WARNING: To avoid excessive spoiler tags, the theories themselves will not be spoiler tagged. However, whether they’re confirmed or jossed will be. Proceed with caution.
Think about it, “Mikey,” is written on the bag. Why would “Fritz” be eating someone named Mike’s lunch?
- Jossed, no one saw his lunch
The 3/3/22 update ended on a cliffhanger of Jeremy and Michael about to kiss, but knowing the nature of cliffhangers, that won’t happen. Prominent theories include:
- Someone will walk in
- Usually Phil or Joan, occasionally Sunny
- Michael will pull away before they actually kiss, out of his fear and insecurity
- They’ll both awkwardly pull away, something along the lines of remembering they have something to be doing
- Jossed: They kissed!
He likes to fish and the lake on his calendar resembles Old Man Consequences’s lake. And he has been hurt by William quite a bit.
It was already a popular theory in the source material that Jeremy was the victim, so it applies again here. There really aren’t many options, so it would make sense if it was the only option who is actually in the source material. It would also be good motivation for Michael
Because if it’s not Jeremy, who else would it be?
It has to happen at some point, so why not the night when the night guard is out?
Jossed.
Options include:
- William (the most popular).
- Vincent (sometimes Scott as well).
- Henry.
Jossed. There’s no one in there.
The creator-run wiki states that due to his uncanny resemblance to his father, he can no longer look in the mirror. This is supported within the comic as well.
And, of course, bathrooms have mirrors…
Semi-confirmed. It DOES involve the mirror, however it’s to show that he no longer has a problem with mirrors, and can look in them and see himself again.
Ever since he became complicit in the disappearances of 5 children, his design has been changing. Namely his teeth have grown sharper and his hair now has red bits that stick up. Combine that with his red eyes, and it paints a picture
- It’s also worth noting that adding red to characters’ designs is a common theme in Blueycapsules—usually to signify loss of innocence in some way. Red was added to Susie’s eyes after her dog died, turning them purple, and the highlights in Michael’s hair became red after The Bite of ‘83
- Bonus: In the October 2021 Patreon bonus image, the characters are seen dressed up for Halloween. Phil, fittingly, is dressed as a demon.
Phil is The Phone Guy, meaning he’s going to die eventually, as The Phone Guy dies in the source material. He dies on night 4 of the first game, killed by animatronics.
In the source material, it’s unclear as to why they killed him, as he appears to be uninvolved with William Afton and his crimes. However in Bluey Capsules, he is involved. He was pressured by William into covering up the missing children incident.
When the animatronics (therefore the spirits of the missing kids) eventually kill Phil, it’s possible their motivation may be because he is complicit in their disappearances. Because he discovered where they were and what happened to them, and didn’t tell anyone, depriving so many people of closure.
- In the 3/17/22 update, we see the puppet staring at Phil menacingly. This tracks with the source material, as The Phone Guy in FNAF 2 claims to hate the puppet because it’s “always watching.” The only difference is now, Charlie has a reason to be staring at Phil.
- There are two glowing white dots around the “D” in uninvited. William has white pupils.
- One of these dots is bigger than the other, and one of William’s pupils is bigger than the other.
- The “D” could be meant to signify Dave, his alias.
- It’s called The Uninvited, meaning someone is coming, and William would definitely show up uninvited.
Confirmed!
We know Michael is going to find his father again at some point, because he has to be sent to “put her back together” like in the source material, so now would the perfect time.
- Going off the theory that Jeremy will be the Bite of ‘87 victim, this also works out because at the time of William’s break-in, the bite is only a few months away, meaning Michael’s identity needs to be revealed soon if Jeremy is ever going to find out.
Semi-Jossed, William did see Jeremy and Michael, but it led to him fleeing before they could see him.
Because of the source material, we know he’ll take night shift eventually. It doesn’t make sense why he’d do this, as he’s not only happy doing day shift, but he gets to spend time with Michael. But if he and Michael’s relationship were to take a hit (perhaps because Jeremy feels betrayed at being lied to), he’d likely want to avoid Michael.
Jossed. He’s supportive and kind towards Michael after he reveals his identity
At the last convention, we saw the Chica’s employees not only present, but interacting with the Freddy’s employees. It’s highly likely this will happen again, and what happens when the Chica’s employees call ”Fritz” Billy?
Semi-Jossed. Yoaj did recognize him, but Michael avoided them and nothing came of it.
Confirmed!
Joan isn’t the greatest at her job. She regularly sleeps on the clock, allowing William, Mary, and who know who else to sneak in. It’s possible that once this is found out, she’ll be fired (or transferred to day shift, knowing Phil
Jossed.
