Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / HeneralLuna

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShownTheirWork: The entire film is impressively researched, one example being the khaki uniforms Luna and Del Pilar are shown wearing by the end, replacing the more famous white pinstriped (''rayadillo'') ones copied from the Spanish army which are seen earlier.

to:

* ShownTheirWork: The entire film is impressively researched, one example being the khaki uniforms Luna and Del Pilar are shown wearing by the end, replacing the more famous white pinstriped blue pinstripes-on-white (''rayadillo'') pattern ones copied from the Spanish army which are seen earlier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Heneral Luna'', released September 9, 2015, is a historical biopic film depicting General Antonio Luna (John Arcilla) and his exploits while leading the Philippine Revolutionary Army against the United States during the [[UsefulNotes/PhilippineInsurrection Philippine-American War]].

to:

''Heneral Luna'', released September 9, 2015, is a historical biopic film depicting General Antonio Luna (John Arcilla) and his exploits while leading the Philippine Revolutionary Army against the United States during the [[UsefulNotes/PhilippineInsurrection Philippine-American War]].
UsefulNotes/PhilippineAmericanWar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As for the Philippine flag, GenreSavvy and knowledgeable viewers might wonder why it is displayed "correctly" in it's "peacetime" position every time it is on screen. The Philippine flag should be inverted during times of war, such as the time of the movie; this would be considered a historical innacuracy, or at least FridgeLogic, except that the one time it isn't (and brace yourself for the FridgeBrilliance): [[spoiler:is when Aguinaldo is proclaiming his innocence. So the Philippines was only ever at war with itself.]] Make of that what you will.[[note]] [[https://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1998/ra_8491_1998.html RA 8491 Section 10]], which depicts how the flag should be positioned during wartime and peacetime, was drafted on February 12, 1998, a century after the events of the film, making this symbolism NewerThanTheyThink. [[/note]]

to:

** As for the Philippine flag, GenreSavvy and knowledgeable viewers might wonder why it is displayed "correctly" in it's its "peacetime" position every time it is on screen. The Philippine flag should be inverted during times of war, such as the time of the movie; this would be considered a historical innacuracy, or at least FridgeLogic, except that the one time it isn't (and brace yourself for the FridgeBrilliance): [[spoiler:is when Aguinaldo is proclaiming his innocence. So the Philippines was only ever at war with itself.]] Make of that what you will.[[note]] [[https://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1998/ra_8491_1998.html RA 8491 Section 10]], which depicts how the flag should be positioned during wartime and peacetime, was drafted on February 12, 1998, a century after the events of the film, making this symbolism NewerThanTheyThink. [[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SequelHook: General Gregorio Del Pilar is set to be TheHero of the ''[[Film/GoyoAngBatangHeneral next film]]''.

to:

* SequelHook: General Gregorio Del Pilar is set to be TheHero of the ''[[Film/GoyoAngBatangHeneral [[Film/GoyoAngBatangHeneral next film]]''.film]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SequelHook: General Gregorio Del Pilar is set to be TheHero of the next film.

to:

* SequelHook: General Gregorio Del Pilar is set to be TheHero of the ''[[Film/GoyoAngBatangHeneral next film.film]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Heneral Luna'', released September 9, 2015, is a historical biopic film depicting General Antonio Luna (John Arcilla) and his exploits while leading the Philippine Revolutionary Army against the United States during the Philippine-American War.

to:

''Heneral Luna'', released September 9, 2015, is a historical biopic film depicting General Antonio Luna (John Arcilla) and his exploits while leading the Philippine Revolutionary Army against the United States during the [[UsefulNotes/PhilippineInsurrection Philippine-American War.
War]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* RatedMForManly: Luna's badasserry was emphasized throughout the film.

Removed: 726

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
5MB shoehorn; one person per role


%%* Five Man Band:
%%** Heroes (''relatively speaking''):
%%*** TheLeader: Antonio Luna.
%%*** TheLancer: Paco Román. José Alejandrino sometimes plays the role.
%%*** TheSmartGuy: Eduardo Rusca, ever the guy with the [[DeadpanSnarker smartest remarks]].
%%*** TheBigGuy: The Bernal brothers.
%%*** TagalongKid: Joven Hernando. Who is technically also a [[JustForPun Tagalog Kid]].
%%** Villains (''relatively speaking''):
%%*** BigBad: Emilio Aguinaldo.
%%*** CoDragons / {{Evil Genius}}es: Felipe Buencamino and Pedro Paterno.
%%*** TheBrute: Tomás Mascardo and his men.
%%*** TheDarkChick: [[GenderFlip Apolinario Mabini.]] (In RealLife, he actually recommended Luna's removal from the Revolutionary Army due to his HotBlooded-ness.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was directly involved in bringing about Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''personally'' killed him, as clear "smoking gun" evidence about this has yet to be unearthed. What is certain is only that Luna was summoned to Aguinaldo's headquarters through telegraph, but the President was missing when he arrived and he was thus alone with Felipe Buencamino and Aguinaldo's presidential bodyguards. At the very least, Aguinaldo can be taken to task for not punishing Luna's immediate killers. But the film takes the definite stance that he was complicit, and the repercussions go all the way to the sequel ''Goyo'' where another of Aguinaldo's generals, Jose Alejandrino, relentlessly prods him about the issue.

to:

** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was directly involved in bringing about Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''personally'' killed him, as clear "smoking gun" evidence about this has yet to be unearthed. What is certain is only that Luna was summoned to Aguinaldo's headquarters through telegraph, but the President was missing when he arrived and he was thus alone with Felipe Buencamino and Aguinaldo's presidential bodyguards. At the very least, Aguinaldo can be taken to task for not punishing Luna's immediate killers. But the film takes the definite stance that he was complicit, and the repercussions go all the way to the sequel ''Goyo'' ''Goyo'', where another of Aguinaldo's generals, Jose Alejandrino, is depicted as relentlessly prods prodding him about the issue.issue - until he finally admits [[IDidWhatIHadToDo that it was for the Republic's sake, or so he thought.]] That film then has Alejandrino relay this to Mabini in a letter, but after Mabini is captured by the Americans, the letter is left behind and lost to history. Furthermore in this film, right after Luna is assassinated, Buencamino searches his pockets for his own copy of the message from Aguinaldo, and destroys it on the spot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForeignCussWord: There are Spanish swears abound. Quite a few of which have also been assimilated into Tagalog, and later Filipino, such as "Putang-ina." [[note]] Translation: "Whoremother, i.e. Son of a Bitch"[[/note]]

to:

* ForeignCussWord: There are Spanish swears abound. Quite a few of which have also been assimilated into Tagalog, and later Filipino, such as "Putang-ina." [[note]] Translation: "Whoremother, "Whoremother", i.e. Son "Son of a Bitch"[[/note]]bitch"; compare Spanish "Puta madre" and "Hijo de puta"[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was directly involved in bringing about Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him, as clear "smoking gun" evidence about this has yet to be unearthed. What is certain is only that Luna was summoned to Aguinaldo's headquarters through telegraph, but the President was missing when he arrived and he was thus alone with Felipe Buencamino and Aguinaldo's presidential bodyguards. At the very least, Aguinaldo can be taken to task for not punishing Luna's immediate killers. But the film takes the definite stance that he was complicit, and the repercussions go all the way to the sequel ''Goyo'' where another of Aguinaldo's generals, Jose Alejandrino, relentlessly prods him about the issue.

to:

** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was directly involved in bringing about Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill ''personally'' killed him, as clear "smoking gun" evidence about this has yet to be unearthed. What is certain is only that Luna was summoned to Aguinaldo's headquarters through telegraph, but the President was missing when he arrived and he was thus alone with Felipe Buencamino and Aguinaldo's presidential bodyguards. At the very least, Aguinaldo can be taken to task for not punishing Luna's immediate killers. But the film takes the definite stance that he was complicit, and the repercussions go all the way to the sequel ''Goyo'' where another of Aguinaldo's generals, Jose Alejandrino, relentlessly prods him about the issue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Lampshaded in the opening text, pointing out how the film is a mix of historical fact and the imaginary. Ironically, the movie is still reasonably true to history in spite of the disclaimer, especially compared to previous movies.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Lampshaded in the opening text, pointing out how the film is a mix of historical fact and the imaginary. Ironically, the movie is still reasonably true to history in spite of the disclaimer, especially compared to previous movies.Philippine history movies, due to its WartsAndAll approach to the people and setting in contrast to more "textbook" or simplified narratives used in the past.

Added: 209

Changed: 126

Removed: 527

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Lampshaded in the opening text, pointing out how the film is a mix of historical fact and the imaginary.
** Ironically, the movie is still reasonably true to history in spite of the disclaimer.
* ArmorPiercingQuestion: [[MemeticMutation From the man himself:]]
--> '''Luna''': NEGOSYO O KALAYAAN? BAYAN O SARILI? '''PUMILI KA!''' [[note]]"Business or freedom? Country or self? MAKE YOUR CHOICE!"[[/note]]
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: A disclaimer at the start of the movie openly states that the film takes historical liberties with some of the RealLife events surrounding Luna and the Revolution, to suit its HistoricalFiction narrative.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Lampshaded in the opening text, pointing out how the film is a mix of historical fact and the imaginary.
**
imaginary. Ironically, the movie is still reasonably true to history in spite of the disclaimer.
* ArmorPiercingQuestion: [[MemeticMutation From the man himself:]]
--> '''Luna''': NEGOSYO O KALAYAAN? BAYAN O SARILI? '''PUMILI KA!''' [[note]]"Business or freedom? Country or self? MAKE YOUR CHOICE!"[[/note]]
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: A disclaimer at the start of the movie openly states that the film takes historical liberties with some of the RealLife events surrounding Luna and the Revolution,
disclaimer, especially compared to suit its HistoricalFiction narrative.previous movies.


Added DiffLines:

* ArmorPiercingQuestion: [[MemeticMutation From the man himself:]]
--> '''Luna''': NEGOSYO O KALAYAAN? BAYAN O SARILI? '''PUMILI KA!''' [[note]]"Business or freedom? Country or self? MAKE YOUR CHOICE!"[[/note]]

Added: 1777

Removed: 1553

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: A disclaimer at the start of the movie openly states that the film takes historical liberties with some of the RealLife events surrounding Luna and the Revolution, to suit its HistoricalFiction narrative.
** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was directly involved in bringing about Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him, as clear "smoking gun" evidence about this has yet to be unearthed. What is certain is only that Luna was summoned to Aguinaldo's headquarters through telegraph, but the President was missing when he arrived and he was thus alone with Felipe Buencamino and Aguinaldo's presidential bodyguards. At the very least, Aguinaldo can be taken to task for not punishing Luna's immediate killers. But the film takes the definite stance that he was complicit, and the repercussions go all the way to the sequel ''Goyo'' where another of Aguinaldo's generals, Jose Alejandrino, relentlessly prods him about the issue.
** The film states that Luna is the only officer with some formal education in military science. But most of this was from a hurried few months' worth of a crash course in Belgium. And since he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, and even longer if they were Spanish-colonial military veterans who had defected.
** Ysabel, the woman portrayed as Luna's LoveInterest here, is entirely made-up, but may be based in part on the (also dubious and politically-motivated) rumour that Luna supposedly entrusted the Revolutionary treasury to a woman named Ysidra Cojuangco, which later allegedly grew into her descendants' vast wealth.



* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: Director Jerrold Tarrog has actually openly admitted that the film takes historical liberties with some of the RealLife events surrounding Luna and the Revolution.
** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was ultimately involved in Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him. The likelier reason the real Luna was killed was because his HairTriggerTemper and BadBoss tendencies as head of the Revolutionary Army, not to mention relative inexperience on the battlefield[[note]]yes, he did have knowledge of military strategy, but most of this from a hurried few months' worth of a crash course in Belgium, and as he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, ''longer'' even if they were Spanish-colonial military veterans who defected—yes, even under Spanish rule much of its colonial army was staffed by natives and mestizos especially in the lower ranks[[/note]] was demoralising enough of the men under his command that some were eventually pissed-off enough to take what they saw as a huge liability out of the equation.
** Ysabel, the woman portrayed as Luna's LoveInterest here, is entirely made-up, but may be based in part on the (also dubious and politically-motivated) rumour that Luna supposedly entrusted the Revolutionary treasury to a woman named Ysidra Cojuangco, which later allegedly grew into her descendants' vast wealth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYK_6W_seNg sequel]] with the same cast and crew, ''[[Film/GoyoAngBatangHeneral Goyo: Ang Batang Heneral]]'' (''Goyo: The Boy General'') about Luna's contemporary General Gregorio del Pilar was released in 2018. A third film about UsefulNotes/ManuelQuezon, President of the later Philippine Commonwealth is also planned. [[SequelHook Both men appear here in small roles.]] Tarrog also did a short film, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DCBRjEuSQNw Angelito]]'', which takes place in between ''Luna'' and ''Goyo''. As of 2020, the full film is officially [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SYWo6FoVacY free to watch]] as well, English subtitles included.

to:

A [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYK_6W_seNg sequel]] with the same cast and crew, ''[[Film/GoyoAngBatangHeneral Goyo: Ang Batang Heneral]]'' (''Goyo: The Boy General'') about Luna's contemporary General Gregorio del Pilar was released in 2018. A third film about UsefulNotes/ManuelQuezon, President of the later Philippine Commonwealth is also planned. [[SequelHook Both men appear here in small roles.]] Tarrog also did a short film, ''[[https://www.''[[https://web.archive.org/web/20180822225439/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DCBRjEuSQNw Angelito]]'', which takes place in between ''Luna'' and ''Goyo''. As of 2020, the full film is officially [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SYWo6FoVacY free to watch]] as well, English subtitles included.

Changed: 694

Removed: 694

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was ultimately involved in Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him. The likelier reason the real Luna was killed was because his HairTriggerTemper and BadBoss tendencies as head of the Revolutionary Army, not to
mention relative inexperience on the battlefield[[note]]yes, he did have knowledge of military strategy, but most of this from a hurried few months' worth of a crash course in Belgium, and as he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, ''longer'' even if they were Spanish-colonial military veterans who defected—yes, even under Spanish rule much of its colonial army was staffed by natives and mestizos especially in the lower ranks[[/note]] was demoralising enough of the men under his command that some were eventually pissed-off enough to take what they saw as a huge liability out of the equation.

to:

** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was ultimately involved in Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him. The likelier reason the real Luna was killed was because his HairTriggerTemper and BadBoss tendencies as head of the Revolutionary Army, not to
to mention relative inexperience on the battlefield[[note]]yes, he did have knowledge of military strategy, but most of this from a hurried few months' worth of a crash course in Belgium, and as he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, ''longer'' even if they were Spanish-colonial military veterans who defected—yes, even under Spanish rule much of its colonial army was staffed by natives and mestizos especially in the lower ranks[[/note]] was demoralising enough of the men under his command that some were eventually pissed-off enough to take what they saw as a huge liability out of the equation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LightIsGood: Mabini notably wears white, to reinforce his being the OnlySaneMan in Aguinaldo's cabinet, and the one [[IncorruptiblePurePureness who comes off the best]]. Especially highlighted in a scene with Aguinaldo and Luna's enemies, where he is the only one in the light and the rest are in shadow. In real life, Mabini was one of the first people to denounce Aguinaldo for his treatment of Bonifacio and Luna through his memoirs, written a few years later.

to:

* LightIsGood: Mabini notably wears white, to reinforce his being the OnlySaneMan in Aguinaldo's cabinet, and the one [[IncorruptiblePurePureness who comes off the best]]. Especially highlighted in a scene with Aguinaldo and Luna's enemies, where he is the only one in the light and the rest are in shadow. In real life, Mabini was one of the first people to denounce Aguinaldo for his treatment of Bonifacio and Luna through his memoirs, written a few years later. (On the other hand, Mabini also did have reservations about Luna being made head of the revolutionary army on the basis of an assessment of his attitude and abilities at the time.)

Added: 1009

Changed: 694

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was ultimately involved in Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him. The likelier reason the real Luna was killed was because his HairTriggerTemper and BadBoss tendencies as head of the Revolutionary Army, not to mention relative inexperience on the battlefield[[note]]yes, he did have knowledge of military strategy, but most of this from a hurried few months' worth of a crash course in Belgium, and as he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, ''longer'' even if they were Spanish-colonial military veterans who defected—yes, even under Spanish rule much of its colonial army was staffed by natives and mestizos especially in the lower ranks[[/note]] was demoralising enough of the men under his command that some were eventually pissed-off enough to take what they saw as a huge liability out of the equation.

to:

** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was ultimately involved in Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him. The likelier reason the real Luna was killed was because his HairTriggerTemper and BadBoss tendencies as head of the Revolutionary Army, not to to
mention relative inexperience on the battlefield[[note]]yes, he did have knowledge of military strategy, but most of this from a hurried few months' worth of a crash course in Belgium, and as he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, ''longer'' even if they were Spanish-colonial military veterans who defected—yes, even under Spanish rule much of its colonial army was staffed by natives and mestizos especially in the lower ranks[[/note]] was demoralising enough of the men under his command that some were eventually pissed-off enough to take what they saw as a huge liability out of the equation.equation.
** Ysabel, the woman portrayed as Luna's LoveInterest here, is entirely made-up, but may be based in part on the (also dubious and politically-motivated) rumour that Luna supposedly entrusted the Revolutionary treasury to a woman named Ysidra Cojuangco, which later allegedly grew into her descendants' vast wealth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was ultimately involved in Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him. The likelier reason the real Luna was killed was because his HairTriggerTemper and BadBoss tendencies as head of the Revolutionary Army, not to mention relative inexperience on the battlefield[[note]]yes, he did have knowledge of military strategy, but most of this from a hurried crash course in Belgium, and as he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, ''longer'' even if they'd defected from the colonial military[[/note]] was demoralising enough of the men under his command that some were eventually pissed-off enough to take what they saw as a huge liability out of the equation.

to:

** For instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was ultimately involved in Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him. The likelier reason the real Luna was killed was because his HairTriggerTemper and BadBoss tendencies as head of the Revolutionary Army, not to mention relative inexperience on the battlefield[[note]]yes, he did have knowledge of military strategy, but most of this from a hurried few months' worth of a crash course in Belgium, and as he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, ''longer'' even if they'd defected from the they were Spanish-colonial military veterans who defected—yes, even under Spanish rule much of its colonial military[[/note]] army was staffed by natives and mestizos especially in the lower ranks[[/note]] was demoralising enough of the men under his command that some were eventually pissed-off enough to take what they saw as a huge liability out of the equation.

Added: 884

Changed: 902

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: Director Jerrold Tarrog has actually openly admitted that the film takes historical liberties with some of the actual events surrounding Luna and the Revolution. In RealLife, for instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was ultimately involved Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him. The likelier reason the real Luna was killed was because his HairTriggerTemper and BadBoss tendencies as head of the Revolutionary Army, not to mention relative inexperience on the battlefield[[note]]yes, he did have knowledge of military strategy, but most of this from a hurried crash course in Belgium, and as he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, ''longer'' even if they'd defected from the colonial military[[/note]] was demoralising enough of the men under his command that some were eventually pissed-off enough to take what they saw as a huge liability out of the equation.

to:

* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: Director Jerrold Tarrog has actually openly admitted that the film takes historical liberties with some of the actual RealLife events surrounding Luna and the Revolution. In RealLife, for Revolution.
** For
instance, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was ultimately involved in Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''did'' kill him. The likelier reason the real Luna was killed was because his HairTriggerTemper and BadBoss tendencies as head of the Revolutionary Army, not to mention relative inexperience on the battlefield[[note]]yes, he did have knowledge of military strategy, but most of this from a hurried crash course in Belgium, and as he joined the Revolution late—in 1898—he had almost no combat experience compared to officers under him who'd been fighting since 1896, ''longer'' even if they'd defected from the colonial military[[/note]] was demoralising enough of the men under his command that some were eventually pissed-off enough to take what they saw as a huge liability out of the equation.

Top