Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ArtisticLicenseHistory / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Added: 299

Removed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/BabylonFive'': In "[[Recap/BabylonFiveS02E21ComesTheInquisitor Comes the Inquisitor]]", Captain Sheridan locates the UsefulNotes/JackTheRipper killings in London's West End instead of the East End. Creator/JMichaelStraczynski admits it was a typo and it was overdubbed in the DVD release.



* In ''Series/BabylonFive'' Captain Sheridan locates the UsefulNotes/JackTheRipper killings in London's West End instead of the East End. Creator/JMichaelStraczynski admits it was a typo and it was overdubbed in the DVD release.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/LawmenBassReeves'': Judge Isaac Parker is played by Creator/DonaldSutherland, who was 88 at the time. He's introduced in 1875 when the actual Parker was around 37.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/MissScarletAndTheDuke'': The show's main premise of Eliza Scarlet being the first female PrivateDetective in London is incorrect: Victorian England had plenty, mainly due to the 1858 Matrimonial Causes Act making investigating husbands for adultery a profitable business model. Eliza consulting with UsefulNotes/ScotlandYard on more serious cases of murder, robbery, and blackmail would be unusual, but not the basic idea of a female private eye.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ArtisticLicenseHistory/Shogun2024''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None of these series purported to be in real time, and these series did not have episodes every single day


* ''[[Series/Combat1962 Combat!]]'' (1962) was a television series depicting American G.I.'s fighting Germans in France during World War II. It lasted five seasons, although historically, after D-Day France was liberated in about four months, and Germany surrendered after less than a year. Total U.S. involvement in World War II was less than four years. Same goes for ''Series/{{MASH}}'' and ''Series/HogansHeroes'', both of which lasted longer than the wars they were set during.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ArtisticLicense/{{Titanic|1996}}''

to:

* ''ArtisticLicense/{{Titanic|1996}}''''ArtisticLicenseHistory/{{Titanic|1996}}''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Typo


** The series used a ''very'' fringe theory that Queen Charlotte was black or at least multiracial as a jumping-off point for an AlternateHistory where black and brown people became accepted into Regency England's nobility (including the male lead in the first season, the Duke of Hastings), as a {{justified|Trope}} exampleof AdaptationalDiversity. The real Charlotte is well-known to have been an ethnic German from Mecklenburg, and although she was partly descended from ''North'' African nobility, it was almost certainly ethnic Berber or Arabic rather than sub-Saharan African -- and, moreover, was an ancestor she shared with a sizable number of other European royals!

to:

** The series used a ''very'' fringe theory that Queen Charlotte was black or at least multiracial as a jumping-off point for an AlternateHistory where black and brown people became accepted into Regency England's nobility (including the male lead in the first season, the Duke of Hastings), as a {{justified|Trope}} exampleof example of AdaptationalDiversity. The real Charlotte is well-known to have been an ethnic German from Mecklenburg, and although she was partly descended from ''North'' African nobility, it was almost certainly ethnic Berber or Arabic rather than sub-Saharan African -- and, moreover, was an ancestor she shared with a sizable number of other European royals!

Added: 843

Changed: 604

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Bridgerton}}'' used a ''very'' fringe theory that Queen Charlotte was black or at least multiracial as a jumping-off point for an AlternateHistory where black and brown people became accepted into Regency England's nobility (including the male lead in the first season, the Duke of Hastings). The real Charlotte is well-known to have been an ethnic German from Mecklenburg, and although she was partly descended from ''North'' African nobility, it was almost certainly ethnic Berber or Arabic rather than sub-Saharan African -- and, moreover, was an ancestor she shared with a sizable number of other European royals!

to:

* ''Series/{{Bridgerton}}'' ''Series/{{Bridgerton}}'':
** The series
used a ''very'' fringe theory that Queen Charlotte was black or at least multiracial as a jumping-off point for an AlternateHistory where black and brown people became accepted into Regency England's nobility (including the male lead in the first season, the Duke of Hastings). Hastings), as a {{justified|Trope}} exampleof AdaptationalDiversity. The real Charlotte is well-known to have been an ethnic German from Mecklenburg, and although she was partly descended from ''North'' African nobility, it was almost certainly ethnic Berber or Arabic rather than sub-Saharan African -- and, moreover, was an ancestor she shared with a sizable number of other European royals!royals!
** Inherited from the books, the peerage of Hastings was a barony at the time of the series (then made a marquessate in 1816). There has never been a Duchy of Hastings.

Added: 700

Changed: 461

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/QuantumLeap'': Being a show all about history and time travel, the creators did their best to be accurate; however, there is one small slipup in the series finale "Mirror Image": while in a small west Pennsylvania town on August 8, 1953, Sam finds himself watching an episode of the kids' sci-fi TV series ''Captain Z-Ro''. While ''Captain Z-Ro'' did exist in 1953, it was not nationally syndicated until 1955, appearing only on a couple of West Coast TV stations before then.

to:

* ''Series/QuantumLeap'': ''Series/QuantumLeap'':
**
Being a show all about history and time travel, the creators did their best to be accurate; however, there is one small slipup in the series finale "Mirror Image": while in a small west Pennsylvania town on August 8, 1953, Sam finds himself watching an episode of the kids' sci-fi TV series ''Captain Z-Ro''. While ''Captain Z-Ro'' did exist in 1953, it was not nationally syndicated until 1955, appearing only on a couple of West Coast TV stations before then.then.
** An example occurs during the episode "Disco Inferno": part of the plot revolves around Sam doing stunt work during the filming of ''Film/{{Earthquake}}''. The problem? The movie came out in 1974. This episode takes place in ''1976''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ArtisticLicenseHistory/{{Isabel}}''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ArtisticLicense/TheCrown2016''

to:

* ''ArtisticLicense/TheCrown2016''''ArtisticLicenseHistory/TheCrown2016''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ArtisticLicense/TheCrown2016''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheFirstLady'': The series acknowledges in a disclaimer before some episodes that artistic liberties have been taken. Probably the biggest examples was having Eleanor Roosevelt have an affair with Lorena "Hick" Hickok, a lesbian reporter friend of hers. Though many historians suspect they had a relationship, it's still not known with certainty what exactly happened (whether it was sexual at least-both had clear love for each other, as expressed in their many letters).

to:

* ''Series/TheFirstLady'': The series acknowledges in a disclaimer before some episodes that artistic liberties have been taken. Probably the biggest examples example was having Eleanor Roosevelt have an affair with Lorena "Hick" Hickok, a lesbian reporter friend of hers. Though many historians suspect they had a relationship, it's still not known with certainty what exactly happened (whether it was sexual at least-both had clear love for each other, as expressed in their many letters).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/ThatMitchellAndWebbLook'': One skit shows Admiral Karl Dönitz learning he's been named Führer after Hitler's suicide, and obliviously wants to make policy decisions when he's told that they just need him to tell the Allies that they surrender. In reality, Hitler abolished the office of Führer upon his death, and split it back to the offices of President and Chancellor, with Dönitz being named President and thus head-of-state. In addition, Dönitz was well-aware that Germany was at the point of collapse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheLawAccordingToLidiaPoet'': The Volumetric Glove is shown being used in 1883 Italy. It was not invented until 1895 in reality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ArtisticLicenseHistory/TheLastKingdom''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheLastKingdom:''
** Unlike the books, the English weapons and tactics appear suspect since they carry rectangular shields instead of round ones like the Danes and Uhtred must explain shieldwall tactics to them. In reality, the Angles, Saxons, and Jutes came to England from roughly the same place as the Danes and had a very similar social and military culture. (In the novels, instead of teaching shieldwall tactics, Uhtred's Danish background gets him sent to Wessex's fledgling navy.)
*** In Season 4 in particular shield walls all but disappear on both sides in favour of the standard chaotic Hollywood melees, only being called on in the final battle as a means of ''halting'' the fighting.
** As in the books, Ubba is given the patronymic "Lothbroksson" as a son of the famous [[Literature/RagnarLothbrokAndHisSons Ragnar Lothbrok]] to [[OneSteveLimit avoid another]] "Ragnarsson".[[note]]Even though "Lothbrok" ("Shaggy Pants") is a personal epithet like "the Great" or "the Bald," rather than a proper name.[[/note]]
** [=Æ=]thelwold is a historical character, but he was only an infant when his father died, not the young man the series portrays him as.
** In Season 3, the final battle in which [[spoiler: [=Æ=]thelwold is killed is depicted as a great victory for Wessex. In reality, Edward retreated before the battle, the men of Kent disobeyed the order to follow, and in the ensuing fight the Danes were victorious but suffered heavy losses, including [=Æ=]thelwold, making it a PyrrhicVictory.]]
** The Cornish Britons receive an absolutely bizarre portrayal in Episode 1.6. They wear chalky face paint that seems to be styled after the Hindu tilaka. Their hairstyles and dress seem to be inspired by Central Asian peoples. Their soldiers wield Inuit fishing spears, Dacian falxes, Renaissance pikes, and crude wooden pitchforks. In terms of armour, they wear Early Roman ‘heart protector’ breastplates, which at this point would be nearly 1000 years out of date. Their shields are made of wicker, and have gigantic holes in the front of them, apart from some where the hole had been covered by a large bronze disc. In what seems to be a low-budget attempt at emulating scale armor, King Peredur wears a leather shirt sewn full of metal buttons, and also wields a late medieval longsword.
** Early in the series, nuns can be seen in the background of some scenes wearing giant ridiculous hats shaped like shoes, possibly a low-budget attempt at a bonnet. Later in the series when nuns show up in more prominent roles, their costumes are less egregious.
** In Season 4 we see Æthelred claiming to be the King of Mercia, whereas in RealLife he was only ever acknowledged as the Lord of the Mercians. In real life he was also older than his wife and appears to have submitted to Alfred's authority several years before he married his daughter.
** The Welsh in Season 4 also receive an odd treatment. They seem to be portrayed as faux Romans with red tunics and rectangular shields, but wear no Roman-like armor (this is likely based on the traditional belief that the Welsh preserved aspects of Roman culture long after the Romans left Britain). They also use the Saxon term ''Wēalas'' to refer to Wales, even among themselves, which they certainly wouldn't have called themselves. The closest Welsh terms they may have used would be ''Cymru'', ''Cymry'', or ''Kymry'', which are all modern names for Wales.
*** Uhtred also quips that they don't look like Christians because of their different apparence, as though Saxons were the only Christian people in Britain.
** Historically, Eahlswith died in 902, eight years before the Battle of Tettenhall, while in the series she's instrumental in the political maneuvering surrounding the campaign.
** Sitryggr is based on Sitric Cáech, a (possible) grandson of Ivar the Boneless who spent much of his life in Ireland (making him about as Irish as Finan), and later became King of Northumbria from 921 until his death in 927. However, while there's evidence that he didn't have a good relationship with Edward the Elder, there's no mention of him ever directly fighting a war against him like in the show (there is numismatic evidence of Sigtryggr having held territory south of the Humber, which would indicate a partial Norse reconquest of lands around 921 - 924 however), and he definitely did not capture Winchester. His reign in Northumbria was also immediately succeeded by another descendent of Ivar named Guthfrith, [[spoiler: whereas in the show Norse rule over Northumbria simply ceases to exist with his death.]]
** Some of the Scots in season 5 are shown wearing early kilts, a-la ''Braveheart'', which they wouldn't have for about 600 years.
** [[spoiler: There was no battle of Bebbanburg as shown in season 5, where Constantine II of Alba (Scotland) fights against Uhtred, Edward, and Stiorra's Jorvik Danes. The entire campaign primarily serves to finish Uhtred's story of finally reclaiming Bebbanburg. Constantine, however, ''did'' later ally with a Viking lord from Ireland and a Brittonic king to fight against Aethelstan.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheLastKingdom:''
** Unlike the books, the English weapons and tactics appear suspect since they carry rectangular shields instead of round ones like the Danes and Uhtred must explain shieldwall tactics to them. In reality, the Angles, Saxons, and Jutes came to England from roughly the same place as the Danes and had a very similar social and military culture. (In the novels, instead of teaching shieldwall tactics, Uhtred's Danish background gets him sent to Wessex's fledgling navy.)
*** In Season 4 in particular shield walls all but disappear on both sides in favour of the standard chaotic Hollywood melees, only being called on in the final battle as a means of ''halting'' the fighting.
** As in the books, Ubba is given the patronymic "Lothbroksson" as a son of the famous [[Literature/RagnarLothbrokAndHisSons Ragnar Lothbrok]] to [[OneSteveLimit avoid another]] "Ragnarsson".[[note]]Even though "Lothbrok" ("Shaggy Pants") is a personal epithet like "the Great" or "the Bald," rather than a proper name.[[/note]]
** [=Æ=]thelwold is a historical character, but he was only an infant when his father died, not the young man the series portrays him as.
** In Season 3, the final battle in which [[spoiler: [=Æ=]thelwold is killed is depicted as a great victory for Wessex. In reality, Edward retreated before the battle, the men of Kent disobeyed the order to follow, and in the ensuing fight the Danes were victorious but suffered heavy losses, including [=Æ=]thelwold, making it a PyrrhicVictory.]]
** The Cornish Britons receive an absolutely bizarre portrayal in Episode 1.6. They wear chalky face paint that seems to be styled after the Hindu tilaka. Their hairstyles and dress seem to be inspired by Central Asian peoples. Their soldiers wield Inuit fishing spears, Dacian falxes, Renaissance pikes, and crude wooden pitchforks. In terms of armour, they wear Early Roman ‘heart protector’ breastplates, which at this point would be nearly 1000 years out of date. Their shields are made of wicker, and have gigantic holes in the front of them, apart from some where the hole had been covered by a large bronze disc. In what seems to be a low-budget attempt at emulating scale armor, King Peredur wears a leather shirt sewn full of metal buttons, and also wields a late medieval longsword.
** Early in the series, nuns can be seen in the background of some scenes wearing giant ridiculous hats shaped like shoes, possibly a low-budget attempt at a bonnet. Later in the series when nuns show up in more prominent roles, their costumes are less egregious.
** In Season 4 we see Æthelred claiming to be the King of Mercia, whereas in RealLife he was only ever acknowledged as the Lord of the Mercians. In real life he was also older than his wife and appears to have submitted to Alfred's authority several years before he married his daughter.
** The Welsh in Season 4 also receive an odd treatment. They seem to be portrayed as faux Romans with red tunics and rectangular shields, but wear no Roman-like armor (this is likely based on the traditional belief that the Welsh preserved aspects of Roman culture long after the Romans left Britain). They also use the Saxon term ''Wēalas'' to refer to Wales, even among themselves, which they certainly wouldn't have called themselves. The closest Welsh terms they may have used would be ''Cymru'', ''Cymry'', or ''Kymry'', which are all modern names for Wales.
*** Uhtred also quips that they don't look like Christians because of their different apparence, as though Saxons were the only Christian people in Britain.
** Historically, Eahlswith died in 902, eight years before the Battle of Tettenhall, while in the series she's instrumental in the political maneuvering surrounding the campaign.
** Sitryggr is based on Sitric Cáech, a (possible) grandson of Ivar the Boneless who spent much of his life in Ireland (making him about as Irish as Finan), and later became King of Northumbria from 921 until his death in 927. However, while there's evidence that he didn't have a good relationship with Edward the Elder, there's no mention of him ever directly fighting a war against him like in the show (there is numismatic evidence of Sigtryggr having held territory south of the Humber, which would indicate a partial Norse reconquest of lands around 921 - 924 however), and he definitely did not capture Winchester. His reign in Northumbria was also immediately succeeded by another descendent of Ivar named Guthfrith, [[spoiler: whereas in the show Norse rule over Northumbria simply ceases to exist with his death.]]
** Some of the Scots in season 5 are shown wearing early kilts, a-la ''Braveheart'', which they wouldn't have for about 600 years.
** [[spoiler: There was no battle of Bebbanburg as shown in season 5, where Constantine II of Alba (Scotland) fights against Uhtred, Edward, and Stiorra's Jorvik Danes. The entire campaign primarily serves to finish Uhtred's story of finally reclaiming Bebbanburg. Constantine, however, ''did'' later ally with a Viking lord from Ireland and a Brittonic king to fight against Aethelstan.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/DerryGirls'': While the show is full of HistoricalInJoke moments, some of them have been moved around or changed a bit. There really was a Lion that escaped the zoo in Belfast, but that happened in 1977. The first season ends with a MoodWhiplash with the parents watching a news report on a deadly terror attack while the girls are joyfully dancing at their school recital; the details of the attack and the footage on TV are an amalgamation of different events, and is meant more as a symbolic event than a representation of anything specific.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/QueenCharlotteABridgertonStory'':
** Charlotte and George really did have a dearth of legitimate grandchildren despite their large brood, but the implications this has on the succession become clear a few years earlier than they did in real life, giving Charlotte's Regency-era storyline emotional heft without moving it beyond the second season of ''Series/{{Bridgerton}}'' (1814). Her granddaughter Princess Charlotte dies in childbirth around 1814 instead of 1817 as in reality. Likewise, [[spoiler:the future Queen Victoria is conceived in the same timeframe, much earlier than her actual birth of 1819. In real life, Queen Charlotte died the year before Victoria was born.]]
** Whatever mental illness George was plagued with — suggestions have ranged from porphyria to bipolar disorder — the symptoms only became evident several years after he and Charlotte were married, and he didn't start receiving the hellish treatment depicted in the show until the 1780s.

Added: 600

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/PerryMason2020'':
** Brooks speaks of having built an MLB-caliber stadium in hopes of attracting a Major League Baseball team to LA. No such stadium was built in Los Angeles at this time. The main baseball park was Wrigley Field, which seated 21,000--too small for an MLB team even though the teams that played there sometimes outdrew MLB teams.
** Season 2 is set in 1933, with reference made to the FBI. This was before the agency existed. At the time, its predecessor was named the DOI (that is, Division of Investigation). It would only be named Federal Bureau of Investigation in 1935.



* ''Series/QuantumLeap'': Being a show all about history and time travel, the creators did their best to be accurate; however, there is one small slipup in the series finale "Mirror Image": While in a small west Pennsylvania town on August 8, 1953, Sam finds himself watching an episode of the kids' sci-fi TV series ''Captain Z-Ro''. While ''Captain Z-Ro'' did exist in 1953, it was not nationally syndicated until 1955, appearing only on a couple of West Coast TV stations before then.

to:

* ''Series/QuantumLeap'': Being a show all about history and time travel, the creators did their best to be accurate; however, there is one small slipup in the series finale "Mirror Image": While while in a small west Pennsylvania town on August 8, 1953, Sam finds himself watching an episode of the kids' sci-fi TV series ''Captain Z-Ro''. While ''Captain Z-Ro'' did exist in 1953, it was not nationally syndicated until 1955, appearing only on a couple of West Coast TV stations before then.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "The Exile" features UsefulNotes/CharlesII attempting to assassinate UsefulNotes/OliverCromwell while the latter is attempting to sign a peace treaty with UsefulNotes/LouisXIV. The episode ends with [[spoiler:the main character convincing Louis to recognize Charles as the rightful King of England and reject Cromwell's treaty.]] In reality, Charles II and Louis XIV were cousins, and Charles spent most of his life in French courts due to the political problems in England, so there's no way they wouldn't have known each other.

to:

** "The Exile" features UsefulNotes/CharlesII attempting to assassinate UsefulNotes/OliverCromwell while the latter is attempting to sign a peace treaty with UsefulNotes/LouisXIV. The episode ends with [[spoiler:the main character convincing Louis to recognize Charles as the rightful King of England and reject Cromwell's treaty.]] In reality, Charles II and Louis XIV were cousins, and Charles spent most of his life in French courts due to the political problems in England, so there's no way they wouldn't have known each other. In fact, Charles' sister Henriette was married to Louis' brother Phillipe!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A minor one in ''Series/{{House}}'': Wilson mentions in passing that Nixon was impeached for conducting illegal surveillance. Nixon in fact resigned to avoid impeachment because he lacked both the numbers in the House to avoid it and in the Senate to avoid being removed as a result.

Top