Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Film / RogueOne

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Is there anything substantive in the film to back up earlier claims made of a GainaxEnding in this movie? This explanation doesn't seem to actually clarify any of the glaring flaws throughout the narrative and would still suggest the presence of one or more plot holes.
to:
Is there anything substantive in the film to back up earlier claims made of a GainaxEnding in this movie? This explanation doesn\'t seem to actually clarify any of the glaring flaws throughout the narrative and would still suggest the presence of one or more plot holes.

EDIT: Also, Johnny\'s AI mother couldn\'t have possibly \"given\" Johnny back his memories as she was already seen \'\'\'dying\'\'\' (\"burned\" out of the [=PharmaKom=] computer mainframe) prior to Johnny unlocking the three-image download code.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Is there anything substantive in the film to back up earlier claims made of a GainaxEnding in this movie? This explanation doesn't seem to actually clarify any of the glaring flaws throughout the narrative.
to:
Is there anything substantive in the film to back up earlier claims made of a GainaxEnding in this movie? This explanation doesn\'t seem to actually clarify any of the glaring flaws throughout the narrative and would still suggest the presence of one or more plot holes.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Is there anything substantial in the film to back up earlier claims made of a GainaxEnding in this movie?
to:
Is there anything substantive in the film to back up earlier claims made of a GainaxEnding in this movie? This explanation doesn\'t seem to actually clarify any of the glaring flaws throughout the narrative.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The action goes from the Scarif stellar system to the Tatooine stellar system, so it certainly can't be minutes. Even with hyperpropulsion, it is commonly accepted that it takes a few hours to jump from a system to another, with variables including their distance and the presence of hyperspace hazards to avoid.
to:
The action goes from the Scarif stellar system to the Tatooine stellar system, so it certainly can\'t be minutes. Even with hyperpropulsion, it is commonly accepted that it takes a few hours to jump from a system to another, with variables including their distance and the presence of hyperspace hazards to avoid.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
It's also probable that the ''Tantrive IV'' jumped to a few other systems in the hope of losing the Imperials before going to Tatooine, so yes, days are entirely possible.
to:
It\'s also probable that the \'\'Tantive IV\'\' jumped to a few other systems in the hope of losing the Imperials before going to Tatooine, so yes, days are entirely possible.
Top