Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AdaptationalWimp / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The title character in ''Series/RoboCopTheSeries'' wasn't quite as durable as his film counterpart. While it would take anti-tank weapons like the Cobra Assault Cannon or the cannons of ED-209 or [=RoboCop=] 2 to do damage to Murphy, he could absorb a lot and keep going, including surviving a 100+ fall and a subsequent gas main explosion in the climax of 'Film/RoboCop2''. with what new damage he had not be from either of those (the scarring on his helmet from Cain's plasma torch). In ''The Series'', larger weapons would shut him down and he'd need a reboot to get back up. In fact, while a crane was also involved, unlike the climax of ''2'', the episode of "Faces of Eve" sees Murphy be severely damaged from a fall from a much lesser height.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/Fallout2024'': Lucy in the show is a stand-in for the Vault-Dweller PlayerCharacter of the first three games, namely the Lone Wanderer of ''VideoGame/Fallout3'' whom she thematically mirrors. However while the Lone Wanderer is a [[OneManArmy One Man/Woman Army]] that can plow through enemies like a MookHorrorShow and typically is armed to the teeth, Lucy by contrast is a ActionSurvivor who almost dies many times, loses her finger, and is captured and tortured by the Ghoul. It's not until Episode 4 that Lucy starts TakingALevelInBadass and becomes more capable like the Lone Wanderer and other Fallout protagonists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/OnePiece2023'':
** Due to being a PragmaticAdaptation, the non-Devil Fruit using characters with CharlesAtlasSuperpower are (with the big exceptions of Mihawk, Garp and Kuro) more realistically grounded. For example, in the manga/anime Zoro and Sanji were capable of great feats of SuperStrength despite being rookies in East Blue - in the live action series however they are "merely" very strong by human standards and don't display anything too crazy beyond some wall running, torso bisecting and Sanji sending Kuroobi flying with Mouton Shot, and even then he doesn't literally kick the fishman through Arlong Park like in the manga/anime.
** Zeff also got this, partly due to his actions in the Baratie arc and Sanji's flashback getting compressed, but mainly due to being a relatively more grounded character. In the manga/anime version of the flashback, Zeff was shown to be strong and badass enough to kick a mast in half and use said mast to save the swept overboard kid Sanji - here however, all his blood-soaked kicking action happens off screen by the time he encountered Sanji and he doesn't display any super strength. Even in the present as a HandicappedBadass with a peg leg, Zeff could still knock Luffy around and at one point uses RazorWind from one of his kicks to blow out some flaming pearls flying at him. In the live action series Zeff is realistically well out of fighting prime with Kuroobi able to defeat him effortlessly. Played With though, as in this series Garp the "Hero of the Marines" and rival to Gol D. Roger considers Zeff a WorthyOpponent and respects him as a fellow grizzled geezer. Unlike the manga/anime where Zeff was never considered or mentioned to be within Garp or Roger's ballpark.
** Hatchan aka Hachi, Arlong's right hand man, due to being heavily DemotedToExtra and being Hachi In Name Only gets this. He only appears in one scene where he plays cards with Nami, doesn't resemble an octopus and is only named in the credits. This contrasts to the manga where Hachi while the silliest and most gentle of the Arlong pirates (with his better nature leading to him going on a RedemptionQuest) was still pretty damn badass, being one of the Sun Pirates and wielder of six swords which he uses to effectively fight (an admittedly wounded) Zoro. In this series however Kuroobi takes his position as TheDragon to Arlong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheLastKingdom:'' In the novels, Cnut Longsword is renowned for his speed and deals Uhtred a nearly mortal wound at Tettenhal. In the series, their duel is much more one-sided with Uhtred coming out unscathed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Henry was a muscly and reasonably competent survivor in the game, and he could take on infected and bandits same as Joel and Ellie. In the show, he’s a more of a weedy NonActionGuy who seeks Joel's help — precisely due to the fact the latter can do what he can’t.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheLastOfUs2023'':
** In [[VideoGame/TheLastOfUs the original game]], main protagonist Joel is a typical OneManArmy video game player character who can mow down bad guys and shrug off getting shot like nothing. In the HBO adaptation Joel is [[DentedIron tough but vulnerable to the effects of old age]], relying primarily on ambush tactics and intelligence to win most fights he gets into. He also suffers from aching knees and is deaf in one ear, which lead to him getting jumped from time to time. The university segment is the most clear example of this. In the game, Joel gets wounded after fighting a dozen men and falling off a balcony onto some rebar while grappling with one bandit who surprised attacked him. In the show, Joel just gets stabbed by a broken baseball bat while killing a single attacker.

to:

* ''Series/TheLastOfUs2023'':
** In
''Series/TheLastOfUs2023'' has several examples in comparison to [[VideoGame/TheLastOfUs the original game]], main game]]:
** Main
protagonist Joel is goes from a typical OneManArmy video game player character who can mow down bad guys and shrug off getting shot like nothing. In the HBO adaptation Joel nothing to a man who is [[DentedIron tough but vulnerable to the effects of old age]], relying primarily on ambush tactics and intelligence to win most fights he gets into. He also suffers from aching knees and is deaf in one ear, which lead to him getting jumped from time to time. The university segment is the most clear example of this. In the game, Joel gets wounded after fighting a dozen men and falling off a balcony onto some rebar while grappling with one bandit who surprised attacked him. In the show, Joel just gets stabbed by a broken baseball bat while killing a single attacker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''VideoGame/TheLastOfUs'' game, main protagonist Joel is a typical OneManArmy video game player character who can mow down bad guys and shrug off getting shot like nothing. In the HBO adaptation Joel is [[DentedIron tough but vulnerable to the effects of old age]], relying primarily on ambush tactics and intelligence to win most fights he gets into. He also suffers from aching knees and is deaf in one ear, which lead to him getting jumped from time to time. The university segment is the most clear example of this. In the game, Joel gets wounded after fighting a dozen men and falling off a balcony onto some rebar while grappling with one bandit who surprised attacked him. In the show, Joel just gets stabbed by a broken baseball bat while killing a single attacker.

to:

** In ''VideoGame/TheLastOfUs'' game, [[VideoGame/TheLastOfUs the original game]], main protagonist Joel is a typical OneManArmy video game player character who can mow down bad guys and shrug off getting shot like nothing. In the HBO adaptation Joel is [[DentedIron tough but vulnerable to the effects of old age]], relying primarily on ambush tactics and intelligence to win most fights he gets into. He also suffers from aching knees and is deaf in one ear, which lead to him getting jumped from time to time. The university segment is the most clear example of this. In the game, Joel gets wounded after fighting a dozen men and falling off a balcony onto some rebar while grappling with one bandit who surprised attacked him. In the show, Joel just gets stabbed by a broken baseball bat while killing a single attacker.

Added: 2151

Changed: 472

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/TheLastOfUs'', main protagonist Joel is a typical OneManArmy video game player character who can mow down bad guys and shrug off getting shot like nothing. In the HBO adaptation, ''Series/TheLastOfUs2023'', he's portrayed as [[DentedIron tough but vulnerable to the effects of old age]], relying primarily on ambush tactics and intelligence to win most fights he gets into. He also suffers from aching knees and is deaf in one ear, which lead to him getting jumped from time to time.

to:

* ''Series/TheLastOfUs2023'':
**
In ''VideoGame/TheLastOfUs'', ''VideoGame/TheLastOfUs'' game, main protagonist Joel is a typical OneManArmy video game player character who can mow down bad guys and shrug off getting shot like nothing. In the HBO adaptation, ''Series/TheLastOfUs2023'', he's portrayed as adaptation Joel is [[DentedIron tough but vulnerable to the effects of old age]], relying primarily on ambush tactics and intelligence to win most fights he gets into. He also suffers from aching knees and is deaf in one ear, which lead to him getting jumped from time to time. The university segment is the most clear example of this. In the game, Joel gets wounded after fighting a dozen men and falling off a balcony onto some rebar while grappling with one bandit who surprised attacked him. In the show, Joel just gets stabbed by a broken baseball bat while killing a single attacker.
** Tess in the game was easily as competent as Joel, able to casually head shot a goon one-handed and mid-conversation, kill numerous infected in gameplay and save Joel from a Clicker. In the show Tess is noticeably less capable, missing her shots repeatedly with Joel having to do pretty much all the heavy lifting in combat, including saving her and Ellie from the Clickers. Her HeroicSacrifice is inversely a case of AdaptationalBadass however; in the game Tess was gunned down after killing two Fedra soldiers to buy Joel and Ellie time to escape, while in the show Tess succeeds in a massive TakingYouWithMe gasoline explosion that obliterates a horde of infected.
** Ellie is still a LittleMissBadass in her own right, but many of the moments from the game where she displayed her competency and skill are adapted out with the result of her being more helpless the majority of the time. This is seen in the show’s version of the university segment, where Ellie shoots wildly at the bandits and misses them, unlike the game where she effectively protected the wounded Joel from a dozen or so men. Similarly in the Silver Lake chapter in the game, Ellie took the cannibals on a wild ChaseFight (initially on horseback) and it took a good deal of effort for them to subdue her. In the show, they fairly easily knock Ellie unconscious after she lures them away from Joel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/TheLastOfUs'', main protagonist Joel is a typical OneManArmy video game player character who can mow down bad guys and shrug off getting shot like nothing. In the HBO adaptation, ''Series/TheLastOfUs2023'', he's portrayed as [[DentedIron tough but vulnerable to the effects of old age]], relying primarily on ambush tactics and intelligence to win most fights he gets into.

to:

* In ''VideoGame/TheLastOfUs'', main protagonist Joel is a typical OneManArmy video game player character who can mow down bad guys and shrug off getting shot like nothing. In the HBO adaptation, ''Series/TheLastOfUs2023'', he's portrayed as [[DentedIron tough but vulnerable to the effects of old age]], relying primarily on ambush tactics and intelligence to win most fights he gets into. He also suffers from aching knees and is deaf in one ear, which lead to him getting jumped from time to time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/TheLastOfUs'', main protagonist Joel is a typical OneManArmy video game player character who can mow down bad guys and shrug off getting shot like nothing. In the HBO adaptation, ''Series/TheLastOfUs2023'', he's portrayed as [[DentedIron tough but vulnerable to the effects of old age]], relying primarily on ambush tactics and intelligence to win most fights he gets into.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The most notable character to suffer this at the beginning of the series is Constantine Drakon, considered one of the best martial artists in all of DC and one of Green Arrow's greatest enemies. In the show, he's just a StarterVillain who isn't able to best Oliver in any way and has the added bonus of being DemotedToExtra, getting killed off in his first appearance in the first episode of the series no less.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The titular ''Series/{{Lucifer}}'' was introduced in Creator/NeilGaiman's ''ComicBook/TheSandman'' as the second most powerful being in all creation, second only to the creator, someone who the eternal and undying AnthropomorphicPersonification of Dreams and Storytelling feared such that entire issue was dedicated to Dream putting his affairs in order and saying goodbye to people due to the possibility that Lucifer might decide to destroy him. In the show he's an angel, an immortal, and a badass, but doesn't appear to be particularly special compared to the other angels that appear in the show.

to:

* The titular ''Series/{{Lucifer}}'' was introduced in Creator/NeilGaiman's ''ComicBook/TheSandman'' ''ComicBook/TheSandman1989'' as the second most powerful being in all creation, second only to the creator, someone who the eternal and undying AnthropomorphicPersonification of Dreams and Storytelling feared such that entire issue was dedicated to Dream putting his affairs in order and saying goodbye to people due to the possibility that Lucifer might decide to destroy him. In the show he's an angel, an immortal, and a badass, but doesn't appear to be particularly special compared to the other angels that appear in the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/GuestFromTheFuture'': Thanks to the episodes three to five being a PacifiedAdaptation, all the children except Kolya Gerasimov and Kolya Sadovsky are hit with it. They never fight the pirates; when they finally do encounter them, they are utterly helpless before getting rescued by an adult. Several examples are particularly jarring:
** In the book, Alice escapes the pirates when she is cornered by them at the hospital, solely thanks to her quick reactions, and later manages to snatch away Rat's gun in the last fight. In the series, she escapes the pirates in the hospital because, for some weird reason, they only search the ward but don't attempt to kidnap her; and the last fight is entirely omitted. The one time Alice and Rat end up face to face, she meekly lets him take her hostage and is only saved when Kolya Gerasimov distracts the pirates and prompts them to go after him.
** In the book, Yulia is one of the best in her class when it comes to sports. She attacks Jolly U at the hospital and contributes significantly to the last fight with Rat, all the while recovering after appendicitis (and in the latter case, with a twisted ankle). In the series, she briefly carries Alice on her shoulders as part of their disguise, but otherwise is just a sidekick for Alice to talk with and never participates in fights.
** In the book, Kolya Sulima is a BadassBookworm who, according to Alice, is going to invent time travel. In the series, he is DemotedToExtra and barely there, and the honor of inventing the time machine is given to Kolya Sadovsky instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheLordOfTheRingsTheRingsOfPower'': In the books, the Númenóreans are described as being physically superior to normal Men in almost every way. Not only are they far stronger, but also the average Númenórean is taller than 6 feet, while Elendil is described as being between 7 to 8 feet tall. They were also the direct descendants of the Men who fought alongside the Elves in their war against Morgoth and were capable warriors in their own right. In the show, the Númenóreans don't look physically distinct from normal Men and are shown to be incredibly inept at fighting, requiring Galadriel to train them personally.

to:

* ''Series/TheLordOfTheRingsTheRingsOfPower'': In the books, the Númenóreans are described as being physically superior to normal Men in almost every way. Not only are they far stronger, but also the average Númenórean is taller than 6 feet, while Elendil is described as being between 7 to 8 feet tall. They were also the direct descendants of the Men who fought alongside the Elves in their war against Morgoth and were capable warriors in their own right.so mighty that they made Sauron's armies flee and the dark lord himself surrender without any bloodshed when they confronted him. This was ''after'' he had forged the One Ring. In the show, the Númenóreans don't look physically distinct from normal Men and are shown to be incredibly inept at fighting, requiring Galadriel to train them personally.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In this version, despite his power, the titular character seems totally unable to beat an opponent without the support of his team (the majority of the time). Justified since not only is Barry still relatively inexperienced, he has a bad habit of rushing in without thinking as well as over relying on his super speed, otherwise he'd function as a StoryBreakerPower.

to:

** In this version, despite his power, the titular character seems totally unable to beat an opponent without the support of his team (the majority of the time). Justified since not only is Barry still relatively inexperienced, he has a bad habit of rushing in without thinking as well as over relying on his super speed, otherwise he'd function as a StoryBreakerPower. He also [[CharacterDevelopment slowly loses this trait]] [[TookALevelInBadass over the course of the series]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheLordOfTheRingsTheRingsOfPower'': In the books, the Númenóreans are described as being physically superior to normal Men in almost every way. Not only are they far stronger, but also the average Númenórean is taller than 6 feet, while Elendil is described as being between 7 to 8 feet tall. They were also the direct descendants of the Men who fought alongside the Elves in their war against Morgoth and were capable warriors in their own right. In the show, the Númenóreans don't look physically distinct from normal Men and are shown to be incredibly inept at fighting, requiring Galadriel to train them personally.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheSandman2022'':
** Dream gets this a fair amount, he’s still essentially a PhysicalGod in the show but one that’s much more easily dismissed, bullied and used as a doormat by other characters compared to his comic counterpart. Notably Constantine is able to do what ever she wants in front of him unlike the comic version where Constantine was the one helpless to Dream’s whims during their mission. Similarly the Corinthian was never a real threat to Dream in the comic even with Rose affecting the Dreaming. There’s also Dream’s interaction with the mocking demon Squatterbloat, in the show Dream telling him to mind his tone to the King of Dreams somewhat comes off as an empty threat, whereas in the comic Dream punctuates his warning by easily overpowering Squatterbloat and sending him flying making it a legitimate case of BullyingADragon. Not to mention Dream almost gets destroyed during the oldest game and needs Mathew’s support, which didn’t occur in the comic.
** Lucifer Morningstar (once again) gets this to some extent by being the one who engages Dream in the oldest game and losing, rather than it being the demon Choronzon. Comic Lucifer was never beaten by Dream in any fashion and merely annoyed Dream had got the better of hell.

Changed: 563

Removed: 532

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheBoys2019'': Homelander never gets the better of comic Stillwell, who is completely unfazed by him and becomes a KarmaHoudini in the end.
** The title group also never inject themselves with Compound V to get superpowers. [[https://www.reddit.com/r/television/comments/cjt17f/im_eric_kripke_the_cocreator_of_the_new_amazon/evg10se/ As the creator explained]], doing so would reduce it to another superhero slugfest, while keeping them as average humans put wits as the priority over strength - "We don't need powers to save the world. We just need each other." Eventually {{Subverted|Trope}} in Season 3, where Hughie and Butcher both use V-24 to give themselves powers.

to:

* ''Series/TheBoys2019'': Homelander never gets In contrast to the better of comic Stillwell, who is completely unfazed by him and becomes a KarmaHoudini in original comic, the end.
** The
title group also never inject themselves with Compound V to get superpowers. [[https://www.reddit.com/r/television/comments/cjt17f/im_eric_kripke_the_cocreator_of_the_new_amazon/evg10se/ As the creator explained]], doing so would reduce it to another superhero slugfest, while keeping them as average humans put wits as the priority over strength - "We don't need powers to save the world. We just need each other." Eventually {{Subverted|Trope}} ZigZagged in Season 3, where Hughie and Butcher both use V-24 to give themselves powers.powers [[PsychoSerum at a cost]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The title group also never inject themselves with Compound V to get superpowers. [[https://www.reddit.com/r/television/comments/cjt17f/im_eric_kripke_the_cocreator_of_the_new_amazon/evg10se/ As the creator explained]], doing so would reduce it to another superhero slugfest, while keeping them as average humans put wits as the priority over strength - "We don't need powers to save the world. We just need each other."

to:

** The title group also never inject themselves with Compound V to get superpowers. [[https://www.reddit.com/r/television/comments/cjt17f/im_eric_kripke_the_cocreator_of_the_new_amazon/evg10se/ As the creator explained]], doing so would reduce it to another superhero slugfest, while keeping them as average humans put wits as the priority over strength - "We don't need powers to save the world. We just need each other."" Eventually {{Subverted|Trope}} in Season 3, where Hughie and Butcher both use V-24 to give themselves powers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking Knife Nut per trs disambig


** Number Two aka Diego actually had SuperNotDrowningSkills along with his ImprobableAimingSkills [[KnifeNut with knives]] in the comics. In the show, however, Diego has only got the knife skills and otherwise is just a BadassNormal. Then again the show's second season does give him some level of [[MindOverMatter telekinesis]] as he was able to [[BulletDodgesYou redirect bullets]] in mid air, a power he doesn't possess in the comics.

to:

** Number Two aka Diego actually had SuperNotDrowningSkills along with his ImprobableAimingSkills [[KnifeNut with knives]] knives in the comics. In the show, however, Diego has only got the knife skills and otherwise is just a BadassNormal. Then again the show's second season does give him some level of [[MindOverMatter telekinesis]] as he was able to [[BulletDodgesYou redirect bullets]] in mid air, a power he doesn't possess in the comics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Clark Kent aka ComicBook/{{Superman}} gets this as he's far less powerful than the comic book version or even other live-action versions for that matter and he's explicitly weaker than Kara who has defeated him, though he's actually [[SoProudOfYou proud of her for it]]. In the comics, while they can be more or less equal DependingOnTheWriter, Clark is still capable of feats that Kara has never accomplished. Averted [[Series/SupermanAndLois in his own show]] where Clark is presented as ridiculously powerful as the budget will allow, he even manages to shrug off getting shot with Kryptonite at one point, something most versions Supes cannot do.

to:

** Clark Kent aka ComicBook/{{Superman}} gets this as he's far less powerful than the comic book version or even other live-action versions for that matter and he's explicitly weaker than Kara who has defeated him, though he's actually [[SoProudOfYou proud of her for it]]. In the comics, while they can be more or less equal DependingOnTheWriter, Clark is still capable of feats that Kara has never accomplished. Averted Averted [[Series/SupermanAndLois in his own show]] where Clark is presented as ridiculously powerful as the budget will allow, he even manages to shrug off getting shot with Kryptonite at one point, something most versions Supes cannot do.



* ''Series/TheWitcher2019'' gives this treatment to Eyck of Denesle in the episode "Rare Species" which is based of the book ''Sword of Destiny''. In the book Eyck is a truly badass KnightInShiningArmor and dragon slaying monster hunter whom even Geralt considers a rival. Apart from saving Geralt and Yennefer from a avalanche, Eyck actually fights the golden dragon Villentretenmerth himself before getting knocked off his house by the dragon's tail and crippled. In the show Eyck of Denesle is a PrinceCharmless and treated like a joke, the only monster he kills is a Hirikka, a creature Geralt says was harmless and would've left them alone if they fed it. Instead of facing the dragon, Eyck is unceremoniously killed [[TheCanKickedHim while shitting in the woods]] by the Reavers.

to:

* ''Series/TheWitcher2019'' gives this treatment to Eyck of Denesle in the episode "Rare Species" which is based of the book ''Sword of Destiny''. In the book Eyck is a truly badass KnightInShiningArmor and dragon slaying monster hunter whom even Geralt considers a rival. Apart from saving Geralt and Yennefer from a an avalanche, Eyck actually fights the golden dragon Villentretenmerth himself before getting knocked off his house by the dragon's tail and crippled. In the show Eyck of Denesle is a PrinceCharmless and treated like a joke, the only monster he kills is a Hirikka, a creature Geralt says was harmless and would've left them alone if they fed it. Instead of facing the dragon, Eyck is unceremoniously killed [[TheCanKickedHim while shitting in the woods]] by the Reavers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Clark Kent aka ComicBook/{{Superman}} gets this as he's far less powerful than the comic book version or even other live-action versions for that matter and he's explicitly weaker than Kara who has defeated him, though he's actually [[SoProudOfYou proud of her for it]]. In the comics, while they can be more or less equal DependingOnTheWriter, Clark is still capable of feats that Kara has never accomplished. Averted [[Series/SupermanAndLois in his own show]] where Clark is presented as ridiculous powerful as the budget will allow, he even manages to shrug off getting shot with Kryptonite at one point, something most versions Supes cannot do.

to:

** Clark Kent aka ComicBook/{{Superman}} gets this as he's far less powerful than the comic book version or even other live-action versions for that matter and he's explicitly weaker than Kara who has defeated him, though he's actually [[SoProudOfYou proud of her for it]]. In the comics, while they can be more or less equal DependingOnTheWriter, Clark is still capable of feats that Kara has never accomplished. Averted Averted [[Series/SupermanAndLois in his own show]] where Clark is presented as ridiculous ridiculously powerful as the budget will allow, he even manages to shrug off getting shot with Kryptonite at one point, something most versions Supes cannot do.

Top