- Matt Schultz- vocals
- Brad Schultz- guitar
- Jared Champion- drums
- Daniel Tichenor- bass
- Lincoln Parish- lead guitar
- Cage The Elephant (2008)
- Thank You, Happy Birthday (2011)
- Melophobia (2013)
This band provides examples of the following tropes:
- Animated Music Video - The video for 'Aberdeen' is animated with beautiful Stop Motion.
- Anti-Love Song - "Around My Head". Well, sort of.
- Careful With That Axe:
- "In One Ear" and "Free Love" both have Matt screaming his head off before the final chorus.
- "Sabretooth Tiger" has Matt doing this for the entire chorus.
- One might have figured Matt had multiple pairs of legs on "Japanese Buffalo".
- Cover Version: On EPs and in live versions, they've covered "False Skorpion" (Pavement), "Kids" (MGMT), "Monkey Disease" (Iodine), "Psycho Killer" (Talking Heads), and "All Apologies" (Nirvana).
- Dying Dream: The music video for "Shake Me Down".
- Getting Crap Past the Radar: One radio edit of "In One Ear" changes the line "The crowd will only like me if they're really fuckin' drunk" to "the crowd will only like me if they're all smacked up". Thus, the band got rid of a curse word, but also exchanged one drug (alcohol) for another, less socially acceptable one (heroin).
- Lighter and Softer: "Melophobia" may not seem like a totally light album, but that's before you listen to "Thank You Happy Birthday".
- New Sound Album: Thank You, Happy Birthday is rawer and more abrasive than their debut. It is often compared to the Pixies.
- Of Corpse He's Alive - The video for "Around My Head". It's an odd Crowning Moment of Funny.
- Precision F-Strike - At the end of the "Around My Head" video and the aforementioned "In One Ear".
- "The Reason You Suck" Speech: "Back Stabbin' Betty" centers on a woman who constantly hammers her man with undeserved examples:You're a no, good, lazy motherfucker
Got a, shit job you worthless motherfucker
You're a, a dead beat, feel sorry for your mother
If I had time, I'd trade you for anotherYou're a two, faced ruthless instigator
You're a low down, triflin' masquerader
You're a cold bitch, controlling conversator
This is too much, I'm out I'll see ya later
- Self-Titled Album
- Something Something Leonard Bernstein: "Sabretooth Tiger"
- Once the main part of "Japanese Buffalo" kicks in, it's very hard to make out anything but the "HA HA HA AND OH HO HO" near the middle of the verse until the pause. One might think Matt is having an attack while he's singing.
- Stalker with a Crush: "It's Just Forever". Even in death, you say?
- Surprisingly Gentle Song - "Shiver", the acoustic version of "Right Before My Eyes". "Flow" and "Rubber Ball" also count.
- "Flow" counts doubly as it also has a surprisingly gentle and very minimalistic music video.
- Take That - "Indy Kidz" is a jab at Hipsters.
- Take That, Critics! - "In One Ear." Well, more of a "Screw You" than a "Take That," but still a bit of a Take That.People talkin' shit / They can kiss the back of my hand!
- Word Salad Lyrics
- Played for laughs with "Japanese Buffalo" where the lyrics are purposely slurred.