The time of an event doesn't happen at the time it was said. Usually the clock or watch is off.
The event either happen early or later, but the characters don't notice until quite after the event. In mysteries, such a discrepancy can make or break an alibi.
Compare Magic Countdown
. Contrast Right on the Tick
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
- In the very first mystery of The Kindaichi Case Files, Kindaichi manipulates a suspect's watch to get said suspect to reveal themselves. Many other mysteries are also solved when Kindaichi realizes that some sort of clock-based manipulation is in play.
- Also happens occasionally in Case Closed; once, a police officer realized that his roommate was up to no good because he kept all of his clocks 5 minutes fast to make sure he was never late to work, but the roommate reset the clocks to read accurately as part of his plot to fudge with his alibi. (Fortunately, more substantial proof of guilt is also found.)
- In an Archie comic, Big Eater Jughead is in class, and informs the teacher, Miss Grundy, that "his stomach" says its lunchtime. She reminds Jug that the clock on the wall reads 10 before noon. At that moment, the school janitor Mr. Svenson enters the classroom with a ladder. The purpose? To adjust the clock, which he said was running ten minutes slow.
- The Maze Agency: In one story Gabe accidentally yanks the killer's wristwatch off his wrist during a struggle. Noticing that the watch is three hours ahead, Gabe realises that the killer had just flown in from the west coast.
- Around the World in 80 Days: At first it looks like Phileas Fogg came a day late and lost the bet, but then he notices the date in the newspaper and realizes that, since they crossed the International Date Line, they had gained a day and are still on time.
- The book 1984 plays with this idea. The main character looks at the clock which reads 8:00. He thinks it's still 8 pm, but instead it was actually 8 am.
- Happens in some Agatha Christie stories, notably Evil Under the Sun, where a watch worn by a witness is deliberately altered to give the murderer an alibi and allow him to stage a fake murder so that the victim appears to have been killed before she really was.
- In Murder on the Orient Express, the broken watch also appears - and Poirot points out that the killer wants him to think that the murder happened at that time.
- There's also an example revolving around the clocks going back in one of the Black Widowers mysteries, where a character is woken up by a phone call at a time that is actually an hour later than he thinks it is (because he hasn't yet set his clock forward for Daylight Savings Time) and thus unwittingly provides a false alibi.
- In another Black Widowers story, a discrepancy between "ten minutes before six" (which would exonerate the accused) and "half past five" (which incriminates him) is resolved in favor of the former — the witness reporting the latter was an accountant used to decimal numbers who unconsciously interpreted the digital clock display "5:50" as "five and a half".
- The Lord Peter Wimsey novel Have His Carcase has a discrepancy that's based on medical evidence rather than timepieces. Harriet finds the body of the victim with still-liquid blood pooled around it; then the body is washed out to sea before it can be autopsied. Peter and Harriet spend most of the book assuming the murder happened almost immediately before she found the body, because the blood didn't have time to clot; in actuality, the victim was a hemophiliac and the murder happened several hours earlier.
- Meanwhile, Harriet is working on a novel where someone has to set a clock to support an alibi. And finding it frustrating.
- A vital part of the solution to John Dickson Carr's The Hollow Man. The reported time of the second murder is so far off that it took place before the first murder, and the victim of the first murder was the killer.
- OCPU Prison by Sven Hassel. The fire control officer fails to synchronize his watch with the other officers; he ends up dropping the artillery bombardment on his own troops.
Live Action Tv
- Shows up as a common contradiction in the Ace Attorney series. In fact, it shows up in the first case of Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney, when witness Frank Sahwit claims the time of the murder was at 1:00 when it was actually 4:00. Given that he's the real killer, the discrepancy is because the murder weapon was a talking clock that was off by several hours at the time of the murder.
- The Learavia Lear Fan 2100 had to have its first flight in 1980 in order to retain some of its development funding after its inventor, Bill Lear, died in 1978. A sympathetic official in the British government (the plane was to be built in economically-depressed Northern Ireland) recorded its January 1st maiden flight as happening on "December 32nd, 1980."