These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
YMMV: The Almighty Johnsons
Blessed with Suck: How Ty views his powers. To be fair, his powers do kind of suck: he's mostly numb to sensation and accidentally froze Dawn while they were in bed.
Ear Worm: Gin Wigmore's "Oh My", the song used in the opening credits.
Evil Is Sexy: Michele/Sj÷fn embodies this trope, given that she's the human incarnation of a goddess of love.
Hollywood Homely: Played straight and somewhat exaggerated with Delphine, who has moles and a small boil on her face and wears frumpy clothes (which may well hide the fact that she's pregnant). Olivia Tennet, the actress who plays Delphine, is much more attractive in real life.
Ho Yay: Zeb's admiration of Axl and addressing him constantly as "My Lord Odin" does make it seem like he's more than a little bit in love with him.
I Knew It: Gaia going to be Frigg, before fate intervened.
The montage near the end of the final episode of season 3.
Amongst the Johnson brothers, Ty, mainly because he always ends up being the "best friend a girl could ever have" (though he gets better for a while with Dawn).
Amongst the secondary characters, Dawn, Anders's assistant, who always ends up cleaning up after his literal and figurative messes. Delphine could also be considered one for being the daughter of Derrick/Thor and for breaking down into tears when Axl gets annoyed with her.
They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: Season three seems to be hit-or-miss with a lot of the show's fans, mainly due to the fact that some major plot elements - the Godhunters, Gaia becoming Idunn and subsequent strain in Axl and Anders' relationship - are introduced and dropped fairly quickly with little or no fanfare.
Unfortunate Implications: Anders's powers of persuasion bear a remarkable resemblance to date rape, especially when some of his "conquests" talk about not even knowing why they agreed to sleep with him. It's hard to tell how much of this subtext is intentional—Anders is portrayed as a dick for using his powers the way he does, but it's never really taken to the logical conclusion.