Literally Laughable Question

The truth is that there are, in fact, stupid questions. Sometimes, a question has such a blatant answer that the person who answers, usually a Deadpan Snarker, can't just say yes or no, or give any normal answer. Instead, that person completely cracks up, to the point where he or she often looks like he or she is giving the phrase a new meaning. When this scene occurs, it is a Literally Laughable Question. If the person laughs for an extremely long time, it is also an Overly Long Gag.

While this sometimes occurs in real life, it is usually used in fictional media as a comedy trope.

Compare Hahaha No and Sarcasm Mode.

Examples:

Fanfic
  • Before the final battle in Infinity, Signum asks Susanoo and Tsukuyomi how to get their older sister to stop hitting on her. Susanoo bursts into laughter and Tsukuyomi giggles.

Film
  • L.A. Story. When Harris K. Telemacher calls up the exclusive restaurant L'Idiot and asks for a reservation for Friday, the response is crazed laughter. When he asks for one on Saturday the response is the same. Only when he asks for one on Sunday does he get a positive response.
  • Porky's: When Coach Ballbricker claims that she can identify a certain penis which had been poked through a peephole to the girls locker room (it has a mole) and demands that she be allowed to examine the suspects' penises, the principal and school administration try to keep from laughing, not always succeeding, as they deny her request.

Newspaper Comics
  • In one strip of Big Nate, Nate's grandparents pay him money for painting their house. When his dad takes him back home, Nate asks if that was enough money for college. Nate's dad completely cracks up, and Nate thinks to himself, "Probably not the best question to ask in a moving car."
  • Garfield strip for January 22, 2016. Jon Arbuckle is a schlemiel who has a female veterinarian named Liz as his girlfriend. When he asks his cat, Garfield, "Do you think I'm good enough for Liz?" Garfield starts laughing uncontrollably. Jon says, "You're the wrong guy to ask," and Garfield muses, "Oh, I think I laugh for everyone."
  • Peanuts Sunday Strip for April 4, 1999. Charlie Brown asks Lucy at her psychiatric booth, "So I'm wondering, could I ever learn to be the life of the party?" Lucy says, "YOU?" and laughs hysterically. She apologizes for laughing and says, "You? The life of the party?" followed by another fit of hysterical laughter.

Literature
  • American Psycho: Patrick Bateman gets this when trying to place last-minute reservations at Dorsia.

Live-Action TV
  • One episode of The Good Wife has Eli Gold trying to figure out if an intern on Peter Florrick's gubernatorial campaign slept with him (she claims on TV that he has a birthmark shaped like Brazil on his penis). When he asks Alicia, Peter's estranged wife, about it, she bursts out laughing at the birthmark part, putting the lie to it.
  • In an episode of My Wife and Kids, Junior wants to follow his girlfriend when she goes to college and says he can get a job in the city she goes to. He asks the guy sweeping the pizza parlour floor what his job pays, and is greeted by hysterical laughter.
  • NYPD Blue: In "NYPD Lou", Alphonse Giardella, a high ranking mob member who has turned state's evidence, hits on the female D.A. who is assinged to his case. She tries to be polite about it but excuses herself to go to the bathroom, where she breaks up laughing over the whole thing. Giardella's enemies take this moment to kill him.
    Giardella: Laura, Laura, I'm trying to tell you how high it is a value I place on our relationship. I'm trying to signify something to you here.
    Laura: Will you excuse me for a moment?
    Giardella: Yeah, sure. Do you gotta go to the bathroom or something? Yeah, you know where it is. Yeah, it's right over there. Just help yourself.
    [Laura enters the bathroom]
    Laura: [silently laughing] Oh, my God.
    Giardella: [through the door] - Yeah, you know, and if I come back, uh, we could drive wherever, you know. Maybe one of them, uh, breakfast and board places in them quaint areas. You know, one of them places with the quilts on the bed and, uh, those pictures of the whaling guys. One of these days, all this bouncing around like a cue ball is gonna stop. I'm gonna get myself set up somewhere. Out west, maybe. Can you hear me, Laura? You fall in in there?
  • Played for Drama in the Star Trek: The Next Generation Series Finale, "All Good Things..." — Picard (and the audience) do not understand why Q finds his question laughable:
    Q: There you go again, always blaming me for everything! Well, this time, I'm not your enemy. I'm not the one who causes the destruction of humanity. You are.
    Picard: Me?
    Q: Yes. You're doing it right now. You did it before, and you'll do it yet again.
    Picard: What kind of meaningless doubletalk is this?
    (The whole courtroom laughs)
    Q: (Laughing) He doesn't understand! I have only myself to blame, I suppose.
  • Babylon 5: Early in season 4 when a Narn demands to know what G'Kar endured while they were under Centauri occupation, G'Kar, bearing scars from being tortured and nearly beaten to death and a patch over a still-raw eye socket, just starts chuckling to himself.

Web Original

Western Animation
  • In Avatar: The Last Airbender, Aang attempts to buy a valuable waterbending scroll from a pirate captain that is selling his wares. He offers three coins, which causes the captain to laugh loudly at him and assume he's joking; when it turns out Aang isn't, he scowls and comments that the perceived 'joke' is wearing thin.
  • Subverted in The Simpsons when Marge tries joining the Springfield Police Department. Her request to sign up is met with the cops laughing for several seconds... only for them to stop and say "welcome aboard". At the end, when she declares her resignation over their stealing the evidence for their own use, they laugh again, but then politely wish her luck.
  • On The Brave Little Toaster, the appliances end up on a spare parts store where old appliances are stripped for parts. When Lampy asks how they can escape, the hanging lamp on the store room says "Did you hear that? They want to know how to escape!", followed by laughter from all the doomed appliances.

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/LiterallyLaughableQuestion