Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / FunHome

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CompositeCharacter: Sort-of.
** Roy retains his book (and real life) position as the Bechdel babysitter and target of Bruce's affections, but also absorbs elements of the other similarly aged (and sometimes underaged) boys Bruce would have encounters with. (The scene in which Bruce attempts to seduce him is based on Bruce attempting to seduce an entirely different former student of his in the graphic memoir.)
** [[PlayedWithTrope Played with]] in terms of Helen. She not only gains the above mentioned AdaptationalHeroism, but also seems to gain aspects of her real life character that were only ever really explored in ''ComicBook/AreYouMyMother'' rather than ''ComicBook/FunHome''-- such as giving Alison "the way out" of a life of regrets.
** Big Alison, of course, exists in real life as illustrator Alison Bechdel. But Big Alison didn't exist as a narrative device in the original book-- in some ways, her meta commentary and self-deconstructive thoughts on her own work run closer to the narrative framing of ''ComicBook/AreYouMyMother'', in which a Big Alison (of-sorts) ''does'' appear to discuss the creation of the original ''ComicBook/FunHome''. Passing bits of Alison's later adulthood that are expressed through Big Alison in the musical are also pulled from ''ComicBook/AreYouMyMother''.

Added: 1377

Changed: 340

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Alison's family gets more screen-time, mainly her brothers and mother, so that we see more CharacterDevelopment. We also get more screentime with Joan, who serves as an AudienceSurrogate when Alison receives the phone call and learns about her father having affairs.

to:

* AdaptationDistillation: Alison's experiences in New York, both the bicentennial she spent with her family and her early post-undergraduate career, are much less important.
* AdaptationExpansion: Conversely, Alison's family gets more screen-time, mainly her brothers and mother, so that we see more CharacterDevelopment. We also get more screentime with Joan, who serves as an AudienceSurrogate when Alison receives the phone call and learns about her father having affairs.


Added DiffLines:

* AdaptedOut: As mentioned in AbledInTheAdaptation, some important events of Alison's childhood go unmentioned:
** Alison's lengthy experience with OCD is cut, as mentioned above-- despite the effect this also had on her record-keeping.
** Bruce's court summons for purchasing a minor alcohol around the same time, (and very likely attempting to sleep with him), his resulting consultation with a psychiatrist, and the tension this adds in his marriage with Helen go unmentioned as well.
** Despite more appearances from Helen, her community acting career and simultaneous earning of her master's degree are also much less present than they were in the book.
* AdaptationalTimespanChange: As mentioned in PlotRelevantAgeUp, several events in Alison's life are moved from their points both in graphic memoir and from when they occurred in real life. In the musical, Alison enters Oberlin for a full four years as a freshman-- while not explicitly discussed in the book, Alison entered Oberlin College as a junior after earning an associate's degree at Bard College at Simon's Rock.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BleachedUnderpants: [[DownplayedTrope Downplayed.]] While "Changing My Major" and other scenes explicitly discuss Alison and Joan's sexual experiences with one another while dating, the musical of course removes the outright depiction of sex that were present in the graphic novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WrongAssumption: When Alison comes out of the closet, she considers herself some sort of dramatic heroine. When her mother reveals that her father is also gay and closeted, she realizes she's actually only the comic relief in her father's tragedy.

to:

* WrongAssumption: When Alison comes out of the closet, she considers herself some sort of dramatic heroine. When her mother reveals that her father is also gay and closeted, she realizes begins to feel that she's actually only the comic relief in her father's tragedy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[ZigZaggingTrope Zig-zagged]], as ''ComicBook/AreYouMyMother'' reveals in its later chapters that Alison believes that Helen "gave her the way out," much in the same way Helen openly expresses these sentiments in the musical. Helen's real-life letters were also very concerned about the effect of Alison's coming-out on Alison herself-- however, ''ComicBook/AreYouMyMother'' also indicates Helen took years to substantially express any open approval of Alison's choices, much less her lesbianism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In a meta sense, the last line of the musical adapts a portion of the first page of the book.
--> Musical
---> "Caption: Every so often, there was a rare moment of perfect balance, when I soared above him."
--> Graphic Novel
---> "Caption: It was a discomfort well worth the rare physical contact, and certainly worth the moment of perfect balance when I soared above him.""

Changed: 1597

Removed: 526

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
You can't do ACI for other people in your life.


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
** InUniverse. Alison and her girlfriend were fond of doing this to classic childhood literature. "God, [[Franchise/WinnieThePooh Christopher Robin]] was a total imperialist!"
** Also of her father. She admits freely that suicide is only her interpretation of his death, and she can never know for sure whether it is correct (the truck driver who hit him said that Bruce had made it to the side of the road, but then suddenly jumped backward "as if he saw a snake"). When telling of things he did, she offers several different versions of what could have been the motivations behind them.
** She also admits that she may be oversimplifying things by automatically defining him as 'gay', rather than bi- or anything else in-between, for the sake of maintaining a sense of symmetry with her own life.
%%* AnachronicOrder
* AudienceSurrogate: Alison's first girlfriend Joan when she sees the Bechdel family home for the first time. "You described it, but I had ''no'' idea."
* TheBeard: It's never stated explicitly, but Bruce is hinted to have married Helen for this reason, though the follow-up ''Are You My Mother'' does briefly acknowledge he could have been bisexual.
* BlackComedy: The Bechdel kids playing in the coffins in the family funeral home, and the whole song "Come to the Fun Home," which is a fake commerical with really dark lyrics.

to:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
**
AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: InUniverse. Alison and her girlfriend were fond of doing this to classic childhood literature. "God, [[Franchise/WinnieThePooh Christopher Robin]] was a total imperialist!"
** Also of her father. She admits freely that suicide is only her interpretation of his death, * AnachronicOrder: The book and she can never know for sure whether it is correct (the truck driver who hit him said that Bruce had made it to the side of the road, but then suddenly jumped backward "as if he saw a snake"). When telling of things he did, she offers several musical jump back and forth between different versions periods of what could have been the motivations behind them.
** She also admits that
Alison's life as she may be oversimplifying things by automatically defining him as 'gay', rather than bi- or anything else in-between, for the sake of maintaining a sense of symmetry deconstructs her relationship with her own life.
%%* AnachronicOrder
father and her sexuality. The musical makes this even more clear, as there are three actresses to represent Alison during various periods of her life, and their scenes are jumbled up in order with the oldest Alison commenting on them all.
* AudienceSurrogate: Alison's first girlfriend Joan is just as incredulous as the reader when she sees the Bechdel family home for the first time. "You described it, but I had ''no'' idea."
* TheBeard: It's never stated explicitly, but Bruce is hinted to have married Helen for this reason, to cover his homosexuality, though the follow-up ''Are You My Mother'' does briefly acknowledge he could have been bisexual.
* BlackComedy: The Bechdel kids playing in the coffins in the family funeral home, and the whole song "Come to the Fun Home," Home" in the musical, which is a fake commerical with really dark lyrics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlotTriggeringAffair: Much of Helen's anguish is dealing with Bruce's numerous affairs. It's no picnic for Alison, either, once she finds out, which spurs her own exploration of the family and its issues.

to:

* PlotTriggeringAffair: PlotIncitingInfidelity: Much of Helen's anguish is dealing with Bruce's numerous affairs. It's no picnic for Alison, either, once she finds out, which spurs her own exploration of the family and its issues.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PlotTriggeringAffair: Much of Helen's anguish is dealing with Bruce's numerous affairs. It's no picnic for Alison, either, once she finds out, which spurs her own exploration of the family and its issues.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer a trope.


* YourCheatingHeart: Much of Helen's anguish is dealing with Bruce's numerous affairs. It's no picnic for Alison, either, once she finds out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalAngstUpgrade: Alison in the book freely admits that she and her brothers didn't grieve normally when their father died. They instead grinned at each other during the funeral and she laughed while telling a friend. In the book, she has a matter-of-fact approach about analyzing his life. In the musical, Alison is screaming at her dead father, asking if her coming out of the closet spurred his suicide. She also desperately begs for her last memory of him to be more than an awkward conversation.

Added: 280

Changed: 154

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Alison's family gets more screen-time, mainly her brothers and mother, so that we see more CharacterDevelopment.

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: Alison's family gets more screen-time, mainly her brothers and mother, so that we see more CharacterDevelopment. We also get more screentime with Joan, who serves as an AudienceSurrogate when Alison receives the phone call and learns about her father having affairs.



* MoodWhiplash: Before the heartbreaking "Telephone Wire," which features Alison's last conversation with her father, she finds out how he made Joan one of the family; by giving her silverware to polish. Joan even sheepishly stops polishing and says her dad was very persuasive.



** Also of her father. She admits freely that suicide is only her interpretation of his death, and she can never know for sure whether it is correct (the truck driver who hit him said that Bruce had made it to the side of the road, but then suddenly jumped backwards "as if he saw a snake"). When telling of things he did, she offers several different versions of what could have been the motivations behind them.

to:

** Also of her father. She admits freely that suicide is only her interpretation of his death, and she can never know for sure whether it is correct (the truck driver who hit him said that Bruce had made it to the side of the road, but then suddenly jumped backwards backward "as if he saw a snake"). When telling of things he did, she offers several different versions of what could have been the motivations behind them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Fun Home'' is a 2006 comic memoir by Alison Bechdel, creator of ''ComicStrip/DykesToWatchOutFor''. The story focuses on her growing up in rural Pennsylvania, living under her oppressive father, Bruce, a high-school teacher and funeral home director. It also focuses on his history, how he came to be, and his lifelong project of restoring a dilapidated Victorian-era mansion. As she asserts her independence and comes to accept her orientation as a lesbian, she discovers that her father is gay and closeted. Soon after Alison comes out, he is hit by a truck, which she believes to have been suicide.

to:

''Fun Home'' is a 2006 comic memoir by Alison Bechdel, Creator/AlisonBechdel, creator of ''ComicStrip/DykesToWatchOutFor''. The story focuses on her growing up in rural Pennsylvania, living under her oppressive father, Bruce, a high-school teacher and funeral home director. It also focuses on his history, how he came to be, and his lifelong project of restoring a dilapidated Victorian-era mansion. As she asserts her independence and comes to accept her orientation as a lesbian, she discovers that her father is gay and closeted. Soon after Alison comes out, he is hit by a truck, which she believes to have been suicide.

Added: 1163

Changed: 624

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ApatheticTeacher: Bruce doesn't like his job much, despite genuinely loving the books he assigns to his students. Said students don't seem to care at all. He's delighted when Alison begins taking his class, because she actually ''reads the books'' -- and understands them.



* NoPeriodsPeriod: Averted; Alison gets her first period at 13, but doesn't tell anyone for several months. She also notes a fair amount of distaste for the experience, since her first few cycles look like "a slight, brown secretion".[[note]]This is often the case with a girl's first periods, and even later in life the blood from menstruation is often dark red or brownish-red, not the vivid color of blood from a cut or wound[[/note]]

to:

* PetTheDog: One genuinely nice moment between Alison and Bruce, when she begins taking his English class in high school, and it quickly becomes evident that she's the only one who actually bothered to do the assigned reading. Bruce genuinely appreciates Alison's attentiveness and intelligence, and she happily discusses the reading in class.
-->'''Bruce:''' You're the only one in that class worth teaching.\\
'''Alison:''' It's the only class I have worth taking.
* NoPeriodsPeriod: Averted; Alison gets her first period at 13, but doesn't tell anyone for several months. She also notes a fair amount of distaste for the experience, since her first few cycles look like "a slight, brown secretion".[[note]]This is often the case with a girl's first periods, and even later in life the blood from menstruation is often dark red or brownish-red, not the vivid color of blood from a cut or wound[[/note]]wound.[[/note]]


Added DiffLines:

* AbledInTheAdaptation:
** Alison's OCD is cut, despite it being hugely disruptive to her day-to-day life when she was a teenager.
** Joan having a glass eye due to a childhood accident is also cut.


Added DiffLines:

* AscendedExtra: Joan gets far more to do in the musical than she does in the book, though she's still not exactly a "main" character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Could also be interpreted as a case of DoubleStandard regarding homosexual vs. heterosexual infidelity - she would have been much angrier at her father had he cheated on her mother with women instead of men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She also admits that she may be oversimplifying things by automatically defining him as 'gay', rather than bi- or anything else in-between, for the sake of maintaining a sense of symmetry with her own life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
no critical reception on work pages


The book took seven years to make. The art was painstakingly reconstructed from family photographs, alongside the panels Alison herself posed for. Upon its release, ''Fun Home'' was well received critically, and is held up as an exemplary work of both its medium and its genre.

to:

The book took seven years to make. The art was painstakingly reconstructed from family photographs, alongside the panels Alison herself posed for. Upon its release, ''Fun Home'' was well received critically, and is held up as an exemplary work of both its medium and its genre.\n



* WrongGenreSavvy: When Alison comes out of the closet, she considers herself some sort of dramatic heroine. When her mother reveals that her father is also gay and closeted, she realizes she's actually only the comic relief in her father's tragedy.

to:

* WrongGenreSavvy: WrongAssumption: When Alison comes out of the closet, she considers herself some sort of dramatic heroine. When her mother reveals that her father is also gay and closeted, she realizes she's actually only the comic relief in her father's tragedy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->--'''Welcome to Our House on Maple Avenue'''

to:

-->--'''Welcome -->-- '''Welcome to Our House on Maple Avenue'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foil}}: Bruce and Alison, especially in the musical. Both grew up in the same small town, both turned out to be gay. Alison handled it considerably better than Bruce did, at least partially due to going to college in a time period that was rather more accepting of the LGBT community. Consequentially, Alison grows up to be a happy, well-adjusted, openly gay adult, while her father remains closeted his entire life, carries out several affairs in his marriage, and kills himself. To drive the point home in the musical, the two sing many of the same lyrics, with different contexts and meanings.

to:

* {{Foil}}: Bruce and Alison, especially in the musical. Both grew up in the same small town, both turned out to be gay. Alison handled it considerably better than Bruce did, at least partially due to going to college in a time period that was rather more accepting of the LGBT community. Consequentially, Alison grows up to be a happy, well-adjusted, openly gay adult, while her father remains closeted his entire life, carries out several affairs in his marriage, and kills himself. To drive the point home in the musical, the two sing many of the same lyrics, with different contexts and meanings. In the book, this is acknowledged by Alison mentioning that an old-fashioned term for gay people was "inverts", and jokes that she liked it because they were like inverted versions of each other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
He was attending the funeral and the Bechdel family were Catholic


* ImagineSpot: Alison has a brief imaginary outburst at her father's funeral of yelling at the minister. The next panel cuts back to reality, where she is quiet and polite.

to:

* ImagineSpot: Alison has a brief imaginary outburst at her father's funeral of yelling at the minister.mourner. The next panel cuts back to reality, where she is quiet and polite.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


%% ZeroContextExample entries are not allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out. Add context to the entries before uncommenting them.

to:

%% ZeroContextExample Administrivia/ZeroContextExample entries are not allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out. Add context to the entries before uncommenting them.

Added: 111

Changed: 109

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* DarkReprise: Helen Bechdel's "Days and Days" in the musical is a dark reprisal of "Welcome to Our House in Maple Avenue."

to:

* DarkReprise: DarkReprise:
**
Helen Bechdel's "Days and Days" in the musical is a dark reprisal of "Welcome to Our House in Maple Avenue."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GayngstInducedSuicide: You can see the contemplation of her closeted gay father's death and its later ruling as suicide. She deals with this during accepting her own homosexuality. It aimed to be a heartwarming family story, but the musical [[https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2016/04/branding-queerness-the-curious-case-of-fun-home/479532/ was still nicknamed the "lesbian suicide musical" by its marketing team]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** {{In-universe}}. Alison and her girlfriend were fond of doing this to classic childhood literature. "God, [[Franchise/WinnieThePooh Christopher Robin]] was a total imperialist!"

to:

** {{In-universe}}.InUniverse. Alison and her girlfriend were fond of doing this to classic childhood literature. "God, [[Franchise/WinnieThePooh Christopher Robin]] was a total imperialist!"



** Demonstrated {{in-universe}} during Alison's literature class.

to:

** Demonstrated {{in-universe}} InUniverse during Alison's literature class.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bruce was also not the nicest parents, tearing up library books, yelling at his children for normal childlike behavior, micromanaging Alison's dress style because she's the only girl in the family,

to:

** Bruce was also not the nicest parents, parent, tearing up library books, yelling at his children for normal childlike behavior, micromanaging Alison's dress style because she's the only girl in the family,



** For Alison, the fear that she may have caused her father's "suicide," if it was a suicide, because she was willing to come out of the closet when he wasn't. In the comic she wonders what it might have been like if he ''has'' come out and succumbed to the [=AIDs=] epidemic, making his death more painful.

to:

** For Alison, the fear that she may have caused her father's "suicide," if it was a suicide, because she was willing to come out of the closet when he wasn't. In the comic she wonders what it might have been like if he ''has'' ''had'' come out and succumbed to the [=AIDs=] [=AIDS=] epidemic, making his death more painful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TurnOutLikeHisFather: Bechdel spends much of the book looking back on her childhood with a new perspective after she learns her dad is gay.

to:

* TurnOutLikeHisFather: Bechdel spends much of Allegedly the book looking back on her childhood cause of Helen's discomfort with a new perspective after she learns her dad is gay.Alison's sexual orientation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IWantSong: In the musical, "Welcome to Our House on Maple Avenue" is a "He [Bruce] wants" song. Then a more subtle straight example in "Ring of Keys," when young Alison, while having trouble articulating it, realizes she wants to dress similarly to the butch delivery woman.

to:

* IWantSong: In the musical, "Welcome to Our House on Maple Avenue" is a "He [Bruce] wants" song. Then a more subtle straight example in "Ring of Keys," when young Alison, while having trouble articulating it, realizes she wants to dress similarly to be like the butch delivery woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** {{In-universe}}. Alison and her girlfriend were fond of doing this to classic childhood literature. "God, [[WinnieThePooh Christopher Robin]] was a total imperialist!"

to:

** {{In-universe}}. Alison and her girlfriend were fond of doing this to classic childhood literature. "God, [[WinnieThePooh [[Franchise/WinnieThePooh Christopher Robin]] was a total imperialist!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakeThat: ''A flair for the dramatic'' While not a song, has Allison calling out her dad to Joan after receiving a reply to her coming out letter believing that he doesn't know anything about what she's going through. Except it's before she finds out that her Dad [[spoiler: is gay]].

to:

* TakeThat: ''A flair for the dramatic'' While not a song, has Allison calling out her dad to Joan after receiving a reply to her coming out letter believing that he doesn't know anything about what she's going through. Except it's before she finds out that her Dad [[spoiler: is gay]].gay.

Top