Poor Image: Is There A Doctor In The House

It's just the trope name on a sign, with no additional context given. It's also heavily artifacted. The scene referenced in the page quote could make a decent replacement pic, though some extensive editing would be required. Thoughts?

Edited by RamenChef on May 4th 2019 at 12:06:27 PM

Agreed, we either need a better quality version or something else entirely.

http://www.nuklearpower.com/2001/03/14/episode-005-run-heroes-run/

Bottom row?

Slightly better than the current, but I'm not convinced.

Pull.

That there are multiple pins stuck in the box, and that it's sawn in half, pushes it just above JAFAAC for me. Weak keep.

pull current. seconding bitemytail's recommendation.

It's not a problem with JAFAAC. It's a problem with not really providing anything more than the title already does.

It could be just me but I kind of assumed that the box with pins stuck in would be indicative of the kind of injuries that would necessitate a doctor.

from the image alone there's no evidence that anyone is even in the box. if, say, there was a tail hanging limply down from the box, it might push it to keep for me. as it is, it's basically just jerry holding a sign with the trope title on it.

I think we need a crowner at this point. We've got about an even split between Pull, keep, and my suggestion.

By my count, there are five votes to pull the current and one weak vote to keep the current. That's hardly an even split. As for the replacement suggestion, there are two votes to put it on the page, and one vote that it's better than the current but still doesn't belong on the page.

I'd suggest a crowner too. There is no clear consensus yet.

Here is a panel from Shaman King Chapter 79 that was mentioned in the trope examples section. Would this work?

Edited by Leporidae on May 7th 2019 at 9:37:22 AM

Yank, regardless of replacement. It adds nothing to the page.

Reclocked. Here's◊ a better-quality version of the current...I'm thinking we need a crowner as well.

Crowner

Thanks, it's hooked.

This one's going to be at a week tomorrow and the crowner is going for just pulling the pic, so that's done and the page is tagged. Going ahead and locking up since we're so backlogged.

Former pic: