Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / SavingTheTitanic

Go To

OR

Added: 484

Changed: 603

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MrExposition: A number of characters fill this role at various points, most notably:
** Frank Bell, apprentice at Harland and Wolff and son of Chief Engineer Joseph Bell, who explains the workings of ''Titanic's'' engines under quizzing from his father, and, in conjunction with Thomas Andrews, explains the functioning of the ship's watertight compartments.
** As in many ''Titanic'' retellings, Thomas Andrews is present to explain the catastrophic nature of the damage to the ship.




to:

* TheWatson: Perhaps surprisingly, it is Chief Engineer Bell who largely fills this role, allowing the engineers and electricians serving under him to showcase their expertise. In one instance, he's seen asking a subordinate engineer about the number and capacity of the ship's pumps, which will be needed to keep Boiler Room 5 from flooding for as long as possible. In another scene, he orders the ship's electricians to provide power for the emergency systems, leaving it to them to work out - and explain for the audience's benefit - just how they can get enough steam pressure to run the generators.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheEngineer: The film focuses on the ''Titanic's'' engineering crew and their efforts to keep the ship afloat and the emergency systems working long enough for help to arrive.

to:

* TheEngineer: The film focuses on the ''Titanic's'' engineering crew and their efforts to keep the ship afloat and the emergency systems working long enough for help to arrive. Special attention is given to Joseph Bell, ''Titanic's'' Chief Engineer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCaptain: While the closest Captain Smith comes to appearing in the film is via secondhand references to his orders, Chief Engineer Joseph Bell is effectively the captain of the ''Titanic's'' engineering crew. He even wears the same rank insignia as Captain Smith.


Added DiffLines:

* TheEngineer: The film focuses on the ''Titanic's'' engineering crew and their efforts to keep the ship afloat and the emergency systems working long enough for help to arrive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->What is she compared to the sea?

to:

->What ->''"What is she compared to the sea?sea?"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoversAlwaysLie: There was no waves or clouds at the night of the sinking.

to:

* CoversAlwaysLie: There was were no waves or clouds at the night of the sinking.

Added: 4

Changed: 31

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Given how not much is known about the engineers and stokers' actions during the actual disaster, this was to be expected. The coal bunker fire theory [[DocumentaryOfLies popularised]] by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The photographic blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a warped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.
* AscendedExtra: Whilst the firemen, trimmers and engineers were hardly even extras in RealLife for their valiant efforts, ''Saving The Titanic'' strove to give them justice and memorialise them as opposed to a few minutes of screen time in most portrayals.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Given how not much is known about the engineers and stokers' actions during the actual disaster, this was to be expected. The coal bunker fire theory [[DocumentaryOfLies popularised]] by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} Spammals and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' ''Titanic Honor and Glory'' dev team. The photographic blemish as seen in ''Titanic - -- The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a warped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.
* AscendedExtra: Whilst the firemen, trimmers trimmers, and engineers were hardly even extras in RealLife for their valiant efforts, ''Saving The Titanic'' strove to give them justice and memorialise them as opposed to a few minutes of screen time in most portrayals.



* TheGhost: It sure makes you wonder where Captain Smith, J. Bruce Ismay and Molly Brown, let alone Jack Thayer or Harold Bride, were in the film. But that isn't what the story is about.

to:

* TheGhost: It sure makes you wonder where Captain Smith, J. Bruce Ismay Ismay, and Molly Brown, let alone Jack Thayer or Harold Bride, were in the film. But that isn't what the story is about.



* SinkingShipScenario: The film is mainly set as the ''Titanic'' is sinking following her fatal collision with the iceberg.

to:

* SinkingShipScenario: The film is mainly set as the ''Titanic'' is sinking following her fatal collision with the iceberg.iceberg.

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HopeSpot: Barrett and the rest of the ship's stokers, firemen, and engineers manage to empty Boiler Room 6 of water. However, by then the water in ''Titanic's'' bow causes the compartment to flood, dooming the ship and rendering their efforts pointless.

Changed: 26

Removed: 100

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheGhost: It sure makes you wonder where Captain Smith, J. Bruce Ismay and Molly Brown, let alone Jack Dawson or Rose Bukater, were in the film. But that isn't what the story is about.

to:

* TheGhost: It sure makes you wonder where Captain Smith, J. Bruce Ismay and Molly Brown, let alone Jack Dawson Thayer or Rose Bukater, Harold Bride, were in the film. But that isn't what the story is about.



* ForegoneConclusion: Being a ''Titanic'' film, pretty much everyone knows what happened afterwards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScrewTheMoneyIHaveRules: [[spoiler:Disgusted at being UsedAllAlong in exchange for being portrayed by White Star as "heroes", Barrett leaves the offices, while his colleague Paddy gleefully accepts the offer.]]

to:

* ScrewTheMoneyIHaveRules: [[spoiler:Disgusted at being UsedAllAlong in exchange for being portrayed by White Star as "heroes", Barrett leaves the offices, while his colleague Paddy gleefully accepts the offer.]]]]
* SinkingShipScenario: The film is mainly set as the ''Titanic'' is sinking following her fatal collision with the iceberg.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DamageControl: The entire focus of the film is the ship's engineers and stokers trying to delay or prevent the ''Titanic'' from sinking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForegoneConclusion: The ''Titanic'' ultimately sinks, as history would tell you.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForegoneConclusion: Being a ''Titanic'' film, pretty much everyone knows what happened afterwards.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 202

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ConspicuousCG: Though it wasn't all that bad, and CGI shots of the ship were used sparingly anyway, with the live-action scenes mostly confined to shots of the ship's interior and engine/boiler rooms.

Added: 118

Removed: 118

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HowWeGotHere: The film starts in New York where Barrett is summoned to testify and recount his experiences on board.


Added DiffLines:

* HowWeGotHere: The film starts in New York where Barrett is summoned to testify and recount his experiences on board.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Narrated by Liam Cunningham and starring David Wilmot and Ciarán [=McMenamin=], ''Saving The Titanic'' is a 2012 [[UsefulNotes/{{Ireland}} Irish]]-[[UsefulNotes/{{Germany}} German]] {{Docudrama}} revolving around the efforts of the ill-fated ship's engineers and stokers at keeping the ship afloat for as long as she could possibly can, [[DelayingAction buying passengers some time]] to board the lifeboats. Told InMediasRes, Leading Fireman Frederick Barrett ([=McMenamin=]) is summoned by the White Star Line to be part of an inquiry on the sinking, in hopes that the company would paint a rosy picture of what happened during that fateful night. This film is also notable for being more about a particular group of people on board (i.e. the aforementioned crew) than on the usual cast of characters typical of a ''Titanic'' drama.

to:

Narrated by Liam Cunningham and starring David Wilmot and Ciarán [=McMenamin=], ''Saving The Titanic'' is a 2012 [[UsefulNotes/{{Ireland}} Irish]]-[[UsefulNotes/{{Germany}} German]] {{Docudrama}} revolving around the efforts of the ill-fated ship's engineers and stokers at keeping the ship afloat for as long as she could possibly can, could, [[DelayingAction buying passengers some time]] to board the lifeboats. Told InMediasRes, Leading Fireman Frederick Barrett ([=McMenamin=]) is summoned by the White Star Line to be part of an inquiry on the sinking, in hopes that the company would paint a rosy picture of what happened during that fateful night. This film is also notable for being more about a particular group of people on board (i.e. the aforementioned crew) than on the usual cast of characters typical of a ''Titanic'' drama.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Given how not much is known about the engineers and stokers' actions during the actual disaster, this was to be expected. The coal bunker fire theory [[DocumentaryOfLies popularised]] by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a warped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Given how not much is known about the engineers and stokers' actions during the actual disaster, this was to be expected. The coal bunker fire theory [[DocumentaryOfLies popularised]] by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The photographic blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a warped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CoversAlwaysLie: There was no waves or clouds at the night of the sinking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HowWeGotHere: The film starts in New York where Barrett is summoned to testify and recount his experiences on board.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheGhost: It sure makes you wonder where Captain Smith and Molly Brown, let alone Jack Dawson or Rose Bukater, were in the film. But that isn't what the story is about.

to:

* TheGhost: It sure makes you wonder where Captain Smith Smith, J. Bruce Ismay and Molly Brown, let alone Jack Dawson or Rose Bukater, were in the film. But that isn't what the story is about.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Given how not much is known about the engineers and stokers' actions during the actual disaster, this was to be expected. The coal bunker fire theory popularised by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a warped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Given how not much is known about the engineers and stokers' actions during the actual disaster, this was to be expected. The coal bunker fire theory popularised [[DocumentaryOfLies popularised]] by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a warped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.

Changed: 561

Removed: 592

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Given how not much is known about the engineers and stokers' actions during the actual disaster, this was to be expected.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Given how not much is known about the engineers and stokers' actions during the actual disaster, this was to be expected. The coal bunker fire theory popularised by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a warped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.



* CriticalResearchFailure: The coal bunker fire theory popularised by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was also thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a warped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Recurring Titanic figure Thomas Andrews does make appearances though, and with Smith sort of absent in the story, Engineer Bell became something of an {{Expy}} for the captain, like when Andrews informs him that the ship is a lost cause and must be abandoned by any means possible.

to:

** Recurring Titanic ''Titanic'' figure Thomas Andrews does make appearances though, and with Smith sort of absent in the story, Engineer Bell became something of an {{Expy}} for the captain, like when Andrews informs him that the ship is a lost cause and must be abandoned by any means possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:300:Because for some, a tale about the crew members most people tend to overlook is a better sell than a sappy love story.]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:300:Because for some, a tale about the crew members most people tend to overlook is a better sell dozen times more compelling than a sappy love story.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CriticalResearchFailure: The coal bunker fire theory popularised by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was also thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a waped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.

to:

* CriticalResearchFailure: The coal bunker fire theory popularised by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was also thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a waped warped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AscendedExtra: Whilst the firemen, trimmers and engineers were hardly even extras InRealLife for their valiant efforts, ''Saving The Titanic'' strove to give them justice and memorialise them as opposed to a few minutes of screen time in most portrayals.

to:

* AscendedExtra: Whilst the firemen, trimmers and engineers were hardly even extras InRealLife in RealLife for their valiant efforts, ''Saving The Titanic'' strove to give them justice and memorialise them as opposed to a few minutes of screen time in most portrayals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Narrated by Liam Cunningham and starring David Wilmot and Ciarán [=McMenamin=], ''Saving The Titanic'' is a 2012 Irish-German {{Docudrama}} revolving around the efforts of the ill-fated ship's engineers and stokers at keeping the ship afloat for as long as she could possibly can, [[DelayingAction buying passengers some time]] to board the lifeboats. Told InMediasRes, Leading Fireman Frederick Barrett ([=McMenamin=]) is summoned by the White Star Line to be part of an inquiry on the sinking, in hopes that the company would paint a rosy picture of what happened during that fateful night. This film is also notable for being more about a particular group of people on board (i.e. the aforementioned crew) than on the usual cast of characters typical of a ''Titanic'' drama.

to:

Narrated by Liam Cunningham and starring David Wilmot and Ciarán [=McMenamin=], ''Saving The Titanic'' is a 2012 Irish-German [[UsefulNotes/{{Ireland}} Irish]]-[[UsefulNotes/{{Germany}} German]] {{Docudrama}} revolving around the efforts of the ill-fated ship's engineers and stokers at keeping the ship afloat for as long as she could possibly can, [[DelayingAction buying passengers some time]] to board the lifeboats. Told InMediasRes, Leading Fireman Frederick Barrett ([=McMenamin=]) is summoned by the White Star Line to be part of an inquiry on the sinking, in hopes that the company would paint a rosy picture of what happened during that fateful night. This film is also notable for being more about a particular group of people on board (i.e. the aforementioned crew) than on the usual cast of characters typical of a ''Titanic'' drama.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/saving_titanic.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:300:Because for some, a tale about the crew members most people tend to overlook is a better sell than a sappy love story.]]

->What is she compared to the sea?
-->-- '''Chief Engineer Joseph Bell'''

Take the oft-portrayed ''UsefulNotes/RMSTitanic'' tale, depict it in the point of view of crew members people mostly overlook in favour of StarCrossedLovers or affluent passengers, i.e. the engineering and boiler room crew, sprinkle it with drama and you'll end up with a film like this.

Narrated by Liam Cunningham and starring David Wilmot and Ciarán [=McMenamin=], ''Saving The Titanic'' is a 2012 Irish-German {{Docudrama}} revolving around the efforts of the ill-fated ship's engineers and stokers at keeping the ship afloat for as long as she could possibly can, [[DelayingAction buying passengers some time]] to board the lifeboats. Told InMediasRes, Leading Fireman Frederick Barrett ([=McMenamin=]) is summoned by the White Star Line to be part of an inquiry on the sinking, in hopes that the company would paint a rosy picture of what happened during that fateful night. This film is also notable for being more about a particular group of people on board (i.e. the aforementioned crew) than on the usual cast of characters typical of a ''Titanic'' drama.

----
!!The show provides examples of:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Given how not much is known about the engineers and stokers' actions during the actual disaster, this was to be expected.
* AscendedExtra: Whilst the firemen, trimmers and engineers were hardly even extras InRealLife for their valiant efforts, ''Saving The Titanic'' strove to give them justice and memorialise them as opposed to a few minutes of screen time in most portrayals.
* ConspicuousCG: Though it wasn't all that bad, and CGI shots of the ship were used sparingly anyway, with the live-action scenes mostly confined to shots of the ship's interior and engine/boiler rooms.
* CriticalResearchFailure: The coal bunker fire theory popularised by Senan Molony and implied to be a major factor for the disaster in the film was also thoroughly debunked by a number of ''Titanic'' scholars and enthusiasts such as [=YouTuber=] and White Star Line fan WebVideo/{{Spammals}} and the ''VideoGame/TitanicHonorAndGlory'' dev team. The blemish as seen in ''Titanic - The New Evidence'' could be dismissed as just that, a ''blemish'', rather than a waped section of the hull indicating an AchillesHeel which may have exacerbated things, if that was a contributing factor at all.
* DownerEnding: [[spoiler:None of the engineering crew made it, and neither did the electricians survive the ordeal. A few firemen and trimmers did make it out alive, Barrett included.]]
* TheGhost: It sure makes you wonder where Captain Smith and Molly Brown, let alone Jack Dawson or Rose Bukater, were in the film. But that isn't what the story is about.
** Recurring Titanic figure Thomas Andrews does make appearances though, and with Smith sort of absent in the story, Engineer Bell became something of an {{Expy}} for the captain, like when Andrews informs him that the ship is a lost cause and must be abandoned by any means possible.
* ScrewTheMoneyIHaveRules: [[spoiler:Disgusted at being UsedAllAlong in exchange for being portrayed by White Star as "heroes", Barrett leaves the offices, while his colleague Paddy gleefully accepts the offer.]]

Top