Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Windtalkers

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnyoneCanDie: It's UsefulNotes/WorldWarII in the Pacific, so this is to be expected. By the end of the film, [[spoiler: only Chick, Yahzee, and Pappas are left of the original squad, and even Pappas dies in the tie-in novelization.]]

to:

* AnyoneCanDie: It's UsefulNotes/WorldWarII in the Pacific, so this is to be expected. By the end of the film, [[spoiler: only Chick, Yahzee, and Pappas are left of the original squad, and even Pappas dies gets a DeathByAdaptation in the tie-in novelization.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnyoneCanDie: It's UsefulNotes/WorldWarII in the Pacific, so this is to be expected. By the end of the film, [[spoiler: only Chick, Yahzee, and Pappas are left of the original squad.]]

to:

* AnyoneCanDie: It's UsefulNotes/WorldWarII in the Pacific, so this is to be expected. By the end of the film, [[spoiler: only Chick, Yahzee, and Pappas are left of the original squad.squad, and even Pappas dies in the tie-in novelization.]]

Added: 58

Changed: 624

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changed names to surnames for consistency


Joe Enders (Creator/NicolasCage) is given the job of protecting a Navajo code talker named Ben (Creator/AdamBeach). Because the code must not be broken, Joe's orders are to kill Ben should he fall into enemy hands. The movie mostly follows the Battle of Saipan.

to:

Joe Enders (Creator/NicolasCage) is given the job of protecting a Navajo code talker named Ben Yahzee (Creator/AdamBeach). Because the code must not be broken, Joe's Enders' orders are to kill Ben Yahzee should he fall into enemy hands. The movie mostly follows the Battle of Saipan.



* ActionFilmQuietDramaScene: Between battles, there's one scene where Charlie and his bodyguard Ox (who has secretly been ordered to kill him if he's at risk of being captured) bond while playing a musical duet with Ox's harmonica and Charlie's flute.
* ActionPrologue: Joe's first scene in the Solomons in 1943.
* AnyoneCanDie: It's UsefulNotes/WorldWarII in the Pacific, so this is to be expected. By the end of the film, [[spoiler: only Chick, Ben, and Pappas are left of the original squad.]]
* AxCrazy: Joe turns into a real demon of war during combat, just looking for more kills to score. Later, after [[spoiler: Whitehorse is killed]], Yahzee takes the role of ax-crazy soldier.

to:

* ActionFilmQuietDramaScene: Between battles, there's one scene where Charlie Whitehorse and his bodyguard Ox (who has secretly been ordered to kill him if he's at risk of being captured) bond while playing a musical duet with Ox's harmonica and Charlie's Whitehorse's flute.
* ActionPrologue: Joe's Enders' first scene in the Solomons in 1943.
* AnyoneCanDie: It's UsefulNotes/WorldWarII in the Pacific, so this is to be expected. By the end of the film, [[spoiler: only Chick, Ben, Yahzee, and Pappas are left of the original squad.]]
* AxCrazy: Joe Enders turns into a real demon of war during combat, just looking for more kills to score. Later, after [[spoiler: Whitehorse is killed]], Yahzee takes the role of the ax-crazy soldier.



* BerserkButton: As expected, Ben didn't take TheReveal about Joe's orders mildly.

to:

* BerserkButton: As expected, Ben Yahzee didn't take TheReveal about Joe's Enders' orders mildly.



* BloodFromTheMouth: [[spoiler: Joe]], to indicate that he's [[KilledOffForReal really dying]].

to:

* BloodFromTheMouth: [[spoiler: Joe]], Enders]], to indicate that he's [[KilledOffForReal really dying]].



** Joe enjoys killing the Japs a little too much after being the SoleSurvivor of the Solomon Islands campaign. There's actually a close-up of a CheshireCatGrin on his face as he gleefully mows down half a dozen Japs with his Tommy-gun in one scene.
** [[spoiler:Ben becomes one following Charlie's death. And, like Joe before him, slaughters any Japanese soldier he comes across.]]
* BottomlessMagazines: Reloading? In a John Woo movie? You're kidding, right? This trope is going to absurd levels with Joe's Thompson. Even if he's the only character ever seen reloading, his mags holds a few times more than they should.
** That said, it is averted mostly. While Joe's got a Thompson with magic mags, his squadmates are not so lucky as they frequently either run low or out of ammo in firefights.

to:

** Joe Enders enjoys killing the Japs Japanese a little too much after being the SoleSurvivor of the Solomon Islands campaign. There's actually a close-up of a CheshireCatGrin on his face as he gleefully mows down half a dozen Japs Japanese with his Tommy-gun in one scene.
** [[spoiler:Ben [[spoiler:Yahzee becomes one following Charlie's Whitehorse's death. And, like Joe Enders before him, slaughters any Japanese soldier he comes across.]]
* BottomlessMagazines: Reloading? In a John Woo movie? You're kidding, right? This trope is going to absurd levels with Joe's Enders' Thompson. Even if he's the only character ever seen reloading, his mags holds a few times more than they should.
** That said, it is averted mostly. While Joe's Enders got a Thompson with magic mags, his squadmates are not so lucky as they frequently either run low or out of ammo in firefights.



** Later in the film Ben mocks his own words toward Joe. First time, he assured Joe that following orders is the most important thing to do, even more important than saving your friends. But when he learns that Joe is ordered to kill him in case of risking capture, [[{{Hypocrite}} he berates him for mindlessly following orders]].

to:

** Later in the film Ben Yahzee mocks his own words toward Joe. Enders. First time, he assured Joe assures Enders that following orders is the most important thing to do, even more important than saving your friends. But when he learns that Joe Enders is ordered to kill him in case of risking capture, [[{{Hypocrite}} he berates him for mindlessly following orders]].



** Ben goes from a TechnicalPacifist radioman, to an AxCrazy [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge revenge-driven]] BloodKnight [[spoiler: following Whitehorse's death at the hands of Joe and the Japanese]], to having a HeelRealization [[spoiler: upon accidentally slashing Joe.]]
** Chick starts out as a racist {{Jerkass}}, but after Whitehorse saves his life during a Japanese attack, he mellows out and becomes much nicer to Ben, to the point he risks his life to save him.
** Joe himself starts off as a ShellShockedVeteran with AxCrazy tendencies, to slowly mellowing up towards Ben, ending with him [[spoiler: [[RedemptionEqualsDeath dying to help protect Ben and the other Marines under fire.]] ]]
* CommunicationsOfficer: Pretty much the role of all the code-talkers such as Ben and Whitehorse.
* ConflictBall: The Windtalkers knew how important they were - so much so that they needed a babysitter to keep them safe - but Ben is ''shocked'' that among Joe's orders are ones to kill him should he fall into enemy hands.
* DeathByRacism [[spoiler: Subverted with Chick, who makes it to the end with [[NiceGuy nice guys]] Ben and Pappas. [[CharacterDevelopment He’s definitely improved by the end of the film, though.]]]]

to:

** Ben Yahzee goes from a TechnicalPacifist radioman, to an AxCrazy [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge revenge-driven]] BloodKnight [[spoiler: following Whitehorse's death at the hands of Joe Enders and the Japanese]], to having a HeelRealization [[spoiler: upon accidentally slashing Joe.Enders.]]
** Chick starts out as a racist {{Jerkass}}, but after Whitehorse saves his life during a Japanese attack, he mellows out and becomes much nicer to Ben, Yahzee, to the point he risks his life to save him.
** Joe Enders himself starts off as a ShellShockedVeteran with AxCrazy tendencies, to slowly mellowing up towards Ben, Yahzee, ending with him [[spoiler: [[RedemptionEqualsDeath dying to help protect Ben Yahzee and the other Marines under fire.]] ]]
* CommunicationsOfficer: Pretty much the role of all the code-talkers such as Ben Yahzee and Whitehorse.
* ConflictBall: The Windtalkers knew how important they were - so much so that they needed a babysitter to keep them safe - but Ben Yahzee is ''shocked'' that among Joe's Enders' orders are ones to kill him should he fall into enemy hands.
* DeathByRacism [[spoiler: Subverted with Chick, who makes it to the end with [[NiceGuy nice guys]] Ben Yahzee and Pappas. [[CharacterDevelopment He’s definitely improved by the end of the film, though.]]]]



* DeathSeeker: Joe was the last man standing after his unit got slaughtered, because he insisted that they must obey their orders and hold their ground. It's haunted him ever since, to the point where he's one step from being outright suicidal.
* {{Determinator}}: Joe. Give him an order. He will do '''anything''' to fulfill it.
* DressingAsTheEnemy: Ben comes up with a way to take out an entrenched Japanese unit through infiltration by putting on a Japanese uniform himself and making his superior Joe look like a captured enemy. The subterfuge is made possible on account of Ben's tanner skin color and non-white features as a Navajo native, which Joe had earlier noted might cause others in the field to mistake him for a Japanese soldier. He really doesn’t look Japanese, which is why Joe also smears Ben’s face with dirt, [[BavarianFireDrill hoping that a guy who’s not white in a Japanese uniform will fool the enemy just long enough to get to the radio.]]

to:

* DeathSeeker: Joe Enders was the last man standing after his unit got slaughtered, because he insisted that they must obey their orders and hold their ground. It's haunted him ever since, to the point where he's one step from being outright suicidal.
* {{Determinator}}: Joe.Enders. Give him an order. He will do '''anything''' to fulfill it.
* DressingAsTheEnemy: Ben Yahzee comes up with a way to take out an entrenched Japanese unit through infiltration by putting on a Japanese uniform himself and making his superior Joe Enders look like a captured enemy. The subterfuge is made possible on account of Ben's Yahzee's tanner skin color and non-white features as a Navajo native, which Joe Enders had earlier noted might cause others in the field to mistake him for a Japanese soldier. He really doesn’t look Japanese, which is why Joe Enders also smears Ben’s Yahzee’s face with dirt, [[BavarianFireDrill hoping that a guy who’s not white in a Japanese uniform will fool the enemy just long enough to get to the radio.]]



* FatBestFriend: ''Fat'' might be a strong word, but Charlei is noticeably stouter than his best friend Ben (who plays a bigger role).

to:

* FatBestFriend: ''Fat'' might be a strong word, but Charlei Whitehorse is noticeably stouter than his best friend Ben Yahzee (who plays a bigger role).



* FlamethrowerBackfire: The film does this to [[spoiler:Harrigan]]
* {{Foil}}: Ox and Charlie to Ben and Joe. The two develop a genuine friendship, and display more loyalty to each other. While Joe is willing to follow their orders to kill the code talkers if necessary, Ox is unable to do so when the moment arrives, and is justified by him and Charlie managing to fight off their attackers [[spoiler: unforuatley, it's only a brief HopeSpot]].
* GenreBlind: Ben, regarding Joe's orders again.
* HiddenDepths: Joe. Sure, he is a killing machine with ''serious'' problems, but outside the battlefield he's really a nice guy. Even toward nominal enemies, as shown with the sick kid to whom he gave his pain-killers.

to:

* FlamethrowerBackfire: The film does this to [[spoiler:Harrigan]]
[[spoiler:Harrigan]].
* {{Foil}}: Ox and Charlie Whitehorse to Ben Yahzee and Joe.Enders. The two develop a genuine friendship, and display more loyalty to each other. While Joe Enders is willing to follow their orders to kill the code talkers if necessary, Ox is unable to do so when the moment arrives, and is justified by him and Charlie Whitehorse managing to fight off their attackers [[spoiler: unforuatley, unfortunately, it's only a brief HopeSpot]].
* GenreBlind: Ben, Yahzee, regarding Joe's Enders' orders again.
* HiddenDepths: Joe.Enders. Sure, he is a killing machine with ''serious'' problems, but outside the battlefield he's really a nice guy. Even toward nominal enemies, as shown with the sick kid to whom he gave his pain-killers.



* HoldTheLine: Joe's unit in the Solomons at the beginning of the film is assigned this mission. Unfortunately, they soon become outnumbered and outgunned by the Japanese, and are wiped out as a result.

to:

* HoldTheLine: Joe's Enders' unit in the Solomons at the beginning of the film is assigned this mission. Unfortunately, they soon become outnumbered and outgunned by the Japanese, and are wiped out as a result.



* ItHasBeenAnHonor: Ben and Joe toward each other at the end.
* ImprobableAimingSkills: Joe. If the Thompson submachine gun was half as accurate as it's shown in his hands, it would have been the ultimate weapon of [=WWII=], especially with his [[BottomlessMagazines 30-round mags that are evidently packed with 200+ rounds each]].
** The Thompson actually ''is'' a very accurate weapon...when fired semiauto. Joe’s long bursts would put one hole in the target and fifteen more...somewhere far, far away.

to:

* ItHasBeenAnHonor: Ben Yahzee and Joe Enders toward each other at the end.
* ImprobableAimingSkills: Joe.Enders. If the Thompson submachine gun was half as accurate as it's shown in his hands, it would have been the ultimate weapon of [=WWII=], especially with his [[BottomlessMagazines 30-round mags that are evidently packed with 200+ rounds each]].
** The Thompson actually ''is'' a very accurate weapon...when fired semiauto. Joe’s Enders' long bursts would put one hole in the target and fifteen more...somewhere far, far away.



* ManlyTears: Joe cries during his NotSoStoic moments.
* MercyKill: Joe has orders to do this if his windtalker should fall into enemy hands, to both save the man from torture and protect the code.

to:

* ManlyTears: Joe Enders cries during his NotSoStoic moments.
* MercyKill: Joe Enders has orders to do this if his windtalker should fall into enemy hands, to both save the man from torture and protect the code.



* NaiveNewcomer: Both Ben and Whitehorse. They not only have no idea into what kind of hell they getting themselves, but are also completely unprepared for racial ostracization by fellow soldiers.
* NeverTrustATitle: Joe is the center of attention and the protagonist in the movie, the windtalkers are... there.

to:

* NaiveNewcomer: Both Ben Yahzee and Whitehorse. They not only have no idea into what kind of hell they getting themselves, but are also completely unprepared for racial ostracization by fellow soldiers.
* NeverTrustATitle: Joe Enders is the center of attention and the protagonist in the movie, the windtalkers are... there.



* OneManArmy: Joe, combining this with DoAnythingSoldier. While [[HandicappedBadass being deaf in one ear]] and living under the heavy burden of SurvivorGuilt, he is still capable of taking down dozens of enemies alone. Heck, he got ''two'' Silver Stars for his insane fighting skills and determination. Somewhat justified, as he’s a DeathSeeker who takes insane risks that ''should'' get him killed.

to:

* OneManArmy: Joe, Enders, combining this with DoAnythingSoldier. While [[HandicappedBadass being deaf in one ear]] and living under the heavy burden of SurvivorGuilt, he is still capable of taking down dozens of enemies alone. Heck, he got ''two'' Silver Stars for his insane fighting skills and determination. Somewhat justified, as he’s a DeathSeeker who takes insane risks that ''should'' get him killed.



* RecklessSidekick: During their last fight Ben is so enraged that he basically endangers his whole squad by going berserk.

to:

* RecklessSidekick: During their last fight Ben Yahzee is so enraged that he basically endangers his whole squad by going berserk.



* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: Joe finds he is unable to perform his vital duty of killing his partner if it came down to it, so he goes to his commanding officer and requests an official transfer to another unit. Because of the village attack soon after, he stays on.
* SecretlyWealthy: Charlie dresses and behaves fairly modestly, but Ben says that his family owns one of the biggest flocks of sheep in the Four Corners.
* ShellShockedVeteran: Joe's last battle deeply messed with his mind.
* ShovelStrike: Ben is using an entrenching shovel to defend himself during the final battle.

to:

* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: Joe Enders finds he is unable to perform his vital duty of killing his partner if it came down to it, so he goes to his commanding officer and requests an official transfer to another unit. Because of the village attack soon after, he stays on.
* SecretlyWealthy: Charlie Whitehorse dresses and behaves fairly modestly, but Ben Yahzee says that his family owns one of the biggest flocks of sheep in the Four Corners.
* ShellShockedVeteran: Joe's Enders' last battle deeply messed with his mind.
* ShovelStrike: Ben Yahzee is using an entrenching shovel to defend himself during the final battle.



* SlashedThroat: Whitehorse and Yahzee, who uses Bowie knives as their backup weapons, disposes many Japanese soldiers using this method. And then there's a MexicanStandoff between Yahzee and a Japanese soldier, who's interrupted by Joe sneaking up behind the Jap and slicing his throat.

to:

* SlashedThroat: Whitehorse and Yahzee, who uses Bowie knives as their backup weapons, disposes many Japanese soldiers using this method. And then there's a MexicanStandoff between Yahzee and a Japanese soldier, who's interrupted by Joe Enders sneaking up behind the Jap enemy and slicing his throat.



* SurvivorsGuilt: Joe suffers from this due to being the SoleSurvivor of his squad in the battle on the Solomon Islands.
* TakeAThirdOption: When Joe can either fight the Japanese or kill Ben to keep the code secured, [[NoOneGetsLeftBehind he choose to take him on his back and run for safety]].

to:

* SurvivorsGuilt: Joe Enders suffers from this due to being the SoleSurvivor of his squad in the battle on the Solomon Islands.
* TakeAThirdOption: When Joe Enders can either fight the Japanese or kill Ben Yahzee to keep the code secured, [[NoOneGetsLeftBehind he choose to take him on his back and run for safety]].



* TechnicalPacifist: Ben starts as one... [[AxCrazy where he ends up is another story]].
* TranquilFury: Joe. All the time.
* TrojanPrisoner: When Ben dresses up as a Japanese soldier and takes his "captive" Joe into a Japanese camp in order to gain access to a working radio.* UnfriendlyFire: Chick was trying to pull this on Ben.

to:

* TechnicalPacifist: Ben Yahzee starts as one... [[AxCrazy where he ends up is another story]].
* TranquilFury: Joe.Enders. All the time.
* TrojanPrisoner: When Ben Yahzee dresses up as a Japanese soldier and takes his "captive" Joe Enders into a Japanese camp in order to gain access to a working radio.radio.
* UnfriendlyFire: Chick was trying to pull this on Ben.Yahzee.



* WideEyedIdealist: Ben. He's just [[NaiveNewcomer an idealistic guy]] [[JumpedAtTheCall who wants to protect his country]] and then spread awareness of native culture as a teacher.

to:

* WideEyedIdealist: Ben.Yahzee. He's just [[NaiveNewcomer an idealistic guy]] [[JumpedAtTheCall who wants to protect his country]] and then spread awareness of native culture as a teacher.

Changed: 110

Removed: 82

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS cleanup: ZCE for one, while the other could fit another trope


* ManOnFire: Harrigan is this before he is [=mercy killed=] by Joe.
** Also the numerous IJA soldiers killed by flamethrowers and incendiary grenades.

to:

* ManOnFire: Harrigan is this before he is [=mercy killed=] by Joe.
** Also the numerous
KillItWithFire: Numerous IJA soldiers were killed by flamethrowers and incendiary grenades.

Added: 89

Removed: 82

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BladeEnthusiast: Whitehorse carries a ''big'' Bowie knife that he uses to good effect.



* KnifeNut: Whitehorse carries a ''big'' Bowie knife that he uses to good effect.

Added: 503

Changed: 494

Removed: 103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActionFilmQuietDramaScene: Between battles, there's one scene where Charlie and his bodyguard Ox (who has secretly been ordered to kill him if he's at risk of being captured) bond while playing a musical duet with Ox's harmonica and Charlie's flute.



* FatBestFriend: ''Fat'' might be a strong word, but Charlei is noticeably stouter than his best friend Ben (who plays a bigger role).



* {{Overcrank}}: After all it's John Woo's film.



* ShellShockedVeteran: Joe.

to:

* SecretlyWealthy: Charlie dresses and behaves fairly modestly, but Ben says that his family owns one of the biggest flocks of sheep in the Four Corners.
* ShellShockedVeteran: Joe.Joe's last battle deeply messed with his mind.



* TrojanPrisoner: When Ben dresses up as a Japanese soldier and takes his "captive" Joe into a Japanese camp in order to gain access to a working radio.
* {{Overcrank}}: After all it's John Woo's film.
* UnfriendlyFire: Chick was trying to pull this on Ben.

to:

* TrojanPrisoner: When Ben dresses up as a Japanese soldier and takes his "captive" Joe into a Japanese camp in order to gain access to a working radio.
* {{Overcrank}}: After all it's John Woo's film.
radio.* UnfriendlyFire: Chick was trying to pull this on Ben.



* WideEyedIdealist: Ben. He's just [[NaiveNewcomer an idealistic guy]] [[JumpedAtTheCall who wants to protect his country]].

to:

* WideEyedIdealist: Ben. He's just [[NaiveNewcomer an idealistic guy]] [[JumpedAtTheCall who wants to protect his country]].
country]] and then spread awareness of native culture as a teacher.
* YoungEntrepreneur: Youthful Marines Pappas and Ox display hopes of achieving this once they get out of the service. Pappas hopes to start a "fleet of taxis" and Ox is hoping that he can be the person to develop strawberry yoghurt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SatchelCharge: Enders volunteers to use a satchel charge on a heavily-defended Japanese pillbox towards the end of the first battle on Saipan, ultimately blowing the enemy structure sky-high after throwing it into the enemy bunker's machine gun slit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigGuyFatalitySyndrome: Averted. Chick survives the entire film unscathed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: Joe finds he is unable to perform his vital duty of killing his partner if it came down to it, so he goes to his commanding officer and requests an official transfer to another unit. Because of the village attack soon after, he stays on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Wanted to make an edit here.

Added DiffLines:

** That said, it is averted mostly. While Joe's got a Thompson with magic mags, his squadmates are not so lucky as they frequently either run low or out of ammo in firefights.

Added: 120

Removed: 120

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* CryingLittleKid: The sobbing little girl in the ruined village that Harrigan tries to comfort with a bar of chocolate.


Added DiffLines:

* KidAmidTheChaos: The sobbing little girl in the ruined village that Harrigan tries to comfort with a bar of chocolate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CryingLittleKid: The sobbing little girl in the ruined village that Harrigan tries to comfort with a bar of chocolate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SlashedThroat: Whitehorse and Yahzee, who uses Bowie knives as their backup weapons, disposes many Japanese soldiers using this method. And then there's a MexicanStandoff between Yahzee and a Japanese soldier, who's interrupted by Joe sneaking up behind the Jap and slicing his throat.

Added: 120

Changed: 320

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SurvivorsGuilt: Joe suffers from this.

to:

* StabTheScorpion: During the village battle, Whitehorse throws his friggin' huge bowie knife towards Chick, who was previously shown to be racist towards Native American soldiers... and kills the Japanese soldier sneaking up on Chick. This moment of rescue causes Chick to have a change of attitude towards the minority soldiers.
* SurvivorsGuilt: Joe suffers from this.this due to being the SoleSurvivor of his squad in the battle on the Solomon Islands.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 71

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ConspicuousCG: [=F6F=] Hellcat fighters. Maybe because they were CGI.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foil}}: Ox and Charlie to Ben and Joe. The two develop a genuine friendship, and display more loyalty to each other. While Joe is willing to follow their orders to kill the code talkers if necessary, Ox is unable to do so when the moment arrives, and is justified by him and Charlie managing to fight off their attackers [[spoiler: unforuatley, it's only a brief HopeSpot]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing unnecesary pothole.


* ConspicuousCG: [=F6F=] Hellcat fighters. [[CaptainObvious Maybe because they were CGI]].

to:

* ConspicuousCG: [=F6F=] Hellcat fighters. [[CaptainObvious Maybe because they were CGI]].CGI.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnyoneCanDie: It's UsefulNotes/WorldWarII in the Pacific, so this is to be expected. By the end of the film, [[spoiler: only Chick, Ben, and Pappas are left of the original squad.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathByRascism: [[spoiler: Subverted with Chick, who makes it to the end with [[NiceGuy nice guys]] Ben and Pappas. [[CharacterDevlopment He’s definitely improved by the end of the film, though.]]]]

to:

* DeathByRascism: DeathByRacism [[spoiler: Subverted with Chick, who makes it to the end with [[NiceGuy nice guys]] Ben and Pappas. [[CharacterDevlopment [[CharacterDevelopment He’s definitely improved by the end of the film, though.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeathByRascism: [[spoiler: Subverted with Chick, who makes it to the end with [[NiceGuy nice guys]] Ben and Pappas. [[CharacterDevlopment He’s definitely improved by the end of the film, though.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustPlaneWrong: The [=F6F=] Hellcats are appropriate for the Battle of Saipan. Their insistence on dropping bombs from an altitude that should see them blown out of the sky by those very bombs, or the bombs’ defiance of the laws of physics, decidedly less so. It would have been far more appropriate if the planes had just been given [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Velocity_Aircraft_Rocket HVAR rockets]] instead, which do pretty much the same thing, and would make much more sense to use at low altitude.

to:

* JustPlaneWrong: The [=F6F=] Hellcats are appropriate for the Battle of Saipan. Their insistence on dropping bombs from an altitude that should see them blown out of the sky by those very bombs, or the bombs’ defiance of the laws of physics, decidedly less so. It would have been far more appropriate if the planes had just been given [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Velocity_Aircraft_Rocket HVAR rockets]] instead, which do pretty much the same thing, and would make much more sense to use at low altitude. Additionally, the close air support mission was much more likely to be performed by Marine [=F4U=] Corsairs than Navy Hellcats.[[note]]While Hellcats were perfectly capable of ground attack, Corsairs were more frequently utilized in the role. Additionally, while the Navy operated both fighters, the Marines were almost exclusively equipped with Corsairs, and Marines on the ground would generally be in contact with Marine fighter squadrons for air support.[[/note]]

Changed: 247

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustPlaneWrong: The [=F6F=] Hellcats are appropriate for the Battle of Saipan. Their insistence on dropping bombs from an altitude that should see them blown out of the sky by those very bombs, or the bombs’ defiance of the laws of physics, decidedly less so.

to:

* JustPlaneWrong: The [=F6F=] Hellcats are appropriate for the Battle of Saipan. Their insistence on dropping bombs from an altitude that should see them blown out of the sky by those very bombs, or the bombs’ defiance of the laws of physics, decidedly less so. It would have been far more appropriate if the planes had just been given [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Velocity_Aircraft_Rocket HVAR rockets]] instead, which do pretty much the same thing, and would make much more sense to use at low altitude.

Added: 955

Changed: 1093

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When in desperate need of a radio, Yahtzee recalls how Chick said that Indians look almost Japanese when not in uniform to excuse almost killing Yahtzee. The squad promptly starts to [[DressingAsTheEnemy collect Japanese uniforms]].

to:

** When in desperate need of a radio, Yahtzee Yahzee recalls how Chick said that Indians look almost Japanese when not in uniform to excuse almost killing Yahtzee.his attempt to murder Yahzee (though none of the rest of the platoon buy his excuse for a second). The squad promptly starts to [[DressingAsTheEnemy collect Japanese uniforms]].



* DressingAsTheEnemy: Ben comes up with a way to take out an entrenched Japanese unit through infiltration by putting on a Japanese uniform himself and making his superior Joe look like a captured enemy. The subterfuge is made possible on account of Ben's tanner skin color as a Navajo native, which Joe had earlier noted might cause others in the field to mistake him for a Japanese soldier.

to:

* DressingAsTheEnemy: Ben comes up with a way to take out an entrenched Japanese unit through infiltration by putting on a Japanese uniform himself and making his superior Joe look like a captured enemy. The subterfuge is made possible on account of Ben's tanner skin color and non-white features as a Navajo native, which Joe had earlier noted might cause others in the field to mistake him for a Japanese soldier.soldier. He really doesn’t look Japanese, which is why Joe also smears Ben’s face with dirt, [[BavarianFireDrill hoping that a guy who’s not white in a Japanese uniform will fool the enemy just long enough to get to the radio.]]



* HidingBehindTheLanguageBarrier

to:

* HidingBehindTheLanguageBarrierHidingBehindTheLanguageBarrier: The Navajo Code was derived from the tribe’s language, but it was still a code.



* ImprobableAimingSkills: Joe. If the Thompson submachine gun was half as accurate as it's shown in his hands, it would have been the ultimate weapon of [=WWII=].

to:

* ImprobableAimingSkills: Joe. If the Thompson submachine gun was half as accurate as it's shown in his hands, it would have been the ultimate weapon of [=WWII=].[=WWII=], especially with his [[BottomlessMagazines 30-round mags that are evidently packed with 200+ rounds each]].
** The Thompson actually ''is'' a very accurate weapon...when fired semiauto. Joe’s long bursts would put one hole in the target and fifteen more...somewhere far, far away.



* JustPlaneWrong: The [=F6F=] Hellcats are appropriate for the Battle of Saipan. Their insistence on dropping bombs from an altitude that should see them blown out of the sky by those very bombs, or the bombs’ defiance of the laws of physics, decidedly less so.
* KnifeNut: Whitehorse carries a ''big'' Bowie knife that he uses to good effect.



* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Oh, how nice of you to feed a starving little girl... [[spoiler: time to blow up your flamethrower and let you burn alive!]]

to:

* NiceGuy: PFC Harrigan, the flame gunner, [[{{Irony}} whose job it is to incinerate enemy troops with napalm.]]
* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Oh, Harrigan, how nice of you to feed a starving little girl... [[spoiler: time to blow up your flamethrower and let you burn alive!]]



* OneManArmy: Joe, combining this with DoAnythingSoldier. While [[HandicappedBadass being deaf in one ear]] and living under the heavy burden of SurvivorGuilt, he is still capable of taking down dozens of enemies alone. Heck, he got ''two'' Silver Stars for his insane fighting skills and determination.

to:

* OneManArmy: Joe, combining this with DoAnythingSoldier. While [[HandicappedBadass being deaf in one ear]] and living under the heavy burden of SurvivorGuilt, he is still capable of taking down dozens of enemies alone. Heck, he got ''two'' Silver Stars for his insane fighting skills and determination. Somewhat justified, as he’s a DeathSeeker who takes insane risks that ''should'' get him killed.



* PoorCommunicationKills: There was really no reason to withhold the information from the Windtalkers that their babysitters were supposed to kill them should they fall into enemy hands. It wasn't like the windtalkers didn't already know how important they were. Heck, if things were that dangerous, they should have already been [[BetterToDieThanBeKilled trained how best to take themselves out]] before the enemy gets to them.

to:

* PoorCommunicationKills: There was really no reason to withhold the information from the Windtalkers that their babysitters were supposed to kill them should they fall into enemy hands. It wasn't like the windtalkers didn't already know how important they were. Heck, if things were that dangerous, they should have already been [[BetterToDieThanBeKilled trained how best to take themselves out]] before the enemy gets to them.[[note]] Real-life Code Talkers knew they couldn’t allow themselves to be captured and interrogated.[[/note]]



** The Japanese tanks prove useless for the most part as well, being taken out easily with small arms and flamethrowers.

to:

** The Japanese tanks prove useless for the most part as well, being taken out easily with small arms and flamethrowers.flamethrowers, which is almost TruthInTelevision.



* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: There were Navajo code talkers, and they really were instrumental in the Pacific Theater,[[note]]Adolf Hitler had served in UsefulNotes/WorldWarI and knew the Allies had used similar code talkers in that war - he sent covert agents to study Native American dialects before the United States entered the war. Knowing this, the US did not use the Navajo code talkers in Europe.[[/note]] but the characters in this movie are all fictional.

to:

* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: There were Navajo code talkers, and they really were instrumental in the Pacific Theater,[[note]]Adolf Hitler had served in UsefulNotes/WorldWarI and knew the Allies had used similar code talkers in that war - he sent covert agents to study Native American dialects before the United States entered the war. Knowing this, the US did not use the Navajo code talkers in Europe. Instead, Code Talkers in the ETO were Comanche, whose native language is even more obscure than Navajo.[[/note]] but the characters in this movie are all fictional.


Added DiffLines:

** The very worst part of the Battle of Saipan, the mass-suicide of Japanese civilians on the battle’s final day (with Japanese soldiers shooting those who hesitated to kill themselves), is not shown. Probably for the best.


Added DiffLines:

** The historical record doesn’t bode well for them.

Changed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BottomlessMagazines: Reloading? You're kidding, right? This trope is going to absurd levels with Joe's Thompson. Even if he's the only character ever seen reloading, his mags holds a few times more than they should.

to:

* BottomlessMagazines: Reloading? In a John Woo movie? You're kidding, right? This trope is going to absurd levels with Joe's Thompson. Even if he's the only character ever seen reloading, his mags holds a few times more than they should.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BottomlessMagazines: Reloading? You're kidding, right? This trope is going to absurd levels with Joe's Thompson. Even if he's the only character ever seen reloading, his clips holds a few times more than they should.

to:

* BottomlessMagazines: Reloading? You're kidding, right? This trope is going to absurd levels with Joe's Thompson. Even if he's the only character ever seen reloading, his clips mags holds a few times more than they should.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JungleWarfare: The first battle scene, set in the Solomons during 1942 or 1943, is a textbook example, with patrols, ambushes, and supply problems in the span of less than 4 minutes.
** The first battle set on Saipan counts as well, thanks to the thick overgrowth on the lower areas of the island.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add 1

Added DiffLines:

* OffWithHisHead: [[spoiler:Henderson]] suffers this fate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HumanShield: Ox uses one of the Japanese soldiers to block a stab from bayonet.

to:

* HumanShield: Ox uses one of the Japanese soldiers to block a stab from a bayonet.



* MoodWhiplash: After upbeat talk about their families and home the main characters are suddenly under artillery fire. [[spoiler: [[KickTheDog Friendly artillery fire]] ]].

to:

* MoodWhiplash: After upbeat talk about their families and home the main characters are suddenly under artillery fire. [[spoiler: [[KickTheDog Friendly artillery fire]] ]].fire]]]].



* NeverTrustATitle: Joe is the center of attention and the protagonist in the movie, the windtalkers, are... there.

to:

* NeverTrustATitle: Joe is the center of attention and the protagonist in the movie, the windtalkers, windtalkers are... there.



* OneManArmy: Joe, combining this with DoAnythingSoldier. While [[HandicappedBadass being deaf on one ear]] and living under the heavy burden of SurvivorGuilt, he is still capable of taking down dozens of enemies alone. Heck, he got ''two'' Silver Stars for his insane fighting skills and determination.

to:

* OneManArmy: Joe, combining this with DoAnythingSoldier. While [[HandicappedBadass being deaf on in one ear]] and living under the heavy burden of SurvivorGuilt, he is still capable of taking down dozens of enemies alone. Heck, he got ''two'' Silver Stars for his insane fighting skills and determination.



* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: There were Navajo code talkers, and they really were instrumental in the Pacific Theater,[[note]]Adolf Hitler had served in UsefulNotes/WorldWarI and knew the Allies had used similar code talkers in that war - he sent covert agents to study Native American dialects before the United States entered the war. Knowing this, the US did not use the Navajo code talkers in Europe[[/note]] but the characters in this movie are all fictional.

to:

* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: There were Navajo code talkers, and they really were instrumental in the Pacific Theater,[[note]]Adolf Hitler had served in UsefulNotes/WorldWarI and knew the Allies had used similar code talkers in that war - he sent covert agents to study Native American dialects before the United States entered the war. Knowing this, the US did not use the Navajo code talkers in Europe[[/note]] Europe.[[/note]] but the characters in this movie are all fictional.

Top