Duplicate Trope: Recycled In Space get usage counts
Deadlock Clock: 17th Dec 2012 11:59:00 PM

Total posts: [66]
1 2
3
51 Xtifr29th Jan 2013 12:07:19 PM , Relationship Status: Having tea with Cthulhu
World's Toughest Milkman
Ok, first this:
If an idea seems to be stealing the plot/premise/pitch of another idea, but the characters and setting are different, it's Whole Plot Reference.

should become:

As a setting trope, this is distinct from Whole Plot Reference. The two may overlap, but it is possible to be either one without being both. For example, The Flintstones is, by Word of God, The Honeymooners recycled in the Stone Age, but is not a Whole Plot Reference.

I also suggest splitting the following into two separate points:

If an idea seems to be ripping off another idea, it's Better by a Different Name. It needs to be blatant in its advertising that it is a copy for it to count. You could argue that "Eragon was better when it was called Star Wars" but since nothing ever advertises the similarities, it doesn't count as this.

There's two different issues there:

  • If an idea seems to be ripping off another work, it's Better by a Different Name. If you were to claim that "Eragon was better when it was called Star Wars", that would simply not be an example of this trope. No setting is mentioned.
  • It needs to be blatant in its advertising that it is a copy for it to count. Taking the previous example: even if you were to rephrase that as "Eragon is Star Wars recycled in a Standard Fantasy Setting", it would still not be a valid example, because nothing ever advertises the similarities.

edit: fixing typos

edited 29th Jan '13 12:10:15 PM by Xtifr

"Existential Despair" is an oxymoron.
I second closing the topic.
53 SeptimusHeap31st Jan 2013 01:41:09 AM from Valle di Muggio, Switzerland , Relationship Status: Mu
Tadpole
[up][up]I would agree with the first idea, but with the second I need some quoteblocking.
54 Xtifr31st Jan 2013 12:05:25 PM , Relationship Status: Having tea with Cthulhu
World's Toughest Milkman
[up]I was suggesting replacing the one bullet point (quoted in my third quoteblock) with the two bullet points at the bottom. Imagine a quoteblock around those two bullet points if it helps. (Everything I was discussing there is bulleted on the page.)
"Existential Despair" is an oxymoron.
55 SeptimusHeap31st Jan 2013 12:15:17 PM from Valle di Muggio, Switzerland , Relationship Status: Mu
Tadpole
A shorter version of your proposed changes is fine for me.
56 Xtifr31st Jan 2013 12:49:02 PM , Relationship Status: Having tea with Cthulhu
World's Toughest Milkman
I'm mostly concerned about the first one (about Whole Plot Reference). If you're not comfortable with the second, I'm willing to let it slide. It's much less important.

edited 31st Jan '13 10:38:48 PM by Xtifr

"Existential Despair" is an oxymoron.
Beside the issue in the last few posts, I still see this:

edited 2nd Feb '13 1:39:27 AM by spacemarine50

58 SeptimusHeap2nd Feb 2013 01:56:26 AM from Valle di Muggio, Switzerland , Relationship Status: Mu
Tadpole
About #1 and #2: We do many tropes without citations, even if they rely on authorial intent. And nobody has shown a problem there anyway.

About #3: Why?

About #4: Already thumbed-down. Also, if you have to say "Is it duplicate to several tropes?" then there is a good chance you are wrong.

59 MagBas2nd Feb 2013 02:04:26 AM from In my house
[up][up]About the second... the third "common thing to avoid" described in the Recycled In Space page is "It needs to be blatant in its advertising that it is a copy for it to count. You could argue that "Eragon was better when it was called Star Wars" but since nothing ever advertises the similarities, it doesn't count as this."

edited 2nd Feb '13 2:05:11 AM by MagBas

60 Xtifr3rd Feb 2013 10:15:15 PM , Relationship Status: Having tea with Cthulhu
World's Toughest Milkman
Last call for objections to my first change proposed in post 51, which is unopposed so far.

(I'll leave out the other change, since it seems both more controversial and less necessary.)
"Existential Despair" is an oxymoron.
61 Xtifr5th Feb 2013 02:07:51 PM , Relationship Status: Having tea with Cthulhu
World's Toughest Milkman
Ok, I made that first change, and didn't bother with the second. As far as I'm concerned, there's no other issues that really need repair shop attention. Cleanup, assuming any is needed, is something that can always be done at any time. Unless someone else has an issue, I move to close the thread.
"Existential Despair" is an oxymoron.
62 SeptimusHeap5th Feb 2013 02:13:35 PM from Valle di Muggio, Switzerland , Relationship Status: Mu
Tadpole
Agree on this motion.
Seems there's no further issue here (assuming there was one to begin with).

Agree with closing.
Why do you think there's no issue left?
65 SeptimusHeap6th Feb 2013 01:40:39 AM from Valle di Muggio, Switzerland , Relationship Status: Mu
Tadpole
See @58 and @59.
66 lu1276th Feb 2013 11:48:29 PM from 七夜 , Relationship Status: Loves me...loves me not
Closing this, then.
The system doesn't know you right now, so no post button for you.
You need to Get Known to get one of those.

Total posts: 66
1 2
3