Follow TV Tropes

Following

History CombatPragmatist / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Merlin}}'': Merlin is enough of a MagicKnight to give lower enemies a fair fight with a sword...but why would he do that when he could just use his magic to hit you with your own weapon, trip you up, drop tree branches on you, or disarm you and let his MasterSwordsman best friend KingArthur clobber you? He even cheats for Arthur in a few occasions, breaking the saddle girth on mounted knights and disarming Arthur's opponents even if it looks like Arthur could handle them, just in case.

to:

* ''Series/{{Merlin}}'': ''Series/{{Merlin|2008}}'': Merlin is enough of a MagicKnight to give lower enemies a fair fight with a sword...but why would he do that when he could just use his magic to hit you with your own weapon, trip you up, drop tree branches on you, or disarm you and let his MasterSwordsman best friend KingArthur clobber you? He even cheats for Arthur in a few occasions, breaking the saddle girth on mounted knights and disarming Arthur's opponents even if it looks like Arthur could handle them, just in case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Banshee}}'': After spending 15 years in prison, Lucas does not fight fair. During his fight with Sanchez he bites his opponent to get out of a choke hold. Later he breaks the guy's finger and then snaps his wrist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''[[Recap/Supergirl2015S3E8CrisisOnEarthXPart1 Crisis on Earth-X, Part 1]]'': During their fight with Prometheus-X in a (presumably Catholic) church, Sara Lance/White Canary grabs the incense censer, using it like a chain flail. While it doesn't hold up against a sword blade, it does allow her and Alex Danvers to get the upper-hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Series/{{Farscape}}'', Chiana is mostly a cheerful, kooky MsFanservice. Until she's genuinely pissed off and afraid for her life, in which case watch her set people alight or spray acid over them!

to:

* In ''Series/{{Farscape}}'', Chiana is mostly a cheerful, kooky MsFanservice. Until she's genuinely pissed off and afraid for her life, in which case watch her set people alight on fire or spray acid over them!

Added: 260

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Captain Malcolm Reynolds, especially, seeing that he has no problem hitting people from behind, turning a duel with swords into a fistfight, shooting horses that his enemies are using as cover, and even throwing people into jet turbines or, worse yet, [[NothingisScarier space]].

to:

** Captain Malcolm Reynolds, especially, seeing that he has no problem hitting people from behind, turning a duel with swords into a fistfight, shooting horses that his enemies are using as cover, and even throwing people into jet turbines or, worse yet, [[NothingisScarier space]]. space]].
** In one episode, where the crew join forces with a brothel to defend it from a ruthless and cruel baron and his armed men, Mal warns the girls to aim for the ''riders'', not the horses: a live, panicking horse is a good distraction, a dead one is good cover.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Stannis Baratheon might join a war where he has the smallest army because Law says so, but he's not above using witchcraft to quickly assassinate his enemies behind the lines rather than suicidally charging against them in the field.
--> '''Stannis:''' Cleaner ways don't win wars.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And then there's Money in the Bank, a [[GimmickMatches Gimmick Match]] whose winner can claim a title shot any time within the next year. It usually gets cashed in right after the current champ has gotten thoroughly beat up by someone else.

to:

** And then there's Money in the Bank, a [[GimmickMatches Gimmick Match]] whose winner can claim a title shot any time within the next year. It usually gets cashed in [[KickThemWhileTheyAreDown right after the current champ has gotten thoroughly beat up by someone else.else]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Jorah Mormont:
*** He has no qualms about fighting an unarmored foe with his armor on, and in fact makes that a principal piece of his strategy to win the fight.
*** In Season 3, he begins counseling Daenerys to take a more pragmatic approach to her campaign to retake Westeros, without concern for the morality of her actions, in opposition to the more idealistic advice given by Barristan Selmy.
*** In the fighting pits he beats another fighter by removing the opponent's helmet and beating him over the head with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Watch Sandor when he fights Polliver's men. He spends almost as much time punching his enemies in the face as he does tearing them apart with his sword — to say nothing of the man whose crotch he rips out. It speaks volumes of how little he thinks of honorable knightly standards.
--> '''Sandor:''' Your friend is dead and Meryn Trant's not, because Trant had armor and a big fucking sword.

Added: 505

Changed: 499

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/The100'': In most instances, no one on this show is able to fight fair if they want to survive but special mention goes to Clarke's fight with Anya. Over the course of the fight, Clarke throws ashes into Anya's eyes, pulls a knife on her unarmed opponent, and finally gains the upper hand by digging her fingers into an open wound that Anya had gotten earlier.

to:

* ''Series/The100'': ''Series/The100'':
**
In most instances, no one on this show is able to fight fair if they want to survive but special mention goes to Clarke's fight with Anya. Over the course of the fight, Clarke throws ashes into Anya's eyes, pulls a knife on her unarmed opponent, and finally gains the upper hand by digging her fingers into an open wound that Anya had gotten earlier.



* ''Series/LegendsOfTomorrow'': In "Shogun" Sara and TheDragon charge one another with swords...and Sara kills him with a hidden knife. [[SingleStrokeBattle In one stroke no less]].

to:

* ''Series/LegendsOfTomorrow'': ''Series/LegendsOfTomorrow'':
**
In "Shogun" Sara and TheDragon charge one another with swords...and Sara kills him with a hidden knife. [[SingleStrokeBattle In one stroke no less]].

Changed: 112

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/HawaiiFive0'': Somewhat PlayedForLaughs in the episode "Kekoa". Steve tells the Killer of the Week, a trained martial artist, to pick on someone his own size. The killer charges and Steve draws his gun and kneecaps him with an almost bored look on his face.

to:

* ''Series/HawaiiFive0'': Somewhat PlayedForLaughs in the episode "Kekoa". Steve tells the Killer of the Week, a trained martial artist, to pick on someone his own size. The killer charges and Steve draws his gun and kneecaps him with an almost bored look on his face. Note that Steve is a Navy SEAL, and probably could've held his own if he were stupid enough to go hand-to-hand.

Added: 1177

Changed: 578

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Bronn wins his fight as Tyrion Lannister's champion by tiring out his opponent with hit and run tactics instead of straight up dueling him, Lysa Arryn reproaches him: "You do not fight with honor." Bronn indicates his slain adversary and answers: "No. He did." When Bronn is called to retrain Jamie Lannister so he can learn how to fight while missing a hand, Bronn tries to teach him how to fight pragmatically, like attacking an opponent who isn't ready, but Jaime finds it in poor taste.

to:

** When Bronn doesn't believe in fighting fair, because he realizes that winning a battle depends on killing your opponent, not making it look noble. This earns him the contempt of some more traditional people who believe he's just fighting dirty.
*** When he
wins his fight as Tyrion Lannister's champion by tiring out his opponent with hit and run tactics instead of straight up dueling him, Lysa Arryn reproaches him: "You do not fight with honor." Bronn indicates his slain adversary and answers: "No. He did." "
***
When Bronn is called to retrain Jamie Lannister so he can learn how to fight while missing a hand, Bronn tries to teach him how to fight pragmatically, like attacking an opponent who isn't ready, ready. He tosses Jaime a blunted practice sword for their sparring and smacks Jaime's hand when he stoops to pick it up. Jaime protests he attacked when he wasn't on his guard; Bronn retorts that's the best time to attack, but Jaime finds it in poor taste.taste.
*** He refuses to wear the customary uniform of the City Watch after being appointed as commander. His simple explanation: capes slow you down in a fight.
*** He kills a Dothraki warrior who was fixated on killing him by using a ballista.
*** He never wears anything heavier than leather, which probably saves his life when he falls into the water during the battle against the Dothraki, while fully-armored Jaime is seen drowning before the screen fades to black.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Series/PowerRangersLightspeedRescue,'': Carter Grayson the Red Ranger. In the first episode he tries to run over the Batlings AND demons with a Humvee and is far quicker to draw a gun than most other Red Rangers who prefer flashy close quarters combat.

to:

* ''Series/PowerRangersLightspeedRescue,'': Carter Grayson the Red Ranger. In the first episode he tries to run over the Batlings AND demons with a Humvee and is far quicker to draw a gun than most other Red Rangers who prefer flashy close quarters combat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''Series/PowerRangersLightspeedRescue,'': Carter Grayson the Red Ranger. In the first episode he tries to run over the Batlings AND demons with a Humvee and is far quicker to draw a gun than most other Red Rangers who prefer flashy close quarters combat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Frank Castle in ''Series/ThePunisher'' is a massive combat pragmatist, just like his comic-book counterpart. When combined with his insane durability, it allows him to rip his opponents to shreds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Series/Banshee}} features Sheriff Lucas Hood, a hardened criminal who learned to fight in prison. He is also a ''ludicrously'' brutal fighter, with his fight against rapist and MMA champion Sanchez showcasing [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqRPaucl8r4 his full arsenal.]]

to:

* {{Series/Banshee}} ''{{Series/Banshee}}'' features Sheriff Lucas Hood, a hardened criminal who learned to fight in prison. He is also a ''ludicrously'' brutal fighter, with his fight against rapist and MMA champion Sanchez showcasing [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqRPaucl8r4 his full arsenal.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Series/Banshee}} features Sheriff Lucas Hood, a hardened criminal who learned to fight in prison. He is also a ''ludicrously'' brutal fighter, with his fight against rapist and MMA champion Sanchez showcasing [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqRPaucl8r4 his full arsenal.]]

Added: 443

Changed: 122

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Smallville}}'': [[{{Superman}} Clark Kent]] of all people does not believe in a fair fight. His usual strategy boils down to "clock you in the head from behind at 500 miles an hour." [[DarkActionGirl Tess Mercer]] is just as bad, if not worse.

to:

* ''Series/{{Smallville}}'': [[{{Superman}} [[Franchise/{{Superman}} Clark Kent]] of all people does not believe in a fair fight. His usual strategy boils down to "clock you in the head from behind at 500 miles an hour." hour", a tactic [[ComicBook/{{Supergirl}} his cousin Kara]] is also fond of. [[DarkActionGirl Tess Mercer]] is just as bad, if not worse.



-->'''Reynolds:''' Huh.
-->'''O'Neill:''' That's odd.
-->'''Reynolds:''' Yeah.
-->''(Both shrug and resume firing)''

to:

-->'''Reynolds:''' Huh.
-->'''O'Neill:'''
Huh.\\
'''O'Neill:'''
That's odd.
-->'''Reynolds:''' Yeah.
-->''(Both
odd.\\
'''Reynolds:''' Yeah.\\
''(Both
shrug and resume firing)''



-->'''Odo:''' 'You'd shoot a man in the back?'
-->'''Garak:''' 'Well, it's the safest way, isn't it?'

to:

-->'''Odo:''' 'You'd shoot a man in the back?'
-->'''Garak:'''
back?'\\
'''Garak:'''
'Well, it's the safest way, isn't it?'



-->'''Mobar:''' [[StrawVulcan Logic would indicate that neither of us has the advantage.]]
-->'''Tuvok:''' [[PreasskickingOneLiner Your logic... is flawed.]] ''([[BlindedByTheLight shines a light in Mobar's eyes]] and stuns him)''

to:

-->'''Mobar:''' --->'''Mobar:''' [[StrawVulcan Logic would indicate that neither of us has the advantage.]]
-->'''Tuvok:'''
]]\\
'''Tuvok:'''
[[PreasskickingOneLiner Your logic... is flawed.]] ''([[BlindedByTheLight shines a light in Mobar's eyes]] and stuns him)''him)''
* ''Series/Supergirl2015'':
** In [[Recap/Supergirl2015S2E13MrAndMrsMxyzptlk "Mr. and Mrs. Mxyzptlk"]], Mon-El wastes no time firing his weapon at Mxyzptlk before their duel has actually begun. Unfortunately, the Imp was prepared for it.
** In [[Recap/Supergirl2015S3E6Midvale "Midvale"]], it's shown teen [[ComicBook/{{Supergirl}} Kara Danvers]] was an advocate of the "knocking them out from behind before they realize you're coming" approach.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ''Series/{{The 100}}'': In most instances, no one on this show is able to fight fair if they want to survive but special mention goes to Clarke's fight with Anya. Over the course of the fight, Clarke throws ashes into Anya's eyes, pulls a knife on her unarmed opponent, and finally gains the upper hand by digging her fingers into an open wound that Anya had gotten earlier.

to:

* ''Series/{{The 100}}'': ''Series/The100'': In most instances, no one on this show is able to fight fair if they want to survive but special mention goes to Clarke's fight with Anya. Over the course of the fight, Clarke throws ashes into Anya's eyes, pulls a knife on her unarmed opponent, and finally gains the upper hand by digging her fingers into an open wound that Anya had gotten earlier.



* In ''{{Deadwood}}'' this trope is omnipresent, resulting in very short confrontations, the majority involving guns. One of the most violent characters [[LampshadeHanging hangs a lampshade]] on the avoidance of a fair fight, just after one had happened -- and even that was an extremely messy affair where the guy who was going for torture over the quick kill lost, despite having the advantage.

to:

* In ''{{Deadwood}}'' ''Series/{{Deadwood}}'' this trope is omnipresent, resulting in very short confrontations, the majority involving guns. One of the most violent characters [[LampshadeHanging hangs a lampshade]] on the avoidance of a fair fight, just after one had happened -- and even that was an extremely messy affair where the guy who was going for torture over the quick kill lost, despite having the advantage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "The Mountain and the Viper", Arya declares that anyone who shuns a method of killing as dishonorable will never be a great killer.

to:

** Arya Stark becomes a fierce killing machine through copious application of this trope. Being a petite teenage girl, she knows she can't take on a grown man with years of combat experience in a fair fight, so she instead relies on sneak attacks, magic, and "the woman's weapon" (poison) to take down her foes before they even know they're a target. After watching her family (including her pregnant sister-in-law) get murdered in the aforementioned violation of Sacred Hospitality, she doesn't give two shits about honor. In "The Mountain and the Viper", Arya declares that anyone who shuns a method of killing as dishonorable will never be a great killer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** He asks Tyrion why killing 10,000 men in battle is more noble than murdering a dozen by violating SacredHospitality. Off course, he conveniently discounts the fact that said 10.000 were cowardly slaughtered too. What makes him a chessmaster here instead of an idiot that violated every principle of diplomacy and SacredHospitality in the worst way possible, however, is that he didn't take any active role in the matter — he simply made some assurances to an already traitorous, ambitious, selfish ally of Robb Stark's, giving the betrayal a guaranteed reward if actually carried out; the actual betrayal, its nature, and all of the extreme diplomatic and cultural taboos involved were not Tywin's idea or something he had a direct hand in.

to:

*** He asks Tyrion why killing 10,000 men in battle is more noble than murdering a dozen by violating SacredHospitality. Off course, he conveniently discounts the fact that said 10.000 10,000 were cowardly slaughtered too. What makes him a chessmaster here instead of an idiot that violated every principle of diplomacy and SacredHospitality in the worst way possible, however, is that he didn't take any active role in the matter — he simply made some assurances to an already traitorous, ambitious, selfish ally of Robb Stark's, giving the betrayal a guaranteed reward if actually carried out; the actual betrayal, its nature, and all of the extreme diplomatic and cultural taboos involved were not Tywin's idea or something he had a direct hand in.

Added: 1044

Changed: 227

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lord Tywin scolds Jaime for sparing Ned in the name of a clean fight, and asks Tyrion why killing 10,000 men in battle is more noble than murdering a dozen by violating SacredHospitality.

to:

** Lord Tywin Tywin's main hat is his prioritizing maximum victory with minimum losses and he'll use every trick he can think of to achieve his political and military goals.
*** He
scolds Jaime for sparing Ned in the name of a clean fight, and fight.
*** He
asks Tyrion why killing 10,000 men in battle is more noble than murdering a dozen by violating SacredHospitality.SacredHospitality. Off course, he conveniently discounts the fact that said 10.000 were cowardly slaughtered too. What makes him a chessmaster here instead of an idiot that violated every principle of diplomacy and SacredHospitality in the worst way possible, however, is that he didn't take any active role in the matter — he simply made some assurances to an already traitorous, ambitious, selfish ally of Robb Stark's, giving the betrayal a guaranteed reward if actually carried out; the actual betrayal, its nature, and all of the extreme diplomatic and cultural taboos involved were not Tywin's idea or something he had a direct hand in.
*** In the History and Lore videos, he justifies the Sacking of King's Landing as this; in his mind it decisively ended the war in one fell swoop of bloody violence rather than prolong it indefinitely and prevent additional casualties.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In "Live Fast and Prosper": Tuvok proves to be this (presumably because its logical). When he faces off against a man who has been impersonating him...and got ''really'' [[BecomingTheMask into the role]]:
-->'''Mobar:''' [[StrawVulcan Logic would indicate that neither of us has the advantage.]]
-->'''Tuvok:''' [[PreasskickingOneLiner Your logic... is flawed.]] ''([[BlindedByTheLight shines a light in Mobar's eyes]] and stuns him)''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A flashback to the Tower of Joy shows how Ned Stark beat the legendary Arthur "Sword of the Morning" Dayne -- but it turns out Ned didn't outmatch him. Dayne slaughters Ned's comrades and, in a one-on-one fight, dominates Ned and knocks his sword out of his hand but -- before he can deliver the killing blow -- Howland Reed impales Dayne in the throat from behind and Ned uses the opportunity to kill Dayne.

to:

** A flashback to the Tower of Joy shows how Ned Stark beat the legendary Arthur "Sword of the Morning" Dayne -- but it turns out Ned didn't outmatch him. Dayne slaughters Ned's comrades and, in a one-on-one fight, dominates Ned and knocks his sword out of his hand but -- before he can deliver the killing blow -- Howland Reed impales Dayne in the throat from behind and behind. Justified as, while he's the Lord of his house, he's not a knight. Ned uses the opportunity to kill Dayne.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Crannogmen of House Reed will use every weapon at their disposal to make their enemies' time in their lands miserable. They ambush foes using their superior knowledge of the terrain and then disappear, deliberately get smaller groups lost to pick them off and even use poisonous weapons (like darts) just to make things even more insufferable. As mentioned abov, Howland is shown to favor surprise attacks over open confrontation, as is his daughter Meera. We also saw the aftermath of their attrition warfare on the Ironborn garrison holding Moat Cailin, bled by jungle disease and sniped with poison darts.

to:

** The Crannogmen of House Reed will use every weapon at their disposal to make their enemies' time in their lands miserable. They ambush foes using their superior knowledge of the terrain and then disappear, deliberately get smaller groups lost to pick them off and even use poisonous weapons (like darts) just to make things even more insufferable. As mentioned abov, above, Howland is shown to favor surprise attacks over open confrontation, as is his daughter Meera. We also saw the aftermath of their attrition warfare on the Ironborn garrison holding Moat Cailin, bled by jungle disease and sniped with poison darts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Crannogmen of House Reed will use every weapon at their disposal to make their enemies' time in their lands miserable. They ambush foes using their superior knowledge of the terrain and then disappear, deliberately get smaller groups lost to pick them off and even use poisonous weapons (like darts) just to make things even more insufferable. As mentioned abov, Howland is shown to favor surprise attacks over open confrontation, as is his daughter Meera. We also saw the aftermath of their attrition warfare on the Ironborn garrison holding Moat Cailin, bled by jungle disease and sniped with poison darts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The SGC's belief in this is wonderfully shown in the episode "The Reckoning, Part 2". After Daniel manages to overpower Replicarter and take control of the replicator swarm, and causes them all to freeze in mid-attack:
-->'''Reynolds:''' Huh.
-->'''O'Neill:''' That's odd.
-->'''Reynolds:''' Yeah.
-->''(Both shrug and resume firing)''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/LegendsOfTomorrow'': In "Shogun" Sara and TheDragon charge one another with swords...and Sara kills him with a hidden knife. [[SingleStrokeBattle In one stroke no less]].
** "Camelot 3000": Damian Darhk pulls a gun when he's lost a sword fight, and Ray wears his ATOM armor underneath his plate armor ensuring he can survive just about anything.

Added: 650

Changed: 97

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Oberyn Martell demonstrates that dagger beats sword in a QuickDraw in "Two Swords". Later, he uses light armour, HitAndRunTactics, and taunting against a larger and stronger opponent.

to:

** Oberyn Martell demonstrates that dagger beats sword in a QuickDraw in "Two Swords". Later, he uses light armour, HitAndRunTactics, and taunting against a larger and stronger opponent. He also uses a poisoned spear to ensure that his opponent will die no matter who wins the fight.


Added DiffLines:

-->'''Lou:''' I did the Merrianhoff Senate campaign. You know those charges that he had weird financial dealings with Taiwanese businessmen?
--> '''Josh:''' He did!
-->'''Lou:''' Those were the charges. Anyway, we ran against Barrack, clean as a bar of soap. We hit him first with everything we could find. By the time he hit back, the voters thought it was just another ugly campaign; a pox on both our houses.
-->'''Josh:''' You're proud of that?
-->'''Lou:''' I'm proud that Merrianhoff defends Medicare and Medicaid in the Senate. I'm proud that he votes against every reckless Republican tax cut. We're the blue team and there's a real war going on.

Added: 259

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** However, the Doctor usually plays with this a little in that, while he rarely gets into physical fights, he will use anything and everything he can to defeat an enemy. There's a reason the dude with the screwdriver is TheDreaded MemeticBadass, after all...



* ''Series/TheFlash2014'': Captain Cold took advantage of The Flash's drive to save people by derailing a train. After Flash saved everybody and stopped to catch his breath, Cold knocked him out from behind.

to:

* ''Series/TheFlash2014'': Captain Cold took advantage of The Flash's drive to save people by derailing a train. After Flash saved everybody and stopped to catch his breath, Cold knocked him out [[IncrediblyLamePun cold]] from behind.

Top