History YMMV / SpikeAndBarleyPlay

* NightmareFace: David Leatherhoff switches between his two models, being "Addiction" and "Dead".

** During Fright Week 2013 in ''VideoGame/GarrysMod'', they try out their custom [[Series/HomeImprovement Tim & Allen]] models before Barley notices Spike as [[VideoGame/AmnesiaTheDarkDescent Mr. Struts]] in on of the toolpouches. Spike takes a look and exclaims that Barley has [[VideoGame/AfraidOfMonsters Charles]]. Barley gives a couple BigWHAT before checking himself ([[FunnyBackgroundEvent breaking the env_cubemap for reflections in the process]]) and notices he also has the decal of the wheelchair before letting out an overjoyed "Ooh my God!~".

** During Fright Week 2013 in ''VideoGame/GarrysMod'', they try out their custom [[Series/HomeImprovement Tim & Allen]] models before Barley notices Spike as [[VideoGame/AmnesiaTheDarkDescent Mr. Struts]] in on of the toolpouches. Spike takes a look and exclaims that Barley has [[VideoGame/AfraidOfMonsters Charles]]. Barley gives several {{Big What}}s before checking himself ([[FunnyBackgroundEvent breaking the env_cubemap for reflections in the process]]) and notices he also has the decal of the wheelchair before letting out an overjoyed "Ooh my God!~".

* SugarWiki/HeartwarmingMoments: Spike's happiness and relief when he finds barley again in ''[[VideoGame/AfraidOfMonsters Afraid of Monsters: Director's Cut]]'' (Part 2).

* ParanoiaFuel: David Leatherhoff instils this, and often does it well in their ''VideoGame/AfraidOfMonsters'': Director's Cut playthrough.
* WhatAnIdiot: Sjas from their ''Ghoul's World'' (Part 1), as noted by Spike and Barley:
-->'''Spike''': Look! It keeps exploding in the fire!
-->'''Barley''': Fuckin' stupid thing!

** David Leatherhoff since he terrorizes and messes with the duo. Even showing occasional shades of SilentSnarker as noted by their ''VideoGame/AfraidOfMonsters: Director's Cut'' livestream.

* BrokenBase: Renny is either loved for his humorous banter and intense reactions. Others find him obnoxious and drags things out because he's too afraid to progress.

-->'''Barley''': "David's a cool guy, he isn't afraid of anything."

** "Meeester maaaan!" and "Lil' ol' man!"[[note]]Spike and Barley's main catchphrases.[[/note]]

* ParanoiaFuel: David Leatherhoff instils this, and often does it well in their ''VideoGame/AfraidOfMonsters'': Director's Cut playthrough.

* {{Narm}}: They tend to do this to normally [[{{NightmareFuel}} scary]] games such as ''The Hotel'' and ''Ghoul's World'' when they would be horrifying in normal circumstances.

* EarWorm: The new jingle/tune that is their intro song is rather catchy.

* MostAnnoyingSound: Sjas's repeated screaming, ''full stop''.
-->'''Sjas''': AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
-->'''Spike''': What do you have?
-->'''Barley''': A fucking lighter, and that thing needs to shut the fuck up!
-->[Sjas then goes away to the point the map had become {{unwinnable}}, requiring a restart.]
-->'''Spike''': You know what man, [[DidYouThinkICantFeel You hurt its feelings.]]

* NightmareFuel: David Leatherhoff switches between his two models, being "Addiction" and "Dead".

-->'''Spike:''' ''Yahaha!'' Yeah! ''Ha ha ha!'', That's his face! It's like, "yeah~!"

-->'''Barley:''' What the-; ''Haha!'' Look at his face!

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: Their most recent intro songs, also, which Barley has made [[https://soundcloud.com/barleyp himself]].

* AwesomeMusic: Their most recent intro songs, also, which Barley has made [[https://soundcloud.com/barleyp himself]].

-->'''Barley:''' What the-, ''Haha!'' Look at his face!

* {{Narm}}: They tend to do this to normally [[{{NightmareFuel}} scary]] games such as ''The Hotel'' and ''Ghoul's World'' when they would be horrifying in normal circumstances.

* {{Narm}}: They tend to do this to normally [[{{NightmareFuel}} scary]] games such as ''The Hotel'' and ''Ghoul's World'' when they would be horrifying in normal circumstances.
* NightmareRetardant: This happens a lot. One to note is in Ghoul's World, when they see Jugulms Face by spawn.
-->'''Barley:''' What the-, ''Haha!'' Look at his face!
-->'''Spike:''' ''Yahaha!'' Yeah! ''Ha ha ha!'', That's his face! It's like, "yeah~!"

-->'''Barley:''' What the- ''Chuckle'' Look at his face!
-->'''Spike:''' ''Yahaha!'' Yeah! ''Laugh'', That's his face! It's like, "yeah~!"

* {{Narm}}: They tend to do this to normally [[{{NightmareFuel}} scary]] games such as ''The Hotel'' and ''Ghoul's World'' when they would be horrifying in normal circumstances.