Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / DoctorWhoStevenMoffatEra

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Unlikely, he doesn't learn the truth of Lake Silencio until the Ganger incident.


Added DiffLines:

* The Doctor spends the entire episode sympathetic to the Gangers, only to turn around and dissolve Amy's Ganger at the end without a thought, why? The "Rebel Flesh" occurs in the 22nd Century, "A Good Man Goes to War" is set in the ''52nd'' Century, around 3000 years later, on paper the Gangers are an excellent saftey precaution, allowing for a level of flexibility in the field a machine cannot mimic, without the risk, the only issue is that the Flesh retains an imprint of the mind that piloted it, with the possibility of becoming a complete clone of their pilot, and that when they are vacated, they are left to rot. Presumably, rather than totally discontinue it's use, after the events of the former episode, the Flesh was redeveloped to genuinely be what it was believed to be; mindless biomatter that can form a replica of a person remotely operating it. Furthermore when the connection is cut between Amy, and later Melody with their Gangers, the Ganger immediately dissolves back into pure flesh in seconds, not slowly and painfully rotting away. Furthermore,the Doctor mentions wanting to study the Flesh in it's early state as his reason for going to the factory, indicating that the Flesh technology does persist, and in the latter episode, the Doctor refers to the Gangers as "Flesh Avatars", perhaps drawing a line between the primitive Ganger version of the flesh, which retains an imprint, and the more developed Flesh Avatars, that are, as the name suggests, simply an avatar for their controller.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** There's something that's been missed in the above notes: in "The Power of Three", Amy tells the Doctor that she and Rory think it's been ten years since they started traveling with the Doctor, but it's clarified that its only been ten years for them, not the Doctor or the Earth. Amy and Rory have essentially aged ten years in the three years since their wedding. Maybe even before. Amy even pointed out in "A Town Called Mercy" that their friends would notice the Ponds were aging faster than them.

Added: 2063

Changed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The conversation between Cass and Eight:
-->'''The Doctor:''' Well, look on the bright side; I'm not a Dalek!\\
'''Cass:''' [[HeWhoFightsMonsters Who can tell the difference anymore]]?
** What makes this conversation absolutely chilling is how right Cass is. We've seen [[Recap/DoctorWhoS30E12TheStolenEarth Davros]] and [[Recap/DoctorWhoS30E17E18TheEndOfTime Rassilon]] at the height of their power during the Time War. And both Davros and Rassilon have amounted to committing total destruction in order to ensure their victory, regardless of the innocent lives caught in their war. Planet Earth, twice victim to the mechanisms of the Daleks and the Time Lords. Davros saught to use Planet Earth as a machination for the Daleks' Reality Bomb, ensuring the total annihilation of all non-Dalek lifeforms in existence. Rassilon saught to replace Planet Earth with Gallifrey itself, and then saught to ensure the total annihilation of all non-Time Lord lifeforms in existence with. Both Davros and Rassilon saught the advice of [[GoMadFromTheRevelation crazed individuals who saw into the Time Vortex, to better predict the futures of their armies and victories]]. But the scariest bit? [[EvenEvilHasStandards Davros held better standards than Rassilon]]. We've never seen Davros exterminate his own Daleks for holding different opinions, granted he did engineer all Daleks to be [[OmnicidalManiac Omnicidal]] [[ANaziByAnyOtherName Maniacs]]. Yet, Davros has never called for the extermination of any Dalek for failure or disappointment. Any failures the Daleks suffered were due to the Doctor. Contrast, with Rassilon, who [[YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness pretty much erased a Time Lord from existence for simply suggesting a different opinion]]. Davros gave [[BodyHorror every fiber of his cell]] and being to ensure that all Daleks were loyal to him and dedicated in pursuit of their victory against the Time Lords (and every other non-Dalek for that matter). Rassilon was very much concerned with not dying at any costs, removing anyone who got in his way of self-presetvation or injured his Time Lord Ego.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end of [[Recap/DoctorWhoS36E12TheDoctorFalls "The Doctor Falls"]], the Doctor refuses to regenerate because he's feeling the weight of being so many different people. Remember that the existence of the War Doctor bumps the modern Doctors' incarnation counts up a number. [[note]]As an unnumbered Doctor, the true ninth incarnation who underwent the ninth regeneration, his "count" shall we say is War/9/9, Nine is 9/10/10, Ten is 10/11/11 until ''Journey's End'' where he becomes 10/11/12, Eleven is 11/12/13 and Twelve is thus 12/13/14.[[/note]] ''Twelve is the Doctor's thirteenth incarnation;'' of ''course'' he'd rather die than change, he's at the point in a Time Lord's life cycle where they die! Double FridgeBrilliance occurs when you realize that ''this is probably why Time Lords are limited to twelve regenerations in the first place.''

to:

* At the end of [[Recap/DoctorWhoS36E12TheDoctorFalls "The Doctor Falls"]], the Doctor refuses to regenerate because he's feeling the weight of being so many different people. Remember that the existence of the War Doctor bumps the modern Doctors' incarnation counts up a number. [[note]]As an unnumbered Doctor, the true ninth incarnation who underwent the ninth regeneration, his "count" shall we say is War/9/9, Nine is 9/10/10, Ten is 10/11/11 until ''Journey's End'' where he becomes 10/11/12, Eleven is 11/12/13 and Twelve is thus 12/13/14.[[/note]] ''Twelve is the Doctor's thirteenth incarnation;'' of ''course'' he'd rather die than change, he's at the point in a Time Lord's life cycle where they die! Double FridgeBrilliance occurs when you realize that ''this the weight that Twelve feels is probably why ''why'' Time Lords are limited to twelve regenerations in the first place.''
place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end of [[Recap/DoctorWhoS36E12TheDoctorFalls "The Doctor Falls"]], the Doctor refuses to regenerate because he's feeling the weight of being so many different people. Remember that the existence of the War Doctor bumps the modern Doctors' incarnation counts up a number: As an unnumbered Doctor, the true ninth incarnation who underwent the ninth regeneration, his "count" shall we say is War/9/9, meaning Nine is 9/10/10, Ten is 10/11/11 until ''Journey's End'' where he becomes 10/11/12, Eleven is 11/12/13 and Twelve is thus 12/13/14. ''Twelve is the Doctor's thirteenth incarnation;'' of ''course'' he'd rather die than change, he's at the point in a Time Lord's life cycle where they die! Double FridgeBrilliance occurs when you realize that ''this is probably why Time Lords are limited to twelve regenerations in the first place.''

to:

* At the end of [[Recap/DoctorWhoS36E12TheDoctorFalls "The Doctor Falls"]], the Doctor refuses to regenerate because he's feeling the weight of being so many different people. Remember that the existence of the War Doctor bumps the modern Doctors' incarnation counts up a number: As number. [[note]]As an unnumbered Doctor, the true ninth incarnation who underwent the ninth regeneration, his "count" shall we say is War/9/9, meaning Nine is 9/10/10, Ten is 10/11/11 until ''Journey's End'' where he becomes 10/11/12, Eleven is 11/12/13 and Twelve is thus 12/13/14. 12/13/14.[[/note]] ''Twelve is the Doctor's thirteenth incarnation;'' of ''course'' he'd rather die than change, he's at the point in a Time Lord's life cycle where they die! Double FridgeBrilliance occurs when you realize that ''this is probably why Time Lords are limited to twelve regenerations in the first place.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* At the end of [[Recap/DoctorWhoS36E12TheDoctorFalls "The Doctor Falls"]], the Doctor refuses to regenerate because he's feeling the weight of being so many different people. Remember that the existence of the War Doctor bumps the modern Doctors' incarnation counts up a number: As an unnumbered Doctor, the true ninth incarnation who underwent the ninth regeneration, his "count" shall we say is War/9/9, meaning Nine is 9/10/10, Ten is 10/11/11 until ''Journey's End'' where he becomes 10/11/12, Eleven is 11/12/13 and Twelve is thus 12/13/14. ''Twelve is the Doctor's thirteenth incarnation;'' of ''course'' he'd rather die than change, he's at the point in a Time Lord's life cycle where they die! Double FridgeBrilliance occurs when you realize that ''this is probably why Time Lords are limited to twelve regenerations in the first place.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He also can't fix it using regeneration energy because the ''only'' times the Doctor has been seen using regeneration energy to heal ''himself'' was in the early stages of a regeneration. He ''can't'' use regeneration energy to heal himself if he's not actually regenerating. And, given out-of-universe UnfortunateImplications if he deliberately regenerates, or injures himself more to force himself to regenerate, just to deal with his current problem, he's not going to consider his current situation bad enough to regenerate.

to:

** He also can't fix it using regeneration energy because the ''only'' times the Doctor has been seen using regeneration energy to heal ''himself'' was in the early stages of a regeneration. He ''can't'' use regeneration energy to heal himself if he's not actually regenerating. And, given out-of-universe UnfortunateImplications if he deliberately regenerates, or injures himself more to force himself to regenerate, just to deal with his current problem, he's not going to consider his current situation bad enough to regenerate. Not to mention that brain damage is, obviously, no small thing. He could probably summon some regeneration energy to heal a broken bone or something, but given how enormously complex his brain is (as noted above), this isn't something he can just siphon off a little for.

Added: 1437

Changed: 451

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Plus, at this point in her timeline she hasn't married Rory yet (but from a chronological standpoint she already has), so there may be that as well.



** It also makes even more sense when you know why he hates himself, [[spoiler:because of what the War Doctor did,]] or at least what he thought he did.

to:

** It also makes even more sense when you know why he hates himself, [[spoiler:because of what the War Doctor did,]] or at least what he thought he did. On top of that, he's spent centuries having to sacrifice one person to save many, watching people die in his name, doing his best but still not being able to save people, and generally going through trauma after trauma after trauma with very few people he can really confide in. Honestly, it's a bit of a wonder the poor guy's even functional.



** This may or may not cause a plot hole as [[spoiler:the Doctor is already at his last regeneration at this point]] but other species might not know so... [[spoiler: but then again the Daleks already knew somehow in [[Recap/DoctorWho2013CSTheTimeOfTheDoctor "The Time of the Doctor"]].]]

to:

** This may or may not cause a plot hole as [[spoiler:the Doctor is already at his last regeneration at this point]] but other species might not know so... [[spoiler: but then again the Daleks already knew somehow in [[Recap/DoctorWho2013CSTheTimeOfTheDoctor "The Time of the Doctor"]].Doctor"]], though it's possible they found that out from Tasha Lemm, given how close she and the Doctor were.]]



** Alternatively, River is pretending to the Doctor not to recognize Rory to protect the timeline.



** Also, if the Doctor is being imprisoned, he would be desperate to escape, but might believe until it's too late that there's some way out. If he's about to be killed, he'll be very desperate with nothing to lose. And a very desperate Doctor with nothing to lose... The Daleks, at least, who know the Doctor very, very well, are '''smart''' enough not to put him in that corner.



** Unless the words were actually written in English, an obscure language to most of the universe, but one the Doctor and Amy are both naturally fluent in (so the TARDIS only needs to translate the coordinates).



* When River first meets the Doctor, ''she's'' in a body he's never seen her in before, and knows nothing about him. When the Doctor first meets River, ''he's'' in a body she's never seen him in before, and knows nothing about her.

to:

* When River first meets the Doctor, ''she's'' ''sh e's'' in a body he's never seen her in before, and knows nothing about him. When the Doctor first meets River, ''he's'' in a body she's never seen him in before, and knows nothing about her.



* This story doesn't show the Blinovitch Limitation Effect when young! and old! Kazran touch each other. Given that the Doctor deliberately brought young Kazran forward in time to meet his future self, he most likely set up some form of protection, either using the TARDIS or some piece of tech hidden on young Kazran, to stop that eventuality (last thing he needs at this point is to deal with that on top of everything else).



** ''Or'' it's the number of people who have been eaten by the crack.

to:

** ''Or'' ''And/or'' it's the number of people who have been eaten by the crack.


Added DiffLines:

** Rory's heart and soul, as all but spelled out in the next season, are what attracted Amy to him in the first place. Of course that would be uppermost in her mind.

Added: 539

Changed: 490

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also (spoilers for Series 6), [[spoiler: the fact that it's River piloting the Tardis is significant. The Doctor had previously seen 26 June, 2010 as the date of the temporal event that destroys the universe. But the significance of this date isn't just about the Tardis exploding -- it's about River's existence. River is the only other person who can pilot the Tardis, because she was conceived in the Tardis on what date? 26 June, 2010: Her parents' wedding night.]]

to:

** Also (spoilers for Series 6), [[spoiler: the fact that it's River piloting the Tardis is significant. The Doctor had previously seen 26 June, 2010 as the date of the temporal event that destroys the universe. But the significance of this date isn't just about the Tardis exploding -- it's about River's existence. River is the only other person who can pilot the Tardis, because she was conceived in the Tardis on what date? 26 June, 2010: Her parents' wedding night.]]




* FridgeBrilliance: How did the Silence cause the TARDIS to explode in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E12ThePandoricaOpens "The Pandorica Opens"]]? Because ''River'' was inside the TARDIS at the time of the explosion and since she was raised by them to be a ManchurianAgent, she was likely compelled to destroy the TARDIS against her will. Hence the reason she uttered the words:

to:

* FridgeBrilliance: How did the Silence cause the TARDIS to explode in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E12ThePandoricaOpens "The Pandorica Opens"]]? Because ''River'' was inside the TARDIS at the time of the explosion and since she was raised by them to be a ManchurianAgent, she was likely compelled to destroy the TARDIS against her will. Hence the reason she uttered the words:


Added DiffLines:

** Also the fact that it's River piloting the Tardis is significant. In Series 5, the Doctor had previously seen June 26, 2010 as the date of the temporal event that destroys the universe. This temporal event ends up being the Tardis exploding. But the significance of this date isn't just about the Tardis exploding -- it's about River's existence. [[spoiler: River is the only other person who can pilot the Tardis, because she was conceived in the Tardis. And on what date was she conceived? June 26, 2010: Her parents' wedding night.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Also (spoilers for Series 6), [[spoiler: the fact that it's River piloting the Tardis is significant. The Doctor had previously seen 26 June, 2010 as the date of the temporal event that destroys the universe. But the significance of this date isn't just about the Tardis exploding -- it's about River's existence. River is the only other person who can pilot the Tardis, because she was conceived in the Tardis on what date? 26 June, 2010: Her parents' wedding night.]]

Added: 1118

Changed: 932

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The first Clara echo is said to be the one who told the Doctor to steal the TARDIS we all know and love. Why did the Great Intelligence not go back before that and try to kill the Doctor as a child? Other stories have implied that he didn't run away until he was in his 200s or so. That's a heck of a big window. ''However,'' for most if not all of that time he was on Gallifrey, pretty much at its height, surrounded by Time Lords. Much, much easier to try and kill the Doctor subtly once he's gone jetting off around the universe already getting into danger with only a human or two for company and protection.
** The Intelligence may well be worried that if the Time Lords catch even one fragment of it, they'll wipe it from time entirely as they did with the War Lord.
** There's also the possibility, as raised above, that Clara's echoes help the Doctor with other, non-related GI problems, such as getting him to steal that particular TARDIS, perhaps guiding other companions to him at the right point, assisting against other monsters, etc.



** Even worse: The Sisterhood are implied to have at least some precognitive ability. They may well have ''deliberately'' crashed that ship and murdered Cass in order to guilt trip/beg the Doctor to save the universe.



* In regards to how "The Day of the Doctor" ended: [[spoiler:Anyone start to feel that Moffat has been foreshadowing the true fate of Gallifrey since [[Recap/DoctorWhoS30E8SilenceInTheLibrary "Silence in the Library"]]? Not to mention a curt reminder of the same idea with the missed moment of awesome with the door dilemma. If the Doctor DID have all that time to think about it, why wouldn't he find the means to save Gallifrey.]]

to:

* In regards to how "The Day of the Doctor" ended: [[spoiler:Anyone start to feel that Moffat has been foreshadowing the true fate of Gallifrey since [[Recap/DoctorWhoS30E8SilenceInTheLibrary "Silence in the Library"]]? Not to mention a curt reminder of the same idea with the missed moment of awesome with the door dilemma. If the Doctor DID have all that time to think about it, why wouldn't he find the means to save Gallifrey.]]Gallifrey?]]



* The insane amount of Daleks that escaped from the Time War makes a lot more sense when you know that they were just blasted by their own crossfire instead of [[DeaderThanDead sealed in a Time Lock]].

to:

* The insane amount of Daleks that escaped from the Time War makes a lot more sense when you know that they were just blasted by their own crossfire instead of [[DeaderThanDead sealed in a Time Lock]].wiped out by the Moment]].



* It looks like the Twelfth (13th?) Doctor turning up to assist Gallifrey has put the Timelords into a situation where they have no choice but to help The Doctor if (as seems likely) he’s run out of regenerations. They can count and they know how many turned up in order to save them all.

to:

* It looks like the Twelfth (13th?) Doctor turning up to assist Gallifrey has put the Timelords Time Lords into a situation where they have no choice but to help The Doctor if (as seems likely) he’s run out of regenerations. They can count and they know how many turned up in order to save them all.



** As is later said: "The first thing you notice about the Doctor of War is that he's unarmed. For many, it's also the last."



** In addition, in "Let's Kill Hitler", the TARDIS voice interface says, "Regeneration disabled." It wasn't because of the poison, it was because despite the Doctor's (willful?) ignorance: the TARDIS knew he couldn't regenerate again. If he tried, he might have ended up like the Master did in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS14E3TheDeadlyAssassin "The Deadly Assassin"]]. Indeed, all the various things that would kill Eleven without regeneration all make sense in the context of Eleven being the last one of that cycle.

to:

** In addition, in "Let's Kill Hitler", the TARDIS voice interface says, "Regeneration disabled." It wasn't because of the poison, it was because despite the Doctor's (willful?) ignorance: the TARDIS knew he couldn't regenerate again. If he tried, he might have ended up like the Master did in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS14E3TheDeadlyAssassin "The Deadly Assassin"]]. Indeed, all the various things that would kill Eleven without regeneration all make sense in the context of Eleven being the last one of that cycle. Also, the Doctor would most likely rather hear that his regenerations are disabled rather than be reminded that he's going to die relatively soon anyway.



* When Eleven admits he'd shaved his head because he was bored, Clara asks if that's what happened to his eyebrows too, and Eleven defensively replies that they're just ''delicate''. [[Creator/PeterCapaldi That's not something he'll have to be touchy about for much longer.]]

to:

* When Eleven admits he'd shaved his head because he was bored, Clara asks if that's what happened to his eyebrows too, and Eleven defensively replies that they're just ''delicate''. [[Creator/PeterCapaldi That's not something he'll have to be touchy about for much longer.]]
]] In fact, if the theory about a regeneration's appearance being chosen subconsciously is true, this may even have been deliberate!



* The Doctor doesn't see any purpose for an entire room for not being awake in, because (according to the Expanded Universe) Time Lords only sleep for about an hour or so. Meaning that whereas humans need 8 or so hours and need a room specifically to house them, Time Lord's can likely just find a chair to nod off in for an hour.

to:

* The Doctor doesn't see any purpose for an entire room for not being awake in, because (according to the Expanded Universe) Time Lords only sleep for about an hour or so. Meaning that whereas humans need 8 or so hours and need a room specifically to house them, Time Lord's Lords can likely just find a chair to nod off in for an hour.


Added DiffLines:

** Also, the reason the glitch happened is that they were programmed to repair their ship with "any materials necessary." Clearly, whoever programmed them hadn't heard of Asimov's Laws of Robotics.


Added DiffLines:

** She could also be his daughter, sister, wife, Susan, or Romana, any of whom would also have a strong connection to the Doctor's timeline.

Added: 4

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The contempt shown to Danny Pink due to his former career as a soldier by both his class and by Clara (and his own resigned acceptance of it) may seem exceptionally dickish, until one remembers that in the Whoniverse, the events of ''[[Recap/TorchwoodS3MSChildrenOfEarth Torchwood: Children of Earth]]'' (in which the military publicly attempted to violently round up millions of children for a very obviously horrible fate) and their impotence in the face of a good dozen or so very public alien incursions over the past decade likely sapped their public image enormously. Considering that some of the children the army attempted to take to the 456 would have been around 9/10 at the time (''Children of Earth'' was set in 2009), and the current Whoniverse year is 2014 ''at the earliest'', as well as the fact that Shoreditch (where Coal Hill School is located) is an inner-city/working class area of London, so may have been selected for the government's KillThePoor solution. It is entirely possible that some of the teenagers in Coal Hill School may have been rounded up for the 456. This would explain their dislike for soldiers.

to:

* The contempt shown to Danny Pink due to his former career as a soldier by both his class and by Clara (and his own resigned acceptance of it) may seem exceptionally dickish, until one remembers that in the Whoniverse, the events of ''[[Recap/TorchwoodS3MSChildrenOfEarth ''[[Series/TorchwoodChildrenOfEarth Torchwood: Children of Earth]]'' (in which the military publicly attempted to violently round up millions of children for a very obviously horrible fate) and their impotence in the face of a good dozen or so very public alien incursions over the past decade likely sapped their public image enormously. Considering that some of the children the army attempted to take to the 456 would have been around 9/10 at the time (''Children of Earth'' was set in 2009), and the current Whoniverse year is 2014 ''at the earliest'', as well as the fact that Shoreditch (where Coal Hill School is located) is an inner-city/working class area of London, so may have been selected for the government's KillThePoor solution. It is entirely possible that some of the teenagers in Coal Hill School may have been rounded up for the 456. This would explain their dislike for soldiers.



[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]][[/folder]]

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The same story has the TARDIS essentially steer herself to pre-Time War Gallifrey. How is this possible, when Gallifrey is time-locked? Well, one possibility is that just the War period itself is sealed away. However, this also raises the possibility that the TARDIS, being the super-amazing advanced piece of technology she is, ''can'' pierce the time lock; the Doctor just chooses not to because it would be too painful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The First Doctor is criticized for being extremely out of character, being a chariceture of who the character was and England as a whole was during the 1960s. But consider that the First Doctor was undergoing regeneration for the first time. Delaying a regeneration has never really turned out to be a good thing for Time Lords, especially for the Doctor. There's a good chance that the First Doctor was mentally relapsing as he was fighting off the natural regeneration process. The Twelfth Doctor did a bit of this as well during [[Recap/DoctorWhoS36E12TheDoctorFalls "The Doctor Falls"]] where he goes through flash imitations of his past incarnations before completely stopping the regeneration process. The reason why the Twelfth Doctor doesn't extremely relapse as bad as the First Doctor is due to the fact that Twelve has had a full regeneration cycle to get used to the process. One is about to start and he's extremely terrified. Add in the fact that his future self has completely different sensibilities and fashion choices, and again with the First Doctor being written as a representation of England during the early 1960s and the Twelfth Doctor being a byproduct of the late 2010s, it's not hard to imagine why the First Doctor acted the way he did. [[TheFutureIsShocking He really didn't want to go]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Oswin's name makes sense, since that was Modern Day Clara's username in The Bells of Saint John, as throughout the episode she talks to everyone via technology rather than face to face.

to:

* ** Oswin's name makes sense, since that was Modern Day Clara's username in The Bells of Saint John, as throughout the episode she talks to everyone via technology rather than face to face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Oswin's name makes sense, since that was Modern Day Clara's username in The Bells of Saint John, as throughout the episode she talks to everyone via technology rather than face to face.
Tabs MOD

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kill Em All was renamed Everybody Dies Ending due to misuse. Dewicking


* One from Series Five here. It seemed a bit weird that the Daleks believe that the Doctor would cause the cracks in the fabric of reality by destroying the TARDIS. But in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E3VictoryOfTheDaleks "Victory of the Daleks"]], he threatens to take them out with the self-destruct button. It makes a lot more sense now. Not to mention how he [[KillEmAll ended the Time War]]. They probably believe him capable of anything.

to:

* One from Series Five here. It seemed a bit weird that the Daleks believe that the Doctor would cause the cracks in the fabric of reality by destroying the TARDIS. But in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E3VictoryOfTheDaleks "Victory of the Daleks"]], he threatens to take them out with the self-destruct button. It makes a lot more sense now. Not to mention how he [[KillEmAll ended the Time War]].War. They probably believe him capable of anything.



* In [[Recap/DoctorWhoS34E2IntoTheDalek "Into the Dalek"]], it looks like [[spoiler:the Dalek has merely changed its position from "destroy all living things" to "destroy all Daleks", not learning from its new ability to conceptualize and appreciate the beauty of life. However, note the Doctor's own words when he melded his mind with the Dalek's: he said he was now "a part of [the Dalek]" — not to explain that they are melding minds, but that the Dalek adopt the Doctor's own core beliefs into its moral compass. The Doctor believed it would adopt his ability to appreciate beauty in life, along with his desire to protect it. He thought the Dalek only saw his hatred and took from that instead. But it's not hard to see the parallels between this "good" Dalek and the Doctor: both turned against their own kind; both attempted to (initially for the Doctor) kill their whole kind. The Doctor turned against the Time Lords because they went against his beliefs — his doctrine concerning the universe, and that they became the very monsters that they opposed — the same, if not ''worse'', than a Dalek. Now the Dalek believes in this concept too: it doesn't seek out the Daleks to KillEmAll because it ''has'' to, it seeks them out because it believes the Doctor once turned against his people for disagreeing with him. The "good" Dalek has adopted the Doctor's doctrine now, too, and if the Doctor turned against his own people to protect it, so too must the Dalek. And recall, a part of that doctrine is how the Time Lords had become ''just'' like the Daleks. Suddenly it's less [[GoneHorriblyWrong "destroy all Daleks" because it can only destroy]]; the "good" Dalek ''has'' to [[GoneHorriblyRight destroy all Daleks because they]] ''[[GoneHorriblyRight must]]'' [[GoneHorriblyRight be destroyed]].]]

to:

* In [[Recap/DoctorWhoS34E2IntoTheDalek "Into the Dalek"]], it looks like [[spoiler:the Dalek has merely changed its position from "destroy all living things" to "destroy all Daleks", not learning from its new ability to conceptualize and appreciate the beauty of life. However, note the Doctor's own words when he melded his mind with the Dalek's: he said he was now "a part of [the Dalek]" — not to explain that they are melding minds, but that the Dalek adopt the Doctor's own core beliefs into its moral compass. The Doctor believed it would adopt his ability to appreciate beauty in life, along with his desire to protect it. He thought the Dalek only saw his hatred and took from that instead. But it's not hard to see the parallels between this "good" Dalek and the Doctor: both turned against their own kind; both attempted to (initially for the Doctor) kill their whole kind. The Doctor turned against the Time Lords because they went against his beliefs — his doctrine concerning the universe, and that they became the very monsters that they opposed — the same, if not ''worse'', than a Dalek. Now the Dalek believes in this concept too: it doesn't seek out the Daleks to KillEmAll kill them because it ''has'' to, it seeks them out because it believes the Doctor once turned against his people for disagreeing with him. The "good" Dalek has adopted the Doctor's doctrine now, too, and if the Doctor turned against his own people to protect it, so too must the Dalek. And recall, a part of that doctrine is how the Time Lords had become ''just'' like the Daleks. Suddenly it's less [[GoneHorriblyWrong "destroy all Daleks" because it can only destroy]]; the "good" Dalek ''has'' to [[GoneHorriblyRight destroy all Daleks because they]] ''[[GoneHorriblyRight must]]'' [[GoneHorriblyRight be destroyed]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Clara's belief that something has gone wrong with the Doctor's regeneration makes perfect sense given her experiences with other versions of the Doctor. She met War and Ten, and traveled with Eleven, and then watched Eleven age from being physically around his twenties to being physically an old man. She would naturally believe that a regeneration starts young and then ages over time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** River's scanner wotsit doesn't show any life signs when she uses it to scan the Doctor's corpse. Of course not; [[spoiler: she's scanning a ''robot.'' It wouldn't have any life signs to show!]]


Added DiffLines:

* [[Recap/DoctorWhoS32E1TheImpossibleAstronaut "The Impossible Astronaut"]]: River shooting at the astronaut is absolutely full of this. [[spoiler: If she remembered who was in that suit, she's ''essentially trying to commit suicide to avenge the man she loves.'']] If she doesn't remember, and if the bullets had managed to penetrate the suit and kill the inhabitant at that point in their timestream...
** Of course, the other possibility is that she does recognize the suit and knows perfectly well that the bullets wouldn't work, and she was just wasting bullets to stay in-character.


Added DiffLines:

*** Hopefully, once the little girl escaped, the Silence would forget about him (what with being busy running and hiding from the rest of humanity) and he'd be able to leave.

Added: 434

Changed: 627

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
We see him in the corridor in the eye, so he couldn't have been in the control room running it.


** It's also foreshadowing for the next season, where the Daleks understanding the concept of mercy is very important.



* There's no sign of the Blinovitch Limitation Effect, despite young Amelia interacting with older Amy. This makes sense for two reasons: First of all, the whole universe is going to pot, so the usual temporal laws are out the window. The second reason is that ''Amy comes from an entirely different timestream''.



** Alternative-alternative explanation: the Doctor's letting himself go. He's at the pinnacle of self-loathing: here he is, in a point where his death is closing in upon him, and he knows that in the end when the plan comes through, he's going to make the people he cares about the most — his companions — feel sad, lonely, and hollow because they think he died. There's also a high chance he is piloting the ''Teselecta'' alone, as it manages to capture his very essence throughout the episode (think about it: it's a bit of a hassle for the Doctor to have to relay to the crew "okay, do this with the arms, and make it swivel like that" while running his MotorMouth and dealing with whatever it is he should be doing). There are a lot of things he'd have to manage on his own, being the self-loathing Doctor that he is, personal hygiene isn't really that high up on his list. After all, he's a dead man walking.
*** [[OverlyLongGag Alternative-alternative-alternative]] explanation: The Teselecta are running the robot, and studied him well enough that they can imitate his mannerisms while he stays in the cockpit and does the talking.

to:

** Alternative-alternative explanation: the Doctor's letting himself go. He's at the pinnacle of self-loathing: here he is, in a point where his death is closing in upon him, and he knows that in the end when the plan comes through, he's going to make the people he cares about the most — his companions — feel sad, lonely, and hollow because they think he died. There's also a high chance he is piloting the ''Teselecta'' alone, as it manages to capture his very essence throughout the episode (think about it: it's a bit of a hassle for the Doctor to have to relay to the crew "okay, do this with the arms, and make it swivel like that" while running his MotorMouth and dealing with whatever it is he should be doing). There are a lot of things he'd have to manage on his own, being Being the self-loathing Doctor that he is, personal hygiene isn't really that high up on his list. After all, he's a dead man walking.
*** [[OverlyLongGag Alternative-alternative-alternative]] explanation: Beards are cool. The Teselecta are running Doctor wanted to try out a beard; it's not a difficulty for the robot, and studied him well enough that they can imitate his mannerisms while he stays in the cockpit and does the talking. Teselecta, so why not?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In this episode, Rory chews out the Doctor for not doing his research. However, as other stories such as "The Fires of Pompeii" and "The Angels Take Manhattan" show, not doing his research ''is actually very clever.'' Once an event has been recorded and the Doctor's seen it, such as with Amy and Rory's grave, it's (pun intended) set in stone, and he has to make sure the timeline (appears to) stay fixed to that course. By not knowing too much about any particular time period or place, the Doctor leaves themself more room to help others and make small changes to the timeline.

Top