History YMMV / ThyArtIsMurder

* CreatorBreakdown: CJ, which led to him leaving the band (though he eventually rejoined after getting help and kicking drugs), and Lee, who also quit because of it and eventually managed to reach a good place again, but has opted to not rejoin.

* BrokenBase: The band's decision to never, ever play anything from the [[MisogynySong van Ryn era]]. Most are accepting towards this decision since the very lyrical theme itself is a BrokenBase, with defenders considering it a good thing as they do not wish to be associated with such a nasty ideology, especially due to van Ryn's infamy as a major asshole. Detractors state that this very thinking is the reason why the world has became so Politically Correct, stating that the music should come before the lyrics, and that people who are offended by such themes should just "man up".

** Brendan van Ryn's reputation of being an unbearable {{Jerkass}} is all of this, especially when someone vandalized the band's Wikipedia page and put that he was returning to the band.

* NightmareFuel: A staple for a deathcore-technical death metal band, but special mention to ''Infinite Death'', due to the lyrics and sheer hatred and anger van Ryn enforces in his vocals. No wonder the band refuses to play music from it again!

* EarWorm: Lots of them.
** "I AM THE PUREST STRAIN OF HATE! EEEEYO!"
** "YOU WILL KNOW PAIN! YOU WILL SEE THE TRUE FACE OF PANIC!"
** "ENTER THE MIND OF A PSYCHOPATH!"
** "JUST BECAUSE I CAN'T BE SEEN DOESN'T MEAN I CAN'T BE FELT!"

* CreatorBreakdown: CJ, which led to him leaving the band.

* BrokenBase: The band's decision to never, ever play anything from the [[MisogynySong van Ryn era]]. Most are accepting towards this decision since the very lyrical theme itself is a BrokenBase, with defenders considering it a good thing as they do not wish to be associated with such a nasty ideology, especially due to van Ryn's infamy as a major asshole. Detractors state that this very thinking is the reason why the world has became so Politically Correct, and that people who are offended by such themes such "man up".

* NightmareFuel: A staple for a deathcore-technical death metal band, but special mention to ''Infinite Death'', due to the lyrics and sheer hatred and anger van Ryn enforces in his vocals. No wonder the band refuses to play music from it again!

** Brendan van Ryn's reputation of being an unbearable {{Jerkass}} is all of this, especially when someone vandalized the band's Wikipedia page and put that he was returning to the band.

** Brendan van Ryn's reputation of being an unbearable {{Jerkass}} is all of this, especially when someone vandalized the band's Wikipedia page and put that he was returning to the band.
* UnfortunateImplications: Brendan van Ryn's lyrics on ''Infinite Death'', actually ''Infinite Death'' in general considering the lyrical matter, to the point of OldShame. Marsh himself has expressed his distaste and discomfort with van Ryn's lyrics, as it's often seen why the band ''rarely'' performs songs off of the EP.

* MemeticMutation: "The Purest Strain of Hate" inspired a lot of memes.

* MemeticMutation: "The Purest Strain of Hate" inspired a lot of memes.
* UnfortunateImplications: Brendan van Ryn's lyrics on ''Infinite Death'', actually ''Infinite Death'' '''''in general'''''. Marsh himself has expressed his distaste and discomfort with van Ryn's lyrics.

* UnfortunateImplications: Brendan van Ryn's lyrics on ''Infinite Death'', actually ''Infinite Death'' '''''in general'''''.

* MemeticMutation: "The Purest Strain of Hate" inspired a lot of memes.

* Determinator: It wasn't unusual for CJ to perform shows whilst he should have really been in the hospital.

** "ENTER THE MIND OF A PSYCHOPATH!"