Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / CaptainFantastic

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TragicHero: Ben. Highly intelligent, charismatic and extremely physically fit, he's raising his kids to be "philosopher kings" with all his attributes. However, his FatalFlaw is his distrust of the standard urban society he left behind and his intolerance of that lifestyle. While the film shows there's much truth to his beliefs, it also leads to Leslie dying from suicide when her bipolar disorder didn't get better living in the wild as he thought, leaving it too late to get her proper treatment. Later, it [[spoiler:leads to his nearly losing his kids when his total inflexibility leads to first clashing with Rellian and Bo as they want to explore the outside world, then nearly getting Vespyr killed in a supremely-ill judged attempt to "save" Rellian from his grandparents]].

to:

* TragicHero: Ben. Highly intelligent, charismatic and extremely physically fit, he's raising his kids to be "philosopher kings" with all his attributes. However, his FatalFlaw is his distrust of the standard urban society he left behind and his intolerance of that lifestyle. While the film shows there's much truth to his beliefs, it also leads to Leslie dying from suicide when her bipolar disorder didn't get better living in the wild as he thought, leaving it too late to get her proper treatment. Later, it [[spoiler:leads to his nearly losing his kids when his total inflexibility leads to first clashing with Rellian and Bo as they want to explore the outside world, then nearly getting Vespyr killed in a supremely-ill judged supremely ill-judged attempt to "save" Rellian from his grandparents]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoubleEntendre: Bo accidentally drops a classic one one of these during his ill-fated proposal to Claire;

to:

* DoubleEntendre: Bo accidentally drops a classic one one of these during his ill-fated proposal to Claire;
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Bo:''' The way she has opened me up, she has penetrated deep, deep inside of me, and I know that I have penetrated deep, deep inside of your daughter. And...[realises what he's just said, starts stuttering] but not - not like that.

to:

--> '''Bo:''' The way she has opened me up, she has penetrated deep, deep inside of me, and I know that I have penetrated deep, deep inside of your daughter. And...[realises what he's just said, starts stuttering] [[ThatCameOutWrong but not - not like that.that]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DoubleEntendre: Bo accidentally drops a classic one one of these during his ill-fated proposal to Claire;
--> '''Bo:''' The way she has opened me up, she has penetrated deep, deep inside of me, and I know that I have penetrated deep, deep inside of your daughter. And...[realises what he's just said, starts stuttering] but not - not like that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DotingGrandparent: While Jack feuds with Ben on various points he does his best to make sure the conflict doesn't affect his grandkids; he's still happy to see them after the funeral, and treats them very well during their stay, even trying their workout routine with them. His wife Abigail is an even straighter example, with none of Jack's antagonism towards Ben. He also promises to take care of Bo's college tuition.

to:

* DotingGrandparent: While Jack feuds with Ben on various points he does his best to make sure the conflict doesn't affect his grandkids; he's still happy to see them after the funeral, and treats them very well during their stay, even trying their workout routine with them.them and promising a worried Ben he'll take care of Bo's college tuition. His wife Abigail is an even straighter example, with none of Jack's antagonism towards Ben. He also promises to take care of Bo's college tuition.



* ParentsAsPeople: Ben clearly loves his kids, has raised them to be very intelligent and capable and honestly thinks he's doing what is best for them but he struggles to accept that they want to live their own lives now and that may not include continuing to do things as he does and he also struggles to accept that, for all the benefits of how he raised them, there were also negative side effects such as an impaired ability to form relationships with people outside their circle.

to:

* ParentsAsPeople: Ben clearly loves his kids, has raised them to be very intelligent and capable and honestly thinks he's doing what is best for them but he struggles to accept that they want to live their own lives now now, and that may not include continuing to do things as he does and he does. He also struggles to accept that, for all the benefits of how he raised them, there were also negative side effects such as an impaired ability to form relationships with people outside their circle.

Added: 484

Changed: 55

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DotingGrandparent: While Jack feuds with Ben on various points he does his best to make sure the conflict doesn't affect his grandkids; he's still happy to see them after the funeral, and treats them very well during their stay, even trying their workout routine with them. His wife Abigail is an even straighter example, with none of Jack's antagonism towards Ben.

to:

* DotingGrandparent: While Jack feuds with Ben on various points he does his best to make sure the conflict doesn't affect his grandkids; he's still happy to see them after the funeral, and treats them very well during their stay, even trying their workout routine with them. His wife Abigail is an even straighter example, with none of Jack's antagonism towards Ben. He also promises to take care of Bo's college tuition.


Added DiffLines:

* ParentsAsPeople: Ben clearly loves his kids, has raised them to be very intelligent and capable and honestly thinks he's doing what is best for them but he struggles to accept that they want to live their own lives now and that may not include continuing to do things as he does and he also struggles to accept that, for all the benefits of how he raised them, there were also negative side effects such as an impaired ability to form relationships with people outside their circle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Ben:''' Then maybe one of you should have shot the fucking sheep!

to:

-->'''Ben:''' --->'''Ben:''' Then maybe one of you should have shot the fucking sheep!



--> '''Nai:''' Let's dig. Otherwise she has to lie under that bullshit forever.

to:

--> ---> '''Nai:''' Let's dig. Otherwise she has to lie under that bullshit forever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EveryoneHasStandards: She seems to be OK hunting and later butchering wild animals , but Kielyr's completely freaked out when she stalks and prepares to shoot a sheep, which, being domesticated, have no instinct to flee or fight back around humans. Ben is competely bewildered by this as his daughter retreats in disgust.

to:

* EveryoneHasStandards: She seems to be OK hunting and later butchering wild animals , animals, but Kielyr's completely freaked out when she stalks and prepares to shoot a sheep, which, being domesticated, have has no instinct to flee or fight back around humans. Ben is competely bewildered by this as his daughter retreats in disgust.

Added: 140

Changed: 137

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PrecisionFStrike:When an upset Nai complains he's hungry after Ben has had a multilingual argument with the equally stressed twins, he gets this response;

to:

* PrecisionFStrike:When PrecisionFStrike:
** When
an upset Nai complains he's hungry after Ben has had a multilingual argument with the equally stressed twins, he gets this response;
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ToughLove: While not taken to extremes (most other scenes show him being somewhat softer), the climbing scene shows Ben's policy of self-reliance can be this. When Rellian falls none of his family make a move to help, with Ben lecturing him that no-one will magically save him and that he has to help himself - which he does, with an injured hand.

to:

* ToughLove: While not taken to extremes (most other scenes show him being somewhat softer), the climbing scene shows Ben's policy of self-reliance can be this. When Rellian falls none of his family make a move to help, with Ben lecturing him that no-one will magically save him and that he has to help himself - which he does, with an injured hand. Given the particulars of this trope, it's perhaps not surprising this incident is specifically cited by Jack later in the film as proof Ben is physically abusing his children.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ToughLove: While not taken to extremes (most other secnes show him being somewhat softer), the climbing scene shows Ben's policy of self-reliance can be this. When Rellian falls none of his family make a move to help, with Ben lecturing him that no-one will magically save him and that he has to help himself - which he does, with an injured hand.

to:

* ToughLove: While not taken to extremes (most other secnes scenes show him being somewhat softer), the climbing scene shows Ben's policy of self-reliance can be this. When Rellian falls none of his family make a move to help, with Ben lecturing him that no-one will magically save him and that he has to help himself - which he does, with an injured hand.

Added: 919

Changed: 558

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EveryoneHasStandards: She seems to be OK hunting and later butchering wild animals , but Kielyr's completely freaked out when she stalks and prepares to shoot a sheep, which, being domesticated, have no instinct to flee or fight back around humans. Ben is competely bewildered by this as his daughter retreats in disgust.
-->'''Kielyr:''' They're just standing there!



* PoliticallyIncorrectHero: Ben. He fakes a heart attack to steal food. He offers a book named "The Joy of Sex" to Nai, a very young boy. Since he's not interested, he offers him Rellian's large Bowie knife to play with. Later, in a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment, he's shown not only reading ''ComicBook/{{Maus}}'' to Nai at his sister's house, but explaining to him what [[UsefulNotes/TheHolocaust the showers]] actually did.

to:

* PoliticallyIncorrectHero: Ben. He He's anti-capitalist/anti-consumerist to the point he fakes a heart attack to so the kids can steal food. food, despite scenes before and after establishing he has no money worries. Vespyr indicates that while he's raised the family to not make fun of anyone, Christians are the only [[AcceptableReligiousTargets fair game]]. He offers a book named "The Joy of Sex" to Nai, a very young boy. Since Nai (a six-year old) after he earlier queried him about it - and since he's not interested, he offers gives him Rellian's large Bowie a Ka-Bar knife to play with.with instead. Later, in a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment, he's shown not only reading ''ComicBook/{{Maus}}'' to Nai at his sister's house, but explaining to him what [[UsefulNotes/TheHolocaust the showers]] actually did.



* PrecisionFStrike: A spectacular one, from 6-year-old Nai of all people, as he sees [[spoiler:his mother's Christian headstone]].

to:

* PrecisionFStrike: PrecisionFStrike:When an upset Nai complains he's hungry after Ben has had a multilingual argument with the equally stressed twins, he gets this response;
-->'''Ben:''' Then maybe one of you should have shot the fucking sheep!
**
A spectacular one, one later in the film, from 6-year-old Nai of all people, as he sees [[spoiler:his mother's Christian headstone]].


Added DiffLines:

* ToughLove: While not taken to extremes (most other secnes show him being somewhat softer), the climbing scene shows Ben's policy of self-reliance can be this. When Rellian falls none of his family make a move to help, with Ben lecturing him that no-one will magically save him and that he has to help himself - which he does, with an injured hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Badass Mustache and Badass Beard are being merged into Manly Facial Hair. Examples that don't fit or are zero-context are removed. To qualify for Manly Facial Hair, the facial hair must be associated with masculinity in some way. Please read the trope description before readding to make sure the example qualifies.


* BadassBeard: Ben sports an impressive beard, and he's an athletic, intellectual survivor. His [[spoiler:shaving it off after leaving the kids with Jack and Abigail]] is indicative of the CharacterDevelopment he experiences after the events described in the BreakTheHaughty entry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TrainingMontage: Including physical exercising, landfarming and art expression, the family members are timing their days with various activities.

to:

* TrainingMontage: Including Ben spaces out the family's days with set amounts of time on various activities, including physical exercising, landfarming and art expression, the family members are timing their days with various activities. expression.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not a trope


* UsefulNotes/TheOtherRainforest: The first part of the film is set in the Cash family's home in the Washington forest, with the scenery shooting taking place both in Washington and Oregon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UsefulNotes/TheOtherRainforest: The first part of the film is set in the Cash family's home in the Washington forest, with the scenery shooting taking place both in Washington and Oregon.

Added: 121

Changed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoPeekingRequest: Ben asks his children not to look before bringing out gifts for them to celebrate "Noam Chomsky Day".



-->'''Ben:''' Leslie and I are their teachers. [[FreudianSlip Are -- were their teachers]].
-->'''Jack:''' So you're teaching them to steal?
-->'''Ben:''' Of course not.
-->'''Jack:''' "Mission: free the food"?
-->'''Ben:''' ...that was part of their training.
-->'''Jack:''' [[DistinctionWithoutADifference So you're training them to steal?]]

to:

-->'''Ben:''' Leslie and I are their teachers. [[FreudianSlip Are -- were their teachers]].
-->'''Jack:'''
teachers]].\\
'''Jack:'''
So you're teaching them to steal?
-->'''Ben:'''
steal?\\
'''Ben:'''
Of course not.
-->'''Jack:'''
not.\\
'''Jack:'''
"Mission: free the food"?
-->'''Ben:''' ...
food"?\\
'''Ben:''' ...
that was part of their training.
-->'''Jack:'''
training.\\
'''Jack:'''
[[DistinctionWithoutADifference So you're training them to steal?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RunningGag: Nai asking his father "What's-?" after hearing a new (and often fairly mature) word or phrase.

to:

* RunningGag: Nai asking his father "What's-?" after hearing a new (and often fairly mature) word or phrase. There's also Zaja's expertly matter-of-fact running commentary on ways to die whenever the family does physical training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbusiveParents: Some of Ben's decisions may be seen this way. [[spoiler:Jack even threatens to sue him for it]].

to:

* AbusiveParents: Some of Ben's decisions may be seen this way. [[spoiler:Jack even threatens to sue him for it]].it after Rellian runs away to live with him, pointing out their training regime has left him with cuts and bruises all over his body, including an untreated broken hand]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Keilyr can only chuckle at Ben's (jokingly) telling her to kill her sister in response to her objecting to his praising Vespyr for accidentally stabbing her in a training session.

to:

** Keilyr can only chuckle at Ben's (jokingly) telling her to kill her sister in response to her objecting after she objects to his praising Vespyr for accidentally stabbing her in a training session.



* AlcoholInducedIdiocy: It's subtle, but Ben's clearly had a good bit of red wine to drink when Bo confronts him - the bottle he has is visibly empty by the time Bo arrives - which might explain his unusually harsh and mocking response to [[spoiler:Bo revealing he's been accepted by every major college, with his mother's help, no less]].

to:

* AlcoholInducedIdiocy: It's subtle, but Ben's clearly had a good bit of red wine to drink when Bo confronts him - the bottle he has is visibly empty by the time Bo arrives - which might explain his unusually harsh and mocking response to [[spoiler:Bo revealing he's been accepted by every major college, with his mother's help, no less]].



* ObnoxiousInLaws: Zigzagged. It's made clear that while Ben's relationships with his in-laws are tempestuous, it's largely due to both sides lacking a middle ground to truly understand each other's way of life.
** While Ben and Jack hardly get on, to the point of threatening to call the cops, many of Jack's issues are shown to have at least some validity to them. It's unspoken but made clear that Jack is trying to remember a daughter he long since ceased to know as she was - something Ben serves as a constant reminder of. Their last conversation is at least fairly respectful, with Jack implicitly acknowledging Ben's love for Leslie when he sees him gazing wistfully at old photos of her.

to:

* ObnoxiousInLaws: Zigzagged. It's made clear that while While Ben's relationships with his in-laws are tempestuous, it's largely due to both sides lacking a middle ground to truly understand each other's way of life.
** While Ben and Jack hardly get on, to the point of threatening to call the cops, many of Jack's issues are shown to have at least some validity to them. It's unspoken but made clear strongly implied that Jack is trying to remember a daughter he long since ceased to know as she was - something Ben serves as a constant reminder of. Their last conversation is at least fairly respectful, with Jack implicitly acknowledging Ben's love for Leslie when he sees him gazing wistfully at old photos of her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmorPiercingQuestion: Rellian puts one of these to Bo in the aftermath of the disastrous funeral; when Bo scoffs at his suggestion that their father is dangerous and made their mother sick, an emotional Rellian asks him if he really thinks their lives are so great, or that Ben is so perfect. He storms off, but it drives a visibly contemplative Bo to confron his father, culminating in the entry directly below.

to:

* ArmorPiercingQuestion: Rellian puts one of these to Bo in the aftermath of the disastrous funeral; when Bo scoffs at his suggestion that their father is dangerous and made their mother sick, an emotional Rellian asks him if he really thinks their lives are so great, or that Ben is so perfect. He storms off, but it drives a visibly contemplative Bo to confron confront his father, culminating in the entry directly below.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlcoholInducedIdiocy: It's subtle, but Ben's clearly had a good bit of red wine to drink when Bo confronts him -the bottle he has is visibly empty by the time Bo arrives - which might explain his unusually harsh and mocking response to [[spoiler:Bo revealing he's been accepted by every major college, with his mother's help, no less]].

to:

* AlcoholInducedIdiocy: It's subtle, but Ben's clearly had a good bit of red wine to drink when Bo confronts him -the - the bottle he has is visibly empty by the time Bo arrives - which might explain his unusually harsh and mocking response to [[spoiler:Bo revealing he's been accepted by every major college, with his mother's help, no less]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlcoholInducedIdiocy: It's subtle, but Ben's clearly had a good bit of red wine to drink when Bo confronts him -the bottle he has is visibly empty by the time Bo arrives - which might explain his unusually harsh and mocking response to [[spoiler:Bo revealing he's been accepted by every major college, with his mother's help, no less]].
* ArmorPiercingQuestion: Rellian puts one of these to Bo in the aftermath of the disastrous funeral; when Bo scoffs at his suggestion that their father is dangerous and made their mother sick, an emotional Rellian asks him if he really thinks their lives are so great, or that Ben is so perfect. He storms off, but it drives a visibly contemplative Bo to confron his father, culminating in the entry directly below.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Leslie's favorite song was ''[[Music/GunsNRoses Sweet Child o' Mine]]''. The family, led by Kielyr as lead, sing this as a tribute to her at [[spoiler:her cremation]].

to:

** Leslie's favorite song was ''[[Music/GunsNRoses Sweet Child o' Mine]]''. The family, led by Kielyr as lead, Kielyr, sing this as a tribute to her at [[spoiler:her cremation]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LudicrousPrecision: When Ben claims that the mother hasn't been gone very long, Keilyr replies that it has been "three months, two weeks, six days, and 11 hours."

to:

* LudicrousPrecision: When Ben claims that the mother Leslie hasn't been gone very long, Keilyr replies that it has been "three months, two weeks, six days, and 11 hours."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassBeard: Ben sports an impressive beard, and he's an athletic, intellectual survivor. His [[spoiler:shaving it off after leaving the kids with Jack and Abigail]] is indicative of the CharacterGrowth he experiences after the events described in the BreakTheHaughty entry.

to:

* BadassBeard: Ben sports an impressive beard, and he's an athletic, intellectual survivor. His [[spoiler:shaving it off after leaving the kids with Jack and Abigail]] is indicative of the CharacterGrowth CharacterDevelopment he experiences after the events described in the BreakTheHaughty entry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassBeard: Ben sports an impressive beard, and he's an athletic, intellectual survivor.

to:

* BadassBeard: Ben sports an impressive beard, and he's an athletic, intellectual survivor. His [[spoiler:shaving it off after leaving the kids with Jack and Abigail]] is indicative of the CharacterGrowth he experiences after the events described in the BreakTheHaughty entry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the bus, Kielyr has to discourse about ''Literature/{{Lolita}}'' when Ben sees her reading it.

to:

** In the bus, Kielyr has to discourse about ''Literature/{{Lolita}}'' when Ben sees her reading it. [[https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/sep/11/captain-fantastic-review-viggo-mortensen Quite]] [[https://anthonyjflorez.wordpress.com/2017/01/03/captain-fantastic-a-beautiful-mistake/ a]] [[https://www.thestateofthearts.co.uk/features/film-review-matt-rosss-captain-fantastic/ few]] [[https://www.maltatoday.com.mt/arts/film/70717/film_review_my_family_other_wild_animals reviews]] have drawn parallels between how Humbert and Ben are portrayed semi-sympathetically despite often not being so due to so much of their narratives being from their POV.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MundaneObjectAmazement: The kids are amazed (and, aside from Rellian, appalled) by their cousin's videogames.

to:

* MundaneObjectAmazement: The kids are amazed (and, aside from Rellian, appalled) by their cousin's cousins' videogames.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MundaneObjectAmazement: The kids are amazed (and, aside from Rellian, appalled) by their cousin's videogames,

to:

* MundaneObjectAmazement: The kids are amazed (and, aside from Rellian, appalled) by their cousin's videogames,videogames.

Top