Originally aired October 7, 2013
Written by Damian Kindler
Directed by Paul Edwards
Ichabod and Abbie search for Jenny, and they track her down to a cabin that once belonged to Corbin. Abbie learns that Corbin had Jenny track down rare and often magical objects, such as a sextant. The sextant reveals an old map of Sleepy Hollow, marking the hidden location of The Lesser Key of Solomon, a book that can open a doorway to the seventh circle of Hell. A secret group of Hessians aligned with the Horseman get their hands on both the sextant and the book, but Abbie destroys the book and ends the ritual. The Witnesses also learn that the demon they are facing is named "Moloch."
Tropes present in the episode:
- Historical In-Joke: The real reason for the Boston Tea Party, was to secure the Book from the British.
- Tome of Eldritch Lore: The titular book.
- Villain of the Week: The Hessians
