When Itchy died between the first and second movie, he went through a time warpThink about it. Dogs live about 10 to 20 human years on average, and both Charlie and Itchy are 25 in dog years. Itchy died from choking on a piece of chicken, and the first movie took place in 1939, while the second took place in 1996, the year of its release.
- Or Carface went through a time warp when he left, or there was a massive Time Skip in the second movie.
- Perhaps Charlie and Carface's short trips back to earth caused chaos in Heaven's bureaucracy and held up a bunch of dogs for several years?
Carface's time in heaven between films is responsible for his Villain DecaySpending so long in Heaven between films softened him a bit. He wasn't a good guy, but wasn't a threat like before. Worked for Dabura in Dragon Ball Z and he was a demon king, makes more sense here to. Also, this would help explain his Heel–Face Turn in the Christmas Special.
Anabelle managed to convince Carface not to return to EarthHe's last seen preparing to steal his life clock at the end of the first film, Anabelle convinced him not to.
- She's last seen chasing after him and screaming "I SAID, YOU CAN NEVER GO BACK!!" In this case, "convince" equals "force."
Belladonna freed Carface from Hell as part of a Deal with the DevilWhenever Belladonna shows up, Carface works for her. It's never explained how he got out of Hell after Red dragged him there. Belladonna probably freed him in exchange for his service, she just didn't call in the favor until she finally showed up herself. When he performed his Heel–Face Turn and redeemed himself, it got him out of the deal.
- It all makes sense: to Carface, a crime lord and ruthless gambler, selling his soul to Red in exchange for life of servitude was "strictly business" and he had no idea he was getting more than he bargained for. He agrees to work for Belladonna because he assumes he'll suffer significant less as her lackie, but come the Christmas special, he sees that he just made the same mistake again and all the years of serving demons have frightened him out of being a criminal, as he knows what true evil is and decided to become a better person for it. Kind of makes his Villain Decay more like Character Development, doesn't it?
Charlie is a reincarnation of Rocky Sullivan from the movie Angels with Dirty FacesBoth Charlie and Rocky use use a similar catch phrase "what da u hear what da u say" Both characters in each movie get out of prison in the beginning of the films, and both are betrayed by their former crime partner who tries to kill Charlie/Rocky to keep all of the casino they built together.
- Charle was even born about the time Rocky would have died!
The couple that adopted Anne-Marie are really...J.R. "Bob" and Connie Dobb. Because, come on, the resemblance is just too uncanny!
The whole movie was a hallucination of Anne-Marie's.She was a half-starved orphan living in a garbage dump full of dogs, and out of loneliness personified the animals herself.
The Heavenly Whippet really did know everything that would happen.All dogs go to heaven, right? Even complete bastards like Carface (and rather more loveable bastards like Charlie). Even if they have done nothing to earn it. And the Whippet claimed that she knows everything that's going to happen, but Charlie manages to "surprise" her nonetheless. He returns to earth and manages to earn his redemption in the process. At the end Carface also plans to escape, and Charlie is convinced that "he'll be back". The whole plot actually makes a lot more sense if you assume heaven is running a Batman Gambit with these "bad dogs", letting them think they tricked their way back to life when its actually all part of the plan for them to redeem themselves. All dogs do go to heaven, but only because the bad ones all try the same thing Charlie and Carface did, with similar results.
Charlie never went back to Earth.When a dog winds up their watch or clock, they are sent to purgatory, set out to look like the place they came from, where a series of challenges and tests are set up to determine whether dogs like Charlie or Carface deserve a place in heaven, or if they should be sent to hell.
Red was the monstrous demon creature from the first film.They've gotta be the same character...they've even got the same chin!
King Gator is a descendent of Louis.Ever since Louis made it as a successful trumpet player, he managed to land a lovely lady gator wife (or several) and started a line of musically-inclined alligators in the New Orleans area over the next few decades. While King Gator hasn't exactly sought a musical career, he still displays a love for song and dance and is quick to befriend anyone else with an affinity for music.
- But don't the films take place around the same time?
- Well, maybe they're brothers or cousins or something.
Charlie is a lich.His watch was his phylactery (Soul Jar in Tropese).
David's step-mother is Anne-Marie or a descendant of hers.It may be possible, both have dark hair and blue eyes, it could very well be possible that David's step-mother could somehow be Anne-Marie living in a different life after the death of Itchy, he could have died while with Harold and Kate since Anne-Marie is an adult now. Also, we never see how David's parents react with Charlie and Sasha, but when he asks them if they would like a pet or two, they seem to accept as David gives them food bowls.
The backstory given in "When Harry met Silly" is a lighter and softer version of how Charlie and Itchy actually met.Charlie didn't want to freak out the kids with details of gangsters, booze and graphic death. In addition, Annabelle would have been on his tail if he told the real version. So he fluffed it up, crafting a well-rehearsed fable that hid certain details under a lightened curtain.