What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to DethroningMoment/Moviebob

 

Larkmarn
topic
04:10:13 PM Jun 23rd 2014
Readded my moment, which was pulled for being about an episode (when it wasn't). My moment only mentioned one thing: the name of the episode as to why it was a DMOS. I can see how someone could think someone thought it was saying that I was saying "the episode 'You Are Wrong About Spider-Man 3'" was the DMOS, but I was saying "the titles 'You Are Wrong About Spider-Man 3' was the DMOS," which is valid.
StormKensho
topic
12:24:04 PM May 11th 2014
So if we can't put whole episodes in the Dethroning Moment page, where CAN we put them?
harryhenry
12:40:15 PM May 11th 2014
edited by 121.99.213.13
What are you talking about?
SeptimusHeap
12:46:40 PM May 11th 2014
There is no place to put whole episodes because we don't want such pages. Dethroning Moment of Suck is a page that survives because it's old. We won't be making such pages anymore.
StormKensho
10:32:50 AM May 26th 2014
Harry Henry: I'm talking about how a lot of examples for Movie Bob got cut because they focused on entire episodes instead of one moment from said episodes. A lot of them were, IMO, nice entries to read as they contained valid criticisms of said episodes(in addition to being standard-issue venting), like the entry criticizing his defending of that travesty Metroid: Other M. So I was simply curious where those entries could be ported to so that they won't be lost.

Septimus Heap: Mmkay. I was simply curious. Still, perhaps they could be brought over to the So Bad It's Horrible section of the Darth Wiki? I'm just interested in preserving those cut entries so that they won't be lost to the nether of the Internets...
Larkmarn
06:14:25 AM May 27th 2014
I don't think it qualifies for So Bad, It's Horrible. Though it looks like the Metroid: Other M section does have a specific moment ("The stupidest point, is where he calls Other M better than Metroid Prime is because it isn't a FPS, which he goes on to say is everything wrong with gaming today") that would be valid, but the rest of the entry would need to be trimmed.
harryhenry
06:18:10 AM May 27th 2014
edited by 121.73.215.127
Plus, we can't even put it in So Bad, It's Horrible because the sections where it would belong (Web Original and Web Video) have been locked due to flame wars.
Larkmarn
06:26:54 AM May 27th 2014
... avoiding things like this being posted on So Bad, It's Horrible is probably part of the reason for the lock. Seriously, as bad as some of those reviews are, do you honestly think that it's turned Bob's works into "A work that is of exceptionally low quality, having been widely panned by critics and a commercial failure"?
StormKensho
12:09:17 AM Jun 6th 2014
Ah, I see. So maybe we could re-add the Other M entry, but trim it down to focus on that particular Dethroning Moment?
Yamato-san
07:35:24 PM Jun 13th 2014
Why was the entry on his defense of Anita Sarkeesian removed?
SeptimusHeap
08:59:16 PM Jun 13th 2014
Because you aren't allowed to "defend" someone here. These pages collect certain opinions. Defenses aren't part of that.
Larkmarn
11:51:13 AM Jun 15th 2014
edited by 108.28.148.135
^ I think you misread. The removed entry was claiming his defense of of Anita Sarkeesian was a DMOS. It was removed because it didn't claim a single DMOS, rather several throughout the entire episode.
Yamato-san
12:00:05 PM Jun 15th 2014
edited by 74.42.181.5
You do realize I was talking about a Dethroning Moment entry that talked about the way BOB defended Sarkeesian in a dismissive, prickish fashion (a controversial act that Bob still refuses to refute to this day), right? I was not talking about any TV Tropes users defending her.

EDIT: Ninja'd.
StormKensho
12:46:48 PM Jul 5th 2014
Obviously, this page isn't fully fleshed out and is undergoing some maintenance. It shouldn't take but some simple trimming to make the previous entries more appropo.
back to DethroningMoment/Moviebob

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy