Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ChekhovsGun / HarryPotter

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter


** Sadly, the cloak also comes with its load of BadWriting. It's claimed that Harry's cloak has unique properties, but no other cloak was ever presented "on-screen" (as it were) to compare it with. But the key element in the cloak's importance was that Harry inherited it from his father, so YourMileageMayVary on whether Rowling's mistake was in [[InformedAbility not setting up the cloak's special powers]], or in [[AssPull believing it had to have them at all]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Forest misspelled; irrelevant self reference


* When Harry is attacked by [[spoiler:Quirrel/Voldemort]] in the Forbidden Forest and is rescued by Firenze, the other centaurs object, citing "the stars." Even Firenze himself mentions to Harry that he hopes that he and his fellow centaurs have been misreading them. Considering the fact that centaurs are particularly gifted at astrology, they're probably seeing [[spoiler:Harry getting killed by Voldemort in the Forbidden Forrest at the end of [[HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows Book 7]], and don't want to interfere with destiny]].

to:

* When Harry is attacked by [[spoiler:Quirrel/Voldemort]] in the Forbidden Forest and is rescued by Firenze, the other centaurs object, citing "the stars." Even Firenze himself mentions to Harry that he hopes that he and his fellow centaurs have been misreading them. Considering the fact that centaurs are particularly gifted at astrology, they're probably seeing [[spoiler:Harry getting killed by Voldemort in the Forbidden Forrest Forest at the end of [[HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows Book 7]], and don't want to interfere with destiny]].



** To add to that, the [[spoiler:Room of Requirement itself. Draco was using it, specifically the Room of Hidden Things, to try and find a way to kill Dumbledore. The room is revealed in Book 7 to be the location of one of the Horcruxes, and Draco comes close to foiling Harry there because of how much experience he has with that room - as he says, "I virtually lived in the Room of Hidden Things last year." He knows how to get in. And let it also be known that this troper went and looked up the exact quote in her own copy of the book.]]

to:

** To add to that, the [[spoiler:Room of Requirement itself. Draco was using it, specifically the Room of Hidden Things, to try and find a way to kill Dumbledore. The room is revealed in Book 7 to be the location of one of the Horcruxes, and Draco comes close to foiling Harry there because of how much experience he has with that room - as he says, "I virtually lived in the Room of Hidden Things last year." He knows how to get in. And let it also be known that this troper went and looked up the exact quote in her own copy of the book.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Dumbledore's brief look of triumph when he is told that Voldemort used Harry's blood to resurrect himelf. It is one of the reason why Harry survived the Killing Curse in hte final book.

to:

* Dumbledore's brief look of triumph when he is told that Voldemort used Harry's blood to resurrect himelf. It is one of the reason reasons why Harry survived the Killing Curse in hte the final book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Dumbledore's brief look of triumph when he is told that Voldemort used Harry's blood to resurrect himelf. It is one of the reason why Harry survived the Killing Curse in hte final book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* "Snape's Worst Memory". [[spoiler: In Book 7, we learn exactly ''why'' it was his worst memory; it was the day he lost Lily forever.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rumor proven false


* The snake Harry released from the zoo [[spoiler:was actually Voldemort's final horcrux, and pet, Nagini.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The snake Harry released from the zoo [[spoiler:was actually Voldemort's final horcrux, Nagini.]]

to:

* The snake Harry released from the zoo [[spoiler:was actually Voldemort's final horcrux, and pet, Nagini.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The snake Harry released from the zoo [[spoiler:was actually Voldemort's final horcrux, Nagini.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The same scene also mentions the [[spoiler:cursed necklace and, though it's presented as no more than a regular cupboard in this scene, the Vanishing Cabinet, both of which also become major plot-points in [[HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince The Half-Blood Prince]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* At Borgin and Burkes, Malfoy notices the Hand of Glory, a magical artifact that gives light only to the holder. [[spoiler:He eventually uses it in Book 6 for his plan to let Death Eaters into the school.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If the ChekhovsArmory in ''[[{{Literature/HarryPotter}} Harry Potter]]'' were an actual army, it would curbstomp everyone in a massive ZergRush. Please list examples by book:

to:

If the ChekhovsArmory in ''[[{{Literature/HarryPotter}} Harry Potter]]'' were an actual army, it would curbstomp everyone in a massive ZergRush. Also, there may be unmarked spoilers. Please list examples by book:
book:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** There is a scene in HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix where Moody mentions that his Invisibility Cloak is starting to lose its powers.

Added: 359

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** FirstGirlWins.









** Trelaweny also predicts that Hermione drops out of Divination class by Easter. Even if she probably did not know it herself at the time.

to:

** Trelaweny Trelawney also predicts that Hermione drops out of Divination class by Easter. Even if she probably did not know it herself at the time.






* During the Yule Ball, Dumbledore makes mention of having a PottyEmergency and discovering a room with "a really rather magnificent collection of chamberpots. When I went back to investigate more closely, I discovered that the room had vanished." Perhaps, Dumbledore theorizes, the room only appears when somebody really, really needs it...






** This book also contains an example of what happens when you overuse Chekhov's Gunmen. When Harry refers in passing to a Mark Evans while speaking to Dudley. This is a throw-away character who is never mentioned again, but many assumed he would have some importance in the future because he had the same last name as Harry's mother. JK Rowling ''publicly apologized'' for that last one.

to:

** This book also contains an example of what happens when you overuse Chekhov's Gunmen. When Harry refers in passing to a Mark Evans while speaking to Dudley. This is a throw-away character who is never mentioned again, but many assumed he would have some importance in the future because he had the same last name as Harry's mother. JK Rowling ''publicly apologized'' for that last one.it.






* ChekhovsBoomerang: Books two and six pretty much parallel each other and they are essentially the same basic plot, only six is much quieter and softer, and the roles of Harry and Ginny are apparently reversed. In the second book, Ginny harbored strong feelings for Harry and had a bewitched diary which was able to take control of her. This book was destroyed by Harry to save Ginny's life. In the sixth, [[spoiler:it is Harry's turn to pine for Ginny. Moreover, Ginny was possessed by Riddle's diary in the second book, which is now revealed to be a horcrux. Harry has a mysterious potions book which, while it doesn’t actually posses him, has something of an addicting quality for him. Ginny throws away the diary after it possess her, and Harry hides the potions book after it gets him in trouble. Tom Riddle is introduced in the second book, and his past is revealed more fully in the sixth.]] Finally, there is the matter of, of all things, the numbers of the books. In total, there are seven books. Numbers two and six are the first and last even numbers in a sequence of seven.

to:

* ChekhovsBoomerang: Books two and six pretty much parallel each other and they are essentially the same basic plot, only six is much quieter and softer, and the roles of Harry and Ginny are apparently reversed. In the second book, Ginny harbored strong feelings for Harry and had a bewitched diary which was able to take control of her. This book was destroyed by Harry to save Ginny's life. In the sixth, [[spoiler:it is Harry's turn to pine for Ginny. Moreover, Ginny was possessed by Riddle's diary in the second book, which is now revealed to be a horcrux. Harry has a mysterious potions book which, while it doesn’t actually posses him, has something of an addicting quality for him. Ginny throws away the diary after it possess possesses her, and Harry hides the potions book after it gets him in trouble. Tom Riddle is introduced in the second book, and his past is revealed more fully in the sixth.]] Finally, there is the matter of, of all things, the numbers of the books. In total, there are seven books. Numbers two and six are the first and last even numbers in a sequence of seven.


Added DiffLines:

Added: 467

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGift: The Invisibility Cloak, which Harry gets for Christmas, which not only helps him throughout the series but turns out to be one of the [[spoiler:titular Deathly Hallows]] in Book 7.

to:

* ChekhovsGift: The Invisibility Cloak, InvisibilityCloak, which Harry gets for Christmas, which not only helps him throughout the series but turns out to be one [[spoiler:one of the [[spoiler:titular titular Deathly Hallows]] in Book 7.


Added DiffLines:

** Sadly, the cloak also comes with its load of BadWriting. It's claimed that Harry's cloak has unique properties, but no other cloak was ever presented "on-screen" (as it were) to compare it with. But the key element in the cloak's importance was that Harry inherited it from his father, so YourMileageMayVary on whether Rowling's mistake was in [[InformedAbility not setting up the cloak's special powers]], or in [[AssPull believing it had to have them at all]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The bezoar mentioned briefly in Harry's first potions class is later used [[spoiler: to save Ron after he accidentally drinks a bottle of poisoned mead intended for Dumbledore.]]

to:

* The bezoar mentioned briefly in Harry's first potions class is later used in ''Book 6'' [[spoiler: to save Ron after he accidentally drinks a bottle of poisoned mead intended for Dumbledore.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Tonks' Patronus changing its form. The fact that it's supposed to represent [[spoiler:Lupin shows that the Patronus often represents someone the caster loves... much like Snape's.]]

Added: 541

Changed: 73

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To add to that, the [[spoiler:Room of Requirement itself. Draco was using it, specifically the Room of Hidden Things, to try and find a way to kill Dumbledore. The room is revealed in Book 7 to be the location of one of the Horcruxes, and Draco comes close to foiling Harry there because of how much experience he has with that room - as he says, "I virtually lived in the Room of Hidden Things last year." He knows how to get in. And let it also be known that this troper went and looked up the exact quote in her own copy of the book.]]



* [[spoiler:Harry's snitch, Dumbledore' Deluminator (aka the Put-Outer), Godric Gryffndor's [[SwordOfPlotAdvancement sword]], dragons at Gringotts, the poem [[TooDumbToLive warning thieves at Gringott's]] entrance, the eye Harry sees in Sirius's Mirror, the locket in the House of Black, Wormtail's hand, Voldemort's claim about Wormtail's loyalty, Wormtail's debt to Harry, Harry's invisibility cloak, and the Basilisk's fangs.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:Harry's snitch, Dumbledore' Deluminator (aka the Put-Outer), Godric Gryffndor's [[SwordOfPlotAdvancement sword]], dragons at Gringotts, the poem [[TooDumbToLive warning thieves at Gringott's]] entrance, the eye Harry sees in Sirius's Mirror, the tiara Harry put on a bust to mark a spot in the Room of Requirement, the locket in the House of Black, Wormtail's hand, Voldemort's claim about Wormtail's loyalty, Wormtail's debt to Harry, Harry's invisibility cloak, and the Basilisk's fangs.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When Harry [[spoiler:hides his potions book in the Room of Requirement]] he marked the spot with a bust of a warlock wearing a wig and [[spoiler:an old, battered tiara. Said tiara becomes immensely important in Book 7 when it's revealed to be the Lost Diadem of Ravenclaw, one of Voldemort's Horcruxes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChekhovsBoomerang: The flying car is used to take Harry from the Dursley's house. Then again to fly to Hogwarts and [[spoiler: then to escape from the Forbidden Forest later.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
spell bezoar


* The beazor mentioned briefly in Harry's first potions class is later used [[spoiler: to save Ron after he accidentally drinks a bottle of poisoned mead intended for Dumbledore.]]

to:

* The beazor bezoar mentioned briefly in Harry's first potions class is later used [[spoiler: to save Ron after he accidentally drinks a bottle of poisoned mead intended for Dumbledore.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Rather [[HilariousInHindsight hilariously,]] there was a book released a short time before the book that discussed Chekhov's Guns from the books. It concluded that since so many people knew about the Invisibility Cloak at this point (reasoning that Snape of course told Voldemort) that the cloak had no more bullets left to fire. Boy was it wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The beazor mentioned briefly in Harry's first potions class is later used [[spoiler: to save Ron after he accidentally drinks a bottle of poisoned mead intended for Dumbledore.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ->[[spoiler:Ron: So...you're gonna suffer...but you're gonna be happy about it...]]

to:

** ->[[spoiler:Ron: [[spoiler:Ron: So...you're gonna suffer...but you're gonna be happy about it...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[Spoiler:Ron: So...you're gonna suffer...but you're gonna be happy about it...]]
** Just a few sentences later we also know that [[Spoiler:Harry will work for the ministry (As an auror, none the less), get unexpected fortunes (from winning the triwizard tournament the next year) and die. Even if it happens a lot later (And under different circumstances) than expected]].

to:

** [[Spoiler:Ron: ->[[spoiler:Ron: So...you're gonna suffer...but you're gonna be happy about it...]]
** Just a few sentences later we also know that [[Spoiler:Harry [[spoiler:Harry will work for the ministry (As an auror, none the less), get unexpected fortunes (from winning the triwizard tournament the next year) and die. Even if it happens a lot later (And under different circumstances) than expected]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Just a few sentences later we also know that [[Spoiler:Harry will work for the ministry (As an auror, none the less), get unexpected fortunes (from winning the triwizard tournament the next year) and die. Even if it happens a lot later (And under different circumstances) than expected.]]
** Trelaweny also predicts that [[Spoiler:Hermione drops out of Divination class by Easter]]. Even if she probably did not know it herself at the time.

to:

** Just a few sentences later we also know that [[Spoiler:Harry will work for the ministry (As an auror, none the less), get unexpected fortunes (from winning the triwizard tournament the next year) and die. Even if it happens a lot later (And under different circumstances) than expected.]]
expected]].
** Trelaweny also predicts that [[Spoiler:Hermione Hermione drops out of Divination class by Easter]].Easter. Even if she probably did not know it herself at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[Spoiler: Ron: So...you're gonna suffer...but you're gonna be happy about it...]]
** Just a few sentences later we also know that [[Spoiler: Harry will work for the ministry (As an auror, none the less), get unexpected fortunes (from winning the triwizard tournament the next year) and die. Even if it happens a lot later (And under different circumstances) than expected.]]
** Trelaweny also predicts that [[Spoiler: Hermione drops out of Divination class by Easter]]. Even if she probably did not know it herself at the time.

to:

** [[Spoiler: Ron: [[Spoiler:Ron: So...you're gonna suffer...but you're gonna be happy about it...]]
** Just a few sentences later we also know that [[Spoiler: Harry [[Spoiler:Harry will work for the ministry (As an auror, none the less), get unexpected fortunes (from winning the triwizard tournament the next year) and die. Even if it happens a lot later (And under different circumstances) than expected.]]
** Trelaweny also predicts that [[Spoiler: Hermione [[Spoiler:Hermione drops out of Divination class by Easter]]. Even if she probably did not know it herself at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[Ron: So...you're gonna suffer...but you're gonna be happy about it...]]
** Just a few sentences later we also know that [[Harry will work for the ministry (As an auror, none the less), get unexpected fortunes (from winning the triwizard tournament the next year) and die. Even if it happens a lot later (And under different circumstances) than expected.]]
** Trelaweny also predicts that [[Hermione drops out of Divination class by Easter]]. Even if she probably did not know it herself at the time.

to:

** [[Ron: [[Spoiler: Ron: So...you're gonna suffer...but you're gonna be happy about it...]]
** Just a few sentences later we also know that [[Harry [[Spoiler: Harry will work for the ministry (As an auror, none the less), get unexpected fortunes (from winning the triwizard tournament the next year) and die. Even if it happens a lot later (And under different circumstances) than expected.]]
** Trelaweny also predicts that [[Hermione [[Spoiler: Hermione drops out of Divination class by Easter]]. Even if she probably did not know it herself at the time.

Added: 512

Changed: 119

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]

to:

* Also, quite a few of the predictions done in the Divination Classroom turns out to be truer than one would've think!
**[[Ron: So...you're gonna suffer...but you're gonna be happy about it...]]
** Just a few sentences later we also know that [[Harry will work for the ministry (As an auror, none the less), get unexpected fortunes (from winning the triwizard tournament the next year) and die. Even if it happens a lot later (And under different circumstances) than expected.]]
** Trelaweny also predicts that [[Hermione drops out of Divination class by Easter]]. Even if she probably did not know it herself at the time.
[[/folder]]

Changed: 576

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
sixth book entry was based on movie plot changes


* ChekhovsBoomerang: Books two and six pretty much parallel each other and they are essentially the same basic plot, only six is much quieter and softer, and the roles of Harry and Ginny are apparently reversed. In the second book, Ginny harbored strong feelings for Harry and had a bewitched diary which was able to take control of her. This book was destroyed by Harry to save Ginny's life. In the sixth, [[spoiler:it is Harry's turn to pine for Ginny, though being sixteen and fifteen, respectively, rather then twelve and eleven, allows them to act more maturely about it. Harry as well is now in possession of a mysterious potions book which, while it doesn’t really posses him, still has something of an addicting quality for him. This book is hidden by Ginny out of concern for Harry's well being and the ultimate fate of the book is unknown. Also there is how Tom Riddle was introduced in the second book, and how his past is fleshed out in book six. Along those lines are the diary, which turns out to have been the first Horcrux, a concept that has to wait until book six to be properly explained.]] Finally, there is the matter of, of all things, the numbers of the books. In total, there are seven books. Numbers two and six are the first and last even numbers in a sequence of seven.

to:

* ChekhovsBoomerang: Books two and six pretty much parallel each other and they are essentially the same basic plot, only six is much quieter and softer, and the roles of Harry and Ginny are apparently reversed. In the second book, Ginny harbored strong feelings for Harry and had a bewitched diary which was able to take control of her. This book was destroyed by Harry to save Ginny's life. In the sixth, [[spoiler:it is Harry's turn to pine for Ginny, though being sixteen and fifteen, respectively, rather then twelve and eleven, allows them to act more maturely about it. Harry as well Ginny. Moreover, Ginny was possessed by Riddle's diary in the second book, which is now in possession of revealed to be a horcrux. Harry has a mysterious potions book which, while it doesn’t really actually posses him, still has something of an addicting quality for him. This book is hidden by Ginny out of concern for Harry's well being throws away the diary after it possess her, and Harry hides the ultimate fate of the potions book is unknown. Also there is how after it gets him in trouble. Tom Riddle was is introduced in the second book, and how his past is fleshed out revealed more fully in book six. Along those lines are the diary, which turns out to have been the first Horcrux, a concept that has to wait until book six to be properly explained.sixth.]] Finally, there is the matter of, of all things, the numbers of the books. In total, there are seven books. Numbers two and six are the first and last even numbers in a sequence of seven.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Ron's spell to turn Scabbers yellow. Maybe Fred and George weren't wrong about it working on rats. They hadn't tried it on an [[spoiler:Animagus.]]

Top