Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion DethroningMoment / DoctorWho

Go To

You will be notified by PM when someone responds to your discussion
Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.
zoop Since: Aug, 2014
Nov 10th 2014 at 1:58:31 PM •••

Most of the episodes seem to be listed in broadcast order. Is that deliberate? It looks like it may have come about by accident (since there's a few that are out-of-sequence).

I'd like to propose making it an official "rule" of this page: Keep the list sorted by episode broadcast order. If you're commenting on an episode someone else has already done, yours goes underneath theirs (and indented).

Ecclytennysmithylove Ecclytennysmithylove Since: Nov, 2013
Ecclytennysmithylove
Jan 29th 2014 at 5:15:12 PM •••

I'm not quite sure about Novus Wulf's DMOS, but do you think maybe the Doctor Who episode "Nightmare in Silver" wasn't exactly a ripoff from "Warhammer 40,000". I think both the Doctor Who episode and Warhammer 40,000 just happened by coincidence.

  • Novus Wulf: How has Nightmare in Silver gone unmentioned? The episode shows signs of running out of ideas when the whole Imperium is unashamedly ripped straight from Warhammer 40,000 - "Punisment Platoon" being a nice rewording of Penal Squad, the soldiers clearly dressed like classic Cadians and armed with Lasguns, and they even have a goddamned Emperor (who mercifully is NOT a corpse on a Golden Throne, thank god)! However, where I really take umbridge with this episode is what it did to the Cybermen. It's something Moffat and team have been doing for a while now - first the Daleks being changed from a Nazi Allegory to "they take love and replace it with hate" or some other BS, but now they've turned the Cybermen into a carbon copy of the Borg! Weren't the Borg Cybermen ripoffs? At any rate, the sheer amount of Plagiarism going on and the absolutely awful reimaging of the Cybermen makes this episode my new low point. Oh, and those insufferable, terribly acting kids (who were to some credit at least out of the way for most of the running time). Good god Moffat and friends was this awful.

"I told you PCs were unreliable." Darwin, The Amazing World of Gumball
Ecclytennysmithylove Ecclytennysmithylove Since: Nov, 2013
Ecclytennysmithylove
Dec 1st 2013 at 9:29:35 AM •••

Hello. I just want to let everybody know that I posted my DMOS for a Doctor Who New Series because I was quite surprised nobody mentioned the episode "Father's Day":

Edited by 108.35.129.10 "I told you PCs were unreliable." Darwin, The Amazing World of Gumball Hide / Show Replies
Ecclytennysmithylove Since: Nov, 2013
Dec 4th 2013 at 7:30:19 AM •••

Thanks! :)

"I told you PCs were unreliable." Darwin, The Amazing World of Gumball
Ecclytennysmithylove Ecclytennysmithylove Since: Nov, 2013
Ecclytennysmithylove
Dec 1st 2013 at 7:03:22 PM •••

Also, I posted my positive backup to Tyler FG's DMOS on The Day of the Doctor.

Update- @Telcontar: Oh, alright. I'm sorry. I just wanted point out some of the evidences that Steven Moffat didn't ignore The End of Time continuity.

Edited by 74.105.136.11 "I told you PCs were unreliable." Darwin, The Amazing World of Gumball Hide / Show Replies
Telcontar MOD Since: Feb, 2012
Dec 2nd 2013 at 2:04:57 AM •••

Not so cool. Natter isn't allowed, and DMOS pages have particularly strict rules about not contesting entries. I've removed the paragraph.

That was the amazing part. Things just keep going.
Ecclytennysmithylove Since: Nov, 2013
Dec 2nd 2013 at 1:31:42 PM •••

Oh, alright. I'm sorry. I just wanted point out some of the evidences that Steven Moffat didn't ignore The End of Time continuity.

"I told you PCs were unreliable." Darwin, The Amazing World of Gumball
OldManHoOh It's super effective. Since: Jul, 2010
It's super effective.
Oct 19th 2012 at 7:09:39 AM •••

There's 10 entries on this page. Is that really enough to have its own page?

Hide / Show Replies
triassicranger Since: Jan, 2001
Oct 20th 2012 at 12:34:29 PM •••

One of the other Live Action shows that have their own pages had 13 entries. I figured to do the same thing for Dr. Who.

For what it's worth, I actually thought 10 entries was enough for a work to have its own Dethroning Moment page. But based on the other live action pages, I used 13 as a benchmark.

Edited by triassicranger
Top