Film: The Siege
London. Paris. Athens. Rome. Belfast. Beruit. We're not the first city to have to deal with terrorism. Tel Aviv. The day after they bombed the market in Tel Aviv the market was open and it was full. This is New York City. We can take it.
— Anthony "Hub" Hubbard
The Siege (1998) is a film about terrorists attacking in New York City made about three years before the September 11, 2001 attacks. The film was directed by Edward Zwick, previously known for (among others) Glory (1989) and Legends Of The Fall (1994). Denzel Washington, Annette Benning, and Bruce Willis play patriotic characters with different ideas about the best way to defend America from terrorists.The film opens with the bombing of American Army barracks in Saudi Arabia. There are multiple casualties and a terrorist cell under Sheikh Ahmed bin Talal is blamed. The action shifts to New York where a series of terrorist incidents occur, escalating in significance. Initially handled by FBI agents Anthony Hubbard (Washington) and Frank Haddad (Tony Shalhoub). Later, CIA agent Elise Kraft (Benning) gets involved. Later yet, the President declares martial law and the Army's 101st Airborne Division, under Major General William Devereaux (Willis), occupies and seals off Brooklyn in an effort to find the remaining terrorist cells. Devereaux has all young males of Arab descent, regardless of ideological affiliation, rounded up and detained in a makeshift prison camp at Yankee Stadium. This only helps worsen the situation. New Yorkers stage violent demonstrations against the army and the racial profiling of the Arabs. The Army has to fight to maintain control. There are reports of Army killings. Meanwhile, Devereaux starts interrogating suspects by torturing them. In one case to death. The situation further escalates.In hindsight, treated terrorism more maturely than many films before 9/11. Unfortunately note , the way the public, the government, and the terrorists acted in the film turned out to be pretty inaccurate when a large scale terrorist attacks happened in Real Life. Well, mostly.Features cameos by a young Aasif Mandvi and Bill Clinton. Tony Shalhoub also figures, as an FBI agent of Middle Eastern origin, whose son is caught up in the profiling and internment. The film was a box office hit, its worldwide gross estimated to 116,672,912 dollars. However, only 41 million of these dollars came from the United States market. There it was the 49th most successful film of its year and received mixed reviews. At least a few critics appreciated it as "a thinking person's thriller".
This show contains examples of:
- A Million Is a Statistic: Deveraux justifies the killing of a civilian who, under interrogation, didn't reveal anything by invoking this trope, saying that one dead man to save a hundred is worth it.
- Anachronism Stew: During the scene where Deveraux is describing what the occupation of New York would entail, he distinctly mentions the "M16A1 assault rifle"; the Army had upgraded to the M16A2 years before the events of the film. Or Bruce Willis simply flubbed the line.
- Also the use of an AH-1 Cobra attack helicopter in the Redhook chop shop scene; the Army had replaced the Cobra with the AH-64 Apache at about the same time as they switched out the aforementioned M16 models.
- Anti-Villain: General Deveraux, who will do anything and everything to ensure his country his safe.
- Bus Full of Innocents: The film plays this trope twice, where the terrorists have taken a Bus Full of Innocents and packed explosives into it to prove their point. The first time, it's a paint bomb, and no one gets hurt. The second time, there are children and old folks (and regular people I suppose) on the bus, but Denzel Washington's character persuades the terrorists to release the children. Then he tries to persuade them to release the old folks, and as they are getting off, the bomb detonates and there's a massive incinerating explosion.
- Cassandra Truth: General Devereaux himself warns his superiors not to use him or his troops in New York City, as he knows that extremely strict martial law and the extreme force the military requires to carry out its operations would result in human rights violations, if not worse. They ignore his protests and everything goes to Hell.
- CIA Evil, FBI Good: While the military is portrayed as doing the best as they can and the General in charge of the operation and the CIA Officer attending to it have major doubts about their operation, they're still trampling on basic human rights, as opposed to the FBI's attempt to handle the situation as cleanly and humanely as possible. The military and CIA go so far as to torture a man to death, simply because he refused to say anything, though the CIA agent attending didn't want to go through with it, and Deveraux was dead certain he had information.
- Deadpan Snarker: Agent Frank Hadad, played by Tony Shalhoub.
- Emergency Authority: The President of the United States declares martial law in Brooklyn and the U.S. Army's 101st Airborne Division, under Major General William Devereaux (Bruce Willis), occupies the city district, seals it off, and proceeds to round up all young Arab males into makeshift detention camps.
- Fair Cop: Agent Hub.
- General Ripper: Deveraux.
- Gunpoint Banter: The climactic standoff between the FBI and General Devereaux borders on breaking out into a gunfight, but Devereaux declines to order his troops to fire and instead talks with Agent Hub, realizing the Xanatos Gambit by Agent Hub he was trapped in.
- He Who Fights Monsters: Devereaux warns his superiors that martial law is a bad idea, but when commanded to do so, he does anything and everything to eliminate the threat.
- I Am the Trope: Near the end of the film:William Devereaux: I am the law. Right here, right now, I am the law!
- I Did What I Had to Do: Again Devereaux.
- Invisible President-Strangely subverted. Newsreel footage of Clinton appears at the beginning of the film, and his portrait hangs in in Denzel Washington's office. But the characters refer to him as if he were a President Invisible. Bruce Willis does manage to get off a joke about the president being good at protecting himself, though.
- Jurisdiction Friction:
- The FBI vs the CIA. The FBI arrest several CIA officers operating on US soil early in the movie for "kidnapping, obstruction of justice and assault".
- FBI vs the United States Army. The FBI usually enforces its own jurisdiction through brute, rigorous audacity, aka "detaining" (if not outright arresting) anyone who gets in their way, in the spirit of "Do Unto Others Before They Do Unto Us". They later arrest several soldiers spying on them, and proceed to later arrest General Devereaux, his entire command staff, and armed military sentries after a tense standoff.
- Knight Templar: Devereaux. He'll do everything he can to protect America.
- Mexican Standoff: Near the end of the movie between the FBI and the 101st Airborne.
- Post 9-11 Terrorism Movie-Subverted, or rather an amazingly literal example of an Unbuilt Trope.
- Prison Rape: Discussed.Hubbard: You know what they do to new girls at Ryker's Island?Kraft (who is a woman): Mmmmm... Yum.
- Profiling: One of the major plot points in the film is, after the military is called in, any young American of Arab descent will be detained in an attempt to find the cell members. There are also reported attacks on Arab Americans from racist New Yorkers, and in-between scene transitions, you can hear phone calls and radio call-ins about those "towelheads".
- Really Gets Around: Elise, but that is part of her professional duties.
- Recruiting the Criminal: Elise takes this approach, though it doesn't work out. In fact, this is what kickstarted the plot in the entire place.
- Running Gag: Frank lamenting about the FBI not having microwave surveillance equipment. He finally gets it, after he detains US Army personnel spying on Kraft.
- Screw This, I'm Outta Here!: Frank has this reaction when the Army detains his son, throwing down his badge and leaving. Hub later manages to talk him out of it though.
- Smoking Hot Sex: Samir Nazhde takes a smoke after having sex with Sharon Bridger in one scene.
- Well-Intentioned Extremist:
- General Deveraux. He's fully aware of the ramifications of a military force bearing down on a scared civilian populace and knows that wartime law enforced would lead to severe rights violations (in his first appearance, he says he agrees with the ACLU on this issue) and an unhappy, uncooperative city, but when ordered to enact military law does it by all means necessary, and is determined to bring down the threat-even if it means civilian casualties.
- Samir Nazhde. He's retaliating against the US for what he sees as injustice rendered to what had been a former ally, thrown away like trash. His final target is a pro-peace march, which he acknowledges as "a tragedy", but rationalizes that all of his victims will be martyrs.
- Xanatos Gambit: The movie ends with a big one when Denzel Washington's Agent Hub leads a team of FBI agents (basically everyone who's left alive) to arrest General Deveraux in the middle of his Army camp. He and his agents are completely outnumbered and outgunned but that doesn't matter because either Deveraux will stand down, he'll order his men to fire and they'll refuse to kill the FBI agents (who are supposed to be on the same side), or he'll order them to fire, they'll follow the order, and the murder of a dozen federal agents will be too much lawlessness for the White House to tolerate, and Deveraux will be relieved of command. Anyway it goes down, Hub (and the rule of law) win. Deveraux sees the play too, which is why he engages in Gunpoint Banter with Hub instead of just ordering his soldiers to fire, but finally he decides since he's going to lose any way he plays it, he'll stand down and avoid throwing good money after bad with another illegal order.