YMMV / Super Dimension Fortress Macross

  • Alternate Character Interpretation: Did Roy grossly miscalculate the seriousness of his injuries and thus caused his own death, or did he correctly assess that his time was almost up and deliberately choose to hide the gravity of his injuries so he could see Claudia one last time?
  • Americans Hate Tingle: Lynn Minmay, because of Character Exaggeration/Flanderization in the Robotech dub, the fact that Reba West/Rebecca Forstadt, the actress hired to play Minmay was not up to the task, and that the songs written for her were likewise poor (especially the bellicose "We Will Win," in the climactic battle, the total polar opposite of the original "Ai wa Nagareru", a very pacifist song.)
  • Awesome Music: Plenty; particularly noteworthy ones include "Sunset Beach", "Zero-G Love", and the classic "My Boyfriend is a Pilot".
  • Die for Our Ship: Minmay would surely get much less grief if she wasn't interested in Hikaru, thus keeping him and Misa apart.
  • Ensemble Darkhorse: Arguably, the Destroid Monster: it's the only mech outside of the variable fighters that has showed up in some form in every series since, however briefly and however importantly.note .
  • Fan Nickname: For the guy currently in charge of the series no less, Shoji Kawamori is known among some fans as the Hory Froating Head)
  • "Holy Shit!" Quotient: Many, but the ones who stand up the most are the titular ship punching an enemy ship in the face (this even in-universe: after seeing it, Breetai and Exedore are left speechless for a moment before monotoning they need reinforcements) and Bodolza glassing Earth as soon as he's in orbit (a first in anime history, and lampshaded by Misa crying they can't do it as soon as she sees the data).
  • It Was His Sled: It's virtually impossible for a new viewer to go into the show without already knowing Minmay as a superstar idol singer, which might lessen the emotional impact of watching her rise to fame from her humble start as a waitress at her family's restaurant.
  • Memetic Mutation:
    • YACK! DECULTURE! - An expression initially meant to display disgust in the fictional Zentraedi language, the expression was used in scenes depicting the Zentraedi reacting to Earth culture, including Minmay's songs as well as people kissing. This eventually led to the expression becoming a positive one both in-universe and among the series' fans.
    • Captain! No smoking on the bridge! note 
  • Nightmare Fuel: What, no one here who got to watch this show as a kid wasn't traumatized by the part where the whole Zentraedi Main Fleet just pops up out of nowhere and immediately showers the Earth with their ships' cannons before the defense forces even gets to put up a fight? And that particular scene depicting a soldier's gallant but futile attempt to shield a little girl from the global destruction....
    • And the worst part comes from Word of God: there are other Zentraedi Main Fleets out there, each just as numerous as that one. Meaning this could happen again and again... And, in the alternate continuity of Macross II, they did.
  • Refuge in Audacity: As the Robotech novels point out, Max stealing a Zentradi's uniform and dressing his Valkyrie in it really shouldn't have worked, but it was just too awesome to not happen.
  • The Scrappy:. Kaifun, because he's a major Jerk Ass and extremely obnoxious on top of it.
    • If anything, the creators acknowledge it: as per Word of God, in the timeframe of Macross 7, Kaifun is part of the Macross 11 fleet where he manages an American knockoff of Fire Bomber, all while claiming they're the originals and Basara is the ripoff. Take That, Scrappy! or what?!
  • Strangled by the Red String: While the show foreshadows it before they've met, Max's feelings for Milia go from "let's go for coffee" to "be my soul mate" at the drop of a hat ( or a dagger in this case.). This is especially funny considering he declares his love right after she tries to kill him in a knife fight for defeating her, once in battle and then at the arcade.
    Hikaru: Excuse me, but didn't you just go out on a date with this girl? I mean fun's fun, but jumping straight into marriage?
  • The Problem with Licensed Games: Not with the case of the 2003 version released for the Playstation 2.
  • Values Dissonance: In Japan, Kaifun being Minmay's cousin and love interest isn't a big deal. For Americans, it's a lot creepier.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/YMMV/SuperDimensionFortressMacross