Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheKnack

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "My Sharona" was written about a real life 17 year old girl, Sharona Alperin, who Doug Fieger was infatuated with when he was 25. Needless to say, talking openly about that sort of relationship in a song would not fly so well today.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItsTheSameNowItSucks: ''...But The Little Girls Understand'' got hit hard with this when compared to ''Get the Knack''; particularly, lead single "Baby Talks Dirty" got panned by critics for sounding too much like "My Sharona", especially after being released only ''six months'' after "Sharona".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FirstInstallmentWins: ''Get the Knack'' is their most successful album, also containing their two most famous songs, "My Sharona" and "Good Girls Don't".

Added: 463

Removed: 431

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceAlienatingEra: Everything after their first LP, due to most of their songs [[StrictlyFormula sounding exactly the same]] with no more catchy hooks or melodies. The liner notes for ''...But the Little Girls Understand'' [[LampshadeHanging even say]]: "The songs are an assortment of feelings and emotions expressed redundantly as only The Knack can... [[MoneyDearBoy This record is very dear to me and my bank manager]]."


Added DiffLines:

* SeasonalRot: Everything after their first LP was an immediate downward slop in quality, due to most of their songs [[StrictlyFormula sounding exactly the same]] with no more catchy hooks or melodies. The liner notes for ''...But the Little Girls Understand'' [[LampshadeHanging even say]]: "The songs are an assortment of feelings and emotions expressed redundantly as only The Knack can... [[MoneyDearBoy This record is very dear to me and my bank manager]]."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed


* DorkAge: Everything after their first LP, due to most of their songs [[StrictlyFormula sounding exactly the same]] with no more catchy hooks or melodies. The liner notes for ''...But the Little Girls Understand'' [[LampshadeHanging even say]]: "The songs are an assortment of feelings and emotions expressed redundantly as only The Knack can... [[MoneyDearBoy This record is very dear to me and my bank manager]]."

to:

* DorkAge: AudienceAlienatingEra: Everything after their first LP, due to most of their songs [[StrictlyFormula sounding exactly the same]] with no more catchy hooks or melodies. The liner notes for ''...But the Little Girls Understand'' [[LampshadeHanging even say]]: "The songs are an assortment of feelings and emotions expressed redundantly as only The Knack can... [[MoneyDearBoy This record is very dear to me and my bank manager]]."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
What An Idiot has a restriction against real life examples.


* WhatAnIdiot: A ''huge'' one courtesy of their label, Creator/CapitolRecords. So, you have a band with a #1 hit single, and a fine album to go along with it. You promote them as the next [[Music/TheBeatles Beatles]], which is a bold claim to make, but whatever.\\
'''You'd Expect''': To let the band do interviews, as any other up-and-coming artists would happily do. That way, they can get their name out there better, and come across as amiable to the public and press. It's not as if most interviewers ask hard-hitting questions anyway.\\
'''Instead''': Capitol specifically tells them ''not'' to do interviews to [[InsaneTrollLogic preserve their mystique]], heavily leading to the backlash against the band, as it causes folks to think they're full of themselves, indirectly leading to the band's failure of a second album, and their unceremonious breakup. [[SarcasmMode Great job]]!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: ''My Sharona'', of course, but several other tracks from their debut album as well, like ''Good Girls Don't'' and ''Frustrated''.

to:

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: ''My Sharona'', "My Sharona", of course, but several other tracks from their debut album as well, like ''Good "Good Girls Don't'' Don't" and ''Frustrated''."Frustrated".



* {{Narm}}: ''Baby Talks Dirty'' from their second LP, which has Doug having ''[[FanDisservice an orgasm]]'' throughout the track. Eww.

to:

* {{Narm}}: ''Baby "Baby Talks Dirty'' Dirty" from their second LP, which has Doug having ''[[FanDisservice an orgasm]]'' throughout the track. Eww.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DorkAge: Everything after their first LP, due to most of their songs [[StrictlyFormula sounding exactly the same]] with no more catchy hooks or melodies. The liner notes for "...But the Good Girls Understand" [[LampshadeHanging even say]] "The songs are an assortment of feelings and emotions expressed redundantly as only The Knack can... [[MoneyDearBoy This record is very dear to me and my bank manager]]."

to:

* DorkAge: Everything after their first LP, due to most of their songs [[StrictlyFormula sounding exactly the same]] with no more catchy hooks or melodies. The liner notes for "...''...But the Good Little Girls Understand" Understand'' [[LampshadeHanging even say]] say]]: "The songs are an assortment of feelings and emotions expressed redundantly as only The Knack can... [[MoneyDearBoy This record is very dear to me and my bank manager]]."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm}}: ''Baby Talks Dirty'', which has Doug having ''[[FanDisservice an orgasm]]'' throughout the track. Eww.

to:

* {{Narm}}: ''Baby Talks Dirty'', Dirty'' from their second LP, which has Doug having ''[[FanDisservice an orgasm]]'' throughout the track. Eww.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm}}: ''Baby Talks Dirty", which has Doug having ''[[FanDisservice an orgasm]]'' throughout the track. Eww.

to:

* {{Narm}}: ''Baby Talks Dirty", Dirty'', which has Doug having ''[[FanDisservice an orgasm]]'' throughout the track. Eww.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*{{Narm}}: ''Baby Talks Dirty", which has Doug having ''[[FanDisservice an orgasm]]'' throughout the track. Eww.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatAnIdiot: A ''huge'' one courtesy of their label, Creator/CapitolRecords. So, you have a band with a #1 hit single, and a fine album to go along with it. You promote them as the next Beatles, which is a bold claim to make, but whatever.\\
'''You'd Expect''': To let the band do interviews, as any other up-and-coming artist would happily do. That way, they can get their name out there better, and come across as amiable to the public and the press. It's not as if most interviewers ask hard-hitting questions anyway.\\
'''Instead''': Capitol specifically tells them ''not'' to do interviews to [[InsaneTrollLogic preserve their mystique]], heavily leading to the backlash against the band, as it causes folks to think they're full of themselves, indirectly leading to the band's failure of a second album, and their unceremonious breakup. [[SarcasmMode Great job]].

to:

* WhatAnIdiot: A ''huge'' one courtesy of their label, Creator/CapitolRecords. So, you have a band with a #1 hit single, and a fine album to go along with it. You promote them as the next Beatles, [[Music/TheBeatles Beatles]], which is a bold claim to make, but whatever.\\
'''You'd Expect''': To let the band do interviews, as any other up-and-coming artist artists would happily do. That way, they can get their name out there better, and come across as amiable to the public and the press. It's not as if most interviewers ask hard-hitting questions anyway.\\
'''Instead''': Capitol specifically tells them ''not'' to do interviews to [[InsaneTrollLogic preserve their mystique]], heavily leading to the backlash against the band, as it causes folks to think they're full of themselves, indirectly leading to the band's failure of a second album, and their unceremonious breakup. [[SarcasmMode Great job]].job]]!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Instead''': Capitol specifically tells them ''not'' to do interviews to [[InsaneTrollLogic preserve their mystique]], heavily leading to the backlash against the band, as it causes folks to think they're full of themselves.

to:

'''Instead''': Capitol specifically tells them ''not'' to do interviews to [[InsaneTrollLogic preserve their mystique]], heavily leading to the backlash against the band, as it causes folks to think they're full of themselves.themselves, indirectly leading to the band's failure of a second album, and their unceremonious breakup. [[SarcasmMode Great job]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatAnIdiot: A ''huge'' one courtesy of their label, Capitol Records. So, you have a band with a #1 hit single, and a fine album to go along with it. You promote them as the next Beatles, which is a bold claim to make, but whatever.\\

to:

* WhatAnIdiot: A ''huge'' one courtesy of their label, Capitol Records.Creator/CapitolRecords. So, you have a band with a #1 hit single, and a fine album to go along with it. You promote them as the next Beatles, which is a bold claim to make, but whatever.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatAnIdiot: A ''huge'' one courtesy of their label, Capitol Records. So, you have a band with a #1 hit single, and a fine album to go along with it. You promote them as the next Beatles, which is a bold claim to make, but whatever. //
'''You'd Expect''': To let the band do interviews, as any other up-and-coming artist would happily do. That way, they can get their name out there better, and come across as amiable to the public and the press.It's not as if most interviewers ask hard-hitting questions anyway. //

to:

* WhatAnIdiot: A ''huge'' one courtesy of their label, Capitol Records. So, you have a band with a #1 hit single, and a fine album to go along with it. You promote them as the next Beatles, which is a bold claim to make, but whatever. //\n\\
'''You'd Expect''': To let the band do interviews, as any other up-and-coming artist would happily do. That way, they can get their name out there better, and come across as amiable to the public and the press. It's not as if most interviewers ask hard-hitting questions anyway. //anyway.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


You'd Expect: To let the band do interviews, as any other up-and-coming artist would happily do. That way, they can get their name out there better, and come across as amiable to the public and the press.It's not as if most interviewers ask hard-hitting questions anthey. //
Instead: Capitol specifically tells them not to do interviewers to prezerve their mystique, heavily leading to the backlash against the band, as it causes folks to think they're full of themselves.

to:

You'd Expect: '''You'd Expect''': To let the band do interviews, as any other up-and-coming artist would happily do. That way, they can get their name out there better, and come across as amiable to the public and the press.It's not as if most interviewers ask hard-hitting questions anthey.anyway. //
Instead: '''Instead''': Capitol specifically tells them not ''not'' to do interviewers interviews to prezerve [[InsaneTrollLogic preserve their mystique, mystique]], heavily leading to the backlash against the band, as it causes folks to think they're full of themselves. themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatAnIdiot: A ''huge'' one courtesy of their label, Capitol Records. So, you have a band with a #1 hit single, and a fine album to go along with it. You promote them as the next Beatles, which is a bold claim to make, but whatever. //
You'd Expect: To let the band do interviews, as any other up-and-coming artist would happily do. That way, they can get their name out there better, and come across as amiable to the public and the press.It's not as if most interviewers ask hard-hitting questions anthey. //
Instead: Capitol specifically tells them not to do interviewers to prezerve their mystique, heavily leading to the backlash against the band, as it causes folks to think they're full of themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: ''My Sharona'', of course, but also several other tracks from their debut album, like ''Good Girls Don't'' and ''Frustrated''.

to:

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: ''My Sharona'', of course, but also several other tracks from their debut album, album as well, like ''Good Girls Don't'' and ''Frustrated''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: ''My Sharona'', of course, but also several other tracks from their debut album, like ''Good Girls Don't'' and ''Frustrated''.
* DorkAge: Everything after their first LP, due to most of their songs [[StrictlyFormula sounding exactly the same]] with no more catchy hooks or melodies. The liner notes for "...But the Good Girls Understand" [[LampshadeHanging even say]] "The songs are an assortment of feelings and emotions expressed redundantly as only The Knack can... [[MoneyDearBoy This record is very dear to me and my bank manager]]."
* HypeBacklash: One of the most famous examples in pop/rock music history with the "Knuke the Knack" movement.
* ValuesDissonance: You don't have to be a women's studies professor to see the soaring sexism in their lyrics.
----

Top