So You Want To / Be Original
One of the biggest obstacles for creators of fictional works is originality. Many works, despite being made by different people, are very similar or even almost identical
and some people don't like it
, because they only try to replicate past success with minimal differences, and because they are often unable to create new ideas by themselves.
One of the most important things to learn for being original is to learn about three paradoxes:
Paradox 1: It Is Impossible To Be New Anymore
The first paradox is that it is impossible to create anything truly "new"
. You cannot create something from nothing. Every fictional work (with a few exceptions
, and even then, Internet Rule 22To wit...
is in full effect here in addition to The Tropeless Tale
) is based on previous works. In fact, all works use "elements" from previous works to make something new. That's basically why this entire website
Think of the periodic table
. Everything that exists is made from that finite number of elements. And yet the variety of unique biological life-forms and inorganic substances is virtually infinite. The source of all fiction is Real Life
and the very first fictional works took their elements from Real Life
; all "new" works are simply derived from those original works.
For instance, taking one popular element of fiction, dragons
are apparently "made from nothing" given that they don't exist. However, they are, in fact, a mixture of different kinds of reptiles
that together make something "new". These new combinations are mixed again to create even more combinations like a "chain-reaction"
. Here's a slightly more specific example:
- First the Sitcom Bewitched inspired both the creation of another show I Dream of Jeannie and the Magical Girl and Magical Girlfriend genres.note
- Then the Magical Girl genre coupled with the sentai genre inspired Naoko Takeuchi to create Sailor Moon.note
- Finally Sailor Moon redefined the Magical Girl genre and created the Magical Girl Warrior subgenre.
For an even more in-depth analysis, this Cracked
article uses Star Wars
and Santa Claus
(It Makes Sense in Context
, trust us) to construct a "cynicism cycle" framework that successive consumers/aspiring creators go through regarding works of fiction. To quote the article, the more you dig into it, the uglier it looks, until eventually it...isn't. Since Weblinks Are Not Examples
, here's the cycle in a nutshell:
- First, you're entranced by the works you love as a child, perhaps to the point where you might even be an unwitting Daydream Believer;
- Then, you grow up just enough to realize they're fictional (as far as we know, anyway) and had Doylist factors at work behind the scenes during their creation, mostly involving maximizing profit, which usually means following the leader in at least some capacity;
- Then, you grow up enough to realize the true scope of said Doylist factors in the creation process and conclude that profit was all it was really for. This is where this paradox begins to make itself known, but it doesn't really occur to you until...
- Then, your Nostalgia Filter (and inner cutie) breaks when you look back and realize this didn't get started when you were a kid; it was already active back then and has been going on literally since storytelling was born. All works of fiction in existence have been recycling elements from those that came before. This is the stage at which you truly realize and grasp this paradox, a realization that hits you like an Anvil on Head (except now you know Toon Physics won't let you off with just a Cranial Eruption, oh no, you know your skull of creativity has just been bashed in but good.)
- BUT... if you can resuscitate your creativity with some perspective and (ironically) your Nostalgia Filter, and realize that:
- The works that you hold dear and got so much joy out of did, in fact, let you get so much joy out of them;
- Those same works are thought by others to be cheap rip-offs in the same way you think some more recent works are;
- That still others hold dear and get so much joy out of those same more recent works; and...
- This cycle of "X hates A and loves B, Y hates B and loves C, Z hates C and loves D..." is going to keep right on going like this,
- ...you'll then be in position to help do just that.
Contrary to how that last point sounds, this is a good thing. Those who scream "It's the Same, Now It Sucks!
!" at a work are somewhere within the middle three stages, and will likely get stuck somewhere in there. The cycle itself is an order of Knights in Sour Armor
: they have gone through its breaking grind, but in the end are part of a handful of their generation who have not gotten stuck, have risen above the paradox at the cycle's core and are now creating works that will groom the next generation so that a handful of them will make it to where they are, and can then create works to groom the generation after that for the same. And thus it will continue. But the only way to rise above the paradox is to make it to Stage Five of the cycle. And then you can do battle with the next two!
Paradox 2: Freedom Is Paralyzing, but Restriction Breeds Creativity
The second paradox is to realize that unlimited creative freedom actually puts limits on one's ability to create a story. Conversely, narrowing one's creative options actually helps to make creativity unlimited. To illustrate this, here's a quick exercise:
- First, on a sheet of paper, write an original short story. You can't use anything from previous works, even from past works you have made yourself.note All the characters must be created by you.
- Now write, on another sheet of paper, a piece of fanfiction based on your favorite fictional work.
Which story was easier to make? You probably struggled more with the first one than you did with the second. When the human brain has unlimited creative freedom, it is unable to actually create anything until its options are more rigidly defined. Instead of thinking, "I want to make a cool story," think "I want to make a Magical Girl
series about a girl that is also secretly a singer". The reason why there is so much more fanfiction than original stories is because it is easier to create new stories based on older ones than from scratch.
An undeniable corollary to the aforementioned paradox is the fact that rules and limitations can actually help in the creative process.note
For example, Executive Meddling
and those pesky Moral Guardians
often put limits on what themes and topics that TV shows are allowed to depict, but writers try to find loopholes and disguise hidden meanings in seemingly innocuous concepts. Say you want to put an Aesop
about peer pressure in a children's television show; specifically, you want to explain why Drugs Are Bad
. The network won't allow any explicit depiction of substance abuse on a show for kids, but you shouldn't let that stop you; just make up a plot device for that episode that has similar effects to many misused substances
. Try to focus yourself and your ideas as much as you can. For example, giving a hero a fatal weakness can create a variety of new potential conflicts and plots. On the other hand, too many limitations might also discourage you from creating new stories.
Paradox 3: Copying Others Makes It Easier To Not Copy Others
The third paradox can be summed up in one of George Santayana's most famous sayings: "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it". If you don't see how people before you made stories, it's very likely that you will unwittingly repeat the same ideas. And even worse, you might think that you
were the first to come up with those ideas.note
If you see how past stories were made, you will still want to put your own spin on it. Tropes Are Flexible
, so even if you rip off another work's concept, you can bend to fit the purposes of your story; the originality in this case is not the trope itself, but how you played with it. For instance, an Unwanted Harem
is not very original, even if it does
contain some non-human characters. A twist on this particular genre would be making the main character bisexual, enabling both male and female love interests. A Magical Girlfriend
story is also rather unoriginal — after all, there are only so many times you can use ghosts, aliens, angels, etc, before it seems redundant and uninspired. In this case, originality stems from making the girlfriend a different type of non-human, a troll for example, or a creature made out of fire. Or perhaps you could take the plot of a Hentai
anime and remove the porn
, creating a story that's much different from the original.
When you get down to it, these little tweaks and spins are really what make fiction interesting. More than one person◊
has observed that the basic plots of most BioWare RPGs
are basically the exact same thing, over and over; and yet, BioWare's video games have consistently ranked amongst the most highly-praised and well-loved in all of history. How is this possible? Simple: because of the wrinkles
in the formula. BioWare take this basic story skeleton and then hang all
sorts of interesting, well-thought-out, compelling details onto them, filling in the spaces to create worlds and characters that feel real, alive, lived-in.
Another thing to keep in mind is that almost all stories can be boiled down to descriptions that make them sound downright idiotic. "Couple fall in love; man dies on boat." Does this sound interesting? Because, when directed by James Cameron
, these eight dumb words became Titanic
, the first film in human history to earn more than $1 billion at the box office, the second to earn more than $2 billion (after Avatar
), and sharing records for the most Academy Award
nominations (14, with All About Eve
) and wins (11, with Ben-Hur
and The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King
). Speaking of Avatar
, what's its dumb premise? "Man pilots blue cat and decides to go native"; or, to quote a satirical X Meets Y
, "Dances with Smurfs
." How could such silly ideas possibly turn into the two highest-grossing films ever? Because execution matters
... and, arguably, it matters a lot more than the premise itself
. History is full of good story ideas that turned into crap products
, and of ideas to which people said, "It Will Never Catch On
," before they went onto become runaway successes. And that's good news for you, because it means you don't need a new idea; you just need a new idea about an old idea.
Try to get ideas straight from the source of all art: Real Life
. Don't be afraid to Write Who You Know
; there are far, far
more real life situations and people than will ever appear in fiction. Remember that funny thing that happened to you on the bus? Or that cool weird friend you met at school? Real Life
has an unlimited amount of ideas; so much, in fact, that you don't need to use ideas from previous works
in order to find something truly "new".
And the best advice of all is to always remember to write what you love and never be afraid to create something that has never been done before. Never forget to have fun and you will create "original" works in no time!