The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Indeed.

Pink-haired girl (Chinami) is 16. As for Mare, "Shinigami don't have ages."

Marginally better, but how much does it matter?

The pink and blue haired girls, Chinami and Isuzu, are dangerous, but the younger white haired girl, Mare, is pretty much over the line.

This will create a precedent on Shana Clone characters, so it's important. With that said, it's probably best to play it safe.

There are a ton of them in eroge.

edited 6th Jul '12 4:14:58 PM by OjamajoLimePie

But how many of them are actually shown to be having sex?

Damn, ninja'd. So many replies. I won't edit anymore ;_;

To my knowledge? none that have gone through the panel

edited 6th Jul '12 4:15:58 PM by Marche90

Okay, how many Shana Clones are actually involved in any sexual activities?

Hm, it looks like my devilhead vote will stick. Oh well.

edited 6th Jul '12 4:15:28 PM by Komodin

I'm gonna have to disagree that it'll really be precedent for Shana Clone characters. Those characters are short and young looking, yes. But even taking into account the game's art style, which makes the characters look younger, Mare looks like she like, 7 to me.

edited 6th Jul '12 4:15:18 PM by KuroBaraHime

What I meant was how many of them period are shown to have sex. Most of the ones I can think of are certainly not in any H-anime.

edited 6th Jul '12 4:15:45 PM by TheFoxsCloak

Thought as much, that's why I edited that phrase out. Can't think of that many offhand, if one (maybe thinking it through, though I won't have that much time to answer). And most of the ones that have one have been purged already, methinks

edited 6th Jul '12 4:20:19 PM by Marche90

Since we're on the subject of Shana Clones... I was thinking about making a page for Flyable Heart, but I wasn't sure if Kururi was going to cause a problem. She's the other eroge Shana Clone I was talking about.

Kururi Page @ Anime Character Database

Arha's played Hoshizora no Memoria (and if I'm not wrong, put up the works page), so I think we should wait for his input before making the judgement call just in case. But yeah, going by the pics of Mare (the white-haired shinigami), it's probably not going to pass muster.

edited 6th Jul '12 6:23:15 PM by Pyrite

Hoshizora does have a sex scene with someone that looks like a little girl, namely Mare. And yeah I launched the page for it. However you cannot see the sex scene in the patch that was released. Instead, the cgs all cut to dolphins or something like that. For Chinami and Isuzu they look like mostly flat teenagers to me rather than the little girl Mare.

As for romance with the little girl, that's surprisingly absent. The sex scene (which remember was censored by the translator, who did not want to see that shit) basically comes out of nowhere in the middle of another girl's story. While said little girl is indeed really important to the plot and the main character, the relationship up to this point was not sexual at all.

Personally, I'd say we can keep the page because of that translation patch replacing the sex scene.

Also Komodin: I believe you voted devilhead based on a sex scene with an actually mature character. As for the others, Chinami (pink girl) is basically a teenager, though she's kind of immature and flat chested. On the other hand, she's not as short as I would expect of a little girl and has a lanky build. Isuzu is too much of a jerk to register for me as a little girl. The silver haired girl (Mare) was the one who had their sex scenes censored.

edited 6th Jul '12 8:25:23 PM by Arha

So... it's "safe" to keep?

Just FYI, Jim Carrey is flagged. Can you zap it?

Come to think of it YMMV's for a creator are banned. Cutlisting.

edited 6th Jul '12 8:10:33 PM by tdgoodrich1

^^ I would say so. Amusingly, some people were mad that that scene was censored (I didn't care, but I found the dolphins weird instead of just using the generic background images) but now it's possibly convenient. We do not see the blatantly underaged girl naked. Period. Even going into the CG gallery after you've seen the scene won't show you a thing.

... Sometimes, people honestly baffle me.

Well, it looks like I've relearned a couple of lessons that I should've had drilled into my head by now: context is important, and one shouldn't be judgin' until they have all the dirt necessary.

I'm sorry if I've inconvenienced anyone here. I should switch my vote, then. Thanks, Arha.

edited 6th Jul '12 8:19:04 PM by Komodin

No problem Komodin. I'm glad to be able to provide information that may save a page I put some effort into and had a generally entertaining story, questionable censored bit at the very end aside.

Edit: Normally I would stay around awhile to see if anyone had anymore questions but I am realllly tired. If there are any more concerns I'll get to them tomorrow.

edited 6th Jul '12 8:26:43 PM by Arha

Sorry about the heads-up, too. I also liked the story and the VN, but I thought that under the current policies the game wouldn't be able to make it (a thought I shared about Da Capo I and II too)

Kinda hated to have played the Devil's Advocate here, for the reasons above.

edited 6th Jul '12 8:41:50 PM by Marche90

Dolphins banzai!

Dolphins? That reminds me of how they censored the Unlimited Bladeworks Anime-Movie.

For a little extra random nonsense before we get back to Serious Business and Nightmare Fuel.

edited 6th Jul '12 8:49:39 PM by Roraborialis

海豚万歳！

So long as our dolphin protectors are around, we won't be affected by the terrible forces of the lolicon!

Everybody rejoice!

Yes, we're saved from the evils of lolicon by an animal that is known for raping its females and sexually assaulting humans.

edited 6th Jul '12 9:21:38 PM by Willbyr

I call the idea "Project Dolphin".