- Bile Fascination: America Unearthed has a large following of skeptics and critics. Critic Jason Colavito's blog gets more hits than the show's own site and Scott Wolter's blog combined.
- Critical Research Failure: It doesn't take much knowledge or research to show the errors made by America Unearthed. However some critics not only do that but also deconstruct the origin of a lot of the fringe history claims made by Wolter. Each episode yields plenty of material to the point where virtually everything about the show is a textbook case of this.
- Opinion Myopia: Any time Wolter discusses something with a rare guest that disagrees with him.
- So Bad, It's Good: Why many people tune in.
YMMV / America Unearthed