eventually learns and appreciates.

Added: 852

Changed: 159

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Don't people care that famous billionaire/adventurer Scrooge McDuck was the Neverrest Ninny? It's something his rivals would have used against him for spite.
** Nobody probably knows. Scrooge last went up Mt Neverrest 75 years ago, he's probably the only living person still alive who knows he was the Neverrest Ninny. (Huey lampshades that noone's used the word "Ninny" in ages)
** More significantly, nobody really cares. Scrooge was beaten by the mountain, but so was everybody else. When everyone loses all the time, the best thing one can do is give up and accept it, which Scrooge eventually learns and appreciates.
* Scrooge never had a chance of winning. He wasn't up against a man-made enemy like a rival or a booby-trapped treasure, he was up against a mountain, a force of nature. No one can ever control or master nature, no matter how hard they try.
* The tourist village at Mt Neverrest may have been created by former explorers who decided to cut their losses on Mt Neverrest and settle down there.

Added: 131

Changed: 273

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The carving of people with their heads/bodies separated by wormholes means there may have been people who lived on Mt Neverrest once and so must have known of the existence of wormholes. It may not have helped them though, if the wormholes are too random to navigate by.


Added DiffLines:

** What's more unsettling, are the wormholes random or are they manipulated by an unknown source? Is the mountain itself sentient?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The comics frequently followed the formula of Scrooge going on a dangerous treasure hunt, finding the treasure, and not being able to keep it because it legally belongs to some individual/group/government, but getting to keep some artifact or memento from the journey to place in his trophy room -- which (after a brief tantrum over losing the money) Scrooge was always perfectly satisfied with because, for him, ItsTheJourneyThatCounts. This episode follows a non-monetary version of the same formula -- Scrooge doesn't achieve the goal he was aiming for (reaching the top of the mountain) but gets a consolation prize (going farther than anyone ever has) sufficient to feed his adventure addiction. Once he gets over the initial disappointment, it's still ultimately the journey that counts with him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When Huey gets confused while charting Mount Neverrest, he scribbles "WTD?" on the map. Although the "D" can stand for several GoshDangItToHeck-type swearwords (e.g. "deuce" or "devil"), it most likely stands for "duck" given the setting. Which is a very subtle way of GettingCrapPastTheRadar considering [[PrecisionFStrike what word it sounds similar to]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Except the events of said story led to Scrooge being estranged from his family, which didn't happen in this continuity until much later and happened for a different reason. If the story is canon then it'd have to explain why Della and Donald continued to adventure with Scrooge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Considering that WordOfGod said ''ComicBook/TheLifeAndTimesOfScroogeMcDuck'' was a mandatory read for the writer crew, and Scrooge's backstory in this continuity largely follows that one, one can assume that "The Empire Builder from Calisota" is canon here.

Changed: 207

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Which might explain the "Point of No Return" sign, even though the first part of the climb seems safe enough; even people who venture that far up the mountain might find themselves unable to make it back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The sheer fact that Scrooge has had people use their dying breaths cursing his very name. How many people would that be? Would they all be his enemies or someone he only perceived as enemies? Worse, would the story "The Empire Builder from Calisota" be somewhat canon in this continuity?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The reason why so many climbers are lost on the mountain isn't just because the portals keep them from the summit. It's also shown that more than a few portals that can be encountered going down the mountain will deposit you further back up it. Not only could these ill-fated explorers not get to the top, they ''couldn't get back down either''.

to:

* The One that doubles as FridgeHorror: the reason why so many climbers are lost on the mountain isn't just because the portals keep them from the summit. It's also shown that more than a few portals that can be encountered going down the mountain will deposit you further back up it. Not only could these ill-fated explorers not get to the top, they ''couldn't get back down either''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The reason why so many climbers are lost on the mountain isn't just because the portals keep them from the summit. It's also shown that more than a few portals that can be encountered going down the mountain will deposit you further back up it. Not only could these ill-fated explorers not get to the top, they ''couldn't get back down either''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!Fridge Brilliance:
* Why is Scrooge so obstinate about getting to the top of Mt. Neverrest, even at the cost of putting his family in danger? His [[FatalFlaw ''pride'']]. Scrooge's pride took a huge hit [[spoiler: 75 years ago when he not only failed, but was betrayed and humiliated to boot]] and he's aiming to settle the score. Plus, Scrooge really doesn't like admitting defeat. The fact that Huey is at all capable of talking him into it is a CrowningMomentOfAwesome in and of itself.

!!Fridge Horror:
* Mt. Neverrest itself and the [[EldritchLocation random wormholes]] that dot it. The wormholes themselves are creepy enough, but the more you think about them the more horrifying they get. For one, they're in a high altitude location where blinding snowfall, or even snow blown about by high winds, can happen at any moment, meaning that visibility is low. The wormholes are ''invisible'' even in clear weather. As such, it's all too easy to not only get turned around on the mountain, but to never realize that you've even ''been'' turned around. Suddenly the best navigational skills on the planet are rendered completely useless for finding your way around the mountain. Add in the possibility of being separated from your survival gear by a random wormhole (assuming you didn't ditch any to lighten your load) or even sudden TeleFrag and it's no wonder so many people don't return.
* The T-Shirt Mallard's skeleton is wearing (for that matter, how in the world did Mallard's body decay to a skeleton in a frozen cave in the first place?). The 'I Didn't Survive Mt. Neverrest' T-shirt that is sold ''in that exact style'' back at the tourist trap at Mt. Neverrest's base. It's highly unlikely those shirts have been on sale for 75 years with no change, especially since Scrooge is surprised by the tourist trap's very existence. Meaning that someone must have found him in that cave and put the shirt on him... and then promptly got lost trying to find their way back and likely died on the mountain themselves.

----

Top